5 ms·
> then someone comes along with their four accounts and downvotes every comment I got In HN you can send an email to the mods so they can take a look. Also the
by gus_massa 5y ago
> then someone comes along with their four accounts and downvotes every comment I got
In HN you can send an email to the mods so they can take a look. Also the site may detect it automatically (the details are unclear, it's part of the secret sauce).
> because I'm not sufficiently ideological
Avoid political threads. Everyone is talking pass each other, and you will not convince anyone. Upvote grey comments if they are not offensive or very wrong, and run away before you get angry and want to start downvoting everyone.
Try to stick to technical threads, preferably if they have less than 100 comments. You will be happier.
- ulucs 5y ago> Avoid political threads. Coupled with the new catchphrase "everything is political", this is quite impossible to do.
- cyberge99 5y agoI haven’t heard that new catchphrase to date. There’s an old joke about the Network OSI layer: What are layers 8 and 9? Political and Financial. I think the context with things like that refer to internal business politics and having diplomatic conversations versus State or National Politics. Avoid religion and politics in general seems like solid advice as it’s too emotionally charged for most people to discuss purely logically. (Also, there are too many x factors and most politicians are relatively short term (speaking of USA here).
- state_less 5y agoThe ground you walk on is not political. If folks learn to take it easy, we'll be in better shape.
- JohnWhigham 5y agoeverything is political Can't stand this phrase that literally came out of nowhere. People will try and justify it with walls of text about the oppressed, blah blah, when it's just an excuse for them to chide you about why you're wrong and why this issue intersects with their politics.
- minikites 5y agoName a subject or domain that involves people which isn't "political".
- dmpk2k 5y agoMe taking a shit? :)
- shoemakersteve 5y agoIs it right for you be taxed for using the sewer system? What are the environmental impacts of the massive scale of human shit having to be processed in treatment plants? Why does the government prevent me from shitting wherever I want, infringing on my freedom? First they take away your rights to shit on your neighbour's porch, then they take away your rights to see your kids on weekends. Stepping stones to tyranny.
- justin_oaks 5y agoYou're demonstrating that everything can be made political by those who want to take it on a political tangent.
- baq 5y agoNot OP, but yeah, that was the point. Humans are social, thus political, animals.
- goatlover 5y agoThat just means there’s a political element to human interaction, not that everything is political. Astronomy is about the cosmos, not politics, but astronomers engage in politics like everyone else. There’s an entire world outside of humanity, and some people are not interested in turning that into more human bickering, which you can easily find in explicitly political and news discussions.
- fendy3002 5y agoDisagree, downvoted! /s Aside from political discussion, I see that opinion (say os or console X is better than Y) also bring downvotes. I find that asking questions and giving facts (not a wrong one) won't get downvoted and stay at 1 at worst.
- higeorge13 5y agoI have been downvoted in technological threads, just expressing my past experience on docker. Should we avoid those as well?
- popcorncentury 5y agoMore accurately, everything is ideological at its core. I say this as science. Even tabs vs spaces is an ideological battle. And so is for and against downvoting. I am against downvoting because I am against censorship and for free speech. And to then say "avoid ideology" or to be modding a platform based on a "no ideology" ideology is like being against meaningful conversation on a conversation platform. So we are left with excessive pampering and everyone walking on eggshells. Whenever something gets ideological, we can't handle it and so we censor it. Or hide behind a downvote. All because we're not allowed, and hence have had no practice. The platform that can handle political discourse without breaking will be the next great social media platform. We owe it to ourselves to build it, instead of pretending this is already it, whatever your platform of choice.
- spaniard89277 5y ago> Avoid political threads. Everyone is talking pass each other, and you will not convince anyone. Upvote grey comments if they are not offensive or very wrong, and run away before you get angry and want to start downvoting everyone. I upvote everyone on this bases. In reddit for example, If I sort by controversial more often than not it just someone with an equally dumb or smart but different opinion. Discussing stuff in the Internet is difficult, and requieres a very good moderation, something that IMO HN does a good job, for what I've seen. Reddit is the wild west of subs, there are good and bad mods, but once a sub becomes too popular it's just impossible to avoid vote brigading. I've also been administrator for a number of forums, and it's basically volunteering job. If you're not paid or getting a profit from it it's very hard to justify the work and the headaches that require to moderate a community. In fact that's the main reason I've closed or sold the communities I had. In the end, there's not a lot of people who is willing to have reasonable and educated discussions, and nobody can do it all the time, so IDK, hope someone else has the energy, I don't. From the communities I had, there's only one left. It has not a lot of users, yet I need time and energy to learn programming while I keep going to my current job and juggle with my life, so I'll probably experiment with it to automate moderation in some way, hopelly not making it miserable for the users.
- pavlov 5y ago> ”Upvote grey comments if they are not offensive or very wrong” Maybe there should be a separate URL to view recent comments with <1 points? /graycomments, or /controversial, or something like that. I’d certainly use that to sprinkle some upvotes. There are often high-quality comments that get downvotes early for whatever reason. It has a discouraging effect even if it gets corrected over time with more votes.
- gdsdfe 5y agoI think you're missing the point of what the guy is saying ... He's not asking for tips and tricks to live happier in a downvote world. He's saying, I think, that downvotes are conversation stoppers and does not help us get to the bottom of things and they should not be the default were people form communities.
- fidesomnes 5y ago> Avoid political threads. Everything is political in the cultural total war that is modern leftism including the weather, Google search results, twitter censorship, forest fires, dildos, wedding cakes, and the family members of journalists your side doesn't like. Only one outcome is tolerated and we all know what side that is.
- marcosdumay 5y ago> Avoid political threads. It's not the political threads that are a problem. There seems to be a few companies that you can't contradict in any way on the threads that repeat their mantra. It's usually not even the large ones, so it's very surprising when you get in a discussion that's quite visibly on a bad sideline, you point a technical flaw, and get downvoted into the minimum, just to have your comment go back up by the long tail of people upvoting unfairly greyed comments. (And you only discovers the "culture sponsor" if you go back and read the comments again.) I imagine that's also unavoidable in a forum where a number of people that breath those mantras through the day frequent. I don't think there's any manipulation going on (except for workplace propaganda), but that does make technical thread political too, and it's probably very disorienting if it's a technical subject you care about. Anyway, I don't think HN has any penalty for accumulating downvotes. So I don't think there's any improvement to make here.