3 ms·
did you ever received a review that you deemed unfair, unjustified, or inexplicable from some peer reviewed academic journal? Did that make you question the way
by filipponeri 5y ago
did you ever received a review that you deemed unfair, unjustified, or inexplicable from some peer reviewed academic journal? Did that make you question the way peer reviewing is conducted?
Unexpected Review is a community for researchers who want to publicly discuss unfair reviews that they have received asking feedback to colleagues.
Consider using the service and spreading the news among your friends working in research and come and visit https://www.unexpectedreview.net https://www.unexpectedreview.net
- jjgreen 5y agoWhy yes I did, so I did some more work on it and submitted it elsewhere. Sometimes it was accepted, sometimes it wasn't, in the latter case maybe the original review was justified. What I didn't do was kvetch about it on a public forum.