6 ms·
Toyota is still trying to sell their hydrogen-powered Mirai.[1] After six years, they're selling a few hundred a month, all in California because that's where t
by Animats 5y ago
Toyota is still trying to sell their hydrogen-powered Mirai.[1] After six years, they're selling a few hundred a month, all in California because that's where there are some hydrogen stations.
The hydrogen station situation is a joke.[2] Not only are there few of them, most of them are offline.[2] Right now, not one hydrogen station in the South Bay is working.
[1] https://www.toyota.com/mirai/ https://www.toyota.com/mirai/
[2] https://cafcp.org/stationmap https://cafcp.org/stationmap
- jdavis703 5y agoYou can’t buy a Mirai, you can only lease them. And they’re only sold in CA because they’re a so called “compliance car” designed to appease regulators. Personal story, when I tried to lease one they wanted me to share my social media info because they only wanted to lease them to “influencers.” Seemed like a bizarre way to run a business, and since I’m not an influencer I looked elsewhere.
- coolspot 5y agoMaybe it was true at some point, but not anymore - you absolutely can buy a Mirai. https://www.toyota.com/search-inventory/page/results/year/2021/series/mirai https://www.toyota.com/search-inventory/page/results/year/20...
- natch 5y agoAlso they’ve had a few explosions. Usually hydrogen delivery trucks, but they list them as explosions “at the plant” in what I guess is a trick to hide the fact that these trucks that are driving around city streets can explode. Then also some at retail filling stations.
- FreakyT 5y agoThe key difference between Toyota's approach and Tesla's was simple: Tesla built out their own charging infrastructure. Just like with battery-electric-vehicles, there's a chicken and egg problem: no one will buy a car if there's nowhere to charge/fuel it, but no one will build fueling/charging stations if no one has that type of car. If Toyota was serious about hydrogen, they should have done what Tesla did, and built a countrywide network of hydrogen stations.
- fossuser 5y agoPart of the difficulty was that when starting off early EV adopters already had charging infrastructure in their homes the same isn't true for hydrogen. Tesla later was able to build and expand superchargers, but initially people just charged at home (and still mostly do except for longer trips). There isn't a path for hydrogen to build out like that - you need the entire infrastructure at once, there isn't a real path to success there. Failure was obvious imo based on this alone (there are other issues too). I'm not even sure Toyota really expected anything other than failure? Based on the attention they gave it, it mostly seemed like something they could point to for marketing and then ignore with some justification that their own failure is evidence people don't want non-gasoline alternatives.
- Dylan16807 5y agoToyota has a lot of money. If they wanted to make a thousand hydrogen stations they could have done it, even without the option of slow home charging. If hydrogen was a good fuel it would have been a reasonable option.
- fossuser 5y agoHas there ever been an example of that working in history? Even with lots of money, I think that’s a story of how to go bankrupt.
- Dylan16807 5y agoHas there ever been an example of that failing in history? I'm not sure you can find any historical situation that's close enough to this one to make a good analogy, especially because hydrogen isn't even a good fuel to start with. > Even with lots of money, I think that’s a story of how to go bankrupt. Well on a pure product/market basis they probably never should have made these hydrogen cars at all.
- fossuser 5y ago
- mikewave 5y agoThere are a few hydrogen power stations up here in Vancouver, but still not enough to make a Mirai practical for many people. I've seen a few driving around but I suspect they're all demo cars... Hydrogen fuel cells make way more sense for semi-trucks and I'd love to see the whole Trans-Canada Highway done up with regularly spaced stations, but whether it makes sense in the city is a harder sell. It's a matter of infrastructure being required before users - "if you build it, they will come". I'd drive a Mirai no problem, but not if I'm worried about running out of H.
- WorldMaker 5y agoI was reading the math on semi-trucks and charging times line up so well with union mandated breaks (at least one stop every so many hours of at least 30 minutes), I've got a feeling pure electric is going to work out well with semi-trucks (and maybe even something the unions will think a great overall win because it adds vehicular enforcement of union rules). I still think hydrogen makes way more sense for ships at sea, maybe for planes (maybe not for dirigibles, though, hah), and probably as one of many "grid shifting" tools in the tool bag (converting excess wind/solar to hydrogen when it is cheap, and then reusing it at times of scarcity/grid outages/off-grid-festivals). Though something was pointed out to me that while far down on the list of immediate greenhouse gas concerns, vastly expanding our production of Hydrogen and the amount that leaks into the atmosphere (and Hydrogen is so small we have no real good way to make a truly leak-proof container; long term storage of "hydrogen fuel" is a problem), it will have a lot of indirect impacts on greenhouse gases (including interrupting the chain process that converts most atmospheric methane to less harsh chemicals) and it's easy to forget that there are other greenhouse gas problems to worry about with respect to climate change beyond just "carbon footprint" and I know some scientists are increasingly of the angry opinion that Hydrogen was always a dangerous red herring distraction especially because while it reduces overall carbon output has enough secondary effects to worry about if it was a more common "fuel".
- Cd00d 5y agoCar and Driver had a very interesting recent article about why hydrogen didn't take off and the lack of infrastructure problem. https://www.caranddriver.com/features/a36341305/hydrogen-might-still-make-sense/ https://www.caranddriver.com/features/a36341305/hydrogen-mig... There are people making monthly payments that literally struggle to get fuel.
- bobsil1 5y agoIt was a glorious day when I could finally delete my home page link to the H₂ stations, because I upgraded to EV.
- tomytosian 5y agowhy not. electricity in the USA is not green. it is powered by coal. harvesting rare earth mineral is a tragedy too. Maybe toyota is right. maybe hydrogen is the future.