3 ms·
Public health officials have the goal of maximizing public health, within the constraints of the law. This often requires second and third order thinking (IE,
by dekhn 5y ago
Public health officials have the goal of maximizing public health, within the constraints of the law. This often requires second and third order thinking (IE, anticipating the actions of people who don't want to comply, and finding ways to convince them or compel them, and even considering the actions of the people who are aware you are doing second order thinking so you can counter them).
I believe it is legal, and sometimes best, but most of the time not, for public health officials to say things which could be construed as "lies" (by a bad faith opponent) but, in full analysis, can be seen as ethically the most economic way to achieve a reasonable public health objective.
No scientist should make any public health pronouncements about herd immunity, there just isn't enough data to suggest its a clearly achievable goal. Make reasonable statements that are well-supported by evidence, and when you need to force people to do something for which there isn't full evidence, be transparent that it's not well-supported, but still prudent.
- whateveracct 5y agoPublic health officials are in a bad situation because average people are never gonna parse a nuanced paragraph explaining the situation.
- AndrewBissell 5y agoThis is both wrong, and an attitude that leads pretty strongly in the direction of authoritarianism.
- whateveracct 5y agoI agree that it can lead to authoritarianism. But it's not wrong. Ever read random convos on the internet? Like on social media? People cherry-pick sentences from essays and paragraphs and people have entire conversations divorced from full context. Because people don't read paragraphs, and they refuse to not be in a binary state of Yes or No. I'm not saying nobody can handle nuanced paragraphs, but I think if your message is always 5+ sentences with any complex logical structure, people will not get it. And bad actors will distort what you say to get people riled up in their favor.
- wkearney99 5y agoAnd it's a bad situation made worse by malicious actors with whole other agendas in play that seek to deliberately twist the explanations.
- whateveracct 5y agoYep - these bad actors will just pattern match or otherwise take things out of context (e.g. finding "contradictions")
- jjgreen 5y agoThe problem with these lies (not "lies") is that they erode public trust in official health advice, so provide support for the antivax crowd and their ilk.
- dekhn 5y agoyes, that's the third-order thinking. How to "lie" in a way that you don't get caught, but still achieve your ethical goal.
- jjgreen 5y agoWhen you treat human beings like objects to be manipulated with lies, you goal is not ethical.
- dekhn 5y agoIs the situation really that simple? Public health officials are working with folks that don't act rationally. Considered from a utilitarian view, if you save more lives by lying, it isn't unethical.
- kian 5y agoI believe that the person you are responding to is basically telling you that 'utilitarianism' is an unethical moral view, to them. Either that, or that there is no utilitarian who is capable of competently calculating the cost of eroding public trust on future life loss, and therefor one should not engage in it.
- version_five 5y ago> Public health officials have the goal of maximizing public health Partially correct, I'd argue they also have the goal of minimizing risk to themselves (things like criticism of policy, like what happened in Sweden, or anything that could jeopardize funding or tenure of the leadership). They are not there to make bold decisions, they are there to minimize flak. Also, like all bureaucracies, they have the goal of growing their influence and size. But even that aside, "maximizing public health" is not the only goal function we have, and when policy decisions are made like that is all we care about, it disenfranchises and discriminates against people who rightfully have competing priorities. This is ine reason why we have a constitution, and there are limits on what government can do. No one entity maximizing it's one goal should be able to trump all other natural rights that we have. Additionally, this is the danger of technocracy overall. The technician is not a politician who negotiates compromise between public good and individual ambitions. He works only to maximize what is in his purview. As such, he's great to listen to for input, but should never be given free reign to dictate peoples behavior.