12 ms·
A blood marker predicts who gets ‘breakthrough’ Covid
- est31 5y agoI wonder if they also studied T-cell responses. Because depending on the T-cell responses, this might have different implications for how long the vaccine protects people. T-cell based protection persists while antibody counts wane over time. If these break through cases are a model for people who had their last vaccine shot years ago, it might imply that you need to get vaccinated regularly to actually be protected from symptomatic covid infections. Nobody wants to be affected by symptoms for weeks, but apparently in these break through cases, 19% still had symptoms 6 weeks after their infection.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoI just found out this week that I don't have the antibodies even though I had the vaccine in March. I also found out that some of my specific T-cells are lower than normal. Likely a side effect from chemotherapy, which was finished in February. Just a PSA that these tests are not included with the normal white cell/neutrophils tests that they give cancer patients. So if you know someone, they might want to ask for an antibodies test and cd4/cd8 test
- Vecr 5y agoWas it a spike protein test? If you want to test the response to anything but a inactivated vaccine you have to test for antibodies to a provided component. No vaccine used in the US has anything but spike.
- snovv_crash 5y agoJust curious, did you get flu symptoms from the second dose of vaccine?
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoI had a bad fever for one night.
- kleiba 5y agoExtensive testing between late January and late April 2021 identified 39 workers who had become infected with SARS-CoV-2 despite being fully vaccinated. All had mild symptoms or none at all, but 19% still had some symptoms 6 weeks after diagnosis. How is that possible? 7 out of 39 people is 17.9% 8 out of 39 people is 20.5%
- BugsJustFindMe 5y agoMaybe they meant 18%.
- abathur 5y agoIt may also be 19% of the undisclosed number who had mild symptoms, excluding those who had none?
- djrogers 5y agoperhaps the actual number is 19% of those with symptoms. This is an unfortunate reality of getting scientific data from news media - when they're not wrong, they're inaccurate.
- yorwba 5y agoIt's given as 7/36 (19.4%) in the supplementary material https://www.nejm.org/doi/suppl/10.1056/NEJMoa2109072/suppl_file/nejmoa2109072_appendix.pdf https://www.nejm.org/doi/suppl/10.1056/NEJMoa2109072/suppl_f... I guess 3 people didn't respond to the survey 6 weeks later?
- kleiba 5y agoNo idea why anyone would downvote this comment. Thanks!
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago39 workers identified with COVID 36 responded to the survey about symptoms later. Almost every study, even small and short-term ones, have some dropouts and people who don’t respond to follow ups
- frettchen 5y ago"People [...] are less likely to become infected with the coronavirus if they have relatively high levels of virus-blocking antibodies..." This seems self-evident, really - 'virus-blockers help block the virus' hardly seems newsworthy. IF they'd worked out the 'threshold of protection' mentioned at the end, that might be more interesting, but this article seems like it should be a footnote in that larger piece (when it comes) rather than something worth reporting on its own.
- Workaccount2 5y agoIn my experience with immune related diseases, and reading about the immune system, the takeaway from all of it is "The immune system is ridiculously convoluted, and nothing necessarily makes sense or doesn't make sense" Given that I can totally understand why they would investigate something that seems self-evident. I wouldn't have been even slightly surprised if they found that high antibody count meant higher susceptibility to re-infection. The immune system really is a spaghetti code mess of a system, and has seemingly as many intuitive as counter-intuitive behaviors.
- whymauri 5y ago++ There was a time when I worked in the intersection of peripheral neuroscience and the immune system, studying the immune response of mammals to optogenetic therapies. It was a widely held belief that, in that problem space, the complexity of the immune system outpaced ambiguities and unknowns we had surrounding the PNS. Basically, what I'm saying is take every statement you've seen in the media and documentaries about how complex the nervous system is, and consider that the immune system is considered equally incomprehensible today. Not only is the immune system spaghetti code, but it likes to break all the time and, to our perspective, is full of weird and undefined behaviors.
- cogman10 5y agoWell, if my bio 200 class taught me anything, it's that we don't have bodies that are created with cells all united to single goals or purposes. Our bodies are microservice hell :D. We have a bunch of cells all performing their complicated jobs and duties working together in a crazy complex distributed system. Even the internals of the cells are a bunch of horribly stitched together glue code that just happens to work because of billions of years of pruning off the glue that doesn't work. It's an incredibly complex chain of chemical reactions which has been selected of eons based on which chains of chemical reactions produce more of the same chains. It's madness.
- roel_v 5y agoTo me as a layman, this reads as a "water is wet" study - what am I missing here?
- teekert 5y agoIt's confirmation that the vaccines work the way we expect them to work. Also, this may help identify people that need a (or more) booster shots, or people that should be more careful even though they were vaccinated. Also it provides an explanation for people getting Covid after vaccination (breakthrough Covid as they call it here). Now you can say to people that scream: "Look they got vaccinated and still got Covid!" what likely happened and why that doesn't mean the vaccine is not doing what is should, in the population. For example the people without (or lower concentrations of) antibodies may share certain traits/attributes (like recently undergoing chemotherapy I read in this thread somewhere), if we know that, we can avoid vaccinating these people too early (and thus needlessly) after treatment and we know we should protect them in another way. It may all seem obvious, but I can tell you (as somewhat of a scientist myself), that any of these things could easily have been found to be not true and we'd have had to deal with that. Biology is complex, if we would have had to change models of how we think the vaccine works, that could have real world implication for how we deal with (partially) vaccinated populations for example. I wonder if one's reaction to the vaccine is a measure for the magnitude of one's immune reaction and related to the effectiveness of the vaccine. I for one slept for 14 hrs after my first shot and spend another half day in bed feeling like I had the flu after the second. I'd like to thing I'm well protected now, but who knows. Only studies like this one can prove such hypotheses.
- galangalalgol 5y agoin short, water is wet studies, and water isn't dry studies are important, in case water is only wet under certain conditions.
- IgorPartola 5y agoSo this is more of a “is ice wet” study?
- sologoub 5y agoReference link has more details: “ Results Higher levels of all immune markers were correlated with a reduced risk of symptomatic infection. Vaccine efficacy of 80% against primary symptomatic COVID-19 was achieved with an antibody level of 40923 (95% CI: 16748, 125017) and 63383 (95% CI: 16903, not computed (NC)) for anti-spike and anti-RBD, and 185 (95% CI: NC, NC) and 247 (95% CI: 101, NC) for pseudo- and live-neutralisation assays respectively. Antibody responses did not correlate with overall protection against asymptomatic infection.” https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.21.21258528v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.21.21258528v... Does anyone know which units these use and how to convert to AU/mL?
- yorwba 5y agoThat's the study mentioned as "earlier data" in the Nature article. The newer study that the article is mostly talking about is the first reference, https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2109072 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2109072 .
- KarlKemp 5y agoI believe these are AU. Only it's AU not as in astronomical units, but arbitrary units. And they are likely arbitrary in a different way than whatever values you have in mind. These are used in cases where you can measure something, such as the how dark some liquid gets after some reaction, but cannot, or don't bother, to turn that into some "real" number such as the number/concentration of particles in the liquid causing the effect. So these units are comparable across several experiments or measurements using the same protocol. Sometimes they are tied to the equipment used and can be compared to other data from the same equipment. But other than that, only the relative values or, as in this case, the finding of proportionality is meaningful.
- sologoub 5y agoThanks for explaining! So in other words these cannot be compared with unrelated studies or test results.
- 5y ago
- CodeWriter23 5y agoSo genetics DO matter when it comes to vaccines.
- minitoar 5y agoWas there ever a doubt about this? After all, if you don’t have a fairly standard human immune system the vaccine isn’t going to do anything at all for you.
- fallingknife 5y agoSo I know this isn't your point, but your comment made me think, does it actually require any type of human immune system? The vaccine exposes you to viral protein which causes an immune response. Wouldn't that work in other species no matter the implementation details of how their immune system generates that response?
- yorwba 5y agoProbably, but the article isn't about genetics.
- rcthompson 5y agoThe "blood marker" in question is anti-COVID antibody titer. That's not genetic. (It may turn out to have a genetic component, but that has nothing to do with this article.)
- 11235813213455 5y agoand mostly probably life style
- brobdingnagians 5y agoIs the government going to insist on quarantining these people in house arrest for "their good and for the safety of society"? Where does it end? If we find genetic markers that determine that a person is a good gymnast or farmer or doctor, are we going to start deciding their profession for them like the Soviet Union? Better farming would help society, after all. If society can simply make arbitrary decisions for you based on "medical experts", where do we end? It might seem silly, but we are already doing similar things, and there are countries which have done even more of the same. We should make a stand for personal choice above "expert tyranny".
- soco 5y agoOn what is based a personal choice? It's based on some information as well - so by trusting a Facebook expert we choose to not trust a medical expert. Choices? Yes. But while some of them are damaging to the feeling of liberty, others are damaging for both the public and personal health, when we are replacing experience with a loud mouth, or substituting medicine with philosophy. And while the state can do only so much for the personal health, we expect from a state to take care of the public health - thus the tyranny of personal choice is in a wrong place in a working society.
- KarlKemp 5y agoThis about people trying to find a method to measure people's susceptibility to a disease. Knowing who is still adequately protected and whose vaccine-induced immunity is waning would allow, among other things, to reduce the number of people that need to be vaccinated again. That should make everyone happy, including the crowd believing vaccines are part of a plot to kill all babies with one-syllable nicknames, or whatever. It would also allow vaccines to go to those needing them more, as long as supplies are constrained, possibly saving a few lives, especially in less rich countries. What I'm trying to say is: are you sure you aren't psychotic?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hardlyanyone 5y ago
- ghastmaster 5y agoOne thing that bugs me with studies like this is the lack of prior study. Unless I am unaware, there isn't an ongoing study of a large random group of people to determine infection rates, hospitalization/death rates, and antibody levels before and after the vaccine/infection. A robust study like this would also bring clarity to the variant debate. There is no apparent way to know if the people who were breakthrough infections had previously not been infected. It is possible the people who did not have breakthrough infections, may have had previous exposure/infection that prevented the breakthrough. A large, long running random selection study is desperately needed to get any true sense of what has been going on the for the past year+. I am unsure if the University of Padua Vò Study is still ongoing. I hope so.
- CrazyPyroLinux 5y ago@brobdingnagians raised a question on genetic discrimination based on COVID-suceptability, which of course got downvoted into oblivion. But this is indeed an issue and a tough gray line to walk as technology continues to advance. (It's probably more like a fractal than a line.) Do we end up in GATTACA, 1984, Brave New World, Dune, Black Mirror, or some combination? Maybe we figure out how to dodge most of those bullets and end up in Star Trek? In the US, the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008 (GINA) may be of some tiny value on the particular point raised.
- rajin444 5y agoThat's why it's so important for us to come to terms with how we view privilege. Society currently only thinks a limited set of things - parental wealth, social status, skin color, etc. - are forms of privilege and we should work to reduce them (currently in the name of "equity"). Once society starts to understand that everything is privilege we need to rethink how we treat privilege, else we will continue destroying one another in the name of equity. Hard work, intelligence, willpower, perseverance are, at the root, all genetic. Environmental factors may influence these traits, but how you react to environmental factors is also genetic...unless you believe in religious concepts such as free will. We need to stop treating privilege as something that needs to be corrected and instead focus on helping those most in need. The logical conclusion of equity is nothingness (if that's even a thing). Stopping short of that is simply giving more to one side at the expense of the other.
- jhfxddgn 5y agoThe first step is to use a word besides "privelege" since that's an ideologically loaded term that, regardless of the many definitions its believers and confused non-believers will offer you, is functionally a form of original sin that can never be truly wiped clean, requiring eternal penance from the privileged. If you don't agree with that concept, you shouldn't cede the linguistic territory by using the term coined by the people who invented that concept
- sreque 5y ago
- rossdavidh 5y ago"The study, published in The New England Journal of Medicine on 28 July, draws on data from almost 11,500 fully vaccinated health-care workers...testing between late January and late April 2021 identified 39 workers who had become infected with SARS-CoV-2 despite being fully vaccinated. All had mild symptoms or none at all..." TL;DR the Pfizer vaccine works, essentially 100% of the time as far as severe cases go, more than 99% never getting it at all. I'm glad they're doing the rest of this research, but this part is what I personally am most concerned with.
- rossdavidh 5y ago...also, being health-care workers, these 11,500 people were virtually guaranteed to be around someone sick with covid-19 more than a member of the general population.
- DavideNL 5y agoThe question will be whether Pfizer will become less effective for example 6+ months after getting it...
- majormajor 5y agoOn a long enough timeline, 99% turns into a much lower cumulative probability number - even if it doesn't weaken over time. That's why it's essential to work towards having the whole world vaccinated, and to understand that weakening so we can do boosters where appropriate.
- donatzsky 5y ago"Two doses of the Pfizer/BioNTech or Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine are estimated to be 96% and 92% effective against hospitalisation with the Delta variant, respectively Vaccine effectiveness against symptomatic cases with the Delta variant is estimated to be 88% after both doses of the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine and 67% after both doses of the Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine." Source: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/conditionsanddiseases/articles/coronaviruscovid19latestinsights/vaccines#vaccine-effectiveness https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...
- suzzer99 5y agoSo the big question - did those people who showed high levels of antibodies after vaccination have a) more symptoms from vaccination, b) less symptoms, or c) no correlation? I had zero symptoms. I'd really like to know if that means my antibodies kicked ass, or were non-existent to create any kind of fever, etc.
- slumdev 5y agoA small amount of malaise, drowsiness, arm tenderness, and subclinical fever are expected after any vaccine. It's most probable that you did have symptoms but didn't notice them because you're a normal, active person with other things to think about. But having zero symptoms, if that was the case, is unusual. It'd be interesting to have your blood tested for antibodies.
- stronglikedan 5y agoI had zero symptoms too. I mean, I had very mild tenderness in my arm, but that was a symptom of the muscular trauma from the shot itself, not the actual vaccine.
- genkimind 5y agoSame. Sore arm after the first shot. NOTHING after the second.
- subsubzero 5y agoYou all are lucky, I had a pretty bad reaction from the second dose(pfizer) wiped out for two solid days, started feeling better and then boomerang fatigue hit, a half mile walk would leave me so tired I needed to rest for an hour after. I also had heart issues and as a runner(I run 20-30 miles a week) had to stop for almost 2 weeks. Interestingly enough I have a garmin watch and it showed my v02 max also drop by 10% during that time, Dr's attributed it to the vaccine but couldn't be sure. That being said I'll still get the booster if and when it arrives as I would rather deal with those side effects than severe covid or death.
- citilife 5y ago> The latest study does have drawbacks. It is based on a small number of cases among young and healthy adults, which limits its application, says Andrew Fiore-Gartland, a biostatistician at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle, Washington. More studies from vaccine trials are expected soon, he says.
- raoa 5y agoIt is not exactly a novel development that infection is neutralized by neutralizing antibodies, and the way the article is written suggests the existence of some cross-sectional variation whereas the more plausible explanation is a longitudinal decline in neutralizing antibodies beyond a sterilizing threshold, despite a more durable presence of binding antibodies which may be responsible for diminishing the severity of breakthrough disease. This is also suggested by the fact the ratio of binding to neutralizing antibodies shortly after full vaccination is very high, something like 4-to-1, which ratio likely explains why the dosing had to be so violently high. What I think was unexpected is the pace of decline in neutralizing antibodies, and possibly also the rising threshold of sterilizing immunity under the newly prevalent variants.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- frg2qwelk 5y agoThere are 4 different articles on Covid on the front page today. Stop pushing this fascist propaganda! You people are creating a fucking dystopian nightmare out of nothing. For a site called "hacker news" you people are some of the dumbest motherfuckers out there.
- at_a_remove 5y agoI have yet to hear any news on some kind of mRNA-based booster based on the delta and gamma variants.