13 ms·
I've got a broken combine harvester – manufacturer won't give me software key
- wyldfire 5y ago> And it doesn't address issues such as product designs that complicate repairs, > We see that in design choices like Apple's soldering of RAM to motherboards, I support lots of ideas behind Right to Repair, but I also think that Apple and other manufacturers sometimes make a serviceability/performance design tradeoff when opting out of socketed memory or CPU. I realize that it can create more waste but I think it shouldn't be constrained. Software lockouts like the ones described in the article are bad. I like the idea of John Deere and Apple being forced to provide service manuals or critical service/repair software. But I also don't want this to become San Bernardino shooter 2.0. The service tools shouldn't be able to subvert things like Trustzone/Secure Enclave.
- mdoms 5y agoAs long as you people keep shoveling money to companies like John Deere and Apple this will keep happening. You have a choice.
- abalone 5y agoOne point about smartphones that doesn’t necessarily apply to combine harvesters is that gluing everything together enables more compact, durable designs. There are plenty of arguments against this but there is a big one for it: consumers like compact, durable products. I actually read the FTC report and it doesn’t actually offer a good argument on this point, concluding only that “further research is required” to see if consumers would be willing to make trade offs for better repairability.[1] [1] https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/nixing-fix-ftc-report-congress-repair-restrictions/nixing_the_fix_report_final_5521_630pm-508_002.pdf#page34 https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/nixing-fi...
- tpxl 5y ago> gluing everything together enables more compact, durable designs Maybe a tiiiiiiiny bit more compact, but definitely not more durable. Frame.work can apparently produce easily serviceable, rather thin designs of laptops that are even modular (www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rkTgPt3M4k). This is way thinner than my 2008 era HP and thinner than my 2021 era Lenovo. As far as phones go, the PCBs are a tiny part of the phone (The cpu, ram, storage combined are less than 1/2 of the phone surface area and probably less than 1/4 of the volume) so gluing them together doesn't even get you much. You might get a _small_ bit by soldering in the battery in the sense that you then don't need a "box" for the removable battery, but that is a small amount of space compared to the battery itself.
- TheParkShark 5y agoIs the only purpose of the glue to make it harder to disassemble? If nothing else changed but glue wasn’t added would the product still function and look the same?
- mrguyorama 5y agoIt makes waterproofing a bit easier I think
- 8note 5y agoI don't think customers like small compact designs. They generally keep their phones in large cases to get the size back up
- iso1631 5y agoSo I didn't drive my tractor through your haystack last night?
- colinb 5y agorelevant song for context https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tb63PdPweDc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tb63PdPweDc
- gadders 5y agoI wondered if many people would get the reference from the headline. Here's the chorus: Cuz I got a brand new combine harvester An' I'll give you the key Come on now let's get together In perfect harmony I got twenty acres An' you got forty-three Now I got a brand new combine harvester An' I'll give you the key
- sideshowb 5y agoI once had a ragtime jam session in a pub with one of the wurzels. Ooo arr ooo arr!
- orangepanda 5y agoFarmers are in a position to spin right-to-repair as a matter of national security - a cyber attack could leave the nation without a food supply
- jacquesm 5y agoFarmers are pretty much slaves to large corporations now, they still have some clout but it is diminishing day by day. Large supermarket chains buy out the independent farmers after first unfairly dumping produce to depress the price to where the farmers go out of business. Then they put their own people in there, typically for a regular wage and without any power to set prices or to ensure that a farm is operated sustainably and responsibly. A nationwide independent farmers strike on the basis of right-to-repair laws probably wouldn't get off the ground but if it did then effect might be less than what is needed to effect change and could very well play right into the hands of their opposition.
- Turing_Machine 5y agoYeah, that ship has pretty much sailed. People no longer spin their own thread, weave their own cloth, and make their own clothes. Most of the metal objects we own are cranked out by the millions in a factory, not hand-forged by the village blacksmith. And so on. To the extent those activities still exist, they are hobbies, or maybe skills exhibited as part of a tourist attraction. For some reason, though, the "family farmer" still has mystique, while the "family weaver" and the "family blacksmith" don't. There are a number of reasons for that, but on a basic level, the situations are exactly the same, and are occurring for exactly the same reasons -- large-scale mechanized production is simply more efficient on every level. When clothes were spun, woven, and tailored by hand, most people could only afford one or two garments. When all metal objects were hand-forged by a smith, they were scarce and super-expensive. Sometimes people would burn down old buildings just to salvage the nails. Same thing with food. Other than for psychological or medical reasons (anorexia and such), it is very, very rare for people to starve to death in modern Western societies. That wasn't the case in the era of the "simple family farmer".
- 5y ago
- wccrawford 5y agoI predict that they'll eventually get what they're asking for: The ability to service their equipment with whoever they want. As a consequence, though, the initial price of the equipment is going to go up. And then they'll be complaining that they can't even afford to get started. I honestly think they should be able to get it repaired wherever they want. But it's not actually going to fix all their problems, it's just going to shift them around.
- libertine 5y ago>As a consequence, though, the initial price of the equipment is going to go up. What would be the arguments for this price increase? Because if they are factoring in servicing into the price of the equipment, then I think that would be even more serious case of planned obsolescence (if we can even use that term here...). Maybe then someone will pick up that inefficiency and develop a new brand of affordable equipment - if the US gov. would allow that of course.
- RandomLensman 5y agoI would not put that into the planned obsolescence category necessarily. Factoring in the lifetime value of a customer doesn't imply that. On heavy machinery there are/can be parts that just really wear down/need maintenance. One of the questions is how profitable is the manufacturing, sell, and maintenance of farm equipment (for example)? Maybe some of the wallets redistribute between buyers, sellers, and maintenance firms - maybe not if the economics are poor. If the profits were to come mostly from maintenance, then pricing could not just stay where it is (absent new market entries creating downward pressure).
- libertine 5y ago>If the profits were to come mostly from maintenance, then pricing could not just stay where it is (absent new market entries creating downward pressure). I just can't wrap my head around that. I mean, if that was the case then probably asset depreciation/wear should be reframed in accounting/finance, because not only they lose value but they have a added cost (arguably planned, since it's part of the pricing structure and business model of that equipment). In the end you're just paying to rent parts that will need to be replaced and paid for, because the equipment won't work without it and they can only be serviced by X player... farming equipment became just extremely large printers, where buy them cheaper to then get looted on refills?
- hnbad 5y agoThe title of the article is a pop culture reference that may fly over most people's heads, so for context here's The Wurzels performing the song "Combine Harvester (Brand New Key)": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tb63PdPweDc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tb63PdPweDc The song itself is a parody/adaption of the Melanie song "Brand New Key" ("I got a brand new pair of roller skates, you got a brand new key"): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iivxuz3dB8k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iivxuz3dB8k
- jet_32951 5y agoAmazing this knowledge is still around. I first heard this song in a bar in Portsmouth UK July 1976.
- hnbad 5y agoI learned about the song watching the 2005 b-movie Evil Aliens: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0383353/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0383353/ The song is featured prominently in an iconic scene involving said farming equipment (CW: mild spoilers and splatstick gore): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8dMlkGKoZE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8dMlkGKoZE (diegetically the song is played back from an audio cassette labelled "motivational farming music" in Welsh)
- mwcampbell 5y agoToo bad the title broke the meter. How about, "I've Got a Broken Combine Harvester, Please Give Me the Key"?
- tibbydudeza 5y agoVW has a good aftermarket parts market for wear and tear items (clutch/brakes) for the Golf Mk2/Mk3 which is very popular with car modders. B5 Passat - dealer only for brake pads/discs - when the car needed a clutch replacement the cost was one of the reasons why I traded it for a Corolla. There should be viable non OEM parts market.
- halifaxbeard 5y agoThere’s no aftermarket/non-OE brake options for the Passat? I find that hard to believe, I thought VW raided Audi for chassis bits for the Passat.
- cartoonworld 5y agoIn the US market, I've found pads and rotors on the aftermarket for VW Passat for any model year including 2021. Centric sells pads and rotors front and rear. VW (and others such as some Jeep) uses an electronic parking brake which requires a scan tool to command the ECU to enter maintenance mode in order to retract the electronic motor on the rear axle to allow the piston to retract. You can do this at home if you have a scan too. If you do not have a scan tool it is still possible to do it manually by disconnecting and removing the EPB servo and manually retracting, but it tricky and not recommended. They use triple square fasteners on the bracket, and are typically a pain in the ass for this make. Is there something else I'm missing?
- jacquesm 5y agoThis is why I'm a great fan of less electronics. An electronic parking brake is a non-feature. It takes away your option of leaving the parking brake off (they tend to seize when activated for a long period). It can break. It make service harder and more expensive than it should be. The classic 'Mini' had it just about right: what isn't on there can't break or fall off.
- swader999 5y agoAn ebike fits this idea fairly well. I commuted for several years on one when I lived in the city. After about a year I could fix anything on it. Was quite liberating.
- supermatt 5y agoI appreciate that the title is a pun on the wurzels song, but article is about a tractor not a combine harvester.
- TekMol 5y agoCould an alternative to "right to repair" be "pay for the value of the service"? So if the tractor works, it generates money for the manufacturer. If the tractor fails, the manufacturer would be charged - say - $1000 per day. This way the user would not care if the tractor works or not. If it works, they make $1000 from hay. If it does not, they get $1000 from the manufacturer. Even if the manufacturer is not interested in this business model, it could be provided by a third party. Either as an insurance against non-working equipment or as a full service by a company that buys the tractor and provides it under the "pay for the value of the service" model.
- rvanlaar 5y agoHeard the same thing about doctors in China. You only pay when you're healthy.
- 7thaccount 5y agoNot a farmer, but missing a single day's planting can cost a lot more than $1000. It could me $1M+ if I had to guess.
- TekMol 5y agoThen the farmer would chose a $1M/day insurance instead of a $1000/day insurance.
- 7thaccount 5y agoOr we just make it to where we actually own things we buy.
- grumblenum 5y agoI think it’s relevant to plug OSE https://www.opensourceecology.org/ https://www.opensourceecology.org/ There are free designs for a large number of useful machines, but the trade off is that you have none of a manufacturers’ warranties for safety or useful life. Personally, I think it’s a lot more palatable to subsidize open designs that can be easily modified by a user instead of legally compelling a manufacturer to give the world their intellectual property. I think a few $M in grant programs to uni engineering programs with a few paid senior industry consultants could really make a difference (I think the motive force behind OSE is basically one guy).
- kortex 5y ago> I think the motive force behind OSE is basically one guy). That's what it looks like; at the very least, they are extremely short staffed vs the problems they want to tackle. They have been at it for years and have barely made progress in terms of the actual wiki. Their main problem right now is you need a pretty full-blown machine shop and access to lots of materials to make the machines. That's fine for industrialized countries, but if you want to help mechanize the developing world, you are probably better off making a tractor which can be kitbashed from a Toyota Hilux. What they ought to be focusing on is the "API" - a standard spec for attaching X to Y. A POSIX for PTOs, if you will, but for more parts than just the PTO. A standard rubric for machines and accessories across the farm, like Morse taper but wider in scope. Regardless, I'd love to see that program get an infusion of cash and talent, and get a full tractor design out the door.
- dna_polymerase 5y agoThese sort of projects are great but as someone in this discussion pointed out, we are talking about food supply. No manufacturer should be allowed to fuck with that in this way.
- grumblenum 5y agoThe manufacturer is making food production at scale possible. John Deere does not “fuck with” you when you buy its products. Expropriating their trade secrets because someone decided this was a special case seems capricious. Why not nullify Pfizer’s patents? Do we not have a “right to repair” our bodies with their drugs? Why not seize Google’s monorepo and publish it in the Library of Congress? Do we not have a “right to repair” our information systems? I guess picking the winners and losers of this policy is to be left up to the lobbyists?
- jacquesm 5y agoTo fix this you first need to fix corporate lobbying. As long as the beneficiaries of the laws get to write the laws this bullshit will continue. And the pox on any software engineer's house that implements this shit, you're co-responsible for it.
- leaveyou 5y agoSpot on. And what makes things look even more hopeless is that the people willing to hit at the roots of the problem and fix the corporate lobbying are not in congress and probably can't even get on a ballot because their voices get throttled early. You need a lot of money to fight other money. How is that going to happen ?
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoIts very easy to fix corporate lobbying. Just limit contributions to x dollars (indexed to % of poverty level or whatever) to persons that can vote. This takes away the personhood of corporations and takes care of moneyed interests. However this would require a constitutional amendment in order to not come in conflict with free speech. Alternatively, you could make elections outcomes somewhat random, and effectively rendering the prize (officeholding) a lot more uncertain and therefore, not worth the risk. Imagine winning a campaign for state senate and getting swapped with the 2nd place ranked for comptroller. Who's going to put money in that campaign
- bloniac 5y agoHow do farmers feel about these harvester companies?
- KMnO4 5y agoI have no idea what company is in the article since it doesn’t say. But if it’s (likely) John Deere, we avoid them like the plague. Granted, my family’s farm is “hobby farm” scale. I see plenty of Deere’s on actual farms. But for me, it’s not worth it. I’ve been half a mile into brush at quarter to midnight fixing a Kubota with very basic hand tools. I have a repair manual that shows how to service every part. It’s how it SHOULD be done. Most people who rely on a tractor don’t have time to mess around with John Deer concierge any time they hit a bump the wrong way.
- jacquesm 5y agoThe same way you feel about Google: they dislike them but have no alternative.
- jet_32951 5y agoSmaller / family-owned farmers detest them [0]. Large / agribusiness farmers tend to think of this sort of equipment as tractor-as-a-service and generally have uptime agreements with service organizations so their problems get fixed first. [0]https://www.extremetech.com/computing/246314-farmers-pirating-john-deere-tractor-software-stick-man https://www.extremetech.com/computing/246314-farmers-piratin...
- Aeolun 5y agoThere’s 350 ish million people in the US, and together they throw away only 400k phones per year? There must be something wrong with that statistic.
- johnchristopher 5y agoMaybe there are lot more people like me who cling to their 4.6 inches smartphone from 2015 and refuse to buy anything new since they got it second-hand for 250 bucks (500 +/- 100€ at launch) and every review I read always have some huge problems (battery life or photo or reception or poor screen or anything). /s
- have_faith 5y agoMost phones end up at the back of a drawer.
- caymanjim 5y agoYeah, I've still got phones from 12 years ago. I upgrade, hang on to it thinking I'll give it away to someone (if it still works), or just toss it in a drawer and forget about it until I move. Then I run into it a year later, think for five seconds about bringing it to the electronics recycling place, and promptly forget about it for another year, because driving to the recycling place is a pain in the ass.
- kissgyorgy 5y agoMy dad used to repair our cars on his own when I was little. He can't do that anymore, because even our simplest car have 2 computers on board now. It's a fucked up future we are looking at.
- lixtra 5y agoYour dad’s car was using 3 gallons per 100 miles. The computers do add some value.
- swiley 5y agoThere's no reason computers should mean you can't repair your car, I repair my computers. That's just a shitty bait and switch marketing trick like the idea that ARM computers cant run FOSS just because of the architecture.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gmueckl 5y agoNo, using computers means exactly that: hardware is now commonly designed to run in conjunction with very specific software control. Without understanding the overall design very, very well, modifications can essily result in delayed comsequences that are hard to understand. The end result is a device that can have a reduced lifetime and/or become dangerous to its environment because the changes introduce a new failure mode. The source code to the software doesn't help much. It doesn't document design decisions that can relate to electrical or mechanical properties of the device. I am not agaist a right to repair in general, but what I want to see is pretty strict regulation that repairs to potentially hazardous devices may only be performed by trained professionals. E.g. the brakes in your car would be off limits anyone except a licensed mechanic. But manufacturers would have to supply documentation, tools and spare parts to any qualified mechanic, not just their own dealerships.
- iamtheworstdev 5y ago
- nickdothutton 5y agoFarming machinery and all heavy equipment/large capital investment items are moving to a use based model. Manufacturer raises debt (his cost of capital is low), builds and leases machines to the customer. Customer pays per ton of grain harvested, per hole drilled, per cubic metre of rock crushed etc. As a farmer why would you want to pay for a machine that is idle most of the year outside of harvest time?
- ohadron 5y agoFor harvesters, the machine will probably be idle most of the year no matter what, since it doesn't make sense to transport it to the Southern hemisphere. So ultimately the farmer will be paying for it.
- bluGill 5y agoMany combines are sold to custom harvesters. They buy them when harvest starts in the south (North America, other continents have different patterns), work them for 16 hour days, and sell them in the north when the season is over. They may be only one year old, but they have been worked hard - equivalent to 75000 miles of city driving on a car! Someone will still buy them (dealers in the north know this is happening and have plans to deal with the influx) as they have a few more years of life for someone who does their own harvest, but they are well used by this time.
- aivisol 5y agoBecause the harvest happens at the same time for all farmers? The harvesting machine will be idle for most of the time anyway, so there can only be one renter at the time (unless you will ship it to Southern hemisphere for half of the year).
- TheRealDunkirk 5y ago> As a farmer why would you want to pay for a machine that is idle most of the year outside of harvest time? Because you want to invest in your business? So that, once it's paid off, you can stop giving part of your profits to someone else? You know, the old 7-year-payoff rule of thumb? That old chestnut? This is the problem with most industries in our over-capitalized system now. In every sector, large companies are trying to monopolize at least a horizontal -- if not an entire segment -- so that they can extract rent from the market forever. The very notion that people are allowed to own things, and not pay service fees till the end of their life, is utterly vanishing, from huge farm machinery to freaking light bulbs. Letting companies permanently insert themselves into our daily use of their products is a total change of mindset, and one which people over 40 will probably never be comfortable with. There's something fundamentally opposed to the idea of a free society when you have a dozen companies requiring constant access to your homes and appliances and cars and personal electronics at all times, in order to keep them running in any useful way. Beyond simple monopolization, every company is doing it. This is quickly leading to an almost collusive situation where there are entire product categories are becoming exclusively IoT devices, with soon-to-follow subscription fees, and there will be no other practical alternatives.
- cletus 5y agoThe whole "right to repair" issue is somewhat complex but farm equipment is a pretty good example of the why this is necessary. For anyone that doesn't know, farm equipment generally lasts a long time. There are farms out there still operating 70+ year old John Deere tractors. With proper servicing such equipment lasts a really long time. Nowadays such equipment attracts a premium simply because it is so simple and can be serviced by the owner for many simple things. You don't need to pay for and (sometimes worse) _wait for_ a "qualified" tech with the right computer to fix a faulty sensor. Companies deliberately make equipment that cannot be serviced to increase total revenue and it's a disgusting and egregious form of rent-seeking. As an aside, your car's warranty is essentially a scheme to make more money similar to this. Using parts of services that aren't "genuine" can void your warranty.
- kickout 5y agoNot sure how you are concluding machines to day are more simple than they were 40 years ago. If anything, they are 100x more complex with electronics, way more hydraulics, plastics, iron, engine mods to achieve power and efficiency. The 'old' tractors are basically a motor strapped to a chasis (e.g. JD 4020). Although my gut reaction is to side with the farmers, its not so black and white. Nobody is making them buy these 'locked down' tractors, they are choosing to. Money could speak louder than words
- neogodless 5y ago> With proper servicing such equipment lasts a really long time. > Nowadays such equipment attracts a premium simply because it is so simple and can be serviced by the owner for many simple things. The comment is about how old, well-maintained equipment is simple and attracts a premium. The manufacturers are coupling "locked down" tractors with... you know, tractors. If there are competitively produced tractors without the restrictions on owner maintenance, they will sell better, but if that market doesn't exist, the farmers cannot simply vote with their wallets. The complexity of the modern tractors does make it a difficult market for new entrants, so the existing ones own the market, and choose some of the restrictions. It's not a simple problem - modern systems are complex, and so it's not trivial to ensure it's repairable without sophisticated tools and knowledge, but it's still a problem worth examining.
- IgorPartola 5y agoThis keeps coming up and makes me wonder: this sounds exactly like a golden opportunity for another manufacturer to offer a different business model. What prevents a new company from selling combine harvesters at a premium price that use widely available parts and sensors? Or what prevents a cottage industry of replacement motors, ECUs, etc. from taking over where John Deere et al are acting in this way? It seems to me that the only reason I would want to buy one of the big name machines is so that if it breaks down I can quickly get it repaired and not lose much due to the stoppage but that’s clearly not the case here so why bother with them and why don’t better options exist?
- bluGill 5y agoDeere makes a ton of money selling parts like those sensors, so that won't work. ECUs need a dealer mostly because they are machines are easy to part out, so by coding the ECU to the tractor it insures there is no black market for used parts and thus no tractor theft to get those parts. (The other reason is some ECUs are reused by many different things so you need the correct code loaded onto it) Near as I can figure out, right to repair is really code for I want to bypass the emissions controls on my equipment. Deere employee, but not speaking for my employer. My opinions are my own.
- IgorPartola 5y agoBut capitalism. If Deere makes more money selling parts that means parts wear out too quick or are overpriced. As Bezos said, your margin is my opportunity. What exactly do I get, as a consumer, from not being able to swap an ECU for a different one myself? What is the benefit for which I would be paying the premium? I have never seen right to repair be framed as trying to bypass emissions. Especially considering the content of TFA and the fact that it also applies to consumer electronics and such. What makes you say that it is?
- bluGill 5y ago> I have never seen right to repair be framed as trying to bypass emissions. Of course not. Nobody with any intelligence will admit that is their real intent. That would be political suicide.
- andrewtbham 5y ago"It's what enables Tesla to turn off features that it doesn't think certain users should have." As someone who follows Tesla closely, it is destroying my trust in the media. This line would lead you believe that Tesla does this on a regular basis. I know that's not the case. If you click the link it's referring to an isolated incident that involves a single largely anonymous person (alec). So it makes me question the whole article. This story is also anecdotal... does anyone know if this really even a problem? If it were, it sounds like an opportunity for a competitor to make a simple to repair harvester.
- post_break 5y agoPeople have bought cars with software already bought and paid for and Tesla has taken it away. So yes, Tesla does do this. Tesla blacklists people from super charging as well.
- TheParkShark 5y agoI thought the blacklist for supercharging is on salvaged titles? You can still charge at home but not on the supercharging network.
- ncallaway 5y ago> If you click the link it's referring to an isolated incident that It doesn’t matter to me that Tesla has only done it once (that we know of), the thing that is disturbing is the capability of Tesla to do this. The fact that vehicle functionality can be locked behind a Boolean column in the Tesla database is itself the thing that is problematic and disturbing. And the article in this instance seems accurate, in that they were referring to the capability for Tesla to do this (by pointing at an extant example), rather than claiming that Tesla had a widespread issue of abusing this functionality.
- andrewtbham 5y agoI get your point... you're concerned "the capability" but my point is... why mislead? what else are they misleading about. > It's what enables Tesla to turn off features that it doesn't think certain users should have the misleading part is the phrase "doesn't think certain users should have" it sounds like it's at tesla's discretion but in fact they are referring to a single accident.
- wonderwonder 5y agoI think this is the key part of the article: "Every time a state introduces a bill, Apple hires the most expensive lobbyists in the state to try to stop it, and they were successful...". Corporate lobbying groups funded by large corporations exert massive control and influence over the US government at the state and federal level. They often write large sections of the bills that are ultimately passed and they fund the campaigns of the politicians they are attempting to influence and often provide them with jobs once their political careers are over. Regulatory capture is very much alive and well. As long as lobbyists have so much influence politicians will continue to use groups like family farmers and individual soldiers as political / advertising illusions while pumping money into the groups belonging to the men behind the curtain, massive corporate farms and defense contractors. This plays out over most large industries, tech included.
- lordlimecat 5y agoAs I've thought about this, the conservative in me has reared its head and asked, "Why is this a federal issue?" And the more I think about it, the less of an answer I have. This primarily affects farming states, which are in a really good position to pass laws that force manufacturers to either comply or leave the state. California has had good success doing this with other things (e.g. emissions standards), and farming is a niche enough category that JD can't afford to just ignore an entire state of farmland. I don't live in such a state. I know some of the story, but it's not my problem and it's a bit presumptuous for me to step in and assume that I understand it well enough to solve it. Federal legislation usually does a bad job of solving the original problem anyways, after all of the sides are done negotiating over it. Far better for the farmers of Nebraska to directly appeal to their state legislators and get a bill that truly addresses the issue.
- blamestross 5y agoflipside to this idea is that corporate interests have an easier time capturing state and local governments then the federal government. JD culturally OWNS those states you are talking about.
- ck2 5y agoPeople are slapping down $200 a month for tesla features, how long until tractors have a $2000/month fee.
- theodric 5y agoI've got a brand-new combine harvester, and I'll give you the key! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZY6jC5Dh6c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZY6jC5Dh6c