3 ms·
The argument here is pretty weak. Yes, all that Substack really is is blogging but with better monetization. Yes, if Substack is to make money then it probably
by lmm 5y ago
The argument here is pretty weak. Yes, all that Substack really is is blogging but with better monetization. Yes, if Substack is to make money then it probably won't be accessible to the widest possible audience. But that's not enough to conclude that it can't be gamechanging. Kickstarter was "just" a way to monetize, but it's had a dramatic impact; likewise Patreon (and OnlyFans).
- draw_down 5y agoRight, I think there’s a lot of value in helping people capitalize on an audience they already have. Build your audience on Twitter or twitch or whatever and then you can go from there. This is good actually. By the way it’s a bit cute to describe some of these authors as simply having “gotten an audience elsewhere”- the other part is how these people get chased out and barred from typical media careers. Glenn Greenwald and Angela Nagle for instance. It’s important that these people have some kind of lifeline. Also Substack doesn’t have to be for writers exclusively. You can post podcasts on it and video is either already possible or could be.
- adventured 5y ago> Yes, all that Substack really is is blogging but with better monetization. That's not even true. Some people enjoy receiving newsletters. Substack gives me a free newsletter platform. I can send out to 100 or 10,000 daily recipients all the same, at no cost. That's actually quite nice and you simply don't get that with vanilla blogging. Newsletters at scale are expensive if you want reliability + frequency. If I just want to operate a free blog and newsletter with eg 10,000 subscribers, with no desire to monetize it at all, I'd otherwise have to eat that cost from my own pocket. Mailchimp wants $1,200 per year for 120,000 sends per month (10k subscribers * 3 newsletters per week) via their transactional offering. Most people can't justify that if you're not going to monetize.
- wnissen 5y agoI think a big part of that price is that it's almost impossible to send a newsletter to a significant amount of people with a personal email account. Craig could never have started his list today without paying for Mailchimp.