7 ms·
Ivermectin Shows Us the Consequences of Politicized Science
- fatsdomino001 5y agoThis post gets flagged in 3... 2... 1!
- seattle_spring 5y ago> Unfortunately, ivermectin is not a miracle cure. At best, the Egyptian study was poorly performed and partially plagiarized; at worst, the data were outright fraudulent qft
- middleclick 5y agoThere seems to be a huge overlap between people who are staunchly anti-vaccines and pushing Ivermectin. I wonder if there is a link.
- mikedilger 5y agoI hope that's mostly just an American tribal thing. I'm pro-vaccine, pro-ivermectin, pro-masks and pro-lockdowns. This is a serious disease and we need to use all the tools at our disposal. Being anti-ivermectin is like being anti-aspirin or anti-vitamin-C. Maybe you're emitting some kind of political virtue signal, but it's almost (but not quite) as dumb as being anti-vax. We don't have RCTs on vitamin C vs COVID-19 but most practitioners use it anyways.
- OrvalWintermute 5y ago> Being anti-ivermectin is like being anti-aspirin or anti-vitamin-C. Maybe you're emitting some kind of political virtue signal, but it's almost (but not quite) as dumb as being anti-vax. We don't have RCTs on vitamin C vs COVID-19 but most practitioners use it anyways. I too am pro-vaccine, pro-ivermectin, pro-masks and pro-lockdowns. Am also pro-socialdistancing, pro-vitamins, and risk mgmt around patients based on their age and risk factors HCQ, Ivermectin, Fapavir, or IV antivirals like Remdesivir - support all of their use for stopping the scourge, as prescribed by doctors.
- OrvalWintermute 5y agoThe whole issue, and that article itself is politicized. So much so, that it is hard to find medical information on it, with the rampant flagging of articles, and "disinformation" labels being thrown around. The article saying that Ivermectin alone is the Flyover Country treatment plan is a misstatement at best, deceptive at worst. The Establishment is pushing vaccines for everyone, or, almost everyone starting from 18 and older, unless you have an allergy to vaccine ingredients. Flyover Country, and some other countries, are pushing treatments using a cocktail of drugs, suggesting vaccines only for high-risk population. Why can't we have some honesty about this? I'd much rather having some open discussions about the pros and cons of each, standard of care around treatments, and which vaccines are best for which populations given the known side effects, than this continual stream of missinformation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- snet0 5y agoWhen did medical science become a plebian democracy? I don't expect to be consulted about the material they make the seat-belt in my car out of. It's politicised because calling it anti-science would bruise some egos. This is not a political disagreement, this is an arbitrary anti-science conspiracy put forward by anti-vaxxers. The only reason it's "political" is because all the people who are questioning science just happened to vote for the same president. And if you think the entire system is broken and needs pulling down, now is quite possibly the worst time in the history of humanity to do so.
- OrvalWintermute 5y ago> When did medical science become a plebian democracy? Medical science is still a science. The science says there are treatments, prevention, and > I don't expect to be consulted about the material they make the seat-belt in my car out of. It's politicised because calling it anti-science would bruise some egos. This is not a political disagreement, this is an arbitrary anti-science conspiracy put forward by anti-vaxxers. Discounting treatments out of hand, or worse, partisanship, is just as bad as anti-vaxx > The only reason it's "political" is because all the people who are questioning science just happened to vote for the same president. The scientific method is all about questions. Science is a process, not an ideological orthodoxy. I support both distancing, vaccinations and treatment protocols that include antivirals such as HCQ, Ivermectin, and Remdesivir. Why? Because the latest science on clinical outcomes from drug cocktails show better outcomes through use of antivirals, immunomodulators, anticoagulants, vitamins, and many other drugs. It is an evolving field.
- mikedilger 5y agoThis article itself is politicizing the science and medicine. Please don't take medical advice from journalists. Talk to your doctor. If you want to weigh in on the ongoing medical debate (this is not settled science), please at least read 10 or so relevant studies first. Far too much chatter by people who don't have not put in the requisite work.
- bb88 5y agoJournalists? What? It's written by a doctor and medical students. Authors: John Havlik, Pranam Dey, and Howard P. Forman Bios: John Havlik and Pranam Dey are medical students at Yale University. Dr. Howard P. Forman (@thehowie) is a professor of public health policy, management, economics and radiology at Yale.
- mikedilger 5y agoThanks for that correction. However they are functioning like journalists here. Notice all of the judgemental, ideological, political one-sided narrative. They fail to apply Hanlon's razor as they claim at the end "[they] know exactly what they are doing." It's paranoid talk. The case for/against ivermectin is very complex and this short diatribe is not helping anyone. They also clearly are Americans who seem to think this is an American issue. Ivermectin use for COVID-19 is worldwide and isn't aconsequence of "rejecting American Institutions" but was a desperate attempt by caregivers to keep their patients alive. They think they are seeing a pattern - that it works. But humans are easily fooled and see patterns everywhere, so we need better data. In the meantime, those doctors will continue to use ivermectin, and an upcoming Oxford study will get us some better data. Might I also add that the evidence in support of Remdesivir is much much weaker than the evidence in support of Ivermectin, that the WHO recommends against Remdesivir, and yet in America it's widely used and nobody is bitching about it. Hypocrisy.
- bb88 5y agoNo, I disagree. They're functioning like doctors. There is not, nor should be, a political side to science. Facts are facts, and numbers are numbers. And false cures give false hope to the afflicted -- it's no different than snake oil. In fact their argument is that it's too early to know so going in front of congress and the media is irresponsible. Hydroxychloroquine, too, showed promise in the early studies. When it became clear it wasn't efficacious, the media and politicians had already grabbed hold informing millions of americans that it was a cure when it in fact was not. The EUA for remedesivir and EUA revocation of hydroxychloroquine are here. They seem to be self explanatory about why the FDA took the action they did. https://www.fda.gov/media/137564/download https://www.fda.gov/media/137564/download https://www.fda.gov/media/138945/download https://www.fda.gov/media/138945/download
- panny 5y ago>despite warnings from the American scientific community that little to no evidence exists of its efficacy. There are dozens of studies on the effectiveness if ivermectin. c19ivermectin.com
- freen 5y agoQuantity != quality.
- panny 5y agoQuantity proves the article's statement is factually false, regardless of quality.
- snet0 5y ago"Evidence" doesn't just mean "a study exists that supports this claim", though. It'd be nice if that was the case, but the quality of studies does actually matter. Do we have "evidence" that the MMR vaccine causes autism based on Wakefield's study? No, because we don't accept the validity of the study.
- bb88 5y agoIt wasn't just "we don't accept the validity" for the Wakefield paper, it was that the paper was retracted for fraud and conflict of interest.
- freen 5y agoOne ton of shit is not equivalent in any sense to a single ounce of ice cream.
- freen 5y agoSociopaths are gonna sociopath. The merchants of bullshit are the same cast of characters, on the same side of the political spectrum: team B of the pentagon/soviet fame, Vietnam, civil rights, tobacco, trickle down economics, Iraq war, climate change, fishery collapse, gay rights, war on drugs, nationalized health care, covid skepticism, covid vaccine paranoia, hydroxychloroquine, injected disinfectant, and now invermectin. At this point is pretty clear: in that epistemological partisan context there are only carnies and rubes.
- OrvalWintermute 5y ago> The merchants of bullshit are the same cast of characters, on the same side of the political spectrum: ...Vietnam Fact Check 101. US Presidents involved in Vietnam Kennedy (D) Johnson (D) Nixon (R) While they may have been sociopaths, I have no idea about that, they were definitely not a member of the same political party, or highly similar. Relevant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnam_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnam_War
- dragonwriter 5y ago> US Presidents involved in Vietnam It’s kind of surprising for someone who doesn't go with the “Vietnam started with Johnson” line not to go back to Eisenhower.
- freen 5y agoRobert Strange McNamara was a Republican. As were the cast of characters who were largely responsible for the disinformation campaign inside the pentagon that lead up to the Vietnam war: Team B. Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, Cheney, Seymour Weiss, etc. some of those names should be familiar for their continued subsequent enthusiastic support of obviously brain dead massively deadly clusterfucks. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Team_B https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Team_B Just for good measure, let’s add watergate and iran contra too. Didn’t Ollie North end up running the NRA for a hot minute? Classic carnie move. Where is the GOP health care plan that Trump was promising was almost ready for years and years? Classic carnie move.
- bb88 5y agoFor those that are curious about the original ivermectin study: "A few days ago, the [original ivermectin] study was retracted amid accusations of fraud and plagiarism. A masters student who had been assigned to read the paper as part of his degree noticed that the entire introduction appeared to be copied from earlier scientific papers, and further analysis revealed that the study's datasheet posted online by the authors contained obvious irregularities. [...] "No-one spent the 5 minutes required to download the data file that the authors had uploaded online and notice that it reported numerous deaths happening before the study had even begun. No one copy-and-pasted phrases from the introduction into Google, which is all it takes to notice just how much of it is identical to already-published papers." https://www.sciencealert.com/ivermectin-study-controversy-is-a-huge-wake-up-call-for-fraud-in-covid-19-science https://www.sciencealert.com/ivermectin-study-controversy-is...