15 ms·
Strengthening our workplace with neurodiverse talent
- bitlax 5y agoSure, like James Damore.
- robotnikman 5y agoGlad to see them taking the initiative to make interviews more accommodating for people on the spectrum. As someone on the spectrum myself, I always dreaded job interviews. I would try to get as much information on what the interview would entail as well as the atmosphere and other specifics so I could mentally prepare myself beforehand and give myself a better chance to show my best side. The example they provided of performing an interview in text through a google doc rather than over the phone really hits home for me, I feel like I am much better able to communicate my ideas through written mediums than verbally. I feel overall there is a lot of untapped talent in the neurodiverse community that is passed over due to some of these barriers in effective communication, so I'm always glad to see companies take initiatives like this.
- Aaargh20318 5y ago> As someone on the spectrum myself, I always dreaded job interviews. I would try to get as much information on what the interview would entail as well as the atmosphere and other specifics so I could mentally prepare myself beforehand and give myself a better chance to show my best side I’m on the spectrum as well and interviews are a bit of a mixed bag for me. I hate everything around it, going to a new, unknown location, not knowing exactly where you end up, meeting new people, etc. The interviews themselves, however, are fine. I basically get to talk about my special interest with people who are presumably equally knowledgable about the subject as I am. I usually enjoy them.
- masterof0 5y agoAs someone on the spectrum as well, I have a question, if you don't like meeting new people, how are you supposed to collaborate with others? At Google at least, we need to work with people across teams all the time. Or you are hoping for a forever-remote gig?
- Aaargh20318 5y agoI choose to work for small companies/startups. Preferably around 10-15 people. As small companies tend to grow, the trick is to get out in time. At a previous job the company grew to over 150 and that wasn’t healthy for me. I should have bailed at around 75.
- dharmab 5y agoInterestingly, 150 people is a natural size where most people can maintain cognitive and social relationships: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number (though it seems to vary in practice up to 500+, depending on the person)
- strken 5y agoDunbar's number is meant to encompass everyone you know. If you've got friends and family outside your work then they're counted too.
- nodejs_rulez_1 5y agoCV: "serial growth hacker". (no offence intended!)
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoI have to mentally prepare for “every” non-personal conversation I have. I speak in a controlled speech cadence so that I can think about what I’m about to say. I speak with confidence and authority because I’m acting. It’s also exhausting and can really burn you out.
- void_mint 5y agoA friend once pinged me about how I'd handle a request from a candidate to do text-only interviewing. He was outraged. The candidate said it would be easier for them to do a better job text-only, and his first thought was "Clearly they're scamming us." I told him, my first task would be contacting HR to ask if they needed some form of accommodation, to more elegantly address the "Why are you asking us to do this" concern he had, but also that if the candidate needed a legitimate accommodation I thought it would be great of them to accommodate. My friend had never considered that there are people that might need accommodation, and that it was a good point. The bummer is, I think, most companies just do not give a shit about accommodating anyone. If you cannot fit their mold, they'll just find someone who can. I'm hopeful that more companies will deploy interview processes to bring out the best in their candidates, rather than processes that will specifically weed out everyone but the specific archetype of person a given interview accommodates.
- nickff 5y agoOne of HR's principal responsibilities is risk mitigation, and different/novel situations present unknown risks, so it is rational to avoid those situations. Most people are not mean (or even inconsiderate, just wary.
- void_mint 5y agoI'm not totally understanding. I suggested HR only because I thought they would be better equipped to ask sensitive questions about interview accommodations than my dev-friend.
- stathibus 5y agoPerson-to-person interaction is an important component of most jobs. If a candidate could not conduct a verbal conversation as part of an interview, I would have a lot of trouble fitting them on any of my teams. Siloing with independent projects is an option, but I think would only be sustainable in larger orgs.
- void_mint 5y ago
- robmerki 5y ago>there is a lot of untapped talent in the neurodiverse community There is going to be a huge advantage for companies that realize this. Massive untapped demand for jobs that recognize different ways of getting work done. I wrote a blog post (https://beta.wildcardpeople.com/what-is-a-wildcard-person https://beta.wildcardpeople.com/what-is-a-wildcard-person) about how people with ADHD tend to do work, and I'm finding random people on LinkedIn putting it right in their bio.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoI’ve never seen myself so accurately described. I love it. May I also LinkedIn this?
- robmerki 5y agoYes please, share as much as you'd like. Glad you enjoyed it :)
- nextlevelwizard 5y agoSkimming the post this feels very horoscop-y, like this could fit most people who read it.
- StevenWaterman 5y agoThat goes for most things about ADHD - it's a collection of symptoms which everyone experiences to different extents (which is why so many people claim that ADHD doesn't exist and everyone has it) The distinction comes when you experience those symptoms constantly and to such an extreme that it becomes debilitating - to such an extreme that in order to cope, you have to structure your whole life around it. In the context of that blog post, it goes from "yes this sounds like me" to "I need almost everything on this list or I will burnout and quit within 6 months".
- nextlevelwizard 5y agoIt is more that there are only positive points, very much like Myers-Briggs personality types or horoscopes. I get that this is basically a sales pitch, but since as you said everything here applies to everyone this feels just "oh, look at us Wildcards(tm) we are so good for your company!"
- renewiltord 5y agoFascinating. An interesting consequence of Google’s search ads business’s rampant success is that they get to run experiments like this at low risk to themselves. The advantage they have over the government is that they have a vested interest in making it succeed - access to an additional labour force - and a vested interest in letting go if it fails - they are still subject to fiduciary duty. If they open up this stuff, it’ll be a win-win for Google and sufficiently neurodivergent people. Reminds me of that old joke about Bill Gates deciding that the best way to help humanity was to impose a corporate tax via MS Office and then use that to build toilets in Africa.
- endisneigh 5y agoThis is great, but I don't see anything that's done specifically for autism. What's described[1] would benefit everyone across the neuro-spectrum, and that's great. My question would be why they weren't already doing these things? Better late than never, they say. [1] - coaching, ongoing support for them and teammates once joining, offer extended time, provide questions in advance, conduct interview in writing One thing people always forget is that these sort of accommodations exist in the beginning for one group, but everyone benefits and that's how we move forward. Perfect example of this are ramps, which originally existed for those who were physically handicapped.
- kradroy 5y agoI'm not at Google, but I'd like to see their support system for post-recruitment and post-hiring. I currently have one neurodiverse (more than one condition) employee who has remained at the same career level for nearly a decade because they don't meet the criteria for the next level. They have expressed interest in advancing though. I don't know how to handle it. I can't promote them, as the next level role has much more responsibility and accountability, and they just aren't there yet. I just give them nice bonuses and salary bumps, but eventually it'll hit a limit for their job level and a higher-up will need to be involved. I've reached out to internal resources I was pointed to, but it's all very informal and difficult to find someone qualified to answer fairly specific questions. I've pointed the employee to resources as well, but one of their conditions kind of hampers their ability following through on vague directions. I feel frustrated because they're a good employee, but I've yet to find useful guidance on helping them get to where they want to be.
- nullsense 5y agoHitting this kind of wall/ceiling in my own career. It sucks. I know there are certain types of responsibilities I just can't or shouldn't take on as I can't guarantee consistent enough performance. By the same token, I also know what it is I'm unreasonably good at. I'd very much like to just be allowed to operate purely to my strengths dipping in and out particular streams of work when I have bandwidth to do it. When and where I've been able to do that it's always been really, really good. When and where something is lumped on me that I can't handle on an indefinite basis it always eventually ends in non-linear behavior due to straying too far outside my safe operating envelope.
- dolni 5y agoThere is a lot of this that seems poorly thought through. Asking for an employee's medical records is forbidden. Asking an employee to undergo a medical exam is forbidden. Asking questions about the employee's health or disabilities during the interview process is forbidden. See https://www.eeoc.gov/pre-employment-inquiries-and-medical-questions-examinations https://www.eeoc.gov/pre-employment-inquiries-and-medical-qu.... With all that said, what prevents anybody from saying "I don't feel comfortable taking a phone call" or "I need extra time for this" without actually being autistic? Then the disadvantage they claim to be removing hasn't actually gone anywhere.
- enkid 5y agoI mean, why make people do a phone call if it doesn't actually help with the interview process?
- dolni 5y agoIt does help with the interview process. A lot of communication lies in body language and tone of voice. Taking that out of the equation, absent a good reason, is going to eliminate useful information. Some people might exhibit behaviors that are problematic in a professional environment. To go into a hiring decision without that information would be a mistake, in my opinion.
- wadefletch 5y agoI think that's very true in the context of sales jobs, or more generally anything that requires the same action of frequent, mission-critical person-to-person communication. I'm not so sure it applies in the context of a remote SWE.
- dolni 5y agoThat's kind of a tone-deaf thing to say, _especially_ given the recent allegations surrounding Activison-Blizzard (https://www.npr.org/2021/07/22/1019293032/activision-blizzard-lawsuit-unequal-pay-sexual-harassment-video-games https://www.npr.org/2021/07/22/1019293032/activision-blizzar...). It absolutely applies and is important.
- mariodiana 5y agoThis is an old article, but it came to mind when I saw this. A software testing company discovered that high-functioning people with autism make good testers. https://blogthinkbig.com/autistic-people-software-testers https://blogthinkbig.com/autistic-people-software-testers
- wlesieutre 5y agoOne weird trick to make readers blindly click through your cookie consent popover: put it in a different language than the page content! https://i.imgur.com/lMz297U.png https://i.imgur.com/lMz297U.png
- randompwd 5y agoAnything about making their workplace less coder hostile? Open plan office - great for sales, HR, marketing and reassuring insecure managers/leaders/CEOs they have worth - not so great for people who need to concentrate hard to solve hard problems and write good code.
- ngc248 5y agoopen plan offices are a blight on this world.
- Lapsa 5y agoread title. sounds stupid
- PradeetPatel 5y agoHopefully this will help to create a more diverse and inclusive workforce. Neurodiversity is very underlooked in the tech industry.
- beervirus 5y agoIs it really? Half the developers I know are somewhere on the spectrum. Maybe the workforce needs to be more inclusive of normies…
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoI think the fact that this field is skill based keeps them out. I've known a lot of kids who entered in our CS program thinking they'd get rich only to drop out or go into Info Sci cause CS was too hard...at a generic state school with some of the most lenient instructors. Frankly I think it's fine. It weeds out the sociopaths just in it to advance their careers seeing as they need to put in the effort. I've had a few jocks even try to mooch off me to basically give them answers.
- beervirus 5y agoYikes. Non-autistic people (“jocks”) aren’t smart enough for computer science? People paying attention to their careers are sociopaths?
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoNone of what I said comes remotely close to your way of putting words in my mouth.
- beervirus 5y agookay.gif
- pyb 5y ago"We will offer candidates in this program reasonable accommodations like extended interview time, providing questions in advance, or conducting the interview in writing in a Google Doc rather than verbally on a call." These would great practices for any job interview, whether the interviewee is on the spectrum or not. Providing questions in advance (behavioral at least) would make the interview process a lot better for everybody. The possibility to answer the more involved questions in writing would also be a great plus overall.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- titanomachy 5y agoYeah, it would be great if those things were offered as options. Personally, I am terrible at studying and getting assignments done, so I like that interviews are usually self-contained and relatively short. I also really appreciate the encouragement and sense of cooperation I get from doing an interview in person rather than in text, I think it makes me perform better. Obviously not as much with zoom interviews. But I recognize my privilege here, that my brain happens to fit the current shape of interviews! It would be great if there were other types of interviews available that fit other people as well.
- kbelder 5y agoAren't 'neurodiverse' people over-represented in IT/Computer Science, compared to their fraction of the population? Is trying to increase their share even further the correct way path to take? If we're talking about the general workforce, instead of specifically tech fields, that would make sense.
- andai 5y agoYes, they're already a large share, and they hate the existing interviewing process, as well as most office environments (and the politics that go along with it).
- brighton36 5y agoOver-representation assumes that there's an objective taxonomy by which representation can be factored. I find it very amusing that no one thinks of this, and/or can't bring this 'obvious' fact to light. "Imagined Communities" is a good book on some of this, if anyone cares to read more. I suspect that there's a lot of civil religion at work, that causes these taxonomies to not immediately appear assumptive. I would guess that we'll lose these components of the civil religion, over time, as a consequence to these initiatives.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoA more reasonable metric to use seems to be whether a group is over/underrepresented in a company compared to the available workforce (not overall population), and I'm not sure whether neurodiverse people are overrepresented by that metric. However, even more important would be to try to give everyone a fair chance, as opposed to trying to meet some metrics which can often lead to discrimination (https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/02/590346891/ex-google-recruiter-sues-alleging-policies-discriminate-against-white-and-asian- https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/02/590346891...). Since neurodiversity isn't one of the "popular" diversity/social justice topics, I suspect the main motivation here is to avoid missing applicants that are technically skilled and suitable, but may not do well in the interview process due to their neurodiversity.
- Thorentis 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ndthrowaway 5y agoAnd somehow, this dissonance meshes fine with allowing/encouraging their management chain to run roughshod over [neuro and other]diverse employees. Eyeroll at best.
- claudiulodro 5y agoI'd say I'm a solid developer (at least that's what my employers have always said!), but I've always really bombed in-person/live interviews. I think it was probably a personality thing, as I'm pretty all-over-the-place when speaking in person. In text though, I can polish my thoughts before sending them! Automattic had (and still has) an interview process that was fully text-based via a combination of Slack, p2, and GitHub, and it really worked well for me. I didn't even speak to a person (on video) until a couple weeks into starting the job! A completely text-based interview process works great for a variety of people: neurodiverse, people with accents/ESL, fidgety people, etc. Especially for remote companies where everyone communicates using text 90%+ of the time! I'm glad it's catching on, and I hope to see it expanded to more companies.
- RivieraKid 5y agoDo they still force candidates to think out loud while solving a problem?
- pvarangot 5y agoNo, they read their minds now.
- RivieraKid 5y agoThere's no need for that, they can simply ask after they complete the task.
- TrinaryWorksToo 5y agoAutism isn't a bad word. We don't talk about LGBTQ+ people as "on the spectrum".
- fuyu 5y agoAutism refers to Autism Spectrum Disorder. There is nothing wrong with using "on the spectrum" for people with ASD. There are also several usages of "Autism" by itself, so I don't know where you got the idea that it is being treated as a bad word.
- TrinaryWorksToo 5y agoBecause people aren't saying the word autism outright and are using euphemisms, like bad words are.
- bitwize 5y agoThere's a bit of nomenclatural history here. There was autism, which usually manifested as a severe disorder that significantly impaired functioning. People with a social deficit like autism, but who were otherwise fine, were usually diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome, which was considered like autism but not quite autism. Then there was high-functioning autism, which wasn't the same as Asperger's syndrome, a major distinguishing characteristic being that people with HFA had a speech deficit in early childhood while people with AS did not. That was where things stood as of the DSM IV. Then the DSM V came along and lumped all of the above into a single classification of "autism spectrum disorder".
- robmerki 5y agoI'm building a job board for the ADHD version of this. Not quite 100% ready but I received more interest in this than anything else I've ever built (1,300 candidate signups in 48hrs). It's to the point that I'm scrambling to supply enough jobs because they keep getting filled. Calling it "Wildcard People" removed the gatekeeping/"medical" aspect while maintaining expectations of how these candidates end up doing their work. https://beta.wildcardpeople.com/ https://beta.wildcardpeople.com/
- kortex 5y agoThis is excellent! I love the branding. There's such a niche for this sort of thing. I used to feel like I didn't "fit it" at most companies, because I tend to be such a generalist and resist being typecast. I can see this as super empowering for many folks.
- robmerki 5y agoThank you! Not going to lie - I got very emotional when I found out the first person got hired to be exactly who they are from my site. The most rewarding thing I've ever worked on.
- dimitrios1 5y agoOh wow is this a trait? I had an adult ADHD diagnosis a few years ago, but not much has come of it since (still struggling with "typical" work arrangements). In fact I just interviewed with a company today where I expressed my resistance being pigeonholed in my own words. Speaking of being a generalist, the book "Range" by David Epstein gave me some hope.
- robmerki 5y agoI'm hesitant to say it's a trait, but he pattern is pretty consistent amongst the dozens of ADHDers I've spoken to. Will read that book, thanks for the recommendation.
- honie 5y agoI'm only asking because this looks like a great initiative, and it's something I care about: how do you plan to keep yourself accountable in the process? I have seen a lot of job boards catering to various niches popping up in recently years, and they all eventually become just a regular job board that generates passive income for the creator without much curation.
- Thorentis 5y agoWhat things are considered "neurodiverse" and what things are considered mental illness? Genuine question. A case could be made that schizophrenia or psychopathy or any other condition is simply another example of diverse neural make-ups. Where is the line drawn? If there is no line, then Google would obviously still be making a call about which types of neurodiversity they want, and which they don't. Which puts us right back to square one anyway. This is just another way for them to fit the "Diversity" buzzword into marketing material.
- 64ffiitdd 5y agoAs an ADHD person I tend to be suspicious of progressive sounding ideas around things like neurodiversity because they usually get tied in with attitudes that culimate in telling me I shouldn't need my medication. Even amongst the academics I know it's very popular to argue I only need my meds because of x societal factor. I'd much rather not be forced to trust society and just have my medication to deal with the problem.
- paul_f 5y agoThis is really difficult and quite a grey area. Just to make a point, is gender dysphoria an acceptable neural diversity, but bipolar affective disorder is not?
- octokatt 5y agoN=1, but I had my most successful group project ever with someone who was dealing with bipolar disorder. The solution? He was a master communicator. He would tell me when he was having a manic streak and took on more work. When he was going back down, he communicated that and I took on more. If he started going unresponsive, I reached out and asked, and he told me where he was and what support he needed. Now he's doing better and found the right medication, but crivens, I've been in a lot of other group projects, and I really miss him.
- paul_f 5y agoThis is a great story and I am happy for the outcome for sure.
- beervirus 5y agoI don’t get it. Tons of programmers are autistic and nobody treats it like a big deal to hire them.
- ganSo 5y agoThis semester I had the opportunity to work with a classmate with Asperger's syndrome. It has been a very bad experience to say the least. In meetings he screams and berates us, gets very angry and easily frustrated when things are not done the way he wants to do them, even when the rest of the group has unanimously decided to do them a certain way. One time he started watching a video in the middle of the meeting and screamed at us to shut up every time we tried to talk because he couldn't listen to his video. My university or department has had absolutely no contact with me or any member of my group to guide us on how to work with a neurodivergent classmate, on how to make the group and project work. It has been a very tiring experience. Can anybody give me any advice on how to try to better the situation? How to make the environment better for him and my group?
- chokeartist 5y agoLet me preface this comment... I have worked a number of years with autistic and "nEuRoDiVeRsE pEoPle". All considered: Fuck them and their antics. If I could send them to a concentration camp..... they would already be gassed. I'm not fucking kidding.
- sterlind 5y ago(I'm on the spectrum as well) We do well with rules. If you have a concrete set of rules of conduct, give it to him, and warn him when he violates them. If he keeps screaming, watching videos during meetings, etc. then loop in HR to get him fired. Being autistic isn't an excuse to be an asshole, it just means we need help on social cues and stuff.
- ganSo 5y agoThank you for your advice. Next meeting I will try to talk to him and set a few rules of conduct. Hopefuly we'll all get along better.
- mjburgess 5y agoIs your classmate aware that he's autistic? I would send an email to the disability service at your university highlighting his likely need for support. He isn't going to be able to complete university without it.
- magnetowasright 5y agoThis is fantastic. Some of those accommodations are great. I’m really hopeful that this program can be a success for all involved. However, I wish google would partner with Autistic self-advocacy orgs or orgs that don’t support harming us, like ASAN (Autistic Self Advocacy Network) or any of the bigger orgs ASAN recommend. No, the Autistic community doesn’t always agree on things, but I think we can agree that as the saying goes, nothing about us without us. The Els org mentioned has a couple of Autistic advisory board members, which is just slightly better than none, so I’ll give them that. However, they base their schools on the inherently harmful ABA, they use the puzzle piece and “person first” language to remind each other Autistic people are in fact people, and some of their staff work with eugenics org Autism Speaks. All of those things are the antithesis of understanding and advocating for Autistic people imo. (NB: some Autistics like the puzzle piece or pf language, as is their right) I can’t find any useful information on the Stanford program. I want to know if there are any Autistic or otherwise neurodiverse people involved and what the org supports. I find it interesting that google partnered with this Els org. It’s like they did enough research to know that Autism Speaks is unequivocally evil (and are of the belief that Autistic folks should either be warehoused, or should be ‘fixed’ by ABA abuse thus require no supports/accommodations at all as adults, so they wouldn’t want to be part of this program anyway, but I digress) so google found an org just inoffensive enough at first glance to use instead. I might be reading too much into it, but I’m really curious why they chose that org. I know google and other companies with similar programs aren’t doing this out of the goodness of their hearts. I just hope that the Autistic people involved really benefit and don’t end up more exploited than their allistic (not Autistic) colleagues. Starting to address some of the complex issues why most of us don’t/can’t work is a great start and could really improve some people’s lives.
- titanomachy 5y agoDoes "person first" just mean saying "person with autism" instead of "autistic person"?
- jckahn 5y agoYep. To me (an Autistic person) they are synonymous and I find neither problematic. I prefer "Autistic person" because I'm into the whole brevity thing.
- templeosenjoyer 5y agoI get it, but I am wary of this brewing corporate FETISHISATION of 'neurodivergence'. The UK government held a similar recruitment scheme a year ago[1] - headed by Dominic Cummings - which is no surprise since he is very much in touch with this culture. Of course, he uses SFW synonyms of mental ailments: weirdos, oddballs, wild-cards, etc. It's almost as if these people recently watched Rain Man (1988). [1] https://dominiccummings.com/2020/01/02/two-hands-are-a-lot-were-hiring-data-scientists-project-managers-policy-experts-assorted-weirdos/ https://dominiccummings.com/2020/01/02/two-hands-are-a-lot-w...
- TheGigaChad 5y agoHow about we stop the workplace from turning into a freak show?