10 ms·
It still blows my mind how police are allowed to turn off body cams while on the clock. That should be considered an offense like a government official burning
by asdff 5y ago
It still blows my mind how police are allowed to turn off body cams while on the clock. That should be considered an offense like a government official burning public documents, because that's basically what is going on when you turn off the video. It's uncanny how the cameras are almost always off whenever something controversial happens.
- reaperducer 5y agoIt still blows my mind how police are allowed to turn off body cams while on the clock. That should be considered an offense like a government official burning public documents, because that's basically what is going on when you turn off the video It depends on the jurisdiction. In some police departments, turning off a body camera is a punishable offense, up to and including firing. It's up to your city leaders to enforce this, and override the local police union's resistance, if possible.
- xupybd 5y agoThere has to be bathroom breaks right?
- kbenson 5y agoFrom what I've seen, the cameras don't really catch those angles to give video on that, and even if they did, that's a problem easily solved through a piece of fabric around the problematic area (as opposed to on the camera, which could be accidentally left in place). Beyond that, requiring sounds from the bathroom be audible is not too much to ask, IMO. If it came down to it being absolutely essential, you could have one office take the camera off (but leave it running), and hand it to their partner to point at the bathroom door as that officer enters and uses the bathroom, and they put it back on as they exit the bathroom. The whole point of a camera system is to be a reliable audit trail of interactions that police have been in, for both their benefit and the public's benefit. Every exception you allow that lets things happen without the camera is a problem for an audit, so you try to reduce those as much as possible.
- giantg2 5y ago"If it came down to it being absolutely essential, you could have one office take the camera off (but leave it running), and hand it to their partner to point at the bathroom door as that officer enters and uses the bathroom, and they put it back on as they exit the bathroom." This is probably the most foolproof. The fabric idea wouldn't be a good idea considering many public restrooms are multi-person. So the concern is with the privacy of others, not just the officer.
- kbenson 5y agoThat's a good point. At the same time I'm not sure what level of privacy people expect in a public bathroom. Anything you don't want someone seeing should be done within a stall. At best I would consider a public restroom as having increased privacy, but by no means being private. I understand that's probably a hard sell though, as people have some idea that it's verboten to record in the open space of a public restroom (it's definitely frowned upon, but I think police cameras are a good exception to have, especially if they need to enter the restroom to perform their jobs because that's where a disturbance is), so whatever gets more camera use in the end I'm on board with, from a practical standpoint.
- giantg2 5y ago"At the same time I'm not sure what level of privacy people expect in a public bathroom." They expect that the law should be followed, which stipulates no recording. Companies have tried for a long time to have security cameras in bathrooms, but it's not allowed. Now if they're responding to a call, then maybe that's an exception. Or they could change the law to allow recording in the bathroom, but there will probably be a ton of public pushback.
- kbenson 5y agoI'm not saying the law should be ignored. I'm just not entirely sure why the law exists as it does, or think that it's ill written to account for certain situations. A large bathroom with twenty people (or more! bathrooms at large events or in large airports can be big) in it is not what I would consider private. I think (but could be wrong) what most people actually care about is that their stall is private (or in the case of urinals, that someone isn't to the side recording what they consider a small private wall space area), but since that's hard to account for and some stalls/urinals already have poor privacy to the rest of the bathroom, we got what we have now. Honestly, to me it seems like a lot of bother to hide bits of our body that we should all be a lot less concerned about shame about in the first place, but I'm not holding my breath on any change there in the U.S.
- asdff 5y agoI would say it should be off for bathroom breaks of course. The main issue isn't these edge cases, but that these cops are shutting them off when they are approaching a person. Its not like they were taking a poop then the call came in and they had to pull up their pants and run and didn't have time to flick it on. They see a situation about to play out where they could end up looking bad in a court of law so they try and remove a potential source of evidence that could be used against them.
- giantg2 5y agoSometimes there are also privacy laws that would need to be addressed at the state level. For example, many places prohibit the camera from being active in a private residence unless permission is granted by the resident.
- kbenson 5y agoUnless police see what they believe is a crime in progress, they aren't supposed to enter a private residence without permission anyway, right? I'm not sure how that can't be easily dealt with even in the problematic states by saying that permission for the police to enter the premises is also permission for them to record.
- giantg2 5y agoThey could be responding to a non-criminal call, like a welfare check. Permission to enter isn't considered the same as permission to record in some states. Yes, they could change the laws about recording. In many cases, not just for police, they probably should.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> They could be responding to a non-criminal call, like a welfare check. Armed law enforcement responding to calls without an evident need for armed law enforcement is itself a problem.
- kbenson 5y agoProbably true, and goes to complaints from police officers that they're also expected to be counselors as well as enforcers. On the other hand, asking someone to go into a situation that may put themselves at risk (for some cases of welfare checks) without appropriate training or equipment (or leaving the distinction of which is which to some third party not on the scene) doesn't seem like a good idea either, and at the point where you have a force that's equipped to protect themselves and possibly restrain others, that begins to sounds a lot like a police force, so I can see why they just use the police. There's probably some solutions along the lines of different shifts for those with different training with different load outs, or additional trained personnel in sets of police, but all of those also have some problems I can see and don't address officers being dispatched that are prone to use force because of a prior altercation that day/week or trauma at some prior date.
- rhizome 5y agoFiring isn't decertification and the punishment isn't even that bad. >It's up to your city leaders to enforce this, and override the local police union's resistance, if possible. It's only possible in jurisdictions where DAs and/or Mayors can get elected without an endorsement from law-enforcement, and look at SF for an example of what police do when one slips through the cracks. By far, most US government is ruled by law enforcement, not the other way around, and this isn't even touching the nationwide police rebellion we've been enduring.
- Afton 5y ago> It's only possible in jurisdictions where DAs and/or Mayors can get elected without an endorsement from law-enforcement, and look at SF for an example of what police do when one slips through the cracks. As someone who doesn't live in SF, what are some of the examples? This is a good faith question, but I'm not really sure what I would google to know what you mean.
- relaxing 5y agoThe 1975 SF police strike, which ended when the police detonated a bomb at the mayor’s house.
- kelnos 5y agoWow, I'd never heard about this, but just read the Wikipedia blurb[0]. It doesn't appear to be established fact that the bomb was indeed placed by the police, but it doesn't seem like it would have been surprising if they had. Pretty shameful that Mayor Alioto override the Supes and caved to the police's demands rather than calling in the National Guard and taking the entire striking force into custody. But I guess people don't always make the best decisions while their lives are being threatened... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_Police_Department#1975_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_Police_Departmen...
- rhizome 5y agoGoogle "Chesa Boudin," the current DA, who is ensuring that criminals run rampant throughout the city, if not inviting them to do so, if you listen to certain opinions. Find a news story about the current crime rate in SF that isn't framed by comments from carceral interests: the police, the police union, former police officers, former hardline prosecutors, and aspiring hardline prosecutors. Many if not most stories only talk to those people. You may be surprised at the difficulty in finding an even-handed appraisal.
- giantg2 5y agoIn theory, there should be no controversial actions when the cameras are on, for the simple fact that everyone can see/hear what happened. The policy can be controversial, but whether the actions were consistent with policy should be evident.
- apendleton 5y agoThere are also potentially privacy considerations... for example, in jurisdictions where body-cam data is a matter of public record, should officers be recording while inside someone's house where that person has a reasonable expectation of privacy? And even assuming the footage isn't automatically public, what about the evidentiary value against the house's occupants? Currently, police need a warrant to execute a search of someone's residence, but there's a "plain view" exception: if while the officer is in the house anyway (either because the occupant let them in, or because they entered due to exigent circumstances like a violent crime in progress), if they happen to see evidence of a crime in plain view while there -- a gun, drugs, whatever -- they don't need a warrant to use that as evidence. If the officer has a camera on the whole time, that potentially means the officer could use not just what they happened to see in the moment, but retroactively whatever can be seen in the footage after the fact, which likely significantly expands the extent of plain-view evidence that can be used without a warrant. Some have asserted that video-recording itself constitutes a fourth-amendment search if the officer is someplace where the person has an expectation of privacy, though I don't think this question has been adjudicated. Also, in two-party-consent states, capturing body camera audio might also require either a warrant or consent for the capturing of at least some kinds of interactions. I think body cams are net-good, but it's more complicated than it seems at first blush.
- syshum 5y ago>> in jurisdictions where body-cam data is a matter of public record Where is this mythical land, because many times people have to go to court to get a court order to release the footage, i would love to know where body cam footage is public record. >>If the officer has a camera on the whole time, that potentially means the officer could use not just what they happened to see in the moment, but retroactively whatever can be seen in the footage after the fact, which likely significantly expands the extent of plain-view evidence that can be used without a warrant. While an interesting topic, i dont believe this is in view of the context. Further how many times does this issue really come up in the course of time. Seems like you are attempting to highlight edge cases in order to defend police corruption and their ability to hide their activities under the guise of public privacy. Most of the body cam footage "lost" or "offline" is when the police are killing people in the plain outdoors in other public venue's not when they are protecting Grandma's privacy from the big bad public.
- jimbob45 5y agoBody cams are a silly idea in the first place. If you're so distrustful of your police that you feel the need to place cams on them, then you need to go back to the drawing board and address the root problem - the trustworthiness of your police force. There's no reason to treat cops as second-class citizens. There's no evidence to suggest widespread power-abuse, despite all the FUD from BLM. Are there some bad apples? Sure, but there are bad apples in every profession and steps like that only punish good officers and make corrupt officers more careful when they perform misdeeds. You cannot neuter the power of every profession of authority. All you're going to do is build instinctive and reflexive mistrust of anyone in authority before they've done anything wrong, just like the reflexive mistrust BLM has whenever anyone interacts with an African-American.
- jackson1442 5y agoWhat? A body cam is useful for the same reason that AWS CloudTrail and other audit logs are useful-- auditing? What part of policing necessitates that it is done in secret? > but there are bad apples in every profession A "bad apple" software engineer probably over-reports hours or is neglectful in their job. A "bad apple" cashier probably skims off the top of sales. A "bad apple" executive probably enriches their personal wealth. A "bad apple" cop probably results in ruining the lives of other people through wrongful arrests, excessive force, or other means. Some people simply should be held to a higher standard because of the responsibilities of their position. When you can quite literally be the arbiter of life and death at times, you should be held to a higher standard.
- jimbob45 5y agoI don’t agree with your analogy. The post-arrest reports that the police fill out is closer to the audit log. A better analogy for SWEs would be keyloggers imo. Also, a “bad apple” SWE can be far and away worse than anything a cop could possibly do. “Bad apple” SWEs are people like Julian Assange, Kim DotCom, and Sammy Kamkar. Those people ruin entire classes of lives. This “higher standard” argument is a slippery slope. Cops actually don’t have very large responsibilities. Worst case, they kill 10 or so people before they’re brought down. Consider Mark Begor, CEO of Equifax, who leaked the identities of millions. Should we force him to install a key logger on all of his PCs? Should we have him wear a body cam at work? He’s certainly someone from whom millions would benefit were he to be locked in a dungeon to work for the rest of his life. Of course not. We’re supposed to believe in liberty and the innate good in man, despite whatever FUD BLM would have you believe.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoIt shouldn’t even have an on/off button.
- Leparamour 5y agoAlthough I agree with you in general, I think this is for practical reasons. It's not helpful to record 24/7, outside of police operations with regard to battery capacity and limits to bandwidth and data storage. One could propose a system where recording is triggered automatically when leaving the patrol car (BLE dongle) and can only be reset by a centralized authority.
- jackson1442 5y agoRecording 24/7 is a simple problem- they turn off when placed on a charging dock in the station. With how microSD is progressing I don't think it's necessary to disable in a patrol car. Perhaps it could somehow communicate with the clock in/out system and only be disabled when the officer is not clocked in to work? Then, lunch would be off the clock and off the camera. I don't see how it's too different from stores recording their cashiers 24/7.
- michaelmrose 5y agoHow about hot swappable batteries with a charger in the patrol car? Can we actually charge the cam through the officers uniform while he sits at his seat?
- d110af5ccf 5y agoThat's a (likely problematic and limiting) technical solution to a social problem. Turning it off inappropriately should be subject to review and meaningful action. Any toggle should be near impossible to trigger unintentionally.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> It's uncanny how the cameras are almost always off whenever something controversial happens. It's because the body cameras that are bought by police departments aren't marketed as devices that keep cops honest, but as devices that protect them from the lying public. That's why they're sold with features that allow the wearer to turn them on and off, and with buttons that trigger the camera to only capture small clips of video. Cops only want to turn them on when they feel like they might need to prove something in court later.
- xwdv 5y agoHave you never heard of the 5th Ammendment?
- Rebelgecko 5y ago>It's uncanny how the cameras are almost always off whenever something controversial happens. I've seen this claim pretty frequently, but never any actual data, so I started tracking the stats in my own city. Since I started ~January, there have been 25 police shootings/use of force events(this includes things like tazing, bean bags, and punches/kicks that require medical treatment. It doesn't include violence against animals or desk pops/negligent discharges). 23 out of 25 events had bodycam footage. The two that didn't both involved off-duty officers, which I think is a reasonable exception to body cam rules. There were no instances of "malfunctioning" body cams, dead batteries, or officers who "forgot" to activate their cams. Even though 6 months of data from one city isn't enough to make any sweeping statements, I haven't found any studies more thorough than my own spreadsheet. If you know of any please send them my way!
- kurthr 5y agoHere's a recent report for a large department that apparently takes body cam footage seriously. 22% failed to have cameras on for "use of force" incidents... which seems like the most extreme example. If the usage was higher in any other circumstances you would have to wonder why, because it would seem sinister. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-07-20/22-of-lapd-officers-failed-to-promptly-activate-body-cameras-in-force-incidents https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-07-20/22-of-la...
- Rebelgecko 5y ago>22% failed to have cameras on for "use of force" incidents IMO that's a an oversimplification compared to what the report actually says[1]. The 22% number isn't how common it was for officers to not have their cameras on, it was how common it was for officers to have cameras that were off OR the camera was on but they were late in hitting the record button[2]. Situations where the officer just straight up didn't record were more rare (that happened 3.7% of the time and if you exclude one instance that was considered justified it's only 3.2%). Funnily enough, LAPD is the department whose data I was tabulating (over a slightly different time period than this study). I think there's 2 main discrepancies between my numbers and the OIG report: I only counted if at least one officer present had body cam footage, not if every officer had body cam footage. Also, I still counted it if the footage of the shooting/use of force was in the 2 minute buffer. [1]: https://a27e0481-a3d0-44b8-8142-1376cfbb6e32.filesusr.com/ugd/b2dd23_65617839b7fc47549eb66001b06096ac.pdf https://a27e0481-a3d0-44b8-8142-1376cfbb6e32.filesusr.com/ug... [2]: Keep in mind that just because they were late to hit the record button doesn't mean the shooting wasn't captured on camera. If an officer talks to witness to ask where a suspect went, radios for help, activates the camera, finds the suspect and then a shooting occurs, they'd be considered non-compliant (e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDThHbrtQE4&t=355s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDThHbrtQE4&t=355s). And even if the officer doesn't activate the camera until after a shooting, it'll still be captured in the 2 minute buffer (e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WT4Ss6ASOrE&t=3m30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WT4Ss6ASOrE&t=3m30s)
- modriano 5y agoA) BWC is constantly recording to a circular buffer. It doesn't "start recording" when an officer presses the button; it just writes the buffered data to memory and adds new video data to that file until ~30-60 seconds after the officer ends the event. This has resulted in some amusing footage where actual bad cops plant evidence, then "start" their BWC, and then get fired when the footage is reviewed, released, and goes viral. B) At least for CPD, the main thing BWC footage does is exonerate officers from unfounded complaints. Most officers have really embraced BWC as it regularly shields them from having to pay out on lawsuits. And when footage should exist on an event number but doesn't, that leaves an officer pretty wide open to having to pay out of pocket. C) What instances are you thinking of regarding your claim that cameras are "almost always off whenever something controversial happens"?
- Nexxxeh 5y agoThere was a high profile instance of B a couple of days ago that I watched today. https://roguerocket.com/2021/07/26/wisconsin-police-deny-planting-evidence/ https://roguerocket.com/2021/07/26/wisconsin-police-deny-pla...