6 ms·
>Haynes noted, however, that the timeline for commercialization of large area displays on TFT panels “will depend on how quickly the industry develops mass tran
by ksec 5y ago
>Haynes noted, however, that the timeline for commercialization of large area displays on TFT panels “will depend on how quickly the industry develops mass transfer technologies that can deliver high accuracy and exceptional reliability.” Indeed, Apple’s latest iPad, which uses white miniLEDs for backlighting, requires the accurate placement of 10,000 emitters, which sounds challenging enough. Positioning 25 million red, green, and blue subpixels on a 78-inch TFT panels for a 4K TV, with a tolerance of only 10 non-functioning pixels, will require an exceedingly robust, highly accurate transfer method.
>Different Paths to RGB...... Basically uLED Backlight with QD
And the rest. As much as I love and want uLED. None of these are new, and the problem has been roughly the same from day 1 in 2016 when all the media were jumping on uLED. Even if they could solve all of that they still dont have a roadmap of cost reduction that could match OLED.
On the other hand OLED cost has been dropping quicker than expected. It is another one of those thing like Solar panel where all industry analysis and projection were wrong. We also have a solid roadmap to improve colour accuracy, burn rate, efficiency etc. Along with other "potential" OLED adjacent technology like QNEDs where it is 80-90% of uLED but could be used on existing OLED manufacturing.
Again as much as I love to see uLED, objectively speaking I just dont see how it could compete. And it is one of those moment where better is the enemy of the best.
- sschueller 5y agoI am old enough to remember when OLED was in the same boat. Yield was low, expected life was short and RGB was far off. I was extremely excited when I got my hands on a 2 line character single color OLED display many years ago. That a phone would ever have an OLED color display was a far off fantasy. I am sure we will see uLED at some point, it just takes time and a lot of research.
- fsloth 5y agoYes, I remember when OLED:s were far off future technology for mass consumption. I think the first OLED display I saw was a tiny Sony PAL TV that probably cost an arm and leg back then. The analyst consensus back then was that OLEDs are too hard/expensive/etc for generic consumers.
- IshKebab 5y ago> I am old enough to remember... It was like 8 years ago!
- brk 5y agoNo, it was much longer ago, especially for pre-RGB applications. OLEDs came about in the late 80's, and mono displays started showing up in the 90s (I think one of my early flip phones had an OLED exterior display). RGB units were demonstrated around 2000 and commercialized in limited uses in the very early 2000's.
- sunstone 5y agoI'm old enough to remember almost nothing...
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoI remember standing the lobby at work watching the company's stock performance displayed on a Sony plasma TV and thinking "that TV cost $12,000 and that's what they're doing with it." Now that seems so long ago...
- ramesh31 5y ago>Again as much as I love to see uLED, objectively speaking I just dont see how it could compete. And it is one of those moment where better is the enemy of the best. Burn in is a very serious issue with OLED as well as overall lifespan due to the organic nature of the diodes. uLED is probably a better technology for a variety of applications that have to factor those issues in.
- xattt 5y agoIt would be quite awful if the supposed durability of miniLEDs would turn out to be an environmental disaster for chemical leaching (due to the number of LEDs) and microplastics.
- Tagbert 5y agoThe amount of plastics in a display panel is much less than the amount of plastic bottles most people go through in a week or less. Yes, every little bit contributes, but you need to focus efforts on the impactful sources first .
- baybal2 5y ago> And the rest. As much as I love and want uLED. None of these are new, and the problem has been roughly the same from day 1 in 2016 when all the media were jumping on uLED. Even if they could solve all of that they still dont have a roadmap of cost reduction that could match OLED. Not even 2016. Samsung had uLED type display RnD going in their Samsung Research Institute since 2006. Just as with OLED, despite all of the crazy tech investor money, it's very clear who will reach the finish line first. Samsung probably already has a commercialisable solution, but is just keeping it in the sleeve, waiting for an appropriate moment, like OLED profits shrinking, or somebody else getting close to microled commercialisation.
- bumbada 5y agoOLED technology has two significant problems that will not be solved anytime soon: 1. Blue OLEDS do not last, they degrade much faster than the other colors. 2. Burnout. This is intrinsic to the technology. LED tech has not those problems. uLEDs technology already works very well, much better than OLEDs, it is just too expensive. There is no need for inventing new technology. Also, when talking about LEDs we must talk about the inverse technology: Solar panels. Improvements and investment in solar panel technologies transfer to LEDs fast because it is the inverse: Any LED or light emitting diode does generate electricity when light. OLED promising advantage for the future is the possibility of being printed extremely cheap and superfast on plastic substrates, specially for solar panels, at cents/square meter. But right now showstoppers exist for that tech.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoAre they really not solved? Because there are a lot of high end devices with OLED displays for a while now, eg Samsung Galaxy, iPhone X series and Huawei, and their displays haven't degraded over say 5 years from what I can tell.
- MikusR 5y agoAll of them have burnin it's inevitable.
- hexa22 5y agoJust like how all SSDs will fail after enough writes. A problem that I will never stress over. I have had many oled devices for many years and I have never once seen noticeable burn in like I have never had an ssd die. I’m not denying it exists. But the scale of the problem and the time it takes to occur make it a non issue for most use cases.
- dharmaturtle 5y agoOLED burn in is the main reason I haven't bought one to use as a monitor. The taskbar is probably gonna burn in as it just doesn't change much.
- ksec 5y agoAnswering to All comments. I am old enough to remember when I first read about OLED too :) It was 1997 in WH Smith ( A book store in UK, ). It was mentioned as the Holy Grail of Display Tech. And I have been following it loosely ever since. Burn-In, It is an issue. But specific to certain usage. The above was written mostly in the view of Smartphone. Apart from gaming, Top quality OLED panel burn in issues on Smartphone is rare due to your usage on smartphone, you dont use the same App for prolong period of time. ( So dont expect OLED on your computer soon, it makes no sense. ) OLED is also a spectrum of technology, WOLED are less susceptible to burn in, along with Quantum Dot OLED. Again with a roadmap to further improves these situation. And I did mention QNED [1] , Nanorod SolidState OLED that drastically improve everything from brightness, efficiency, burn in and even cost. Although that is somewhat 5 years in the future. The difference between comparing to LCD to OLED and OLED to uLED mostly comes down to cost / benefits. OLED was thinner, lighter, more efficient, profitable than LCD. There is nothing on LCD roadmap that could compete with OLED for Smartphone display. Nothing. There is a reason why even low end Smartphone are switching or planning to switch to OLED display. Entry Level OLED and LCD price are already level except LCD are virtually operating at a zero margin, while OLED are profitable and with a roadmap in this decade to further dipping below $10 per panel for average sub 6" Smartphone Display. ( Ask BOE ) And a whole positive feedback loop to further evolve the spectrum of technology. Again this is mostly looking at Smartphone. We could see uLED take on TV and large size display where OLED dont make sense. But then uLED is also a spectrum of technology and those used in the current Samsung and Sony Wall Size TV aren't the same as those that wants to fit in to tablet and phone. [1] https://www.displaysupplychain.com/blog/are-quantum-nano-emitting-diodes-qneds-the-next-big-thing https://www.displaysupplychain.com/blog/are-quantum-nano-emi...
- baybal2 5y ago> And I did mention QNED [1] , Nanorod SolidState OLED that drastically improve everything from brightness, efficiency, burn in and even cost. Although that is somewhat 5 years in the future. Nanorod LEDs are not OLEDs but fairly standard blue leds. Samsung got a 15 years headstart. I think they are going straight for skipping the mass transfer stage altogether, and growing LEDs on the glass. Their first working blue GaN led on glass was in 2011. 4 or 5 years since they launched the effort. > There is a reason why even low end Smartphone are switching or planning to switch to OLED display. Low end smartphone sized OLED screens are actually cheaper in China than decent LCDs from time to time.