3 ms·
No, because the underlying data demonstrated that there was a statistically significant death effect occurring, with a wide range of evidence implicating prions
by dekhn 5y ago
No, because the underlying data demonstrated that there was a statistically significant death effect occurring, with a wide range of evidence implicating prions, before there was a mechanism. You shouldn't require a plausible mechanism to trust your experiments (seen this a hundred times, like in RNA enzymes, heart of the ribosome, various dna-is-the-heritable-agent experimetns).
- XorNot 5y agoYes you should: because all you have otherwise is a death rate that could be caused by any number of things. Biological organisms die all the time for all sorts of reasons: there's a difference between showing a series of factors lead to an death rate, and proposing the specific mechanism by which that happens and it's important. That light behaves like a wave did not summarily prove there was an aether through which it propagated, and not finding it up-ended physics.
- dekhn 5y agoNot only did they know the death rate, they had an infectious agent in a tube they knew was protein. If you identify a reproducible agent you can study in the lab, you don't need any plausible mechanism. Note that aether was the plausible mechanism, and it mislead people for a long time. The experiment that "disproved" aether just showed that the mechanistic proposal was simple, and wrong.
- jjk166 5y agoClearly you do not need to know the mechanism by which light waves propagate to prove that light waves do propagate. It would be ass-backwards to wait until special relativity was formulated to accept the existence of electromagnetic waves.
- XorNot 5y agoShowing you have an infectious agent in a vial is not showing what that agent is.