6 ms·
There's a lot of people who live in suburbs and commute by car into cities. Most anti-car proposals are all downside and no upside for these people. We should l
by josephcsible 5y ago
There's a lot of people who live in suburbs and commute by car into cities. Most anti-car proposals are all downside and no upside for these people. We should look for proposals that give them appealing alternatives to cars, rather than just making their lives worse.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThere are such proposals, commuter rail and local public transport. But ultimately, suburbs are built around the car. No matter what you do, suburbs will not be as functional without cars as they are with cars, because they were specifically built with the assumption in mind that everyone using them has a car. So yes, people in suburbs will lose out, it's unfortunate but it's not really anyone's fault. The reality is that life in the suburbs is already full of negative externalities and is generally only sustainable because of subsidies from the cities and to some extent the rural sectors. So the solution is going to be making the city a liveable place for many of them, which is much easier with cars reduced, as well as build suburbs that can be lived in without cars, but those will look very different from the North American suburbs of today. Beyond that, every solution such as commuter train, suburban public transport options, etc... is inevitably going to be worse than the car, and that's the sad consequence of how these places were badly designed.
- bookofsand 5y agoI have very fond memories of a quaint ~100k Netherlands city where most of the commuting happened by bike because everything was within a 20 minutes bike ride. Using a car was simply a hassle. By the time you walk to its parking spot, drive, park, walk to your destination, you are already there on bike. I live in a North American city. The city is zoned the almost all of the jobs are in downtown, u district and maybe the port. Everywhere else is a job desert. To commute by bike to downtown from within the city limits, forget about the suburbs, is an hour each way. This is unfeasible, other than for young people, usually men, with no kids or other obligations. It's a luxury lifestyle, not the obvious choice. The problem is not the suburbs. The problem is the downtown. The problem is the expectation that millions of people have to commute in/out the downtown every day. Break down the downtown. Build small office parks all over the 'suburbs'. Spend real $$$ to help families solve the two-body problem. Edit. Apparently I feel quite strongly about this. Here's a bit more. Suburbs are build around people wanting a decent living space for their families. The car helps, quite a lot, but it's not like suburbanites wake up on Sunday mornings, hop on their Cars and go to the CarTemple to sing praise and offer their first borns as sacrifice to the CarGod. There is simply a dearth of real alternatives, which mostly boils down to a simple question: Are the jobs anywhere near where people want to live?
- Karrot_Kream 5y agoYeah single-family residential zoning is an intimate part of the car dependency trap in North America.
- bookofsand 5y agoI don't speak Dutch, so I could not retrieve relevant statistical data. From my memories, the quaint ~100k Netherlands city was mostly townhouse rows and SFHs. I don't recall many 6+ floor megabuildings. Feel free to drop some StreetView pins around and see for yourself: https://www.google.com/maps/place/''s-Hertogenbosch,+Netherlands https://www.google.com/maps/place/''s-Hertogenbosch,+Netherl...' The #1 US problem is the centralization of jobs in the downtown. If we want to get to reduce car usage, we need to zone to geographically spread the jobs around. Edit: Orthogonally: https://missingmiddlehousing.com https://missingmiddlehousing.com
- Karrot_Kream 5y agoI don't disagree at all. My comment was perhaps just a tad too pithy.
- sudosysgen 5y agoWhat you're describing is not really a suburb, though. Suburbs are built around a city, it's in the name, sub-urban. Commuting downtown for your job is the core to the idea of the suburb. You're describing a nice, low density, urban place. You don't need to commute to downtown by bike. Really, you just need to commute to a metro station, somehow, either by bike, by bus, or by your own two feet. When I was a kid, I had the chance of being able to go to school alone. That is the real solution for families - we need to make an environment where it is possible for kids to move themselves safely. Nowadays, even in my fairly walkable and nice city of Montréal, this isn't really possible anymore. Anyways, I think you really underestimate what is possible using public transport. It takes around 40 minutes for me to commute from a low density borough of Montreal, Ville Saint Laurent, which is full of SFH, to an office downtown, without using a bike at all. That compares very well to 30 minutes in a car. And this can still be improved considerably. Thankfully, I don't work downtown, and instead it takes me around 25 minutes to get there without a car. Before that, my family of 6 lived in a duplex, from which you could bike downtown in 30 minutes flat. You can definitely build spaces where families can live and still get to work and to school in around half an hour. The key is to make it possible for children to get where they have to go by themselves, safely, as fast as possible, and to have enough public transit and bike accommodations for older people to get downtown - which is the worst case - in 30 minutes more or less. Around 2 million people live in Montreal. Our public transit system is not great at all. 55% of people in the island commute to work every day. I know people that commute from the suburb of Laval all the way downtown in less than an hour using only public transit, and that's a family of five. We can do much better still. There are ways for people to live comfortably as a family without going to the North American suburb, while still having cities with more than a million people. Also, simply building offices in the suburbs as they exist right now isn't going to be helpful - try commuting even within a normal suburb by bike for 30 minutes and you're going to see why. It's damn near suicidal.
- bpodgursky 5y agoSeriously. The bicycle gang needs to realize that posting pictures of urban bike lanes does nothing to convince the family w/ 3 children that they can possibly get a family of 5 around in a day without a minivan.
- quadrifoliate 5y agoThe "family w/ 3 children" gang also needs to realize that they should stop voting down local transit measures, otherwise they will have to resign themselves to spending hours in traffic in narrow streets while cyclists zip by.
- jcims 5y agoA two stop park-n-ride shopping trip with three young children sounds substantially worse than chilling in traffic.
- tolbish 5y agoWith different transit measures, there will be more livable communities available, freeing up that family of 5 to move somewhere where they don't need to take such long winded trips in the first place.
- bpodgursky 5y agoMaybe? But like... you'd basically have to live within a very short walk of a grocery store, b/c hauling groceries for 5 people w/ 3 children is uh... ambitious. So you're living in an apartment building, or townhouse at best. So I guess no yard, not urban enough. And since the best you're going to get is a corner store or very small grocer, I hope you're not looking for any bulk items or specialty stuff. God forbid you ever need to go to a hardware store. Maybe you're rich, and can afford delivery groceries? And I guess you're never really going out for a hike or anything outside the city proper, because taking a 3-stop transit to get to a hiking trail becomes a full-day affair, aka impossible. I think at the end of the day, nobody is _actually_ going to do this, which plays out by the low-fertility stats of European cities. You've got 1-2 kids at most. I think we need to be honest in these discussions and admit that dense urban communities do not practically support anything other than small families. Which isn't something everyone is happy with.
- iammisc 5y agoWe should reduce crime in our cities and end homelessness so our cities are appealing places to live. As a conservative minded urbanist, it is disheartening to see people leave cities because many american cities are descending into chaos and many people are not as dedicated to urban living as I am. Frankly if it weren't for my absolute hatred of car commiting, I would probably follow them. The suburbs offer a superior quality of life other than proximity of conveniences. That is all at this point. Covid destroyed culture. Homelessness and crime destroyed a true sense of community and shared ownership of public property.
- trog 5y ago> We should reduce crime in our cities and end homelessness so our cities are appealing places to live. The thing that would make my [Australian] city more appealing to live would be removing most of the cars from it. One of my big dislikes of inner city living is the noise, fumes and congestion from vehicles.
- iammisc 5y agoWell you live in Australia. In Portland where I live, murders have spiked and many of my local businesses have armed security now due to the decline in social cohesion due to the proliferation of false narratives.
- whakim 5y ago> As a conservative minded urbanist, it is disheartening to see people leave cities because many american cities are descending into chaos and many people are not as dedicated to urban living as I am. Total crime rates as well as violent crime rates have been declining almost continuously for about 30 years. In the early 90s, crime rates were more than double what they are today. Rates of homelessness are harder to measure, but the most comprehensive statistics (as measured annually by the Department of Housing and Urban Development) show that the total number of unhoused individuals hasn't changed drastically since 2007 when reporting began. While I do not deny that homelessness and crime are problems, American cities are not "descending into chaos" on the basis of rates of crime and homelessness.
- photonios 5y agoI am not sure what appealing alternative you could offer. I didn't have a car up until recently. I got one because I had a kid. Even though I live in a small European city [0] (400k inhabitants) with bus lines everywhere, taxi's that are dirt cheap etc. It's impossible with a kid. I tried for the first few months. I don't have time to wait for the bus for 10 minutes with a screaming baby, neither do I want to stress that the entire bus or train needs to listen to my crying baby for the ride. Taking the kid to the doctor halfway across town is just a nightmare with any of the alternative modes of transport. Give me a good alternative for taking a screaming baby to the doctor without pissing off everyone and I'll happily get rid of the car. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cluj-Napoca https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cluj-Napoca
- perryizgr8 5y agoEven without a kid, a car is almost always the best way to travel. If we lived in an ideal world with unlimited space and resources, everybody would be driving a car. Only restrictions due to population density or political incentives may create situations where one might prefer traveling by some other mode.
- fy20 5y ago> Taking the kid to the doctor halfway across town I live in a similar sized European city, and the one good thing the Soviets did here was to make sure services are available nearby to where people live. I have a friend who has two toddlers, and when they need to go across the city they have no issues going by bus. If someone get pissed off because there is young human who is not mature at controlling (or more likely supressing) their emotions, that's their own problem. Almost all of the services they need are nearby though. During the winter lockdowns they didn't need to leave their district for 4 months.