8 ms·
After Neurodiversity
- giantg2 5y ago"Computer scientists and ‘techies’ wear the ‘neurodiverse’ label with pride" Is this true? Maybe I'm missing some context on this claim.
- laputan_machine 5y agoFrom my experience, compared to other industries, absolutely.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 5y agoComparatively I can see that. I just didn't think people were very open about it. I do know my company recently partnered with a resourcing company for neurodiverse contractors. I think it's mostly a marketing ploy because I don't see them hiring/promoting anyone as an employee who is noticeably neurodiverse. It seems deceptive to me, almost like segregating them. Not to mention they tend not to be very receptive of different thought patterns and opinions in my experience.
- caddemon 5y agoI have a family member that works at a company like that, they do basic skills training and then try to match the people with jobs. They end up mostly with people that were desperate for a job, meaning their disorder was bad enough they couldn't find one on their own. For those seeking engineering jobs, they usually are fairly skilled workers, but the deficits in other areas are extreme. People that would show up to the office smelling like they hadn't showered in a month. So at least in the case of this one company, it seems they are selecting not only for neurodivergence, but also for prior inability to get/hold down a job. I think for the companies that are considering hiring, it is a cheaper way to test potential employees than the normal hiring process would be. They get a free trial and can start the person at a lower payscale if promising, so they can benefit if the resourcing company manages to get a couple of the people to a hirable state. I would suspect there are also neurodivergent people who are more functional hired through the normal process, although maybe that varies by company. Certainly they're relatively common at FAANGs.
- giantg2 5y ago"So at least in the case of this one company, it seems they are selecting not only for neurodivergence, but also for prior inability to get/hold down a job." Yeah, that can make sense. My company doesn't really hire contractors into employees. They used to, but now they switched the policy. Basically, I hope our company is doing it for the right reason, but I doubt it based on the trajectory the company has been on lately. It seems in our case it's likely just PR. The company is finance related and I have only noticed a few neurodiverse individuals, and they are usually lower level and aren't promoted. I have heard that finance in general likes specific types to be quants, although I can't say how true that is.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- serverholic 5y agoI had a coworker that non-ironically said "I think autism is the next stage of human evolution"
- blamestross 5y agoI think it is realistic to say that having neurodiversity kicking around the genepool is evolutionarily beneficial. Social animals probably benefit from have a stable set of neurodiverse outliers showing up in the population. This is only more true as we invented oral history and civilization. We can mitigate the disadvantage and leverage the benefits of rarer perspectives. I'd argue high intelligence alone is a neurodiversity, we just don't pathologize it. It has plenty of undesirable side effects too. We also have situations where 3+ sigma outliers in brain function don't see any benefits at all and need constant support to survive in our environment (natural and societal). So, no autism isn't the next stage of evolution, but having somebody with 2 sigma deviation from normal cognition existing and contributing to society is probably more of a good thing than a bad one.
- caddemon 5y agoI certainly wouldn't call it the next stage of evolution, but it does seem to be increasing in prevalence with at least some of the cause lying in genetics: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/fullarticle/2765489 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/fullarticle/... I am curious to see how the population changes over time as a result of increased freedoms for women. It's only really been a couple generations so far (and only in some countries), but now that women and men are on more equal footing when choosing a partner (and both sexes are more likely to settle outside their hometown) you end up with a lot more pairings that match career status and to some extent intelligence. There's definitely going to be (on average) a difference in offspring between an MIT dude that married his secretary and one that married someone also from MIT, and for all we know the former may be healthier, especially as you extend this N generations. Of course that's a drop in the bucket relative to overall population size, but I think the effect could exist across various societal groupings.
- webnrrd2k 5y ago
- darkpine 5y agoI don't think there's people walking around in t-shirts that say 'neurodiverse'. However, I've definitely had interactions with co-workers or classmates that think they are the most special and the most smart, to the detriment of their ability to work with a team. Not sure if that's 'neurodiverse' or just bad manners. In certain online forums there's also a tendency to laud highly intellectual but somewhat antisocial behaviours, and to talk down about 'neurotypicals'.
- guerrilla 5y ago> I don't think there's people walking around in t-shirts that say 'neurodiverse'. There literally are though. I have friends that do but if you don't believe me, then [1] and [2] are for you. I'm not sure why you would think there wouldn't be considering the pride movement. The article talks about how the movement started. 1. https://www.zazzle.co.uk/neurodiverse_universe_adult_t_shirt-235876093862526079 https://www.zazzle.co.uk/neurodiverse_universe_adult_t_shirt... 2. https://www.redbubble.com/i/t-shirt/Neurodiversity-by-PrintPress/29774682.6N0CH https://www.redbubble.com/i/t-shirt/Neurodiversity-by-PrintP...
- thrower123 5y agoYou can discriminate and persecute introverts and misanthropes with no legal and few societal restraints. Claims to neurodiversity are in some sense a play (in some cases somewhat cynically) to take on some protections afforded to disabilities and minorities.
- giantg2 5y agoSometimes I wonder if things would be easier if I had a diagnosis. No idea if I would get one legitimatly though. (I wonder this because of the stories where people are diagnosed as adults, I had a professor in college that said I remind her of her autistic husband, and I've always been different.)
- uCantCauseUCant 5y agoImagine a fly bumping against a glass roof. That is what humanity was for most of its time in the past. Ressources oversupply, exponential growth, bump, war and then dump back into the valley of exaustion. Rince and repeat. Those who could repeat faster and without distraction, and add more genetic lottery tickets to the cycle, got rewarded by being more numerous. Try to envision humanity, not as a carbon copy of the same template, neuralwise, but as a adaptable to circumstances by shifting neuro-sub-group-proportions as a FFT curve mapped to the cycle. Those that were able to drag the society towards the part of the cycle that is most adapted to their lifestyle, got rewarded. These adaptions to the various stages of the cycle, is what we call mental sickness now - or neuro diversity. Now riddle me this. The cycle produces a creature, that is optimized for war. No compassion, no obsession but the one for the fight, no love, but for abstract concepts like the group, the country. How to integrate such a element into a society? If a facist, is just a mental-adaption to a world were the roof comes down every generation, were does it have a place in that city on the hill? Neuro-diversity is just a placeholder for a problem that is slowly recognized, but in the end, we will have to rewrite ourselves.. its the only way to get rid of lots of baggage. The schizophrenic living in the cardboard box outside of your office, is optimized for dangerous times, hostile environments, wandering great distances and improvisation. It could be useful if retrained and forced to contribute, but then again, is neuro-diversity a idea, that has a willingness to invest behind it.
- kochikame 5y agoI mean, it’s an interesting theory and all, but nothing more.
- JabavuAdams 5y agoFalse dichotomy. There is currently no good reason other than historical precedent and religion to believe that mind is separate from body. I.e. mostly brain + gut + maybe some physical/material factors we're not aware of yet. Let's just call this "brains" but understand that I mean brain + other organs + biochemistry. Totally agree that much of what we do, what we think, what we believe, both consciously and unconsciously is a product of culture and society -- not just the individual. BUUUUT -- culture and society are created by brains and experienced by brains. So, I expect that you have in your body physical artifacts that map to your understanding of culture, and your history of experiences in society. Like a lossy shard of the whole. So to say that we can't understand all of this in terms of neuro, or even chemistry, or even physics is wrong and a false dichotomy. To say instead that psy- studies provide a different (higher) layer of abstraction that is more expressive for describing and understanding certain behaviours is correct. If you're teaching someone tennis, you tell them where to put the racquet. You don't enumerate the positions of the atoms in the racquet. In the same way, neuro descriptions should be true. In fact more true than psy descriptions, but psy descriptions should be more useful for understanding large-scale behaviour. Invariably they will be a leaky abstraction and we will often have to go down to the neuro level of detail for greater insight. The other issue is that I think there's a stigma to psy-sciences because of poor replication, and poor statistical techniques. Neuro is supposedly harder science. You can fool the people, but not the molecules. Whether this is actually true is open to debate, but the the psy-sciences definitely need to up their game.
- jchanimal 5y agoYou are describing supervenience, in theory of mind it’s called anomalous monism. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anomalous-monism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anomalous-monism/
- anotherman554 5y ago"So to say that we can't understand all of this in terms of neuro, or even chemistry, or even physics is wrong and a false dichotomy." Since we are not omniscient, we can't understand it in terms of this. Certainly not now, possibly not ever. It's not even clear that you could hypothetically attempt to understand the human mind in terms of physics without invasively doing all sorts of horrific things to human test subjects.
- xyzzy_plugh 5y agoAs other comments subtly point out, this is a slippery slope. I don't know any folks who are neurodivergent who desire their traits. I have ADHD and while it's a minor blessing it's mostly a major, horrible curse. There's no amount of drugs, psychology or rehabilitation that will "fix me", to the best of current human knowledge. Sure, it's nice that society might be taking steps to accommodate me, but I'd rather just be a "normal" person. This is in stark contrast to folks for whom drugs, psychology and rehabilitation is proven to fix their problems. Should society be understanding and accommodating of people who don't fit the traditional mold? Of course. But should we pave a path for people to double-down on problematic behavior? I'm not so sure.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- caddemon 5y agoThere definitely are neurodivergent people who think that way, I'm not sure what proportion but I've absolutely seen it IRL in addition to the messaging being rampant online. In some milder cases I can see the argument, but I agree for the most part it gets into dangerous territory - doubling down on bad behavior like you said. It reminds me of how parts of the deaf community will refuse treatments that could improve their ability to hear, as they use strikingly similar arguments to the neurodivergent people that act like they have an advantage. People should be able to make their own choices about medical treatment of course, but I don't think we as a society/culture should be indulging delusions. Not being able to hear is very clearly a bug. With neurodivergence there is such a range of severity it's harder to quantify, but I've seen way too many articles/posts in ASD communities encouraging behavior that clearly shouldn't be encouraged. I think some of this arises from how hard it is to walk the line between accomodations and enabling. Society was so unaccommodating for a long time that I think we are seeing the pendulum swing the other way. It's interesting to talk to therapists that work with children, as it's especially critical to find this balance in that population. It can be a hard thing for the trained professional to determine in some cases, let alone for the parents to handle. Ultimately I think we need to emphasize the fact that everyone has things they could improve on, because that mindset seems to be increasingly lost across the board (see obesity epidemic, "I'm just not a math person", etc.). It's okay to struggle with something but it's an entirely different beast to stop trying because you've decided that society is actually the wrong one and you're perfect the way you are. Doubly so if you proceed to bitch about research on these issues (which others may have much worse!) or impose your beliefs on your children. The latter being a problem in the deaf community, as some treatments work much better at a young age but parents will deny for their children: https://time.com/76154/deaf-culture-cochlear-implants/ https://time.com/76154/deaf-culture-cochlear-implants/ Although it's hard to blame the individuals here too much, because it's compelling to humans for obvious reasons to push the blame off themselves, and when you see 1000s of people online agreeing that you don't have a problem, it's easy to believe that.
- serverholic 5y agoAs someone with mild autism I don't want people celebrating it. We should support autistic people but I don't want people celebrating a condition that causes myself and others significant difficulties in life. I'm worried that once we start "celebrating" autism, researchers will be scared to study it in fear of getting cancelled. This is important because there are studies that show, for example, that gut microbiome can affect autism symptoms. I might be downvoted for saying this but we should be trying to prevent autism, not celebrating it. Ultimately I'm pessimistic. I don't think normal people will ever truly understand and accept autistic people, merely tolerate them. This notion of celebration is just feel-good, wishful thinking. What'll actually happen is we'll pressure normal people into putting up a facade of acceptance. But privately, I think normal people will still want to avoid autistic people when possible. Will autistic people get invited to social events more often? Will normal people want to date them more? I don't think so.
- crazy_horse 5y agoThere is an overenthusiastic, uncritical way of looking at it, but there is a cynical way of looking at it, too. I realize now that I'm older that I'm a creep I'm a weirdo (I'm not a creep) and it is because I had a ton of undiagnosed neurodivergent behaviors that I didn't really figure out how to handle (or even have diagnosed) until I was in my 30s. Would I ask for my disorders? Would I want them on anyone? Hell no. It sucks, I've felt out of place more than once, not noticed obvious social clues more than once, and not wanted to exist for days on end more than once. I'm not going to throw a party over it and when people pat me on the back it annoys me. We're all fucked up, some more than others, and some more aware of it than others. However, I don't know about you, but to function in my mid 30s I'm pretty aware of my mental state. I know that I can be really, really wrong. Nobody has to tell that to me. I know how this machine runs and how it breaks down. I also know that a lot of people never ever figure that out because they don't have to. I think the part of this "divergence" that is absolutely, absolutely critical is the ability to see the world from different perspectives. We're slowly understanding the importance of that as a society through notions such as representation, but the way some people will look at you when you admit you are in one of these categories - you know we still have along ways to go. But be proud of yourself, things will continue to improve and most importantly, you've got a lot of wisdom you can share if you wish.
- hkt 5y agoI read this the other day and concluded that "psydiversity" is yet another academic wading in to tell people struggling for their rights that they're doing it wrong. The idea of the immutable self is definitely fiction, but it is a useful fiction which we use to prevent people trying to "cure" autism so we can instead be accepting and humane. It shifts the onus of change onto society instead of the individual, and ties in neatly with the social model of disability by doing so. By tacitly attacking the idea of the immutable self, the author opens the door to "cures" for autism, homosexuality, and a variety of other things which we're currently forced to accept. It may be the case that all that is solid melts into air but academics like this one accelerate that process instead of slowing it.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoThis looks like the classic "science vs. humanities" war. It's a humanities person (now a disciple of Focault, who they of course take pains to mention) attempting to take leadership of a social movement. It's fundamentally parasitism. (I want an article about what the Prophet Mohammed said about autism, and how we can make a better, more Islamic social movement. ... Actually we can probably find a Catholic analogue of that, if we look.) They make this clear in the following disingenuous paragraph: > Historically, both ‘psy’ and neurosciences have been mobilised to justify large-scale social injustices in democratic countries, from confinement to forced sterilisation and hormone treatments to ‘cure’ aberrant sexualities. We must be under no illusions here. However, it doesn’t make sense to denigrate one and eulogise the other. Indeed, often it’s psychologists taking a ‘softer’ approach to human motivation that’s served to ward off more draconian approaches to brain-based difference. For example, when eugenicists such as Carlos Blacker in the UK equated ‘mental deficiency’ with social and economic redundancy after the Second World War in order to advocate for sterilisation, it was psychologists such as Neil O’Connor and Beate Hermelin who argued that psychological and social intervention was always preferable. It's disingenuous because it says > it doesn’t make sense to denigrate one and eulogise the other. but then it immediately goes about setting up associations of badness with the "hard", sciency, "brain" approach (which, y'know, led to eugenics), and of better-ness with the "soft" "psy" approach, which is more "embedded in a historical context". Let's be clear what this is: It's a power-grab by a humanities person who wants to colonize this new identity-group on behalf of his field. It's the highbrow left-version of the thing Trump does when he tries to convince "ordinary (white) Americans" that they should go with him, and his ideology. It's a grifter showing up in the hopes of riding you to a career.
- ceilingcorner 5y ago"Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." - Phillip K. Dick
- tristor 5y agoAs someone with a form of high-functioning autism and multiple family members with autism (some very much not high-functioning), I hard agree with serverholic's point above. While some of my personality characteristics may be related to my autism, and those personality characteristics might have enhanced or enabled my engineering career, in general it's a seriously disabling problem that massively impacts my quality of life. I spent most of my youth seeing professionals and just begging to be normal. I don't want anyone celebrating my condition, I want you to treat me the same way you'd treat anyone else, including being critical if I behave in a socially unacceptable way. It's a critical feedback loop that's improved my life over time, albeit slowly. I'm now in a committed long-term relationship, work in a management role in tech that is built on relationship-building, and have overcome many of my anxieties. If I'd been coddled this never would have happened, god forbid my oddities had been celebrated. Autism is a disorder, if there's a cure for it or even anything that's proven to resolve common symptoms, that would be a blessing for the world. The new model of sociology has had deleterious effects on medical research, and we need as much research as possible into misunderstood conditions, not less.
- caddemon 5y agoI also worry about publish backlash if the neurodiversity movement continues to pick up steam. An increasing fraction of the general public is likely going to disagree with the enabling, and when that happens it usually involves an overcorrection. Especially because neurodivergence is much more likely to result in non-PC behavior, it is plausible that both sides could end up feeling resentment. It's going to be brutal for a kid being raised today with the coddling mindset if the real world decides to go back to the unnecessarily harsh old days.