6 ms·
Facebook has so far tried, and failed, to do this. Twice. First was Facebook Spaces. Opened 2017, closed 2019. This was a VR world. Not a very good one. It was
by Animats 5y ago
Facebook has so far tried, and failed, to do this. Twice.
First was Facebook Spaces. Opened 2017, closed 2019. This was a VR world. Not a very good one. It was mostly a 3D approach to a desktop.[1] You could hand other people flat pictures. Sharing! Total flop.
Second was Facebook Horizon. Opened 2020, still running, but not getting much attention. It's a 3D cartoon level VR world. Works OK, not very interesting or pretty. Big emphasis on "safety", which means no sex. Avatars have no legs; nothing below the waistline. Plus there's a panic button which puts you in a "personal safe zone", where you're in a bubble until Security gets there to rescue you from whomever is annoying you. While it's still running, Facebook doesn't mention Horizon any more.
Zuckerberg's vision is probably more like that video I've linked before, "Hypereality". The real world, with overlays from augmented reality. Overlays of more ads.
[1] https://youtu.be/_kGRpSd4vnc https://youtu.be/_kGRpSd4vnc
[2] https://youtu.be/Uf_9J_EdzZw https://youtu.be/Uf_9J_EdzZw
[3] https://youtu.be/YJg02ivYzSs https://youtu.be/YJg02ivYzSs
- giobox 5y agoVR/AR is such a new paradigm for interacting with computers I think that its inevitable companies will make many failures before finding the apps and hardware that clicks with customers. In 2017, we had only had mainstream non-beta VR headset hardware in the marketplace since 2016 (original consumer Rift, HTC Vive), lets not forget the 20 years of PDA hardware/software attempts we lived through before the mainstream smartphone designs we all use appeared in 2007. I expect a very similar arc will be followed for VR/AR, especially as the interaction model is so different from screen based. I'm happy to see some development out "in the open", and wouldn't be so quick to criticize small project flops; VR/AR needs to begin somewhere. Zuck isn't trying to pretend VR/AR is ready for primetime either yet, he's made it clear he wants to be in a very strong position when/if the market does heavily move to VR/AR hardware, which he obviously believes strongly it will over time.
- erikpukinskis 5y agoNotably, I think eye contact is a killer app for VR and none of the headsets can do it yet. Facebook is smart to be in there doing experiments and failing though. That's table stakes for having a shot at winning the competition.
- Animats 5y agoVR/AR is such a new paradigm for interacting with computers. Not really. I tried Jaron Lainer's original VR rig back in the 1980s. The Autodesk system from the 1980s. The W Industries system ... the HTC Vibe. The Microsoft HoloLens. There's been progress, but usability really hasn't improved all that much. You can shoot at people. That works fine. You can sort of use swords. Everything else, not so much. That's why Beat Saber is still the most successful VR game. Some Autodesk people once thought that VR would make it easier to use CAD, because selection in 3D with a mouse is such a pain. Didn't work out, and 3D selection with a mouse got much better. If anybody gets this right, it might be NVidia Omniverse. That's an attempt to do for 3D what shared text editors do for text documents.
- baby 5y agoOh my, reading your comment I couldn’t stop myself from laughing. I too tried the old VR headsets, played doom on one and got a massive headache. I thought VR was bad and stupid after that. Then I tried the HTC Vive and holy molly I almost cried after trying it. Now I own an Oculus Quest II and… it is the future. I’m sorry but this is it.
- h2odragon 5y agoThe Autodesk system ran on what, a pair of RS/6000? I got to chat with some of their guys showing that off at a trade show in off moments over a few days; they were great at running the demo but were umm... unenthused about the prospects of anyone keeping the system running for any time without high grade help.
- andybak 5y ago3d selection in VR is better. Just give it a hundredth of the investment we've given desktop UI
- wcarss 5y agoI think the biggest selection problem is the Minority Report UI problem: hanging hands are not precise tools, nor are they comfortable to hold up for > ~a minute. In particular, it is very hard to do even one pixel-perfect point+grab+release in 3D space, let alone do it over and over -- in large part because you can't easily lock a dimension or the position and rest your hand. Touch-screens are hard to get precise-clicks on for a similar reason: with a mouse I can line it up and hit fire, with touch I'm firing until I let go. If someone gets the right metaphor going there, I think it could work great, but the naive solution of 1:N direct scaling the position of your hand to a co-ordinate in space isn't it. I imagine it'll be something like direct correlation to get 'in the neighbourhood' and then an easy modal toggle to a 'precision' mode, where you move something in small increments along just 1 or 2 dimensions, using a comfortable binary gesture. Or maybe AI will get really good at guessing what alignment the user wants.
- Bombthecat 5y agoI thought horizon is still in beta?
- Ajedi32 5y agoInvite-only closed beta. That's probably why GP hasn't heard about it in a while.
- rubicon33 5y agoI'm in the beta and I have played Horizon. I'm not impressed at all. The worlds are tiny and uninteresting. The color pallet is cartoony. Audio has enough delay still to be unnatural (a problem with cell phones too, btw, but made much worse when the person is standing in front of you). Their world building tools are kind of interesting, and surely were difficult to implement, but lack any real purpose or traction. All in all, I'm surprised more by how basic and bad Horizon is than I am by how good it is. Its been in development for a long time, and by now, I expected a lot more.
- astlouis44 5y agoHorizon is a terrible experience and won't be the MVP of the metaverse even when it's launched publicly out of beta. Try vrland.io instead, it's a web-based social 3D/VR platform that runs everywhere with a browser which includes WebXR. Link: https://vrland.io/lobby https://vrland.io/lobby
- Animats 5y agoIt's been stuck in beta for a year now. More likely to shut down than advance from beta.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoI love Hyperreality, and I can't wait for it to come true. I think my world would be much better. Look at how cool it is! I get that it's not for everyone, but sign me up.
- grishka 5y agoYou can't wait for there to be even more ads in this world? You want them to physically follow you around? You can't wait for corporations to see your every move? No thanks. We need to fix our current internet before allowing it to permeate our lives any deeper.
- Adrig 5y agoMeh, I'll use the Mozilla VR OS with uBlock 2040 on it
- shrimp_emoji 5y agoAlthough the present shows us that most people will be happy corpo serfs. : p
- tablespoon 5y ago> Meh, I'll use the Mozilla VR OS with uBlock 2040 on it Adblockers may not work so well in the future, when everything's a binary blob of Web Assembly.
- grishka 5y agoAndroid apps are binary blobs of dalvik bytecode, yet simply blocking a bunch of domains at the DNS level is surprisingly effective to get rid of most ads.
- sudosysgen 5y agoAlso, tools like lucky patcher can do bytecode analysis and patch out ads automatically.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Plus there's a panic button which puts you in a "personal safe zone", where you're in a bubble until Security gets there to rescue you from whomever is annoying you. While it's still running, Facebook doesn't mention Horizon any more. > [2] https://youtu.be/Uf_9J_EdzZw https://youtu.be/Uf_9J_EdzZw That video is kind of amazing. It's all people of color, until one white guy shows up and immediately gets blocked. Also, all their safety team can do is make a recording and submit a report for further review? That seems stupid and pointless.
- tkiolp4 5y agoUmm, I’m not American so bear with me: - the lady in blue, she looks like a white person after having sun in the beach - the guy with purple tshirt, he looks readhead, so white - the guy with white hat and black hoodie looks south American - the guy with glasses and red jacket, looks black - the ladies with white tshirt, look white - the lady with glasses and brown tshirt, looks white - the guy with grey hat and orange hoodie looks white
- 83457 5y agoYou are responding to a silly comment. With that said, I think straight black hair often implies non-european ancestry. I'd just assume main woman is Spanish, one in white is Asian. The non-black males are all pretty ambiguous (shrug)
- dathinab 5y agoThe fact that people have to speculate this shows IMHO nicely not just that there are no clear borders between peoples "race" but that the concept of race seems pretty pointless.
- tablespoon 5y ago> The fact that people have to speculate this shows IMHO nicely not just that there are no clear borders between peoples "race" but that the concept of race seems pretty pointless. We are talking about cartoons, so we're really talking about symbols and coding. You're taking too much of a leap by inferring that much about the underlying concept from the use of symbols. You might have a point, but you need different support.
- pteraspidomorph 5y ago> Avatars have no legs; nothing below the waistline This is the biggest mistake a lot of VR developers made and are still making. People want to look cool in VR. They don't want to look like flying blobs (unless that's their actual chosen aesthetic). This affects their platform and purchase choices to a degree that many don't seem to fully comprehend.
- astlouis44 5y agoCheck out vrland! It's a social 3D/VR metaverse platform on the web. Decentralized and works everywhere including VR headsets via WebXR. Link to the platform: https://vrland.io/lobby https://vrland.io/lobby Link to our Discord: https://discord.gg/cNfG834 https://discord.gg/cNfG834
- mkl 5y agoI gave it a try in a web browser. To be honest it barely seemed to work, had a frame rate of about 1fps in very simple scenes, and there didn't seem to be anything actually there, just a few empty low-poly rooms. I didn't see any sign of social or metaverse features. The mouse controls are backwards, and that combined with massive lag means looking around is pretty difficult. If you're serious about making such a product, some screenshots and description of the good bits (if you're serious there must be some somewhere) on the home page would be way more effective than making people go into it and mostly just be confused and frustrated.
- astlouis44 5y agoThanks for the feedback! What device did you try on? Love the blunt and honest feedback. The platform comes alive in VR btw, but understand if you don’t have a headset. You can start building using the editor tool and share your room with others to view it in a social manner. If there’s any features you’d think would make this more like a proper metaverse, please let me know.
- mkl 5y agoI tried it on a desktop PC, Chrome on Linux, Nvidia GPU several years old (seems to work well for most WebGL things though). I think what's missing from the current presentation is the "why". Why would I build something with it, and why would other people want to join in? I'm not saying there aren't good reasons, but the empty home page doesn't provide any, and nor did a few minutes playing around. I think interoperability is what would really make a metaverse experience, so I'm pretty doubtful any single company could do it, even with Facebook's resources. I think the web itself is the closest thing to a metaverse we have, but it's still far away in terms of actual experience. I think that it's become universal because of the interoperability and common standards that mean it doesn't matter what software or hardware is used to create, interact with, or consume content, so it's a level playing field without one organisation controlling it, and so people are free to go nuts making stuff, without threat of losing it or losing access.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> https://youtu.be/Uf_9J_EdzZw https://youtu.be/Uf_9J_EdzZw I don't know why the no legs thing seems so incredibly frightening to me. It's like a really bad "uncanny valley" feeling - everyone walking around, chatting normally, but seeming to not realize they've all been sawed in half.
- whall6 5y agoIt’s easy to say that because they’ve failed twice they’ll fail again. But I could just as easily see that in a few years the success of the meta verse was due to these failures.
- siculars 5y agoThe fact they failed twice, as you point out, is only more reason to believe they will succeed. There isn't much that success first contact with reality. A trillion dollar company with the temerity to endure will eventually succeed.
- prawn 5y agoYes, it demonstrates they're confident this is a direction things are taking and that they are in a good position to achieve it. I don't use Facebook so it all makes me a bit uncomfortable, but I think they'll get there. Solid VR option, massive userbase, stable of smart employees, warchest, etc.