7 ms·
Sgt. Pepper’s to get new Atmos mix: current version ‘doesn’t sound quite right’
- meristohm 5y agoStereo is cool enough[0]? [0] Stereo sound and 13th century painting THE BLINDBOY PODCAST 2021 APR 13 ⋅ 1:16:46
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PAGAN_WIZARD 5y agoPersonally, only the mono mix sounds right.
- gdubs 5y agoIn some cases the mono mixes were the ones the Beatles themselves were present for. Some of the stereo mixes were the audio engineers experimenting on their own — this is why Beatles mono mixes are highly sought-after. Can’t recall whether Sgt. Pepper’s was a mono mix originally, but probably an easy search to find out — I’m too lazy to go to my bookshelf and flip through to the Beatles studio notes at the moment…
- websites2022 5y agoSgt. Pepper was indeed a mono mix originally, that was the version that the Beatles themselves oversaw. But, the new mixes are fantastic!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PAGAN_WIZARD 5y agoIt was, and there are even some significant differences. On she's leaving home, the mono mix was speed up with the mono version's length coming in at 3:26 and the stereo at 3:35 [0]. I believe (running off of memory here too) that the first album where the stereo mix got some actual attention was the white album. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/She%27s_Leaving_Home https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/She%27s_Leaving_Home
- gerdesj 5y agoI've listened to the real thing ie Beetles live and releases on vinyl, tape cassette (of various grades - iron n chromium etc) and CD. I am not a sound engineer nor do I buy cables that cost more than a few quid. Sgt Peppers sounds right to me because that's how it sounds. A bit self referential but you have to remember that things were a bit different back then. Rather a lot of sound engineering stuff in popular music was being invented at the time. In my view, the sound that was recorded and post processed at the time and released is the correct one. A well preserved record (vinyl) from the time will have a decent representation on it. I don't think you can go back and retrospectively "improve" it. This proposed change is just a remix and a re-interpretation. It is not canonical.
- shoo 5y ago> the sound that was recorded and post processed at the time and released is the correct one that's a fun angle - what is the "correct" sound? a different way to define the "correct" sound could be to claim that experience of listening to the band playing live is the one true correct "sound". In principle you could try to approximately recreate that live sound using a live beatles cover band or some kind of computer simulated beatles [+]. but that perspective of "correct" being a live listening experience ignores the contribution of production to the end product that was shipped & listened to, as you're advocating for. [+] e.g. try to simulate the sound of all the instruments and the vocals from first principles or something, perhaps fitting them to the actual recordings using some belief about the observation model & error model of how the true sounds would have gotten recorded/distorted/mangled/mixed into the recorded sounds, using the standard equipment and techniques of the day. now we've turned the problem into an arbitrarily hard ill-defined inverse problem, so we can probably make it sound like however we want depending on what assumptions we make, so arguably this is a weird and overly complex way of producing one of many possible remixes or reinterpretations.
- onionisafruit 5y agoDid The Beatles ever play Sgt Pepper's live? I'm too young to remember, but I think that was from after they stopped playing live.
- smoldesu 5y agoA lot of old music "doesn't sound right", and most of the time it's because we didn't understand stereo imaging in the 60s and just went with "what sounded good". Turns out, we're willing to make the same mistakes today by remastering this in a format nobody will use instead of standard stereo.
- Wolfenstein98k 5y agoThey released a standard stereo mix at the same time. This is a cork-sniffing extra.
- mastrsushi 5y agoElton John on morning glory seeds album? Pfff BIG DEAL
- tehnub 5y agoAnyone else find the crescendos on "A Day in the Life" to sound very different on the 2017 remix compared to older mixes? Not just more/better stereo mixing, but it almost sounds like the instruments are playing different notes. I'm not saying I think they actually rerecorded it, but it almost sounds like they did.
- Wolfenstein98k 5y agoVery much so - the sounds aren't new but the mix is. Giles mixed in a lot more of what was present to try and capture the original intention of that section. He discusses it in a release interview somewhere.
- emsy 5y ago> the Atmos mix of Abbey Road, which was produced for its 50th anniversary in 2019 is “a much better-functioning Atmos mix because it’s much closer to the stereo mix, sonically.” Having listened to the mix after a recommendation on HN I couldn’t disagree more. The atmos mix sounds terrible. I don’t have high expectations for the sgt peppers mix, the mono mix is just a very high bar. I assume any modern mix will sound good for people that otherwise listen to a lot of modern music but terrible to people used to 60s music.
- Applejinx 5y agoExactly this. Whether it's Giles Martin (who IS NOT George Martin, and who did not work with the Beatles) or Steven Wilson remixing every great progressive rock record known to man, all of these are the same. Replace the vibe, atmosphere and space of whatever the original thing was, with a version in which every little detail is a little bit too close and carefully cut out from its background to be presented, pristine, as if it could be listened to isolated from the music it's in. Generally if you have a sense of the vibe and space of the original work you'll find the remixing appalling, terrible. It's improved if the goal is to pick out all the details as if you were going to fill out a report or perhaps a postmortem. It's like being mad old Eno records don't have enough 18k content and blaming the original vinyl and fixing it. Sometimes the artists go along with this nonsense and sometimes they just put up with it, or have passed on and can't be consulted about it. It is only for the glorification of the remixers: Steven Wilson at least does his own music, though I haven't liked it all that much.
- exmadscientist 5y ago> Generally if you have a sense of the vibe and space of the original work you'll find the remixing appalling, terrible. It's interesting that one can see this in other arts as well. One example from typography is how Trade Gothic, a mutt of a typeface if ever there was one, got "remastered" into Trade Gothic Next by Akira Kobayashi. The original is warm, scatterbrained, charming, completely imperfect, and generally has a soul. The remaster has... nothing. Completely "corporate neutral". The only thing it has going for it is that it fills out the weight and width axes more completely. (Kobayashi's remasters of other Linotype typefaces were similarly deflating, but Trade Gothic had the most soul to lose.) (Recently mentioned on HN was MD Primer https://mass-driver.com/typefaces/md-primer https://mass-driver.com/typefaces/md-primer , which appears to actually back off this trend and go back to things with imperfections, but alas, commercial fonts are a little tough to use in FOSS projects....) I think one of the main drivers behind these trends is the switch from analog to digital technologies as media for creation. Analog tech tends to be "one-shot": if you didn't capture something you like, do it again until you do. Often some level of editing is possible, depending on the particular medium, but it's usually a pretty blunt, coarse-grained instrument. Digital, on the other hand, allows unlimited tweaking of every last digit and detail until everyone is bored with it and can no longer go on. This power to revise forever is more dangerous than it looks, because now perfection actually appears attainable, peer artists are already chasing it, and so artists feel they have little choice but to do the same. Even if that's not the best thing for their work as a whole. You can see this in action with photography: in the recent photo threads here, or anywhere else for the last decade, how much time is spent whining about sharpness and gear foibles versus the composition of interesting photographs?
- Wolfenstein98k 5y agoI don't care for whatever Atmos is or how you listen to it. The latest Giles Martin mix sounds absolutely perfect. It is the pinnacle. If you haven't listen to the 2017 of Sgt Pepper's, go and do it right now.
- throwitaway1235 5y agoI just heard a 2020 remaster of Black Sabbaths symptom of the universe and it sounded great. Drums were way heavier. That being said, it's so different from the original that it makes me a bit uncomfortable.
- esfandia 5y agoIs it just me or Sgt. Pepper always sounded a bit "muffled" to me?
- Applejinx 5y agoBack in the day, what you had was vinyl records pressed off a signal chain that was a pile of old retro ALL TUBE equipment, and you could listen to it over stereo systems (or indeed mono systems) also built off tubes and made so you could turn the record up REALLY LOUD. They didn't have transistor mixing consoles until Abbey Road. Geoff Emerick, their best engineer, is on record in his autobiography that they lost a lot of energy and power in that transition, and had to work like hell to make the band still sound good when it sounded that much smaller and weaker than it did back in the days of Pepper and Revolver and the White Album. I have measured these albums off the original vinyl and know the dynamic energy permitted to that format was substantially greater than anything you get in the 'un-muffled' modern day. You had to turn the record up to get the fullest sound as it was not limited and heavily equalized to compensate for idle, inattentive listening. In particular, peak energy could be 18 dB or more, over the loudest RMS output the records could produce. They also cut a 15k tone on literally this record, Sgt. Pepper's, so dogs could enjoy the music too. And it worked (as did the later quadraphonic records done using carrier tones of 30 to 50k) I'm gonna suggest the fault is not in the original record…
- smlss_sftwr 5y agoI think a lot of the muffled aesthetic is a consequence of the decisions made in the recording/mixing process, there's a strong room reverb across the recording particularly noticeable on Ringo's drums which combined with the high-end softening of the Fairchild 660 compressor featured on Beatles records gives it a "rock concert while standing in line for the bathroom" color. I could be mistaken but it sounds like a lot of the instrumental parts were recorded in single takes in the same room compared to say Abbey Road where it sounds like they were tracked independently. A consequence of tracking multiple lines together is there can be cross-instrument fuzzing that results in "muffling", it can be an intentional effect though for a more live sound. Just my 2c
- coolandsmartrr 5y agoThe Beatles personally supervised the mono mixes until their stereo-only release "Abbey Road". During the 1960s, the stereo audio systems weren't as prevalent, so the band delegated stereo mixes to their producer George Martin. These mixes tend to separate instruments completely on the Left and Right tracks. Perhaps Martin hoped that this would produce an effect of the instruments coming from many places. Personally, I feel this is gimmicky at best, and disintegrated at worst especially when listening on headphones. In September 9, 2009, EMI released their then-latest remasters of the Beatles studio discography. In fact, they released two versions: stereo and mono. If I recall correctly, the mono box set sold out quickly, and had to be reissued. This suggests that audiophiles perceive providence in the mono releases. If you want to listen to the Beatles as the band has intended, you should listen to the mono mixes on vinyl.
- klodolph 5y ago> Perhaps Martin hoped that this would produce an effect of the instruments coming from many places. Personally, I feel this is gimmicky at best, and disintegrated at worst especially when listening on headphones. This is not how it happened. Stereo record players started appearing in the late 1950s and were seen as somewhat a gimmick at first. The equipment for producing stereo records was not like it is today. You might use a four-track tape machine to record the band, and mix it on a console which had a three-way switch for each channel: left, center, and right. Sgt. Pepper came out in 1967 and was produced on such equipment, although the studio was able to synchronize two tape machines together (and they also bounced mixes to tape to build up layers). They just didn’t have pan pots on their mixing consoles back then. By the time Abbey Road came out in 1969, the studio had moved to eight-track machines which could more easily be synchronized, you could find a basic “pan” knob on your mixing console, and no mono mix of the record was made.
- ingas 5y agoI understand motivation for remix of "Let it be" - McCartney was very dissatisfied with "wall of sound" by Spector. And it's already done. But "Sgt. Pepper" - I think the only motivation is to try squeeze a little bit more money from fans. My hope is that sometime in future we will get a remix of Metallica "Justice for All" with bass on it. But Hetfield already stated that they don't plan to do that: > "And why would you change that? Why would you change history? Why would you all of a sudden put bass on it? There is bass on it, but why would you remix an album? You can remaster it, yes, but why would you remix something and make it different? It'd be like… I don't know. Not that I'm comparing us to the Mona Lisa, but it's, like, 'Uh, can we make her smile a little better?!' You know?! Why?" That's quite sad but that's creator's decision.