10 ms·
Large cars kill US pedestrians, don't make drivers safer
- RegnisGnaw 5y agoThe headline seems to be lying. I quote the article: “ The rate of pedestrian deaths has been increasing recently, even as driver/passenger deaths have fallen.” So it seems to be safer for the passengers and drivers. The link makes no defence to not making the driver safer.
- jeffbee 5y agoThe abstract says "I find no evidence that the shift towards larger vehicles improved aggregate motorist safety." That driver deaths have fallen doesn't imply SUVs caused them to fall. Occupant safety has improved across all vehicle types.
- 908B64B197 5y agoAre people also less healthy than they were, on average, 20 years ago? For instance, obesity and its associated illnesses won't make recovering from a crash easier.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIf the driver/passenger death rate has dropped similarly in, say, Toyota Corollas and Mini Coopers - which I suspect is the case - the article's headline remains accurate.
- Supermancho 5y agoThe headline is inaccurate, that is correct. The term "lying" doesn't make sense here. There's plenty of data that larger vehicles make the driver safer...which is common sense. eg the number of tank drivers that die in accidents when in a tank. https://www.iihs.org/ratings/driver-death-rates-by-make-and-model https://www.iihs.org/ratings/driver-death-rates-by-make-and-...
- tupac_speedrap 5y agoSUVs are getting ridiculous. They are too wide and long for narrower UK roads and parking spaces but I keep seeing more and more, and they are getting wider.
- LightG 5y agoCybertruck has entered the chat.
- MiddleEndian 5y agoShaped like a wedge so it can not only slice through pedestrians, but also boxier cars like the Scion xB!
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoWhy are SUVs so much more profitable than cars?
- akmarinov 5y agoYou can charge disproportionately more than the resources you put in, since it’s bigger.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThey cost more?
- gabereiser 5y agomarketing to suburban mothers. It started with "SUV's are safer" which then led to "SUV's can carry more" and the other option of "SUV's aren't minivans" to woo over the dads. Eventually it became the question of "can I afford to put gas in it?" as well as "do I ever want to go offroad?" (even if they never plan to). Car Talk gave an interesting history here: https://www.cartalk.com/blogs/jim-motavalli/how-we-got-here-history-suv-mania https://www.cartalk.com/blogs/jim-motavalli/how-we-got-here-...
- 5y ago
- wil421 5y ago1,100 extra deaths from 2000-2019 doesn’t seem like that much. I would’ve expected it to be higher. In 2019 there were 36k total fatalities in 33k accidents. IMHO, the flat front fad in many new model trucks is going to cause more issues than bigger vehicles.
- sjg007 5y agoDeaths should trend down as tech and safety improve.
- colinmhayes 5y agoDepends on how much usage increases. I don't see any claims of deaths per driver or mile or time driven going up in the article from a cursory glance.
- kevingadd 5y agoI would expect that if deaths increased, injuries probably have increased dramatically in severity alongside that.
- akira2501 5y agoThere may be a weak correlation here, but the author doesn't seem to explore it. Other factors to consider when analyzing accidents: Age of driver, Was the driver intoxicated, and (incredibly important for pedestrian accidents) what Time of Day was the accident and what Type of Road was the accident on? The last time I looked at the data, the 2015 FARS data set, the biggest factor in pedestrian deaths seemed to be pedestrians walking at night along roads without a dedicated sidewalk. This happens in rural areas far more than you may think.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoNight drivers are the worst. I occasionally jog at night and have a stretch of road where there is no sidewalk. I have reflective gear and a headlamp on. I had someone have the audacity to stop and honk their horn at me because I was jogging in the left lane...which is the lane your supposed to be cause you can see the oncoming traffic.
- cycomanic 5y agoThe author not only correlated the increased number of deaths with the increased number of large vehicles around, but also found that there is cities with larger increases in vehicle size had a correlated larger increase in deaths. So essentially there is a correlation on different levels, which is a much stronger indicator for causation. If you are saying this is a spurious causality you should suggest alternative reasons why we should see the correlation. To me it doesn't seem that there should be any reason why cities with increased vehicle sizes should also have increased number of people walking on the roadside without sidewalks. Moreover considering the large numbers we are talking about i would imagine intoxication for example would average out.
- frontiersummit 5y agoI remember looking at the same data some time ago and reaching the same conclusion about accidents at night. Another factor was that the pedestrians themselves are very likely to be intoxicated.
- zip1234 5y ago"the biggest factor in pedestrian deaths seemed to be pedestrians walking at night along roads without a dedicated sidewalk" So... pedestrians existing? It sounds to me that people are driving too fast for the road conditions.
- bryanmgreen 5y agoIf anyone has ANY additional data around the dangers or problems to either people or the environment by large / heavy vehicles, please reach out. I am preparing arguments for stronger regulation around vehicle size/weight. Focused on non-commercial usage. Email in profile.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe fact that regulation precludes the viability of a small vehicle that is able to punch above its size (like a Chevy Astro, or older Ford Ranger) in terms of capability is a large part of why vehicles have grown so large. Commercial needs that used to be served by these small vehicles are being solved by F150s and Transits. Commuters who used to commute in hatches and wagons which could sufficiently perform their weekend duties as well are buying crossovers and SUVs which have nearly identical interior dimensions. This vehicle inflation has been largely driven by fuel economy and safety regulations. The road to hell is legislated with good intentions.
- majormajor 5y agoSeems like the smart thing to do would be to treat law and regulation as something that needs - just like any other product - continual feedback, iteration, and improvement. "Oops we created this bad side effect, let's narrow things down further" in the same way that we'd patch a security hole introduced by a new product feature. Saying "the answer is to just stop trying to prevent bad things" is nonsensical on the face of it. The problems that caused people to care enough to want regulation didn't just magically go away!
- asdff 5y ago>This vehicle inflation has been largely driven by fuel economy and safety regulations. Why don't we see this in europe, or japan, or any other first world urban area where you see a proliferation of tiny trucks, tiny vans, tiny vehicles, mopeds, etc? Surely these other places also chased fuel economy savings and safety, but they ended up with a market that looks (and weighs) a lot different. I doubt these cars are any more dangerous or less fuel efficient than some American market car. What sort of policies were enacted in these places that lead to the markets for these small vehicles, which we don't see here?
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoVehicle weight increased more before pedestrian deaths skyrocketed. His wording is correct, but headline readers will infer that the correlation fits across time, to before smartphone popularity.
- foxyv 5y agoI've noticed that taller vehicles tend to drive much faster in places where pedestrians may be. Being up that high messes up my ability to judge speed making it feel like I'm crawling. I'm really careful and slow in parking lots. Especially when I'm driving my truck. But I see 3 ton SUVs zipping around like sports cars in some parking lots. Absolute insanity. http://vehicledynamics.com/suvs-why-you-may-drive-fast/ http://vehicledynamics.com/suvs-why-you-may-drive-fast/
- iamricks 5y agoTo add to this, why is it that every single SUV now has a sports variation of it, i don't understand the appeal of having 500+ HP SUV's.
- D13Fd 5y agoIt's because enough people are willing to pay a premium for the sports variant to make them worth manufacturing and selling.
- rsynnott 5y agoThe industry is willing to make arbitrarily stupid items, if people are willing to buy them at a premium...
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoHigh performance SUVs let people scratch that itch for a nice, fun to drive, car to reflect their current financial situation (most people get richer over their careers) while still being a practical A to B family hauler befitting a responsible adult. Think of it like being an expensive way to have both a Honda CRV and a Dodge Challenger while only using up one parking spot.
- asdff 5y agoI doubt its as fun to drive as a light weight convertible. The market for these super fast SUVs aren't driving purists, but those people you see who go 90mph on the freeway and drift right to left to right again with zero blinker. The people who see you trying to get over, then hit the accelerator to cut you off lest they let you get ahead of them and damage their pride. The people who merge into the exit only lane and try to hit the throttle and pass you on the right side before the exit lane barrier appears. Manufacturers are playing right into all the bad habits I see drivers do on the road.
- CarelessExpert 5y agoThis is just another externality. Sounds like we need a body count tax for large vehicles like this. Edit: BTW, I'm honestly serious about this. These vehicles clearly come with a significant cost, and while it's a bit callous, that cost (in the form of human lives) can be quantified in financial terms and then incorporated into the price of these vehicles in the form of taxation. Doing so sends a price signal to the market: if you want a big truck, then you have to pay a large fee for the privilege, recognizing you're more likely to kill someone crossing the street. The alternative is trying to legislate the size of vehicles or other safety features, which is absolutely an option. But speaking for myself, I'd prefer to discourage the purchase of these monsters in the first place by raising their prices so much as to render them unattractive versus smaller, safer vehicles.
- bagacrap 5y agoI dunno, this seems akin to making murder legal but taxing it. Currently you're basically allowed to murder anyone by hitting them with a car, as long as you are sober. Let's remove the sobriety loophole. I'd favor harsher criminal and civilian punishments for killing/injuring pedestrians, which should naturally discourage people from driving larger vehicles.
- syshum 5y agoWas there a claim that shifting to larger cars is safer I drive a large vehicle for many reasons, #1 being comfort. I am a tall, large person. I want a vehicle with lots of leg room, and a ride height that does not require me to climb down into the vehicle. SUV's and Pickup trucks fit that bill. Cars do not.
- Miner49er 5y agoThey are safer for the vehicle's occupants, and the article agrees with that, but not safer overall. The risk is moved from the vehicle's occupants to pedestrians and occupants of smaller vehicles, it seems.
- rdtwo 5y agoIn America individuals optimize for individual outcomes. Collective benefits are not in favor
- syshum 5y agoIn America we believe people working towards their own individual self interest is better in the long run for everyone than having Authoritarian Central Planning that through out Human history always fails
- crispyambulance 5y ago> I am a tall, large person. If you're Andrei the Giant, for sure. But if you're just 6 foot and change and under 300 lbs, virtually any modern sedan has plenty of room and isn't hard to get into.
- Skunkleton 5y agoI'm (not op) 6'6" and ~240 lbs. I have a seriously hard time finding cars that are comfortable to drive. That said, there are plenty of smaller cars that are just fine, and plenty of large cars that are seriously cramped. I fit just fine in an Impreza (at least 10 years ago I did), but I cannot fit in a 4runner.
- postalrat 5y agoI'm looking for a wedge shaped car that's designed to go under a SUV in a collision. Something like: https://imgur.com/4xHxlZg.png https://imgur.com/4xHxlZg.png
- crispyambulance 5y agoThere's at least one Italian supercar from 1970 that fits your requirements perfectly, the Lancia Stratos: https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a20977036/lancia-stratos-hf-zero-the-ultimate-wedge/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a20977036/lancia-stratos-h...
- sparrish 5y agoBecause being under a 2 ton SUV during a collision is better?
- postalrat 5y agoThe car would be made to take the forces. It wouldn't be much of a collision.
- gruez 5y agoSo basically this from gta? https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/gtawiki/images/5/55/RampBuggy2-GTAO-front.png/revision/latest?cb=20161213202129 https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/gtawiki/images/5/55/RampBu...
- postalrat 5y agoLooks about right. Just make it look pretty.
- NathanielK 5y agoI think the Flip Car[0] from Fast & Furious 6 would make a great commuter vehicle for you. [0] https://fastandfurious.fandom.com/wiki/Flip_Car https://fastandfurious.fandom.com/wiki/Flip_Car
- closeparen 5y agoI’m hearing people now saying things like a vehicle as large as the BMW X3 is “fine if you don’t have kids.” As a kid who grew up in a Subaru Outback and later a Prius, it leaves me scratching my head.
- D13Fd 5y agoIf you have kids that are close together in age, carseat and seat belt requirements can get tough. We had to move from a Subaru Outback (which I loved) to an Ascent (which I do not love) just to fit the 4th car seat in. It is impossible in an Outback, although 3 car seats work fine.
- sparrish 5y agoIt's true. I don't know why you're getting downvoted. You simply can't put carseats/boosters three across in most smaller or even mid-sized vehicles. They're too wide. To stay legal (meaning use carseats/boosters), you have to get a vehicle with a third row or something enormously wide.
- D13Fd 5y agoExactly. To be clear, I did fit three across in the rear of the Outback, but my state does not permit a carseat in the front seat (plus there needs to be room for a 2nd adult). So we had no real choice, we had to get something with third-row seating.
- jeffbee 5y agoThe practical needs of families with three or four children can’t explain the demand for large vehicles. That family arrangement is pretty rare.
- in_cahoots 5y agoEven with two kids it starts to add up. Two car seats in a compact car basically means you can’t fit an adult in the third row. It means you can’t squeeze in a third seat for play dates or carpool. With a double stroller you’re going to be hard-pressed on packing space for even a weekend vacation or camping trip. Most of the families I know with two kids (myself included) have one smaller car for the daily commute / school, and a second larger car or SUV for road trips and weekends.
- mips_avatar 5y agoWe really need to stop treating SUVs and light trucks like something other than passenger vehicles. The difference between a mom driving a minivan, and a mom driving an SUV is functionally no different in terms of passengers. But the SUV doesn't have to follow "passenger vehicle" pedestrian safety requirements, so it's a lot more lethal to pedestrians/cyclists than the minivan.
- jaywalk 5y agoWhat are you talking about?
- mips_avatar 5y agoSport utility vehicles and light trucks are allowed to mount their grill higher than a passenger vehicle and with less slope on the hood. This means that a collision with a pedestrian is more abrupt and that’s why a collision with an SUV is 2-3x more deadly for a pedestrian than a collision with a passenger vehicle. https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-suvs-are-more-lethal-to-pedestrians-than-cars https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-s...
- jaywalk 5y agoThat article doesn't say anything about regulations. The only thing I can find that relates at all to what you're talking about are the Federal Bumper Standards, which only apply to passenger cars. Minivans are excluded as well as SUVs. Please link to the regulations you're actually referring to, not a generic article about SUVs causing more deaths.
- mips_avatar 5y agohttps://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/49/523.5 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/49/523.5 Specifically this regulation, the distinction between passenger and non passenger vehicles. A Lexus NX SUV should be considered and regulated as a passenger vehicle except for its 28 degree sloping chin giving it a “non passenger” vehicle exemption. This means it can avoid a slew of pedestrian safety measures.
- jaywalk 5y agoPedestrian deaths were trending down until smartphones came onto the scene. This report is junk.
- kube-system 5y agoThe average size of a vehicle on the road also started getting larger around the exact same time.
- Tiktaalik 5y agoThe hoods on trucks are so massive now if you put a 6 year old in front of one you wouldn't be able to see them at all. Like seriously wtf are we doing here? Regulators badly need to reign the car makers in.
- quantumBerry 5y agoCAFE standards (regulations) are the reason why trucks are so large. Fuel efficiency standards are based on the size of vehicle, so a bigger vehicle allows for more fuel consumption and thus a more practical to build vehicle while still meeting standards. There is no shortage of small trucks internationally. If you want smaller trucks, you seek deregulation (removal of fuel efficiency standards and the chicken tax).
- Skunkleton 5y ago> If you want smaller trucks, you seek deregulation This is a false equivalency.
- quantumBerry 5y ago> This is a false equivalency. This is a false statement. Unless you are oblivious to the current regulations, and the fact that one must remove (deregulate) CAFE as it stands before small trucks are economically feasible.
- chadash 5y agoPass a higher gas tax. If we paid European gas prices most new cars would get much smaller pretty quickly.
- mips_avatar 5y agoEuropean regulators also take pedestrian safety much more seriously than US regulators. You only see cars in Europe with the pedestrian safe sloping nose.
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoI wonder what the numbers are on accidents caused by lack of visibility through suv's I get why people prefer being higher up...but if everybody starts driving this big cars to compensate for the increase in big cars we're back to where we started but with a much larger environmental impact.
- calebm 5y agoWould larger/higher vehicles reduce injury/death in the event of a crash with a deer?
- MarkLowenstein 5y agoPickups, SUVs, and minivans are wider on average than other cars. Could they just be simply hitting more people per car, because they're sweeping more area? (Can't access full paper.)
- kderbe 5y agoThe 2014 paper "Pounds that Kill" by Michael L. Anderson and Maximilian Auffhammer looked briefly at pedestrian deaths from vehicles, but focused more on multi vehicle collisions and estimated driver and passenger deaths in relation to vehicle weight. The OP estimates $100/yr external cost of light trucks to account for the increase in pedestrian deaths. This paper estimates a cost several times higher to additionally account for driver and passenger deaths. Summary article: https://www.accessmagazine.org/fall-2014/pounds-kill/ https://www.accessmagazine.org/fall-2014/pounds-kill/ Full paper: http://are.berkeley.edu/~mlanderson/pdf/anderson_auffhammer.pdf http://are.berkeley.edu/~mlanderson/pdf/anderson_auffhammer....
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe SUV craze peaked in the late 00s. We've on average been moving to smaller crossovers since. Boxy 90s iterations of midsize SUVs like the 4Runner Cherokee, Durango, Explorer, etc and fullsize pickup based SUVs like the Armada, Suburban, Expedition, etc (regardless of age) have become much rarer than they used to be and the crossovers that displace them tend to be built for sale in other parts of the world with much more stringent passenger safety requirements. I'm very suspect of any analysis that doesn't try to account for smartphone use. They came onto the scene in the 2010s and were instantly and obviously bad enough that they became a known issue and subject to regulation in short order yet the author doesn't even mention this.
- janitor61 5y agoI don't know if it's just me, but the increased height of these large cars greatly increases their headlight glare and causes me to feel less safe around them at night. If one is directly behind me, it's usually blinding.
- emerged 5y agoI think this is a large part of why these cars become popular. If you’re in a normal sized sedan it feels like you’re surrounded by giant aggressive death machines. I’m also absolutely convinced people buy them because they want people to feel that way.