5 ms·
YT is the wrong subject for such a lawsuit. Creators affected by abusive bans would have to go after the entities filing DMCA claims "under penalty of perjury".
by mschuster91 5y ago
YT is the wrong subject for such a lawsuit. Creators affected by abusive bans would have to go after the entities filing DMCA claims "under penalty of perjury"... the problem is, either you're heading up against some shell company that gets dissolved at the first whiff of trouble or you're heading up against mega-corporations that spend more money for lawyers defending against your suit than you'll earn in your entire life.
- masswerk 5y agoAs I understand it (I may be in the wrong), the problem is that those copyright claims do not have any DMCA status. Which is the crux of the matter, as there are no real consequences to false claims other than those eventually effected by YT.
- msandford 5y agoI can't help but think that YouTube is the right target. I don't believe that the three strikes system is a part of copyright law or the DMCA. This is something that YouTube did beyond the law to avoid getting sued to oblivion. They might actually be the right target if their copyright claim system isn't the law but their own system.
- Denvercoder9 5y agoBut what law did YouTube violate? They're not obligated to host your content.
- anigbrowl 5y agoLaws don't have to be violate din civil litigation. Most cases are about torts (or contractual violations. big corporations generally get people to agree to big contracts that effectively say 'we can do anything and you have no rights ha ha' but as soon as any exchange of money takes place, things gt to e more complex. In extreme circumstances, contracts can be declared to be unconscionable. Of course, wealthy defendants often try to spin the process out as long as possible and then offer a fat settlement right before trial if all else fails.
- msandford 5y agoAgreed! They have no moral, legal or ethical responsibility or obligation to host anyone's content. They also don't have any legal, ethical or moral responsibility to ensure that any one copyright holder gets "their fair share" of the revenue for a particular video. The law already has a provision for the recourse copyright holders have if people use copyrighted material improperly. That's called a DMCA takedown request and it requires certain conditions to be met. What YouTube has done with the contentid and three-strikes system is to create an extra-judicial system for settling claims of a similar kind to DMCA takedown requests, but without going through the courts. That's their prerogative! But it may or may not be legal for them to do so, especially using the language that they use. For example something they might get sued for is fraud. These copyright claims that copyright holders are able to make. Are these legal claims via the courts? Or are they YouTube claims made through YouTube? What if YouTube has appropriated too many legal terms for this system? Imagine that I created a Security as a Service (SaaS) called The Police (tm) and for a small monthly fee you can subscribe to The Police (tm) and if/when you find yourself in some kind of tight spot they'll show up and fix things for you. It's not hard to imagine that this might not go well, and for similar reasons one could suspect that YouTube using legal-like terms for an entirely private "copyright policing" system they might eventually find themselves on the losing side of a legal challenge. It's really up to what kind of legal theories the plaintiffs could come up with that would put YouTube on the wrong end of the law.
- lupire 5y agoAre you under the impression that "security guards" are not legal?
- msandford 5y agoYeah I see the analogy there. Another counter analogy is imagine that a publisher finds out part of your book is plagiarized and they decide to give all your royalties to the person who you plagiarized without a court order to do so. A person might call that theft.
- ipaddr 5y agoFraud. Racketeering. Money laundering.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIf YouTube asserts a claim of authorship in violation of facts, the moral right of authors to attribution: That's 17 U.S.C. 106a under US Code, and is a key element of European copyright generally ("droit d'auteur") https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/106A https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/106A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights
- tinus_hn 5y agoThe dmca actually requires them to implement things like contentID.
- kelnos 5y agoNo, it absolutely does not. ContentID (and YT's copyright dispute system in general) goes much farther what the DMCA requires. Google's system is incredibly biased toward large content copyright holders, at the expense of small, independent creators.
- tinus_hn 5y agoIf Google hadn’t implemented ContentID they could very well have lost the suit from Viacom about Google not doing what the DMCA requires. And rightfully so of course, Google claims they can’t review everything for copyright infringement yet for instance they succeed pretty well in filtering adult content. While it is true that the YouTube takedown and strikes system favors large companies, it’s just about the same as the basic provisions of the DMCA, with the unwarranted takedowns, claimants who never get held to the ‘penalty of perjury’ for false claims etcetera. And compare exactly the same complaints about for instance Twitch.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If Google hadn’t implemented ContentID they could very well have lost the suit from Viacom about Google not doing what the DMCA requires. Viacom’s suit wasn't about DMCA requirements (in fact, it was originally dismissed based on the DMCA safe harbor, but that was reversed on appeal) but basic commercial copyright infringement.
- tinus_hn 5y agoIt’s one and the same, if you claim the DMCA does not protect a host, you say they are exposed to basic copyright infringement claims. That’s why the suit went through appeals from yes, the DMCA protects Google, to no it doesn’t, to yes it does to settlement.
- colejohnson66 5y agoWorth noting: ContentID is not the DMCA. If it was a ContentID takedown, you basically have no recourse outside YouTube.
- mschuster91 5y agoThe screenshots in the tweet and the thread look like a DMCA claim to me.
- kmeisthax 5y agoA related fact: some companies with ContentID access have an additional indemnification agreement with YouTube. They agree to pay any judgment brought against YouTube in exchange for YouTube ignoring DMCA counterclaims entirely. What that means is that if that particular claimnant decides they own your video, they own your video, and your only recourse is very expensive legal action against them to prove it's yours. YouTube has so thoroughly contravened the intent and spirit of the DMCA it's hilarious.
- EE84M3i 5y agoWhere can I read more about those agreements?
- snowwrestler 5y agoI don’t see how Google can ignore DMCA counterclaims because handling them properly is a matter of federal law. There is no way a private party can indemnify Google against illegal behavior. I would not be surprised if Content ID participants have indemnification agreements with Google related to Content ID, which is itself a private agreement.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Google cannot ignore DMCA counterclaims Yes, they can. > because handling them properly is a matter of federal law. They can ignore them unless they have some legsl obligation outside of the DMCA not to take the content down, because the only matter of federal law applicable to handling counterclaims properly is the DMCA safe harbor, which: (1) continues to protect against copyright liability to the purported rights holder so long as they do not restore the content without a proper counternotice, an (2) protects against any liability they would have under any other law to the user for taking down the content unless they fail to restore it with a valid counternotice. But, there is no separate liability for not honoring a counternotice, and Google (like most free content hosts) structurrs their relations with users so that there is almost possibility of liability for taking content down with or without cause, so #2 isn’t much of a concern.
- IshKebab 5y agoYeah I don't know. Yes YouTube has to obey DCMA takedowns but these aren't DCMA takedowns. They're part of Google's own ContentID system that they created themselves. They could definitely improve it to avoid this sort of nonsense.