5 ms·
M4 has some well-known uses like Sendmail and GNU Autoconf, but I don’t think this can be counted in M4’s favor: For operating in a standard Unix-like environme
by teddyh 5y ago
M4 has some well-known uses like Sendmail and GNU Autoconf, but I don’t think this can be counted in M4’s favor: For operating in a standard Unix-like environment, there is really no good alternative to m4 for generic text macro expansion. You can try to force cpp – the C preprocessor – into this, but it is really only suited to being part of a C compiler pipeline. For better or for worse, m4 is it in the world of Unix and shell tools, even though its syntax is quite annoying to use.
Of course, if you operate within a language ecosystem, you can probably find a nice templating system there. Python, for instance, has Jinja2. Or, if your needs are simple, you can use something more basic, like sed(1).
(Repost: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22770406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22770406)
- ricardobeat 5y agoIt seems to me that a combination of sed and simple shell scripts would be much better than this. The syntax is really not friendly.
- WmyEE0UsWAwC2i 5y agoM4 syntax looks that way because it has to work for arbitrary text files. Quotes can be redefined to an arbitrary string changequote(`[[[', `]]]') And some editor give you syntax highlighting.
- acdha 5y ago> M4 syntax looks that way because it has to work for arbitrary text files. That seems like an odd assertion given the existence of other templating systems which have friendlier syntax while being capable of generating arbitrary output. Is there a reason why you think on the M4 approach is valid?
- bonzini 5y agoMost templating systems work in combination with an external program written in a high-level language, e.g. Ruby for Liquid or Python for jinja2. m4 does not.
- zbentley 5y agoAnd m4 works in combination with a bunch of C code. Virtually any system with m4 can come with an interpreter for a higher level language without running out of space (I can't imagine many uses for m4 at runtime on systems where, say, a perl interpreter wouldn't fit). Why is relying on such a runtime a problem?
- bonzini 5y agoNo, m4 is written in C but it is autonomous. Liquid needs something like Jekyll around it.
- ricardobeat 5y agoWhat does “autonomous” mean? There are a ton of template engines that don’t depend on a parent framework, there is no reason you can’t implement all features in C. Something like mustache for example, which has a C implementation that includes support for includes/partials: http://mustache.github.io/mustache.5.html http://mustache.github.io/mustache.5.html
- bonzini 5y agoJinja2 is an API and it needs a Python program to determine the values for the substitution variable and invoke the template engine. In contrast the M4 executable is the engine.
- M3t0r 5y agoThere are a couple of tools that try to package Jinja2 (and probably also other templating engines like go-templates) in a CLI friendly way: - https://github.com/M3t0r/tpl https://github.com/M3t0r/tpl (mine) - https://github.com/kblomqvist/yasha https://github.com/kblomqvist/yasha - https://github.com/mattrobenolt/jinja2-cli https://github.com/mattrobenolt/jinja2-cli
- bloopernova 5y agoCan anyone explain how m4 is different to tr?
- timonoko 5y agoI can. tr translates letters, m4 translates words and simple expressions.
- ShrigmaMale 5y agoThe Mustache template language has a bash version that is good for simple stuff: https://github.com/tests-always-included/mo https://github.com/tests-always-included/mo
- packetlost 5y agoSeconding `mo`. It's pretty nice
- fomine3 5y agoenvsubst is forgotten one.
- totony 5y agoI use PHP when I need non-trivial templating. Always struck me as odd that people would invent/use their own templating engines (think HCL, jinja, smarty, m4). All of these are implementable as either a PHP file or a haskell interface