12 ms·
Perceptual distortions in late-teens predict psychotic symptoms in mid-life
- imvetri 5y agowhy does perceptual distortion occur?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 01100011 5y agoThis is a bit disturbing to read as someone who had perceptual distortions in my late teens. I always attributed it to HPPD after using LSD around 15 years old. Now I'm not so sure.
- ImuMotive 5y agoI get a world tilting thing maybe once a year. Usually while falling asleep. I also sometimes get this weird perceptual thing where objects look huge, again, normally while in a dark room. I've also had odd sensations that accompany these perceptual changes. All of these occur very rarely. Like I said, maybe twice a year, but closer to once per year. I can't find it now, but I had learned about seizure activity and how you can experience one without really knowing it, things just might get wonky like your perception, feelings, smells, etc.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoSounds like vertigo maybe? Does it feel like someone tilted the floor and there's no "up"? Followed by sweating and vomiting and 48 hours of headaches? (Source: I get it a few times a year.)
- ImuMotive 5y agoNone of that, it just looks like the floor is tilted forward. It doesn't feel like it though. It's a very odd visual distortion. I noticed while at the eye doctor when testing different lenses I guess he could recreate the feeling by using incorrect magnification on one eye? Making my brain thing the room is tilted left or right. Unrelated, anybody ever feel like they lost consciousness for 250ms? Super rare, but I get the feeling that I feel asleep and all my muscles went limp in that moment. It's like when you are falling asleep and you sometimes jerk yourself back awake.
- fzzzy 5y agoSee another comment on this post about Hypnic Jerk.
- meowface 5y ago>I get a world tilting thing maybe once a year. Usually while falling asleep. I think this is very common and occasionally experienced by most people, including myself. Typically when you're on the border between being awake and falling asleep. >I also sometimes get this weird perceptual thing where objects look huge, again, normally while in a dark room. Haven't experienced this one, but perceptual distortions in a dark environment shouldn't be a concern, I think. I definitely get thrown off sometimes. It's natural, since your brain is constantly trying to predict what should be there, and ambiguous signals due to limited light can throw a wrench into that, especially if you're not habituated to the light conditions. >I've also had odd sensations that accompany these perceptual changes. Could there be a nocebo effect? After learning about seizure auras, it's possible that when these things happen, you might enter a brief positive feedback loop where aura-like things could psychogenically manifest. Was this also the case before you learned about such things?
- EamonnMR 5y agoThe name for what you're talking about is Hypnic Jerk https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypnic_jerk https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypnic_jerk
- meowface 5y agoI was going to mention that, but I'm actually not 100% sure if it's the same thing. Maybe it is? Either way, I definitely occasionally experience hypnic jerks and sudden vertigo-ish feelings when I'm right on the edge of falling asleep.
- klipt 5y agoAlso a great name for a person who wakes you up just as you're trying to fall asleep. "You, you hypnic jerk!"
- pjerem 5y ago> I also sometimes get this weird perceptual thing where objects look huge, again, normally while in a dark room. Does this happen in total black ? I sometimes (really rarely, like once or twice a year) have a strange « feeling » at night while in my bed without any source of light : I can distinctively see the objects around me. The twist is : I’m heavily myopic and even with my glasses (which I don’t wear at night) I can’t see anything in the darkness. So there is no way I could distinctly see things with their contours in the darkness. It only happened in places I know, so I can’t know if my brain is making my bedroom up or if I really see something, or if it’s a combination.
- ImuMotive 5y agoWon't happen in total darkness. Also, it's happened in full daylight. Like all the sudden someones head just looks absolutely massive, like I've lost the ability to perceive size. I find the effect pleasurable so I kinda zone out and let it happen. Otherwise I can snap myself out of it pretty quickly.
- loves_mangoes 5y agoI've had an object appear huge once (right after an LSD trip), so might as well share my anecdote. For me it was in a dark environment (bedroom), but I was looking at my phone, without glasses, and holding it pretty close to my eyes (I'm also heavily myopic) so that it occupied maybe ~60% of my field of vision. The "picture" I had in my field of vision never changed, the "pixels" (though I don't think there is such a thing) did not change. But suddenly my phone was this giant monolith just above my head. Consciously I could clearly tell this was a hallucination, but the dissonance of having this seemingly suddenly huge object held right above my head was really unsettling to me, a bit scary even. I'm so used to not questioning how my sense of scale pretty much always matches what I see, it never occurred to me my instinct could be fooled by this wide a margin while consciously seeing that everything was normal. But on the other hand, I can't say I've really ever had an unusually distinctive awareness of objects like you describe.
- layoutIfNeeded 5y ago>I also sometimes get this weird perceptual thing where objects look huge, again, normally while in a dark room https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_in_Wonderland_syndrome https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_in_Wonderland_syndrome
- bamboo2 5y agoMigraine. You needn’t have a headache either. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2289227/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2289227/
- soared 5y agoFWIW the objects looking large is talked about quite a bit by epileptics and can be a ‘focal awareness seizure’. I got these as a kid and my family has a history of epilepsy but I’ve never had an adverse affect. https://epilepsysociety.org.uk/about-epilepsy/epileptic-seizures/focal-aware-seizures https://epilepsysociety.org.uk/about-epilepsy/epileptic-seiz...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iammisc 5y agoThe distortions while falling asleep is sleep paralysis. There's nothing weird about this. Every once in a while, i'll have this and there's an entity in my room. Once, everything in my room flew and the world 'cracked'. It's just a waking dream. Wiggle your toes, and things will go back to normal. Toes still work when the delusion sets in because it takes time for the hormone that causes bodily paralysis to get to your toes, and when the brain notices you moving your body, it wakes back up.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BizarroLand 5y agoBack when I smoked cigarettes I could tell I had smoked to much because I would get Alice in Wonderland Syndrome. I would feel like my bed was rotating in the world, my head would feel like it was too big for the room or that my feet would be dozens of meters away from me. I thought I was going crazy for a while until I found out what it was.
- meowface 5y agoHPPD would definitely be a major confounder, here. I really wouldn't be worried. If it's been many years since it happened and you haven't ever experienced anything that seems like it could be psychosis, then it very likely isn't something to be concerned about, I think.
- colechristensen 5y agoThey seem to be lumping things together pretty widely which is a disservice to people like you. A bit of hallucinating here and there is quite common especially as you age and isn't a big deal (though if it happens suddenly go see a doctor, it can be a symptom of something happening), being unable to determine what is and is not real can be quite a problem.
- anyfoo 5y agoCan you elaborate a bit? I don't remember hallucinating when growing up[1], so I'm interested what this would look like. I don't doubt that it may still be common without everyone experiencing it. [1] Or ever, really, unless fever dreams when being really sick count. Though, without any reference point to compare to, they really seemed more like intense dreams.
- throwuxiytayq 5y agoI consider myself to be a very mentally-stable person, but I have encountered occasional hallucination-like experiences. They're very brief, and my brain seems to correct itself retroactively, which makes them somewhat difficult to notice. For example, a soft noise could be vividly interpreted as someone calling my name, but when it becomes apparent that this didn't happen, my brain files the experience as "probably misheard something", and my attention is immediately diverted. Supposedly smell hallucinations are pretty common too. These are hard to recall because they're so unremarkable. It's difficult to tell these things from common daily "mistakes", but is there really a difference except in effect size?
- meowface 5y agoYes, these are quite common. I believe persistent, full-on visual hallucinations tend to be rare among the general population, assuming you're sober and not sleep deprived or in a half-asleep state or in the process of waking up.
- BrianOnHN 5y agoThis, and similarly Déjà vu, both happen to me too, very occasionally. I definitely also see a correlation with times I'm significantly fatigued, for example after being awake for 20 hours during a multi-day fast.
- iammisc 5y agoOne single dose of LSD can cause permanent psychosis, so this is not surprising. This is why drugs like LSD need to be absolutely banned. They can turn functioning people into permanently non-functioning ones. It is an incredibly dangerous drug.
- valec 5y agono, it's not. best estimates (admittedly poor) put the incidence around 1/50,000 for frequent users. considering the potential mental health uses and the extremely low toxicity (i'm not sure anybody has ever overdosed on lsd) banning psychedelics would be a huge mistake. and > They can turn functioning people into permanently non-functioning ones. It is an incredibly dangerous drug. applies to legal drugs too. alcohol for example. or painkillers or benzos.
- iammisc 5y agoOne drink of alcohol is unlikely to lead you to become unstable. I don't know about the others. I didn't call for a blanket ban. LSD may have therapeutic uses (other debilitating drugs like paracetamol do), but the self-dosing that people do 'for fun' shouldn't be tolerated.
- scollet 5y agoYou called for a blanket ban.
- iammisc 5y agoSorry, I figured doctor prescriptions were not included. My view is that they should be a controlled substance, the way they are now. You'd have to show amazing cognitive effects for an illness to legalize it for prescription. I don't know the science here though. By 'absolute ban' I mean they should be controlled, and classified as an illegal drug. This is not something people should self-medicate. Those using without a prescription or worse, distributing, should be jailed.
- 5y ago
- julienchastang 5y agoPossibly related article on synaptic pruning in adolescence: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41593-018-0334-7 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41593-018-0334-7
- colordrops 5y agoI have always had these distortions throughout my life. I sometimes feel like high-functioning psychotic. I recall the story of that researcher James Fallon that found out he was a psychopath when he scanned his own brain. Everything feels intellectualized rather than a concrete physical reality.
- GavinMcG 5y agoPsychosis and psychopathy are distinct, for what it's worth.
- handol 5y agoThe article seems to treat psychosis, psychotic symptoms, and Schizophrenia as though they all refer to the same thing.
- GavinMcG 5y agoBut not psychopathy.
- nextaccountic 5y agoPsychopathy isn't a medical diagnosis but it generally refers to antisocial personality disorder, which doesn't include psychosis in its diagnosis criteria.
- ma2rten 5y agoI think it's a common misconception that Psychopathy refers to antisocial personality disorder. It's a related but distinct concept. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychopathy_Checklist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychopathy_Checklist
- euthymiclabs 5y agoWhich is how people think clinically. Schizophrenia spectrum disorders are the most common forms of lasting psychosis. Psychopathy isn't related.
- AnEro 5y agoSo for the med nerds in here, what would this mean for someone that have something like a dysmorphia or other distortions around eating disorders. Is there a distinction between those visual distortions and a less structured one?
- leksak 5y agoIn a book on eating disorders I recall an anecdote relating back to World War 2 and interviews with people that survived various camps while extremely malnourished. Several people we're completely out of touch with how skinny they were. The book had a very women-centric perspective so the only stories pertained to women perceiving themselves as curvaceous (in the positive sense) despite being very skinny. Their body image was distorted from being so underfed but unlike a person presenting with something like anorexia the way they viewed their body was not as "hateful".
- metra 5y agoWhat is a perceptual distortion or aberration? Is it an umbrella term? What's included? Migraine auras? Vertigo? Seizures? Acid trips? I haven't been able to find a precise definition.
- meowface 5y agoNot sure if there's a clear definition, but the article lists these as symptoms: >These early perceptual distortions included a heightened awareness of sound or color, uncertainty about the boundaries of one’s body, feeling that the world around them is tilting, and similar experiences.
- ojnabieoot 5y agoFor me (as someone formally diagnosed with schizophrenia): as a child I had a lot of flickering lights/shadows and brief whispers/noises, horrible depth perception, frequent dizziness, and bad temperature coordination (sweating or shivering way too much in response to weather). One particular indication which I thought was universal but is apparently somewhat uncommon: visual “snow” in low light conditions, meaning that dark rooms look like grey TV static to me. (When my eyes are closed in the dark I usually just see black.)
- shrimpx 5y agoWhen I close my eyes I see "snow", and yes the same thing with my eyes opened in the dark. But this is normal, no? It seems like seeing pure black is abnormal. There will be some kind of noise on the optic nerve, it's hard to imagine it being hard "off".
- sitharus 5y agoSeeing snow when your eyes are closed or in darkness is fairly typical from what I understand. Visual snow as a diagnosis is visible at least in reading-level light and against light backgrounds. I see snow against all colours in a typical office environment. It’s less noticeable in daylight but still there.
- obvious8 5y agoWouldn't a better title be: Psychotic symptoms across a range of psychiatric disorders in midlife preceeded by perceptual distortions in late teens in xx percent of cases, exclusive of circumstances concomitant with perceptual distortion but not psychosis such as ptsd, synesthesia, autism, genius, artistic talent, prescription, drug, alcohol use, trauma, poverty, poor nutrition, health issues, the world actually being tilted...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- soared 5y agoThis reads similar to some reading I’ve done on epilepsy and visual/physical “distortions”: https://epilepsysociety.org.uk/about-epilepsy/epileptic-seizures/focal-aware-seizures https://epilepsysociety.org.uk/about-epilepsy/epileptic-seiz...
- tcj_phx 5y agoAll this study says is that stressed teenagers who don't know how to cope become stressed adults who don't know how to cope. People display more psychotic attributes when they don't have the resiliency associated with being a teenager. Emotional stress is the primary cause behind "psychotic breaks" and "schizophrenia" (a worthless diagnosis). Stressed brains need more fuel, derived from glucose, b-vitamins, etc. > The precise causes of illnesses such as schizophrenia are largely unknown, although genetics and brain-based factors are known to play an essential role. My understanding is Psychosis is basically a metabolic disorder: people become psychotic when their brain runs out of fuel. When I first met my friend who taught me about "mental illness", I thought she was 'high as a kite'. As the months went on, I noticed she was most chatty ("psychotic") when she was using crack cocaine. I didn't know about the term "psychosis" at the time, or that cocaine shreds the mitochondria [2][3]. When the effects of cocaine wore off, she was basically normal. When we ate well, she did pretty well. It wasn't until she ran out of alcohol that she became profoundly psychotic. The involuntary doctors said, essentially, 'Patient expects us to believe that she was psychotic because she was drinking 2 bottles of liquor a day, and using cocaine. We know that this is not the case because we previously got her stabilized on medicine 5 years ago and 7 years ago. After those year-long orders for treatment she discontinued services. Here it is, 4 years later and she's back in the mental hospital. She's clearly been psychotic this whole time.' I read that one of the problems of psychiatry is that they usually see people when they're at their worst, thereby missing that they were mostly functional just before they fell apart. One of the early nutritional treatments for schizophrenia was Niacin. Psychiatrists who think in terms of drugs managed to torpedo this line of research, so our doctors tend to not think in terms of physiology. But the research is still being done: Two-decade-long study links lack of vitamin B3 to schizophrenia among Indians - https://researchmatters.in/news/two-decade-long-study-links-lack-vitamin-b3-schizophrenia-among-indians https://researchmatters.in/news/two-decade-long-study-links-... Successful treatment of schizophrenia requires optimal daily doses of vitamin B3 - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19238764/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19238764/ Nutrition, NAD and exercise: vitamin B3 supplements to stay fit and healthy? - https://www.endocrinology.org/endocrinologist/135-spring20/features/nutrition-nad-and-exercise-vitamin-b3-supplements-to-stay-fit-and-healthy/ https://www.endocrinology.org/endocrinologist/135-spring20/f... My friend eventually figured out that she's a poor methylator whose genetics are such that she can't turn folic acid (a shelf-stable provitamin B-9 used to fortify foods) into L-Methyl-Folate. (My previous comments said the treatment providers ran this test [1][2]. She later corrected me: new clients at the treatment center were getting their cheeks swabbed, she wanted to be swabbed too. The test came back that she needed methylated B-9. She'd previously said it was like flipping a switch from 'depressed' to 'not-depressed'.) But the doctors kept her on tranquilizers anyways. Just last month she convinced her doctors to take her off tranquilizers. What's wrong with Psychiatry, that they think people become broken and require palliative treatments for the rest of their lives? Do any of you have any insights? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23859585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23859585 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15591378 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15591378 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22132272 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22132272
- re-al 5y agoI always wonder with these sorts of things, is it the person who is 'wrong' or it the society? Perhaps the society has too narrow a definition of 'normal', or perhaps the society we experience causes these issues (overcrowding, poor food+water, stress), etc. I also wonder whether 'mental illness' is a field where you can literally create illnesses in order to then treat them. Obviously, there are some genuine mental issues - I just don't think we are able to ascribe causality correctly, when the only ones trying to 'treat' the issue are the same parties that stand to make financial gains.
- tiahura 5y agoThis sounds rather intuitive. Is anyone using ML to look at inputs like 3rd - 6th grade writing exercises to predict things like schizophrenia and other mental illness?
- a9h74j 5y agoThe British Psychological Society produced a report[1] in 2014 or so from the perspective that specific symptoms can be found in populations on a spectrum, and significant in terms of treatment is the question: Do these cause distress? Looking for a link I found this[2] article in response, which contributes mightily to a back-and-forth. It is a longer read, but worth it. [1] https://www.bps.org.uk/what-psychology/understanding-psychosis-and-schizophrenia https://www.bps.org.uk/what-psychology/understanding-psychos... (YMMV getting past GDPR consents at that link; a second try worked for me.) [2] https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/saving-normal/201412/procon-british-psychological-society-report-psychosis https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/saving-normal/201412...
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe experiment had 191 random participants, and around .5% of people have schizophrenia. Without seeing the full paper, it seems like there would be single digit differences in the resulting cohorts.
- ordersofmag 5y agoThe original paper indicates the starting sample was 3500. On a quick read I didn't quite follow how things were narrowed from there (it's complicated) but it was not just 191 random folks off the street.
- ggm 5y agoYou could have predicted a parade of "but I had this.. does it mean.." from the story. (I wrote that as a late age male who read the medical dictionary and had everything, from leprosy to pregnancy. Classic hypochondriac)
- ribble 5y agonot forgetting the fact that 99% of psychiatry is 99% bullshit. goes parabolic within that last percent, though.
- seastonATccs 5y agoI went though Alice In Wonderland syndrome in my mid teens where it would feel like my hands would grow to a massive or super tiny size.
- warent 5y agoI had this a few times when I was really young, probably around 7 yrs old or so. Super bizarre perception distortions, it was really scary. The bed and my legs would stretch out really far, my fingers would become cartoonishly huge and swollen or tiny. But the worst part by far was the distortion of time, my experience could move in fast-forward, like 10x speed. I think around after puberty these things stopped happening. The developing brains of children can be so wild. I think it's a temporary form of synesthesia that happens as your synapses are developing and pruning.
- wydfre 5y agoThe government rations rationality, but hey, that's just like my opinion, man.
- dgan 5y agoI cannot relate to any of distortions mentioned in the article. The most "bizarre" thing that happens to me, is that I unvolontaly see wierd shapes and colors when about to fall asleep,that's about it
- chownie 5y agoI had alice in wonderland syndrome a lot as a child and a teen, I distinctly remember feeling like I was a smaller "core" further inside my body. I hadn't ever noticed this was clearly a perceptual distortion, but it is isn't it? For the most part I haven't had many psychotic symptoms aside from during lockdowns when I've had constant, obsessive thoughts about suffering. Sometimes I'll lay awake unable to fall asleep thinking about people forced into slavery, human trafficking, torture, my own future death etc.
- RalfWausE 5y agoAs far as i can think back i always had this weird thing that i heard something like distant voices whenever there was some monotonous background noise in the room (e.g. a fan running or so)... sometimes i could swear that someone called me from downstairs or from the neighbouring room, but in 99% of the cases nobody was there. Though... never spoke with a doctor about this, i just accepted it as one more fact on the "i am sometimes weird" list.
- pmdulaney 5y agoHow long before we see comic-character ads related to perceptual distortions?