6 ms·
Well, that's not chicken feed, even for Amazon. Still a bit light on detail? The original complaint is linked from https://www.laquadrature.net/en/personnal-da
by pjc50 5y ago
Well, that's not chicken feed, even for Amazon. Still a bit light on detail?
The original complaint is linked from https://www.laquadrature.net/en/personnal-data/ https://www.laquadrature.net/en/personnal-data/ - it's in French https://gafam.laquadrature.net/wp-content/uploads/sites/9/2018/05/amazon.pdf https://gafam.laquadrature.net/wp-content/uploads/sites/9/20...
The lack of publicity or even publicly available copy of the ruling is odd. I guess the choice of Amazon to reside in one of the secretive tax haven jurisdictions of Europe has the side effect that it also has a really secretive information commissioner.
- za3baec 5y agoTL;DR: LQDN claims Amazon used their users' data for targeted advertising without their consent The interesting bit is section 2.3 page 17 and is very short.
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoWhich is an absolute joke because everyone using amazon to actually purchase anything signs their terms and data collection is clearly part of those terms (as one would expect for an online retailer). In addition, they run Amazon Marketplace and a well known recommendation engine and clearly allow sellers to advertise. This always seems to be more about posturing than anything else. Or rely on weird logic loops.
- bosie 5y agoIs it reasonable to assume I can agree (as a non-lawyer) to terms and conditions that are 50 pages (wild guess) long? Especially since they are written in legalese?
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoThey are very long because of things like the GPDR. That said, amazons are pretty darn clear. "We receive and store any information you provide in relation to Amazon Services. " "We use your personal information to display interest-based ads for features, products, and services that might be of interest to you"
- bosie 5y agoTC have always been long and legalese and it wasn't because of GPDR. I can't find your examples in the T&C, it seems to be about 'privacy notice'. Am i supposed to read that too and keep up to date? I signed up in 2003, do you mind showing me what i agreed to? And out of genuine curiosity, 'any information' seems to be a superset of 'personal information', isn't it? what is "any information"? and are you saying amazon is only using personal information (which is what, exactly?) to display ads?
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoAmazon is much better than most. You can read historic t&c's. That said, you have a big misunderstanding. If you have continued to use the site, all T&C's updated based on continued use.
- freeone3000 5y agoThe ruling states their EULA doesn't actually say that they are using the data they're collecting in order to advertise. Collecting data doesn't mean you're allowed to use that data for advertising without explicit, revocable consent.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoConsent is only valid if it's informed and specific. More than that the data minimization applies - you can't require using personal data if it's not necessary. https://gdpr.eu/article-4-definitions/ https://gdpr.eu/article-4-definitions/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protection/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/principles/data-minimisation/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoThey run a marketplace and make $20 billion in ad revenue (or more) per year. Obviously - targeting ads helps them make this money - how is this not a legit business purpose?
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoLegitimate business purpose is another basis for processing personal data, but it can't override interests of the data subject: https://gdpr-info.eu/art-6-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-6-gdpr/ It's like asking why a doctor can't sedate you and transplant your kidney, you have another one so you don't need it and they'll make a ton of money.
- HelloMcFly 5y agoIf the statement "collecting this data without consent so we can more effectively sell ads helps us make money, so it's a legitimate business interest" was considered a valid argument, would that make much of GDPR toothless?
- krageon 5y agoIf "Wow this makes me a lot of money" made your business legitimate, the heroin industry would be enormous.
- einpoklum 5y agoIn many jurisdictions, even if consent is informed and specific, a contract which is not the result of actual negotiations but is standard - e.g. between a client and a large company - can often have clauses nullified by the courts, either for being unfair/detrimental to the client, or for their presence being detrimental to public interest.
- fmajid 5y agoAt least the Luxembourg DPA is doing its job, unlike the Irish DPA that seems to think it is a division of the Irish Industrial Development Agency charged with shielding multinationals from accountability.
- ElKrist 5y agoThat's also the reaction [1] of "La Quadruature du Net", the association that brought the complaint "(...) this historical fine shows even more blatantly the complete resignation of the Irish authority for data protection, which in 3 years hasn't been able to process any of the 4 other claims we made against Facebook, Apple, Microsoft and Google." it also goes after the French authority for data protection (CNIL) to say basically: you used to be one of the best in Europe, now you're a mere shadow of your former self [1] https://www.laquadrature.net/2021/07/30/amende-de-746-millions-deuros-contre-amazon-suite-a-nos-plaintes-collectives/ https://www.laquadrature.net/2021/07/30/amende-de-746-millio...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thepangolino 5y agoIn most European countries court rulings are quite hard to get a hold off.
- doikor 5y agoNot they are not. They are public records in most. Luxembourg is one of the few exceptions. They might not be available online but can be ordered from the court clerk (which is the case here in Finland for example) but the 2 largest EU countries (Germany and France) has them online for free. Though as most European countries are not using a case law system the actual value of getting these is not that important for lawyers etc.
- corty 5y agoIn Germany you do not get all the cases, just the ones the courts deem important enough. E.g. if the ruling is different from earlier ones in some aspect, if it is a higher court or if the case was of particular public interest.
- xxpor 5y agoIs this a them being lazy thing or a German privacy thing?
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoIt's not just a German privacy thing. There is little reason for the vast majority of lawsuits to be public.
- xxpor 5y agoOh that's just extremely not true. Open, non-secret courts are incredibly important for avoiding impropriety. Especially in a common law system, there's just no way that would work. The only exception are family law cases.
- 5y ago
- ElKrist 5y agoSummarized conclusions of the original complaint [1]: 2.2.3.1 claims that Amazon does not disclose anything proving they intend to get consent from their users to process their behavoural data for ad targeting purposes 2.2.3.2 is a rebuttal against one potential line of defense from Amazon. This defense is "We have to collect/use data because this is precised in our contract with our users and so we need to respect this contract". The rebuttal is that the main goal of the contract is a marketplace to buy/sell goods. Ad targeting is not essential to fulfill this goal and it is not something that can be considered as reasonable user expectations 2.2.3.3 It says that Amazon does not explicitly states that it's in its legitimate interest to process data and do ad targeting. It then refers to section 2.1.3 which shows that Amazon could not claim legitimate interest anyway. Section 2.1.3 is too complicated for me as it quotes a lot of precedent rulings in European law to prove it can't be legitimate interest Please keep in mind that it is the complaint, I don't have details on the ruling of today [1] https://gafam.laquadrature.net/wp-content/uploads/sites/9/2018/05/amazon.pdf https://gafam.laquadrature.net/wp-content/uploads/sites/9/20...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Anthony-G 5y agoThanks for providing relevent details. I first came across this story on local media (syndicated from Reuters) and they were similarly light on detail. I then checked the News page for the Luxembourg National Data Protection Commission¹ but there was no mention of this case. 1. https://cnpd.public.lu/en/actualites.html https://cnpd.public.lu/en/actualites.html
- throwawinsider 5y agoThe EU is doing politics, trying to capture population resentment at big tech, with a disproportionate fine for breaking rule 29.6.4.23.iv, while european companies have gotten away for decades with national monopolies. EU has many problems of acceptance among the population, so they will play dirty as a marketing campaign (see case against AstraZeneca and anything british)