4 ms·
Prions are weird. I was at UCSF during the time they went from a fringe theory to an established fact and a nobel prize. The professor who studied them (Prusi
by dekhn 5y ago
Prions are weird. I was at UCSF during the time they went from a fringe theory to an established fact and a nobel prize. The professor who studied them (Prusiner) had to overcome tons of resistance and the experiments were heroic (often waiting months for mice to die). It's really funny that everybody resisted it until somebody mentioned that there was a plausible physical mechanism of refolding catalysis.
- jtbayly 5y agoMakes complete sense that there was resistance until a viable mechanism was proposed. Otherwise it just sounds like voodoo.
- dekhn 5y agoNo, because the underlying data demonstrated that there was a statistically significant death effect occurring, with a wide range of evidence implicating prions, before there was a mechanism. You shouldn't require a plausible mechanism to trust your experiments (seen this a hundred times, like in RNA enzymes, heart of the ribosome, various dna-is-the-heritable-agent experimetns).
- XorNot 5y agoYes you should: because all you have otherwise is a death rate that could be caused by any number of things. Biological organisms die all the time for all sorts of reasons: there's a difference between showing a series of factors lead to an death rate, and proposing the specific mechanism by which that happens and it's important. That light behaves like a wave did not summarily prove there was an aether through which it propagated, and not finding it up-ended physics.
- dekhn 5y agoNot only did they know the death rate, they had an infectious agent in a tube they knew was protein. If you identify a reproducible agent you can study in the lab, you don't need any plausible mechanism. Note that aether was the plausible mechanism, and it mislead people for a long time. The experiment that "disproved" aether just showed that the mechanistic proposal was simple, and wrong.
- jjk166 5y agoClearly you do not need to know the mechanism by which light waves propagate to prove that light waves do propagate. It would be ass-backwards to wait until special relativity was formulated to accept the existence of electromagnetic waves.
- XorNot 5y agoShowing you have an infectious agent in a vial is not showing what that agent is.
- contravariant 5y agoIt's not exactly that rare for a phase transition out of a metastable state to happen spontaneously when given an appropriate nucleation seed.
- boxed 5y agoNot really. Look at how Darwins theory of evolution was published in 1859, while the mechanism wasn't really clear until at earliest 1928, and in some ways it's still not fully understood.
- ricksunny 5y agoIf ancient Romans could have shown correlation & causation between lead pipes & drinking vessels to poor health outcomes, they should have ceased using lead for these purposes even while lacking the capability of understanding the underlying mechanism. There's no voodoo in that.
- dmix 5y agoThis bit in the article drove home how difficult it would be: > The two types of CJD can only be distinguished through a postmortem examination of brain tissue.
- varispeed 5y agoIs it because many researchers put their ego first over the science? It's so many times that they ridicule ideas, that often amounts to bullying and then they rarely even say sorry when it turns out they were wrong. Why won't academia flush out these types of people? The toxic atmosphere with no way of getting rid of bad apples is what put me off from studying.
- hprotagonist 5y ago>Why won't academia flush out these types of people? Because this behavior is part of human nature. Do you think scientists as a class are are somehow exempt from this, say, by some form of rationalistic purity?
- Swizec 5y agoIt’s because discovering something completely new and unheard of that isn’t even hinted at hy any existing theory is extremely rare. Most people with such claims turn out to be wrong, doing bad experiments, fudging data, or worse. The scientific community is resistent to such things because 90% of the time they are right to be resistant, the hypothesis is conclusively disproven, and we never hear about it again. Sometimes, rarely, the claim comes through, survives the scrutiny, and scientists quickly change their minds based on new established fact. Imagine if someone came out with “I have found a way to run 50 compute cycles per CPU instruction!!”. We would justifiably ridicule that person’s idea as implausible or impossible. It would take a lot of evidence to change the whole computer industry’s opinion on what’s possible.
- patall 5y agoExactly, though I would rather put that number at >99%. I would think, its kind of black swan event where in hindsight, everyone thinks its easy to see but it was not. Recently, we see that here and there with covid research where some single lab (or doctor) comes up with theory that matches some peoples preformed believe. When most scientists then oppose that theory, those people claim that this one of those <1% of cases were all the science is disproven, citing all the cases where it was, failing to see the many more situations where it wasn't.
- agumonkey 5y agoany article about the replication mecanism ? not too short, not too detailed (if possible) thanks
- andrewflnr 5y ago> everybody resisted it until somebody mentioned that there was a plausible physical mechanism This is a good instinct IMO. Experiments by one person can easily be nonsense, especially if you don't already know and trust that person. Without a physical mechanism, given extraordinary results, I would certainly remain skeptical.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]