4 ms·
"This is somewhat insulting to to those of us who, despite being "sophmoric" technologists, are actually quite well rounded." Only if you commit the logical fa
by timr 15y ago
"This is somewhat insulting to to those of us who, despite being "sophmoric" technologists, are actually quite well rounded."
Only if you commit the logical fallacy of assuming that "a way" means "the only way". Saying that X is a way of getting to Y does not imply that !X is not a way of getting to Y.
Said differently: there are lots of different rites of passage in our world, and they're not universal. Jewish people see the Bat/Bar Mitzvah as a rite of passage to adulthood; Catholics have confirmation; certain young girls have debutante balls. This guy thinks a liberal arts degree is one particular rite of passage, and it's no more or less insulting than any of the others.
- zinkem 15y agoI think the term "rite of passage" may have prompted the response. A rite of passage is generally something that every member of a culture (or subculture) goes through to get from X to Y.
- timr 15y agoThat's why I wrote the second paragraph. It's still a logical fallacy to assume that "rite of passage" means "this is the only way to proceed". It's just an event that marks an important stage in someone's life. There are lots of different rites of passage in every culture/subculture, and most people ignore most of them. If you're atheist, is it "insulting" that Jewish kids have Bar/Bat Mitzvahs?
- zinkem 15y ago>If you're atheist, is it "insulting" that Jewish kids have Bar/Bat Mitzvahs? No. If a someone told me I am not an adult because I had not had a bar mitzvah, I might be insulted. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rite_of_passage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rite_of_passage