7 ms·
Pretty much all of us at HN are against censorship, but we habitually fail to get to grips with the very real problem of deliberate lying. There's abundant evid
by anigbrowl 5y ago
Pretty much all of us at HN are against censorship, but we habitually fail to get to grips with the very real problem of deliberate lying. There's abundant evidence that the 'marketplace of ideas' is in no way self-perpetuating. I think this conception is a side effect of software development, where the computer is a pretty reliable honest referee, so ultimately either your code works or it doesn't.
The problem is that wetware is inherently messier, and it can quite profitable to mess with it. Consider this (graphic and horrifying) example of fake news I saw a troll circulating earlier today:
https://m.beforeitsnews.com/politics/2021/07/tortured-baby-corpses-come-to-surface-during-european-floods-3240656.html https://m.beforeitsnews.com/politics/2021/07/tortured-baby-c...
This website is obviously trash, but it pulls in an estimated $30k/mo in revenue: http://www.whoismark.org/beforeitsnews.com http://www.whoismark.org/beforeitsnews.com
More importantly, there are quite a lot of people who buy into this sort of nonsense, and it's a problem.
- betwixthewires 5y agoWhere did you see the troll circulating that page earlier today? You want to link to the post, wherever it is?
- anigbrowl 5y agoNo, I don't want to link to it. It was not on HN.
- betwixthewires 5y agoSo I'm just supposed to take your word for it that you saw someone circulating it earlier today? You can link to the misinfo itself but not your source for it?
- anigbrowl 5y agoSure, why not? I don't save the URL of every troll post I see. This is the originator if you want to follow their posts. https://disqus.com/by/lore11/comments/ https://disqus.com/by/lore11/comments/
- throwanem 5y agoIf you want to see people trying to spread conspiracy theories on HN, turn on showdead in your profile and, soon enough, you will. It's not all that common, but it does happen, and has proven a fairly fertile source of search terms for my own occasional research interest in the subject. Would that that interest could remain as academic as it was when the Internet and I were both young, and the stuff was all UFO abductions, or similarly innocuous and rather silly. On the other hand, it tickles my historiographical curiosity to watch a new iteration of American revivalism, rehashing the "Satanic ritual panic" of a few decades ago, evolve in near real time. So I suppose at least there is some consolation for the regret.
- reedjosh 5y agoCurious, so I turned on shadowdead, but what does it actually do?
- chrononaut 5y agoFrom my understanding, with that option enabled HN will now show you all the comments (and submissions) that are marked [dead], which are not visible by unregistered users and users that do not have that option enabled. Comments are marked [dead] due to being flagged by too many users, or the user is shadowbanned, which I believe means their comments default [dead] unless vouched. I may be mistaken here.
- throwanem 5y agoAll correct as far as I know. It can be a bit From Beyond at times, albeit sadly impaired by the lack of Jeffrey Combs.
- GlennS 5y agoA weird extra effect this time around: a sizeable chunk of the internet is trying to trick journalists into talking about the silliest thing imaginable as if it were something people really believed. (I wasn't around for the first Satanic panic, nor am I American, so perhaps that was happening the first time too and I just don't know about it?)
- bjcy 5y agoAgreed, and furthermore, I think it’s easy for most of us to take for granted the influence of our domains of work and study. In general, many of us have backgrounds which pride themselves in their methodology, consistency and pursuit of understanding (whether or not we actually work in line with these values is another matter.) A lot of people outside of these circles aren’t privy to that sort of training (self-taught or otherwise), so adequately analysing the news that shows up on news feeds and timelines is difficult. Any news on the pandemic and the varying responses of the general public are a fine example of this. There’s always room for differences in opinion, but the intense variability highlights the race across the internet between access to all sorts of information and educational material that was previously unavailable, and the ill-intended trash like the link you shared.
- beebeepka 5y agoDon't pat yourself on the back too much. "We" are just as susceptible to propaganda, it's just that different mindsets require different approaches to manufacturing consent. You may not always see it, but it's there
- troydavis 5y agoBackground: In Thailand, this is about residents and media discussing COVID updates - often including case counts released by the Thai government. It’s not an attempt to stop lies from spreading. Thailand sets new case count and death records almost every day (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-thailand-idUSKBN2EZ01U https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-thaila...) and the government is scared of residents talking about it. Keep in mind that Thailand is essentially a dictatorship right now (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prayut_Chan-o-cha https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prayut_Chan-o-cha). Here’s how the AP described this order: https://apnews.com/article/business-health-media-coronavirus-pandemic-ebbe28f11fb5a2f12b6663522a148765 https://apnews.com/article/business-health-media-coronavirus...
- anigbrowl 5y agoSure, but I am addressing a more general issue that always comes up in these discussions. There's another thread above where the specifics of the Thai context are being discussed in depth.
- paulddraper 5y ago> but we habitually fail to get to grips with the very real problem of deliberate lying Deliberate lying....like about Iran-Contra, Iraqi WMDs, IRS targeting, NSA surveillance? I have no illusions that deliberate lying isn't a problem, but asking the fox to guard the henhouse will make it even worse.
- edmundsauto 5y agoHow does it make it worse? I agree with what you’re saying but that bit of the logic fees like an assumption.
- tsimionescu 5y agoMost reputable news organizations already control the narrative of the world for most people. Allowing them to entirely censor other opinions will block both fabrications like the example you showed, and inconvenient truths like the situation in Palestine, the general strikes in India, even the miner's union protests in New York.
- anigbrowl 5y agoI didn't propose any particular solution, I just said we should discuss the problem.
- paulddraper 5y agoFair enough. I think there isn't a solution.
- salawat 5y agoI know of one specifically for the Government centric case. Inspector General gets moved under the Legislative and is blessed with absolute unfettered access to classified information. A timer is started on declassification the first time the Office is asked a question. Executive gets a limited number of "not yets", judiciary gets an "F you, declassify it button" in cases involving Executive privilege. Checks and Balances.
- kortilla 5y ago> I think this conception is a side effect of software development No, it’s been a pretty consistent concept for about 250 years at least.
- anigbrowl 5y agoTimes have changed radically since it was first mooted. Broadcast and social media didn't exist then, so the 250 year old model has no mechanism to handle market failure.
- adventured 5y agoYeah it sure has changed. People on social media today are more polite toward eachother than the revolutionary era founders of the US were toward eachother. The politics has calmed down considerably.
- anigbrowl 5y agoNot true. There is no shortage of rude or aggressive commentary today, and just because rude aggressive commentary existed in the past doesn't mean it was the default or median.
- kortilla 5y agoNothing has changed. Presidential candidates were vicious in the US early on. > old model has no mechanism to handle market failure. “market failure” has absolutely zero relationship to free speech.
- colordrops 5y agoAre you implying that censorship is necessary? If so, who are the non-liars that will police the liars?
- redis_mlc 5y ago> Pretty much all of us at HN are against censorship False, HN is a Marxist echo chamber - there's nothing but lying on here about Biden's health, CRT, antifa, BLM, etc. > but we habitually fail to get to grips with the very real problem of deliberate lying. Amen.
- moksly 5y agoWell, it’s sort of a hard issue isn’t it? Because as it turns out Mao was sort of right about the importance of controlling the story your society tells. I’d argue that we don’t actually have a problem with deliberate lying, but that we have an issue that too many people are doing it. Because our democracy has always been build on a certain degree or twisting facts to whatever purpose. The difference is that until very recently we had a society where the public narrative was controlled by a set of institutions and authorities. With too many billionaires and populists questioning those institutions for too long, we now have split narratives where people have to chose the lies they believe in, and that’s turning out to be a bigger problem than anyone ever imagined. It’ll likely also end up biting some of those billionaires and populists in the ass when enough people decide to follow the same path of lies. It’s a tad ironic that we’re likely witnessing another relatively free and liberal society fall due to too much decadence between the ruling class who have failed to live up to their responsibilities. Either because they were too stupid to realise the fire they are starting or because they were to greedy to care, but in either case, you need a coherent story to have a functional society where it’s different members don’t turn on each other because their world views become too different. A lot of libertarians believing in total free speech, and a lot of HNers share this. Which is understandable, because when you are part of the technical elite of a society you tend to value the essence or basic human rights and personal liberties. So much like the masons of the past formed the free masons, you too see engineers going down similar lines of thought. But the thing is, if you look at history, that’s just not how society works as a whole. Which brings me back to my opening statement about Mao, because while we little about Mao beyond the cultural revolution and the hunger travesties and attribute most of the sway of socialism and communism to Marx and Lenin in the west. The true brilliance of Mao is still at play in the core of what is modern China, in that the revolution never actually ends and that you need a tight grip on information and the public discord on matters that effect society as a whole if you want to control society. Unfortunately we are currently very busy proving him right. The populists may have taken some hits recently because the reality caught up to their stupidity, and the world has woken up to the foreign influence, but we still don’t have strong enough support behind our democratic institutions to have any form or safe future for our western ideologies. Unless that changes, we’ll soon become what China used to be for us. Not because we didn’t strike down on lies, but because we didn’t mutually agree on one of the lies.
- belorn 5y agoIn every discussion around censorship on HN we see a very large portion agreeing that censorship is good when targeting the right kind of people for the right kind of reasons, and bad otherwise. One side thinking that companies or government are enlightened enough to figure it out, the other disagreeing that such enlightened entity doesn't exist. It is about trust, not hardware vs wetware. I would not trust a AI to do it better than an moderator. The least harmful method of censorship are strict defined legal systems written by democratic elected people, and as the article demonstrate, it has some flaws. Everyone can agree that some people has been inspired by fake news to commit crime, leading to death and suffering. Everyone would also agree that without fake news there would still be people doing crime that leads to death and suffering. Crime is a problem, and censorship as a tool to combat crime has its up and downs in popularity. It does not however change the issue of trust.
- murgindrag 5y agoI think intentional lying is special, and should be an exception to censorship. I don't feel okay censoring things I disagree with, even strongly (e.g. hate speech, taboo topics, sexual moores, and whatnot), but on intentional falsehoods, I think it falls into a different bucket. We have good precedent here: - Slander laws - Libel laws - Yelling "fire" in a crowded theater - Etc. The problem is that an unregulated free market will choose memes over truths. There needs to be some correction there. I'm not quite sure what that correction ought to be. I don't think it should be mobs, tech companies, or governments. I do think the processes we have in place right now for dealing with untrue speech, with due process, make a lot of sense to me, though. Perhaps they might be expanded such that: - There isn't a $200k barrier to dealing with slander/libel - Some places (for example, academics and government employees) have criminal liability for intentionally lying or withholding information I'm not quite sure, but we do need to change incentive structures, or we'll be overwhelmed with misinformation.
- wccrawford 5y agoRight, but let's say someone claims that something is a conspiracy. Are they intentionally lying, or do they believe it? How can you tell the difference? Many people claim that each instance is emphatically not a conspiracy, but sometimes it turns out it really is a conspiracy. People on both sides of the argument believe they are correct, but one side is wrong. (And probably even both sides, when it comes to details.) I don't think "I believed it" is much of an excuse in the situations you list above. I searched a bit. https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/defamation-libel-slander-key-elements-claim.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/defamation-libel-sla... says that there are 3 ways it could be defamation: lying, disregarding the facts, or acting negligently. So it's kind of about lying, but more than that.
- eggy 5y agoThe COVID lab leak hypothesis was not called outright "deliberate lying", because it was a hypothesis, however, it was banned from open discussion by even experts who feared the wrath of social media platforms and their members. It was called "False" by various "fact-checking" groups too, which many took as "it's a lie". Way before the internet people would say, “If you believe that, I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell to you”. You cannot legislate intelligence, so stop trying to filter and ban things being written and said, if you don't agree with censorship especially from big tech or gonvernment. I always enjoyed reading the trash newspapers while waiting on the checkout line at the supermarket for fun (aliens (sorry, I doubted you, Kevin!), conspiracies, etc...). I knew they were false, and I know some people who actually believed them, but there will always be gullible people. Then there are facts as plain as day like the Uighur concentration camps in China being forced to make goods for the West (pick cotton, etc. Nike, Zara, H&M) and elsewhere, and Disney makes a movie in the same vicinity, and it's business as usual - profits before principals. Don't tell me it's different today with social media. I think it's the same, but social media has amplified ignorance by ameliorating facts and rewarding narcissism. I left LinkedIn and Facebook years ago.
- helloworld11 5y agoWhy exactly is this such a problem? People have been making up bullshit stories to sell a narrative since there have been printed media (before even) and the world hasn't been harmed by this in any way that's remotely comparable to how much harm giving governments powers of censorship for the sake of "protecting truth and morality" has caused in real human lives and repressions. As a basic general rule, private people absolutely should have the right to lie and spread lies in most contexts except those where contractual or professional obligations intervene, or where a legitimate criminal investigation is underway or in the case of government employees in positions of trust with the public.
- sellyme 5y ago> Why exactly is this such a problem? People have been making up bullshit stories to sell a narrative since there have been printed media You've answered your own question. It's tough to get your bullshit spreading when you need to yell it in the town square. When you have instant access to hundreds of millions of idiots, it's far more dangerous.
- helloworld11 5y agoOh my god, Yes! let's use new media types as an excuse to justify the same bullshit reasons for censorship of the kind that has always been so wisely, carefully used by politicians, ideologues and states throughout history. Because obviously no authority has tried that before.... Mass media is nothing new and you greatly over estimate how differently rumors and gossip circulate today vs any time in the last couple centuries. It's far too early to tell if anything about modern social networks in any way makes them comparably dangerous to the apparent proposed alternative of some authority figure dictating what people should be allowed to say. This new love of crushing certain opinions in the name of fighting misinformation is all the more surprising coming from tech types, who I remember being more oriented towards messy freedom.
- sellyme 5y ago> Mass media is nothing new You literally used "before printed media" as an example. > you greatly over estimate how differently rumors and gossip circulate today vs any time in the last couple centuries No, I'm pretty sure I'm correct in saying that the Internet has made broadcasting (mis)information easier.