4 ms·
I'd like to note, donning my #2 at amzn hat again, that when the idea for affiliate sales originally came up, we certainly did imagine people creating pages wit
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
I'd like to note, donning my #2 at amzn hat again, that when the idea for affiliate sales originally came up, we certainly did imagine people creating pages with lists like "best bikes for under $500". However, I feel fairly confident in saying that nobody involved in that in the 95-96 timeframe was imagining that such pages would be created by anyone other than actual enthusiasts (probably a reflection of the state of the internet at the time).
In retrospect, this was a profound failure of our imaginations back then. It's also somewhat damning that in the 25+ years since, nothing about the affiliate sales concept has been substantially modified to mitigate the weaponization of this by "best X for 202X" pages.
- GoodJokes 5y agoFailure of imagination of the bad things Amazon would go on to do seems like the hallmark of the early days. Great job. Did you also game out the exploitation of warehouse workers?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI left Amazon after 14 months because, indeed, the exploitation of warehouse workers was obviously a part of the company's future. Didn't want to be a part of that.
- baggy_trough 5y agoAn actual "best X for 202X" page is extremely useful; the problem is that there are no search signals to distinguish it from a trivially created spam mockery.
- antihero 5y agoThere's consumer advocate sites like https://www.which.co.uk/ https://www.which.co.uk/ that are pretty cool. I'd be interesting in knowing other trustable sources, mind.
- robertlagrant 5y agoI came here to say this. Embedding trusted sources like that [0] would a) help fund such useful organisations and b) help drown out link farms. [0] in fact I think in Germany there is a state-sponsered impartial review body for consumer products.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoPart of the point of my other comment in this thread [0] is that we shouldn't need to drown out link farms. Google chooses to not hide link farms. Does anyone seriously think that a company (Alphabet) that is capable of sucking in known protein structures and then spitting out predicted structures for thousands of other proteins is not also capable of identifying link farm pages? Yes, it's a non-trivial problem, but chess, go and protein folding are non-trivial problems too. Google appears to have chosen not to treat this as a problem worthy of its capabilities. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27996639 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27996639
- hoppyhoppy2 5y agoThere is Consumer Reports in the US: http://cr.org http://cr.org They are a nonprofit that has been independent for decades and have strict policies against accepting gifts, sponsorships, ads, etc, and take other steps to remain free from influence. For example, when they review new cars they send an undercover individual to buy it at normal price from a random dealer so the company and the dealer don't know the buyer is CR (and maybe sweeten the deal or throw in upgrades or take steps to improve its reliability or whatever). They also review a lot of household and kitchen appliances, mattresses, etc. The New York Times now has their "Wirecutter" reviews of tech and household stuff, but they do rely on affiliate links for income so take that as you will. There is not a single independent consumer organization that can test every product out there, so if you're looking at road bikes you may end up with a different set of trusted reviewers than if you're looking at computer hard drives or roof shingles.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoCR also tends to limit itself to middle-of-the-range items. If you're actually interested in the best, their surveys don't always cover it, since they prefer to review things that most people can/would purchase. This has changed a bit in the last few years, but it's still the case that if you want to find solid unbiased reviews of, for example, high end ranges or washing machines, CR is not always the most helpful.
- lumost 5y agoI think that's a failure of imagination. In the early days of search engines and web crawling companies paid subject matter experts such as librarians and other experts to manually grade and categorize web pages. Spam pages tend to be filled with Ads and derivative content, owned by spam company domains, and do not provide unique information relative to other sources. If we as humans can recognize a spam page, why can't the machines? At the very least Google can penalize repeated spam domain owners/domains to help reduce the problem.
- CWuestefeld 5y agoIf we as humans can recognize a spam page, why can't the machines? I think that many of these automated aggregators have come a long way. On the better sites, it's not immediately obvious that the page is spam, until I've read some way into it and notice patterns in the language and a lack of "meat".
- marlowe221 5y agoMy dad can't seem to recognize spam pages 99% of the time...
- bjowen 5y agoI find the advertising to content ratio is a decent clue as well.
- rchaud 5y agoCan humans recognize spam pages though? Back in the day, such pages would be created on blogspot or other spammy domains, so there was at least a visual signal of some sort. Now the spam is on Facebook groups, Whatsapp group chats, TikTok, Twitter, Medium, Linkedin.....the list goes on. Online misinformation would not be as destructive as it is if people could tell the difference between say a credible news site and a Macedonian troll farm-run 'news' site written in broken English.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Now the spam is on Facebook groups, Whatsapp group chats, TikTok, Twitter, Medium, Linkedin.....the list goes on Of that list, Medium is the only one I would ever expect/want a search engine to even consider returning results for searches on "how to buy a bicycle for under $500". If I was King, you'd need to add allow:social to any google search to get any results at all from anything remotely like a social media or messaging application. I'd include LinkedIn and Pinterest and similar sites in that exclusion. If you want that stuff, you need to ask for it.
- keanebean86 5y agoAre those sites generated by bots now? They always seem to just be the top x results if you search on Amazon directly.
- mtoddsmith 5y agoThe reviews are usually somewhat accurate but only include items found on Amazon. So I'm guessing they hire people to write the reviews.
- FabHK 5y agoI have the impression that they use ghostwriters that summarise a couple of Amazon reviews, gain some superficial familiarity with the subject (talking points), but have no real experience with it. I've seen many of such sites (mattresses, bike accessories, VPNs, certain apps, etc.) that seem superficially plausible, but here and there betray profound ignorance of the subject matter.
- detaro 5y agoSome for sure are (i.e. some really just are stringed-together sentences comparing numbers), many probably are just really low quality manual work.
- jeltz 5y agoI would guess most are written by humans. I know a lot of affiliates (mostly gambling but also finance and shopping) and most of their stuff is produced manually. There is some more automation these days but the industry is surprisingly manual.
- sjg007 5y agoI imagine that once these "businesses" get a hold of GTP2 or GPT3 they will crank them out.
- hedora 5y agoI think they already have: https://francescocolumbu.com/best-laptop-for-openbsd/ https://francescocolumbu.com/best-laptop-for-openbsd/