7 ms·
In particles physics, they have a different explanation of electromagnetism that is also very natural, almost inevitable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_
by gus_massa 5y ago
In particles physics, they have a different explanation of electromagnetism that is also very natural, almost inevitable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_electrodynamics#Mathematical_formulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_electrodynamics#Mathem... The explanation in particle physics is compatible with Quantum Mechanics and Special Relativity, but no one is sure about how to extend it to General Relativity. I'm not sure how compatible is it with the proposal in the article discussed here.
Non technical version (ELI25):
In quantum mechanics the wavefunction Ψ is has complex values. If you multiply everything in the universe by -1, nothing changes because all the physical results use ΨΨ* (where * is the complex conjugation). You can also multiply everything by i or -i. Moreover by any other complex number of modulo 1 because ΨΨ* does not change. (The technical term for this is U(1) global gauge symmetry.)
But you can be more ambitious and want to multiply each point of the universe by a different complex number of modulo 1. ΨΨ* does not change but the derivatives of Ψ change and they are also important. (When you use the same complex number everywhere, the derivatives is just a multiple of the original derivative. When you use a different number in each point, it changes.)
The only way to fix the problem with the derivative is to add a new field A. When you and multiply each point of the universe by a different complex number of modulo 1, then A changes in a simple to calculate but not obvious way. The change in A fix the problem with the derivatives of Ψ.
So now the equations of the universe with Ψ and A don't change when you make this change. (The technical term for this is U(1) local gauge symmetry.) When you write carefully how a universe like this look like, the new field A is electromagnetism. (Actually, you can get the electric field and magnetic field using the derivatives of A.)
This explanation looks more complicated than the explanation of the article, but the article is full of technical terms that you really don't want to know, like:
> Riemann curvature tensor is more than just Ricci curvature—electromagnetic fields stretch and bend the spacetime
- KirillPanov 5y ago>_In particles physics ... very natural Er, I'm not sure that things like dressed particles [1] and off-shell matter [2] violating E=mc^2 [3] could be described as even remotely "natural". Perhaps they are valid theories, but "natural" certainly isn't an appropriate description of most of what unavoidably follows from particle assumptions. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dressed_particle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dressed_particle [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_shell_and_off_shell https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_shell_and_off_shell [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_particle#Properties https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_particle#Properties
- eigenket 5y agoVirtual particles are basically just a mathematical trick to make doing calculations easier in perturbative quantum field theory. You shouldn't take them too seriously. If you do the calculations in another way (e.g. by discretizing stuff on a lattice) no virtual particles appear but your calculations become a lot harder.
- goldenkey 5y agoThey are still a trick because they are used to propagate a particle exactly where it needs to go in order to exert the force of the field. So the field is everywhere, but is pretty much invisible except for when virtual particles mediate it.. No efficient simulation on a computer could operate in such a manner. It's explanatory but not a constructive proof. I can't build an efficient simulation of our universe based on the virtual particle paradigm.
- KirillPanov 5y agoThey don't just become harder, they become open problems -- open problems with a million dollar bounty on them! There is no known non-perturbative quantization of the Yang-Mills theory. http://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/yang–mills-and-mass-gap http://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/yang–mills-and-m...
- namanyayg 5y agoThanks for the explanation. If you have the time, can you also explain _why_ would we be multiplying "each point of the universe with a different complex number of modulo 1?" What does it mean in physical reality; why multiply points with any number at all?
- ufo_pilot 5y agoNot GP, or a physicist, but my understanding is that the different number at each point you multiply with represents a degree of freedom at each point of spacetime, and in this degree of freedom is where the electromagnetic field lives.
- tagrun 5y agoTo find out what kind of symmetry a field (as described by a Lagrangian) admits. It's called gauge symmetry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gauge_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gauge_theory It's a complex number for QED but in general, it's a unitary matrix: a rotation which preserves the magnitude of a wavefunction (a complex vector). In physics, symmetries play a fundamental role.
- cshimmin 5y agoThe simple answer is "because we can". In general, physicists have found that we should write down the most general mathematical theory compatible with what's observed. A famous example of this is Einstein's cosmological constant -- I'll leave that one to wikipedia [1] since I'm a particle physicist and not an expert on GR. In the case of gauge theory, the idea that we should consider the most general case has been well proven. As GP pointed out, all observable phenomena ultimately depend only on the absolute modulus of the field Ψ, so a theoretical physicist naturally wonders, what happens if you allow its complex phase to vary. Turns out nothing interesting happens if you apply a global phase, but if you allow the phase to vary at every point in spacetime, it ends up breaking the theory. That is, unless you include an additional field at every point in spacetime that precisely cancels out the change induced by the gauge freedom. In other words, the motivation is that we can't simply look and "see" whether or not there is a locally varying phase on the wavefunction Ψ, since we only can measure |Ψ|^2. So we have to assume there is, until proven otherwise. Since a local phase would imply the existence of an extra field to cancel it out, we can indirectly check for this scenario by looking for the corresponding field. As pointed out by GP, in the case of a U(1) gauge, it turns out there is such a field, and electromagnetism (and all of its laws) exactly fit the bill. There are other "unmeasurable" symmetries you could apply to the wave function as well, beyond just a complex phase. SU(2) is a Lie group symmetry which would mean that the measurable properties of certain tuples of fields (Ψ, ϕ) are indistinguishable under a sort of complex-valued rotation of Ψ->ϕ and ϕ->Ψ. Again, if you assume a such symmetry is locally varied at every point in spacetime, you end up requiring not one but three new fields to cancel out the effects on the SM Lagrangian. It turns out that the vector bosons W+, W-, and Z, which mediate weak nuclear forces exactly fit the bill. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant
- vecter 5y agoIs this A you speak of the electromagnetic vector potential?
- bifftastic 5y agoI'm not the person you're replying to, but yes A definitely is the electromagnetic vector potential (from classical electrodynamics). In gauge theory A tells you how to relate the phase of Ψ at nearby points in space/time. Now that may purely a choice of convention for Ψ at different points in space/time (a choice of "gauge" in the jargon), but where it gets interesting is if your successive nearby points in space/time trace out a closed loop. If your A is such that the phase of Ψ ends up different as a result of going round the loop, you have an electromagnetic field!
- ufo_pilot 5y agoThe more correct technical term is "electromagnetic four potential", or "four vector". A is quantum, the electromagnetic potential is classical, so they are not really the same thing.
- dataflow 5y agoRelated question: is it settled which one is "real"? A or B? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aharonov%E2%80%93Bohm_effect#Potentials_vs._fields https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aharonov%E2%80%93Bohm_effect#P...
- cshimmin 5y agoActually since it's a spacetime potential, it's a 4-vector valued. So it's related to both the (three-)vector potential A and the scalar potential V.
- ChuckMcM 5y agoBased on my reading, the particle physics explanation/theory is precisely the current consensus. And, given my research into electrodynamics in order to understand the propagation of EM wave fronts in antenna design, I also think the article has some merit (which is, at its core, a call for some experiments). Given that "light" is fundamentally a electromagnetic wave and its propagation in spacetime is constant, and this results in time slowing down when you go faster to maintain this property, it isn't unreasonable to hypothesize a more fundamental basis here. Personally, I think adding in the time component will be essential to completing this puzzle but all in all it makes for an avenue of investigation which is interesting.
- eigenket 5y agoNote that light isn't particularly special in this context, what is special (very special) is the speed of light. Other things travel at the speed of light, indeed everything massless is forced to travel at the speed of light. Other things that travel at the speed of light include gravitational waves and gluons*. Basically "the speed of light" should be called "the speed of massless things" or possibly "the speed of causality" or something. We just call it "the speed of light" because light is the first thing we discovered that travels at this special speed. *the star is because everything about quantum-chromodynamics is terrible so gluons don't really ever exist as particles themselves. If they did they would travel at the speed of light.
- rolleiflex 5y agoI’ve found that this way of phrasing it helps people click: Speed of light is infinite*. What we call speed of light is the speed of reality. * not actually infinite, because reality itself propagates at a finite speed (I’d love to know if this is wrong - this is my best attempt to make sense of it from college classes)
- Smithalicious 5y agoIt's always helped me to think of c as the speed of causality. It's the speed at which one thing causes another
- infogulch 5y agoSo A/electromagnetism is a natural consequence of the universe having a free (complex modulo 1) parameter/field in addition to just the wavefunction Ψ. ?
- codethief 5y agoIf I understand you correctly, you claim that electromagnetism follows immediately from quantum mechanics because Born's rule exhibits a U(1) symmetry? That doesn't seem right to me.
- gus_massa 5y agoIt's not only the Born's rule. All the equations have a similar symmetry. (You may have ∂Ψ=VΨ, or Ψ∂Ψ*+∂ΨΨ*+ΨΨ*. See the real examples in the link in Wikipedia. But you never have something like ΨΨ+Ψ*Ψ* that mix the number of times that the linear and the conjugate version appears.) Also, it's not so immediate, because you must be stubborn enough to think that a global obvious symmetry "must" be extended to a local symmetry. And in any case, it took like 40 years a few brilliant persons to discover it.
- hilbert42 5y ago"I'm not sure how compatible is it with the proposal in the article discussed here." Right. It seems to me that both approaches make sense. Perhaps with some cleaver yet-to-be-determined math both ideas can finally be mated. I've never been convinced that the æther doesn't exist. Sure, it's been long debunked in the luminiferous æther sense but as the article points out "...the aether hypothesis was abandoned, and to this day, the classical theory of electromagnetism does not provide us with a clear answer to the question in which medium electric and magnetic fields propagate in vacuum." It is this aspect of the abolition of the æther that has always worried me. For starters, any new model of the æther would have to exhibit Lorentz-invariant properties. Then there's the matter of vacuum permittivity ε0 and vacuum permeability μ0 to consider as the speed of light/aka 'electromagnetism' is directly linked to these physical constants via the expression c = 1/(μ0 ε0)^0.5. If one constant were to change then so too would the others including α Sommerfeld's fine structure constant, RK the von Klitzing constant, and Z0 the vacuum (free space) impedance, etc., etc. (Anyway, one would expect them to change—not that we'd ever know as we'd likely not exist if they did). ;-) But I digress a little. We know that ε0 and μ0 have actual non-zero values and cannot be equated out (as we sort of tried to do in the days when we expressed electromagnetism in cgs units). In essence, physical constants ε0 and μ0 are absolutely intrinsic to electromagnetism, and whilst I cannot prove the fact, it seems to me they would be just as intrinsic to any new definition of the æther. Moreover, similar reasoning makes me think that QFT, ZPE/Zero-point energy/quantum vacuum state, ε0 and μ0 are all inextricably linked to GR. It seems to me that whilst matters such as whether the spacetime manifold is Ricci-flat, etc. are extremely important principally from the perspective that when properly dovetailed into any new theory they'll provide proof thereof—are secondary to the proposition (note, I'm not saying they're secondary aspects of physics, only that they're secondary to the initial proposition). Moreover, an equally important question to ask is why the constants ε0 and μ0 have the values they do given the quantum vacuum state, etc. Of course, the same logic applies to both α and c. Finally, we base just about everything on c it being the fundamental immutable constant (despite the the perennial emphasis/importance of α ≈ 1/137). The question is, is it in fact so, or is it that underlying physics first determines ε0 and μ0 and thus these constants could be considered more fundamental to any new formulation of the æther than that of c, it being the consequential resultant of the properties of those constants. (Heresy I know, but it would seem to make sense to view c in this context if or when we end up with new definition for the æther.)
- soheil 5y agoThis is absolutely an amazing explanation of local gauge symmetry I've ever seen. Thank you for writing this up. Gems like this is the reason I love HN!
- Accujack 5y ago> but the article is full of technical terms that you really don't want to know The article looks a lot like word salad... too many specific technical terms for the average person to manage, yet lacking in the specifics that would be needed by someone capable of understanding their theory. If it's written for their audience, then the only audience they seem to be targeting is average people who won't understand their assertions may be a load of crap. Or is there someone here with a deep understanding of these topics that would care to chime in?
- codethief 5y agoThe article is based on a paper which is linked at the very end. Here's my take: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27944642 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27944642 (Warning: Rather technical and full of math)
- brianpan 5y agoI have been really interested in general relativity and watching youtube videos for the past few months. I understood all the words (I would not have a year ago.) I think it does have enough detail to understand what they're saying. There's a lot missing, but I assume you'd go to the paper for that. But I think the article is well written. It essentially says, "We think this interesting thing is true. It has these nice properties, and should be provable/falsifiable. Please help us prove it!"
- poorjohnmacafee 5y agoWant to try ELI15?
- ikiris 5y agoI'd be satisfied with ELHighschool
- gus_massa 5y agoIt's very hard! I tried to simplify as much as possible and use as many small lies as possible, but keep the explanation faithful to the central idea. For example, I used that if k is a complex number with modulus 1, and k* is the conjugate, then kk*=1. It's a subject from a course of the first years of the university of a technical degree and perhaps a high school. Adding a detailed explanation in the middle makes the explanation too long. Also, it's a very important part of the correct technical complete version of the explanation, it's not a side comment or a metaphor. I think it could be explained better, or with different tradeoff to make it easier to understand. Anyway, it's my best effort with my personal taste. If you tell me the part that confused you, I can try to explain that part more. (And if you provide some personal background, like age range and what you studied, I can try to tailor it more.)