11 ms·
I am legitimately not sure if this is a bug or a feature. I'll take all the side-channels I can get though. These "exploits" are really useful for regaining co
by bob1029 5y ago
I am legitimately not sure if this is a bug or a feature.
I'll take all the side-channels I can get though. These "exploits" are really useful for regaining control over my own PC.
Just yesterday I learned how to Run-As TrustedInstaller, and that let me remove a lot of unwanted bullshit on my windows 10 install.
- majkinetor 5y agoYeah, it was the only way to remove defender. Then I used debloaters and shutup10 to remove all other "features". Windows didn't like it and returned ALL of them on update. Now I disabled update, and are totally motivated to go back to linux. Luckily all the tools I use on Windows are x-platform and with PowerShell, vscode, sql server etc. on linux and games working nothing holds me any more. I will probably miss Autohotkey and Foobar2k (maybe total commander but Dobulecmd is decent alternative and much better in some domains).
- gruez 5y ago>Yeah, it was the only way to remove defender Why not just disable it using group policy?
- malwarebytess 5y agoBecause he wants to removed unwanted software from his machine, not disable it. It's not dissimilar to being unable to remove bundled software on android.
- gruez 5y agoWhat's the difference, that you save 200MB of disk space? >It's not dissimilar to being unable to remove bundled software on android. It actually makes less sense on android since bundled apps are typically installed on the /system partition, which means they don't really take up any disk space (the space allocated to the /system partition is the same regardless of whether the app is there or not).
- bob1029 5y agoTotally removing defender as TI is the only option if you dont want it turning itself back on arbitrarily. I went through this hell yesterday for about 3 hours.
- gruez 5y ago>Totally removing defender as TI is the only option if you dont want it turning itself back on arbitrarily I disabled it via group policy 2 years ago and just checked, still disabled.
- bob1029 5y agoWhat version/edition of Win10 are you on?
- gruez 5y agoLTSC
- majkinetor 5y agoIt was working like that before, but on latest updates it automatically turns on every restart (or so). I don't really need to remove it, only disable it because it visibly slows down machine x2-x10 depending on what you do.
- gruez 5y ago> It was working like that before, but on latest updates it automatically turns on every restart (or so). that's if you disable through the normal settings interface. the group policy settings stick, although you might have to turn off "tamper protection" first before applying the group policy.
- majkinetor 5y agoDo you have any handy script for that? I am not going to click around for sure.
- Karunamon 5y agoFor one thing, setting that policy merits a malware detection in defender itself! https://twitter.com/Karunamon/status/1413280394439397376 https://twitter.com/Karunamon/status/1413280394439397376
- techrat 5y ago>...and are totally motivated to go back to linux. Windows 10 was what broke me and got me to using Linux full time. Before that, I barely knew how to even just get my way through debian to resume a disconnected screen session. Now I prefer to be in Linux. Even if the software that I can run using Wine/PlayOnLinux/Proton/Lutris isn't 100%... it's sufficient to where I don't miss being on Windows at all. I recently upgraded my main system and used the extra parts to rebuild my Win 10 standby box. I grew up on Windows. Started with Win3.0/DOS and used every iteration except WinME and Vista... and the rebuild only reminded me how much of a pain in the ass Windows is to install. 10 still has a lot of the usability bugs I've encountered from way back in the Win98 days but all the extra crap we have to deal with now (most inconsistent and overencumbered UI ever) just makes it even more of a chore to use than it ever has been. For what it's worth, Foobar2K runs great in Wine.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Datagenerator 5y agoDue this feature or was this possible normally too? Any links?
- gruez 5y ago>I'll take all the side-channels I can get though. These "exploits" are really useful for regaining control over my own PC. Not really? What does this exploit let you do that you couldn't already do with a local administrator account? Or are you making the general argument that "EoP exploits are features because they allow you to jailbreak your device"? >Just yesterday I learned how to Run-As TrustedInstaller, and that let me remove a lot of unwanted bullshit on my windows 10 install. They're not really comparable. You need admin to do it, which means you already crossed the security boundary[1]. This is in contrast to this exploit which allows you to cross a security boundary. [1] https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20121207-00/?p=5893 https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20121207-00/?p=58...
- majkinetor 5y ago> What does this exploit let you do that you couldn't already do with a local administrator account There are some things that users in Administrators group still can't do. Hence the need for TrustedInstaller perms. For example, try running this script: https://github.com/W4RH4WK/Debloat-Windows-10/blob/master/scripts/disable-windows-defender.ps1 https://github.com/W4RH4WK/Debloat-Windows-10/blob/master/sc... You will get access denied since few months back: https://github.com/W4RH4WK/Debloat-Windows-10/issues/273 https://github.com/W4RH4WK/Debloat-Windows-10/issues/273
- gruez 5y ago> > What does this exploit let you do that you couldn't already do with a local administrator account >There are some things that users in Administrators group still can't do. Hence the need for TrustedInstaller perms. By "this exploit" I was referring to the exploit mentioned in the article, not whatever gp did to get trustedinstaller permissions. As far as I know I don't see why you'd need access to the SAM file to give yourself trustedinstaller permissions. You can do that yourself if you're administrator. Also, from a security point of view there isn't much that administrators can't do. You're right that they can't directly delete certain files, but they can take ownership of any file they want and adjust the ACLs to give them the required permissions. I don't think is some sort of EoP/exploit/hack, but rather protection against accidental deletions (eg. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23054506 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23054506)
- chungy 5y agoFeature, I'd say. Volume Shadow Copies are used to make consistent online backups of an NTFS file system. I don't think non-admin users are normally able to make them in the first place, and if admin is required, it's hard to see the fuss.
- gruez 5y ago>I don't think non-admin users are normally able to make them in the first place, and if admin is required, it's hard to see the fuss. shadow copies are automatically created as part of system protection (enabled by default).
- rawoke083600 5y ago>" for regaining control over my own PC. Just yesterday I learned how to Run-As TrustedInstaller, and that let me remove a lot of unwanted bullshit on my windows 10 install." I understand Linux, Mac, FreeBSD, Magic-Pony-OS is not everyone's cup of tea or they might not be in a position to choose their OS (Work etc) But DAMN that quote above is really showing me how bad it is out there ! Sure it can/does happen on other OS as well, but I'm betting Windows is the leader in "my-pc-is-not-my-pc-anymore" :/
- Sebb767 5y ago> I'm betting Windows is the leader in "my-pc-is-not-my-pc-anymore" :/ There are PCs out there running ChromeOS and Android. Not to mention smartphones and game consoles. Windows is not good in this regard, but it's by far not the worst (though the UX for administrative actions is really not great, IMO).
- techrat 5y ago(Nearly?) All ChromeOS devices use CoreBoot. You really can't get much more open than that. Android is open source and if you don't buy a locked down device from a carrier, the bootloader is unlockable and the system easily rootable. Your two examples of something more 'not my pc anymore' than Windows aren't exactly good ones. Now, if you were to mention MacOS and iOS... then you definitely would have had a point.
- Sebb767 5y ago> (Nearly?) All ChromeOS devices use CoreBoot. You really can't get much more open than that. Last time I looked, it was really hard to install anything other than ChromeOS on Chromebook hardware. You can install a chrooted Linux on them, yes, but on the device itself you can't even execute unsigned binaries. Impossible? No. Harder than executing an installer with elevated rights? Yes. Plus, they also come with pre-installed software like Google Docs. > Android is open source and if you don't buy a locked down device from a carrier, That's quite a big if. Android itself is open source, yes, but >90% of the ecosystem rely on Google Play services, which are anything but. And, when talking about pre-installed apps that the user can't remove without a lot of effort, Android basically invented that. > the bootloader is unlockable and the system easily rootable. If you wipe your device and void your warranty. And then install a third-party binary to actually use those rights, while similarly loosing the ability to use quite a few apps (like banking). That is, if the manufacturer makes it that easy (Xiaomi, for example, needs you to sign up and wait for that - it's possible, but anything but frictionless). > Now, if you were to mention MacOS and iOS... then you definitely would have had a point I can't talk about MacOS, to be honest. Though, as far as I know, getting a root shell is not hard and running own software is not a problem. We agree on iOS, but the grandparent talked about PCs - iOS really does not fall into that category (that's why I explicitly mentioned smartphones). > Your two examples of something more 'not my pc anymore' than Windows aren't exactly good ones. Windows is not a good example of that. Don't get me wrong, I don't like windows. But it's by far not the worst example of a locked-down, vendor-owned system and it would be even less bad if the administration UX would be simpler.
- rootsudo 5y agoHuge oversight, it renders and breaks previous GPO, meaning that the tech debt in Windows NT itself is huge. Which makes you wonder really how comfy OSX POSIX is, but they had their own fun bugs lately too, sudo for example and other ones. Plus they're doing an CPU Arch jump. Kinda feels like the 90's again, in a sense.
- sveiss 5y agoDefinitely a bug. The Unix equivalent would be a package update silently making /etc/shadow world readable, exposing the hashed passwords of local users. Not a big deal for a single user machine — there’s nothing you can do with this that you can’t do some other way as a local admin/root — but not good if you have untrusted, non-admin user accounts.