4 ms·
Why We Compete with Google
- senthil_rajasek 18y agoFrom the comment on the original post by the author. "But a company like Google that has such sky-high margins today will find it hard to stomach to adjust to lower margins. That is my real point." As far as I know financial statements don't reveal how many people are allocated per business unit ... curious how the author arrived at these numbers for the profit margins. How does Zoho plan to adjust to its own decreasing profit margins? Does Zoho believe that the off shore development cost advantage will last forever?
- daveambrose 18y ago"Now it is clear why we compete with Google. Google is perhaps the most stunning technology success story ever, but we simply don’t believe Google has the rational business incentive to get too deep into the business/IT software category. The lower revenue and profit per employee figures would be tolerable if there were huge growth opportunities there, but when very successful companies like Adobe and Intuit pull in revenues well shy of a Yahoo, when even the enterprise software leader SAP is smaller, and slower growing than Google (Google makes nearly as much in profit per employee as SAP or Oracle Salesforce make in revenue per employee), it is fairly clear this market is not going to make a material contribution to Google’s growth and profitability objectives. So what is Google’s plan here? It is fairly obvious they are in it to put Microsoft on the defensive on its home turf, so that Microsoft’s offensive capability in the internet is diminished. It is also perfectly clear why Microsoft wants to be an internet player - as Google has shown, it is a higher margin business even than its monopoly-profit core business."
- mattmaroon 18y agoThat is the worst logic I've ever seen. Loosely translated: "Microsoft makes hit tons of money, both per employee and overall, a huge chunk of which comes from their Office products. Google makes slightly more money per employee, but far less overall, none of which comes from their Office products. Therefore, Google would not want to succeed in the Office space. Why? Because Adobe doesn't make all that much." Huh? I'm just going to assume, since the poster's name is Sridhar, that he actually just doesn't speak English well enough to express his thoughts coherently, because it is either that or he doesn't have them.
- shabda 18y ago(The you read the Innovators Dilemma? They argue this point very well..) The logic goes something like this, as companies grow, they tend to move from lower profit margin businesses to higher profit margin businesses. Each company needs a specific profit margin over their overhead costs to justify investment of resources. Google with find it hard to invest in lower margin Office Suite business. > 2. I'm just going to assume, since the poster's name is Sridhar, that he actually just doesn't speak English ... Thats generally a wrong assumption, I have lived in India all my life, and >70% of my communication is in English. I am pretty sure everyone at Zoho uses English at Office
- mattmaroon 18y agoWow, way to cut my sentence off and attack it. How does this get voted up? Read PG's article about how to argue. Also, Office is an incredibly high-margin business. Google isn't moving into it because they don't expect it to return cash if it succeeds.
- bluishgreen 18y ago"Huh? I'm just going to assume, since the poster's name is Sridhar..." I stopped reading after this, since I understand that you cant complete such a sentence into something which will make any sense. Yes, we can all use a reading/re-reading of PGs article on how to make/present an argument.
- mattmaroon 18y agoWell, perhaps that came off differently than I meant it. His article came across as rambling and incoherent, and I was saying that may be due to English not being his primary language rather than a poor thought process. It's very hard to argue in a second tongue. Much harder than simply conversing. Nonetheless, I'm appalled that someone can cut my sentence in half, argue with an entirely different statement than the one I made, and get voted up that far.
- samataro 18y agowtf! am i lost or does this blog post make absolutely no sense?
- markbao 18y agoThat spreadsheet FROZE my browser as it loaded.
- ordinaryman 18y ago"I am saying support staff is absolutely vital to succeed in the business software market. That is one of the reasons revenue/employee numbers are lower." Google does want to reap money from such low-margin, support-intensive "business software markets" too. But not directly. It enables 3rd parties to build such applications over it's platform (GAE). Such suites will soon show up to compete with the likes of Zoho/Salesforce/Intuit/SAP. A quote from "Fear the Right Things" section in http://www.paulgraham.com/startuplessons.html http://www.paulgraham.com/startuplessons.html "What you should fear, as a startup, is not the established players, but other startups you don't know exist yet. They're way more dangerous than Google because, like you, they're cornered animals. Looking just at existing competitors can give you a false sense of security. You should compete against what someone else could be doing, not just what you can see people doing. A corollary is that you shouldn't relax just because you have no visible competitors yet. No matter what your idea, there's someone else out there working on the same thing. That's the downside of it being easier to start a startup: more people are doing it." Google makes starting such startups easier and it becomes a mass market again, with apps competing against each other, running on its platform. Whoever wins/loses, Google ends up making better revenue.
- 13ren 18y agoWho cares about employee count when you can have profitability? Using their spreadsheet (which I like, but not all the shortcuts work in the browser): profit/revenue as % MS 29% ORCL 25% GOOG 25%
- sridharvembu 18y agoI will respond to Matt Maroon's argument directly: revenue per employee is one of the most important metrics in a software company, which is about as pure human labor as you can get. The eventual business goal of every such effort, including Y Combinator (if you define "revenue" to include the proceeds of an exit, which is accurate when you consider that Y Combinator itself is an ongoing business entity) is to maximize revenue per person. So Google's management, having tons of cash to invest in growth, faces this question "What do our next 5000 employees do?" My argument is that even with a monopoly in two areas, Microsoft is underachieving Google in that metric today. A new competitor to Office, Exchange, Sharepoint etc. will, by definition, not be a monopoly (at least at first, perhaps for a long long time), so their revenue/profit numbers will have to be lower than the monopoly's numbers. Then there are markets like CRM etc. where very successful incumbents make a lot less than what Google makes today. Put all these together, and the conclusion is obvious. (I will ignore the irrelevant tangent on English - I have nothing to prove).
- burp 18y agoWhen daggers are pointed at innocent hearts And muskets are ready to fire When tyrants ride high and govern with fear As the forces of evil conspire Then from out of the night a hero must rise With courage that even a mask won't disguise They turn to . . . the man called Zoho One who's larger than life and defender of all Is this man who the people acclaim He's the one who strikes back for the poor and oppressed A hero . . . whose name is Zoho His name is Zoho