6 ms·
>Robinhood users could not sell their GameStop positions while trading was frozen, a particularly difficult situation for those traders who borrowed money to pu
by gruez 5y ago
>Robinhood users could not sell their GameStop positions while trading was frozen, a particularly difficult situation for those traders who borrowed money to purchase the stock.
This is false. You could close positions (ie. sell), just not open new positions.
https://blog.robinhood.com/news/2021/1/28/keeping-customers-informed-through-market-volatility https://blog.robinhood.com/news/2021/1/28/keeping-customers-...
>In light of recent volatility, we restricted transactions for certain securities to position closing only.
- c54 5y agoAgreed. I think plenty of articles have covered what happened that day, and the conclusion is that the central clearing risk controls (which are designed to protect both traders as well as the system as a whole) kicked in appropriately to handle the skyrocketing single stock risk. The big problem here IMO is Robinhood's messaging. What the heck was their PR department thinking? Why didn't they just come right out and say "hey look, we have legal requirements which we're unable to fulfill in the short term, here's an explanation of the risk controls we're unable to meet. We want to help you do these trades safely, we're working to put more capital on the table for you, our beloved users"? Why molly-coddle your user base with "uhh sorry can't, goodbye"?
- hemloc_io 5y agoI agree and there are lots of potential reasons, some of them better than others. 1. PR people didn't really understand what was going on 2. Ppl at the company didn't expect retail traders to understanding what was going on. 3. They had trouble with regulation in the past and are trying to appear as a legit brokerage. 4. Maybe they figured that they could get enough capital quickly enough to open up trading again or they were in active negations with DTCC. (Which they sort of did.) EDIT: Formatting
- c54 5y agoThis makes sense. It’s easy to speculate on the right thing to have done, after the wrong thing has already been done. In the heat of the GME pump I’m sure things where 100% chaotic at robinhood HQ
- zenbane 5y agoThe big problem is a retail broker shutting down trading to protect hedge funds who were short. Confirmed in Congressional Testimony: "NSCC examined the market activity and clearing member margin requirements to consider whether it would be appropriate to adjust or waive the capital premium charge, as permitted under the applicable rule. NSCC determined that the spike in market volatility, particularly in the so-called meme stocks, was a material contributor to elevated VaR charges for several clearing members, including most of those subject to capital premium charges. NSCC determined that it would be appropriate to waive the capital premium charge for all clearing members, using the discretion provided in the rule to reduce or waive this charge.4 Just after 9 a.m., prior to the market opening at 9:30 a.m., updated daily margin statements reflecting the waiver were released in NSCC’s portal and revised excess/deficiency notices were emailed to clearing members. All clearing members timely satisfied their clearing fund requirements...NSCC’s role in the market is a neutral one. It does not impose trading restrictions upon its clearing members or their customers, and it did not instruct any clearing member to impose restrictions during the market volatility events of late January." - https://www.dtcc.com/-/media/Files/PDFs/DTCC-Statement-February-2021-Mike-Bodson.pdf https://www.dtcc.com/-/media/Files/PDFs/DTCC-Statement-Febru...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 5y agoThere's no evidence at all that any retail broker --- many besides Robinhood applied the same restrictions --- did anything to protect "hedge funds that were short", and substantial countervailing evidence. People have weird ideas about how settlement works.
- MattGaiser 5y agoMy understanding was that Robinhood was basically out of money to put up as collateral. What happens when a bank or broker announces that they are out of money? Historically, there were runs on them as customers tried to pull their money out to prevent being left with a worthless IOU. Now, that is now how things actually work, but I could easily see such an announcement causing that.
- mbesto 5y ago> What the heck was their PR department thinking? You must be new to RH's PR team. This is the same company that tried to roll out a 3% savings account, but had to pull it back because they deceived the public about it actually being a true savings account[0]. But the best part of this campaign was they got to keep all of the customer acquisition (even if some churned) to people they could upsell into brokerage accounts. Legality and ethics aside, this probably netted them more customers/money than the perceived mishap of the rollout...win for the PR team. [0] - https://clark.com/personal-finance-credit/robinhood-checking-savings-3-percent/ https://clark.com/personal-finance-credit/robinhood-checking...
- legitster 5y agoRobinhood would rather let people assume malice than admit to incompetence.
- HWR_14 5y agoThe problem was even people with no leverage were able to purchase GameStop stock. Yes, people who were using (or had already taken) any credit were locked up due to their collateral being all screwy, but people with cash were only impacted because RobinHood didn't properly manage their reserves.
- gruez 5y ago>but people with cash were only impacted because RobinHood didn't properly manage their reserves. ...because they failed to prepare for a 99 percentile event?
- zenbane 5y agoRobinhood, along with half a dozen other banks/brokers who were well capitalized all decided to restrict trading, and continued to do so until the price was 1/10th of the high. Just a little poor money management folks, nothing to see here!
- gruez 5y ago>Robinhood, along with half a dozen other banks/brokers who were well capitalized They weren't well capitalized. What gave you that idea? Just to preempt the "but DTCC said so" reply: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28000185 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28000185 >and continued to do so until the price was 1/10th of the high Because the price isn't a relevant factor. GME being 1/10th the price just means that people would buy 10x more shares, leading to the same deposit requirements.
- HWR_14 5y ago>>but people with cash were only impacted because RobinHood didn't properly manage their reserves. >...because they failed to prepare for a 99 percentile event? Because they used the funds that their clients had deposited to buy stocks with as cash to make their margin business work. At least that's how I understand it.
- spiderice 5y agoYes, but by doing so RH drastically lowered the value of their customer's assets. It's like your real estate agent knocking down a few walls of your home before selling it for half price.
- gruez 5y ago>It's like your real estate agent knocking down a few walls of your home before selling it for half price. Not really, because there's an extenuating circumstance that forced them to do it (ie. DTCC raising deposit requirements).
- oakwhiz 5y agoThat's untrue. The DTCC waived the additional capital clearing charges for all clearing members prior to market open on January 28th. All DTCC clearing members satisfied their requirements before the market opened. EDIT: Updated with source. I'm curious about the downvotes. 1. Page 4. https://www.dtcc.com/-/media/Files/PDFs/DTCC-Statement-February-2021-Mike-Bodson.pdf https://www.dtcc.com/-/media/Files/PDFs/DTCC-Statement-Febru...
- gruez 5y ago>The DTCC waived the additional capital clearing charges for all clearing members prior to market open on January 28th. Source? And for how long? >All DTCC clearing members satisfied their requirements before the market opened. That says nothing about the requirements they'll face later, as a result of trades made on the 28th.
- tptacek 5y agoThis is a WSB conspiracy theory. What in fact seems to have happened (I'm going from a reported account in Fortune) is that the NSCC substantially waved a multi-billion-dollar collateral call that would have bankrupted Robinhood because they halted trading in the meme stocks at question. WSB has taken this to mean that NSCC was unconcerned with the collateral risk.
- jaredeklee13 5y agoAppreciate the correction. Will update. I mixed up my frozen trading stories here. It was March 2020 where we saw fully frozen trades due to internal Robinhood infrastructure failures, unrelated to DTCC infrastructure and margin.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]