7 ms·
NASA investigates renaming James Webb telescope after anti-LGBT+ claims
- metalliqaz 5y agoWebb was born in 1906. Why beclown themselves like this? JWST already has a name, they can't undo that association, even if they change the name.
- garblegarble 5y ago>JWST already has a name, they can't undo that association, even if they change the name. To the technical people who're already interested perhaps, but the general public won't have that association. It seems valid not to glorify people who were involved in atrocities (perhaps overstating things in this case, I've not looked into it - but as a general point) from the past. Personally I can't see them deciding to rename it, but I don't think it's silly for them to consider it, and if they did I wouldn't be bothered... just get the thing launched so we can do more science!
- Beached 5y agothe issue is that every has skeletons in their closet. if you go by that mentality, you can never name anything after anyone. you can never celebrate people's accomplishments ever, because that person will have ALWAYS also had something bad in their life.
- garblegarble 5y agoI understand the point you're making and I'm sympathetic to it, and the knee-jerk reaction that people who do anything seriously bad are irredeemable - but I think there's a distinct difference between the different "skeletons on their closet" that makes it not the slippery slope you're worried about. There will be plenty of figures for whom "something bad" is just generally being rude/an asshole their whole life, for example - and that's quite different from actively furthering the systematic persecution of people based on something they can't control like who they love.
- AllegedAlec 5y agoIt's also a bit like: 'Man born over a century ago hasn't the same values that we do today. More news at eleven.' Do you really think that Hubble didn't have such views, or any other person you name stuff after?
- bostonsre 5y agoYea agreed, he held a belief that most people in society held at the time. We probably hold beliefs that will be shameful to those in the future. I constantly look back at my past self and think he was an idiot. People are fallible and make mistakes as well.
- sp332 5y agoPlenty of people have the same values today. here is the 2016/2020 Republican platform [PDF] https://prod-static-ngop-pbl.s3.amazonaws.com/media/documents/DRAFT_12_FINAL%5B1%5D-ben_1468872234.pdf https://prod-static-ngop-pbl.s3.amazonaws.com/media/document... It includes an endorsement to "bar government discrimination against individuals and businesses for acting on the belief that marriage is the union of one man and one woman". So you can't argue that we should forget his bigotry just because it's old and not relevant anymore.
- AllegedAlec 5y ago> So you can't argue that we should forget his bigotry just because it's old and not relevant anymore. I never said any of that though.
- sp332 5y agoJames Webb has values that people still do today. Your summary of the issue says the opposite.
- JoeyBananas 5y agoThat really shouldn't be a controversial statement. Having a government that imposes the values of one group on everyone sounds great when you happen to be a part of that group, but what happens when they decide to impose values that you don't agree with?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> JWST already has a name, they can't undo that association I think this is all quite silly, but wanted to push back on this narrow point. Renaming works. Uluru was renamed in the last few decades; the new name has stuck [1]. (With more time, New York and Istanbul.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uluru#Name https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uluru#Name
- rscoots 5y agoI think the variables here are how tenuous the current name is, and also how cool/enduring the replacement name is. Mt McKinely -> Denali is another great example. I think these factors will usually be stronger than any moral dimension.
- metalliqaz 5y agoI think your example is a good illustration of my point... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denali https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denali "McKinley" occurs 60 times on that page and is in the first sentence of the article.
- denimnerd42 5y agojust don't name anything after anyone because chances are they are not flawless
- RspecMAuthortah 5y agoOr name after people mainstream media would approve and never dare to question.
- drstewart 5y agoI'm not sure why you're downvoted. MLK was a rampant cheater and emotionally abused his spouse, and yet I've never seen anyone dare to say the many things named after him should be renamed despite the glorification of infidelity this clearly promotes. I wonder why?
- AllegedAlec 5y agoOr accept that people have flaws and celebrate them in spite of that.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Or accept that people have flaws and celebrate them in spite of that You don't even have to celebrate them. Just acknowledge the contributions they made.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jacknews 5y agoWhy do we have to name things after people to celebrate them? We can acknowledge and celebrate Einstein's contributions without calling his theory "Einsteinian Mechanics" or whatever, but instead the more descriptive and accessible "General Relativity".
- AllegedAlec 5y ago
- acer4666 5y agoI think at this point we shouldn't name anything after anyone ever again, its the only way to be safe
- Causality1 5y agoWe're going to quickly run out of names if every person we ever memorialize has to be without sin. I bet Isaac Newton was pretty racist, let's rename physics to "pride math".
- echopurity 5y agoHow about just physics? "Newtonian physics" is a fake and outdated attribution anyway.
- whatshisface 5y agoNewtonian physics is a specific kind of physics distinct from other kinds which is why it has a sub-name.
- sp332 5y agoNewton only contributed the three laws of motion to the model. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Newtonian_mechanics https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Newtonian_mechani... The model includes additions from Leibnitz, Euler, Lagrange, and others from around the same time. The name "classical mechanics" doesn't pretend that Newton came up with all that stuff.
- whatshisface 5y agoClassical mechanics includes everything that's not quantum, including general relativity and the Navier-Stokes equation. It is not a suitable term for Newtonian mechanics because it already refers to a much larger category.
- sp332 5y agoAccording to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_mechanics#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_mechanics#History, that's a recent change. It didn't used to include special or general relativity.
- lolbrels 5y agoThis just turns more people and myself anti-LGBT. They obviously have no qualms erasing history so hopefully they will be erased as well.
- lrdswrk00 5y agoYeah who cares if they change it? It’s a mental name tag to be sure one is not referring to a different space telescope. It means nothing to the stable structure of reality. This stuff only means something to the snowflakes on the “manly” side of the political aisle.
- jaywalk 5y ago> It means nothing to the stable structure of reality. This is a pointless argument to make. Your entire existence means nothing to the stable structure of reality, but I bet there'd be people who'd be affected by your absence.
- millzlane 5y ago>but I bet there'd be people who'd be affected by your absence. On the other hand there'd be billions that wouldn't.
- jaywalk 5y agoNo kidding. What's your point?
- lrdswrk00 5y agoSpeaking of pointless arguments to make… My one comment on the insipidness of clinging to labels we give to machines set you right off on one. Some of us are able to put things in appropriate context. The root idea of this thread is the name of a satellite. What does that possibly have to do with how I treat those closest to me? You sure inferred a whole lot more than you needed to about a complete stranger. Brilliant work, Mr or Ms 1 in 7 billion. Why are you worth listening to, really? This comment sure isn’t providing much reason to…
- wyager 5y agoBecause constantly renaming mental name tags is a huge pain in the ass. We might as well just give everything in the world a UUID - at least that’s immutable.
- selimthegrim 5y agoPayne-Gaposchkin is actually a good choice considering what a raw deal she got.
- olivermarks 5y ago'Those who control the present, control the past and those who control the past control the future.' - George Orwell We need to have a serious think about the value of erasing historical figures based on their actions in a very different past. I know people who were bigots in the past but have substantially changed their perspective, and I also know people who have become more rigid and bigoted in their views over time. One of those people is gay fwiw. Why is it that perceived character flaws based on current social mores result in historical people being cancelled in our current climate? Rinsing out perceived offensive behaviors from history will surely lead to a future featuring a bland lack of knowledge and no real world behavioral social frameworks
- matzab 5y agoRefraining from honoring someone is not the same as erasing them.
- runjake 5y agoWhen you're quite literally erasing James Webb from the name, that seems like erasing and supports olivermark's point entirely.
- ineedasername 5y agoHistory isn't about who has their names on objects, that's just window dressing. Taking his name off an object when it was put there to honor him is clearly not that same as erasing his history.
- sp332 5y agoAsking people to forget his bigotry would be erasing everything but his name. Removing his name from the project is a potential result of a more complete knowledge of history, pending this investigation.
- polytely 5y agoThere is a big difference between erasing someone from history and not naming something in someone's honor. It isn't like nasa is now going to scrub all the history books of the name James Webb or outlaw mentioning his name. I would think there are enough people worth naming a telescope after after.
- wyager 5y agoNot a single person of note who has died above age 30 has had opinions entirely in line with the cutting edge of American progressive thought.
- lovecg 5y ago> Former NASA administrator Sean O’Keefe named the JWST after Webb in 2002, when the telescope was in the early stages of development. It was a unilateral decision that took many by surprise, because NASA’s telescopes are typically named after scientists. Webb, who died in 1992, was a bureaucrat who held several administrative roles in the US government. I actually had no idea who Webb was, I always assumed he was an astronomer or something. Maybe it’s not a bad idea to change it and honor an actual scientist regardless?
- tptacek 5y agoIf this article had been written about the "controversy over naming a space telescope over a bureaucrat rather than a scientist", every comment here would be advocating for the name change. The framing is everything, which is why people click on stuff like this.
- cjensen 5y agoThe notion that we can only recognize perfect people in history seems misguided since there are precious few perfect people. Audubon owned slaves. Muir was racist. Webb was discriminatory. These are all teachable moments: the evils in our past were not solely the fault of the worst people in society; even the best people were responsible.
- echopurity 5y agoNo, the "best people" weren't responsible for slavery. Any rich guy can write a book or do math especially if they live off slave labor. There were plenty of people who opposed slavery. Those were the best people, even if they're not remembered in a culture that worships slavemasters.
- cjensen 5y agoYou're right that the abolitionists were better people who lived at the same time. My point is really that people can be good in many honorable ways and yet also be complicit in the common evil of their time. Likely many abolitionists were against LGBT; it's good to remember both their greatness and their failings.
- tosstoyevsky 5y agoYou can bet that even the “best people” held some unpopular view. I’m sure they used words that would be considered terrible by today’s standards. It’s the same as going all the way back to the beginning of someone’s Twitter account to find a rap lyric quote to get them fired. Even the most cautious careful views today may look terrible 100 years from now.
- acer4666 5y agoThere's a passage in Alan Turing's autobiography that suggests he performed a non-consensual sexual act on a male friend.* I would certainly not use this as cause for renaming the many things we have named after Turing. *Alan Turing: The Enigma, page 132: "They were ordinary people, who made Alan feel more at home than did the grand Princeton figures. In their old-fashioned country way, they put Alan and Maurice in the same double bed. The compartments of life were fractured. Maurice was amazed - he had not had the slightest suspicion. Alan apologised and withdrew at once. Then he blazed out"
- JoeyBananas 5y agoThis is the perfect bike shed to delay the JWST for another year. Great job social justice!
- scrollaway 5y agoI'll preface this by saying that I obviously don't support anti-LGBT+ rhethoric, no matter when it happened. But without digging into the claims themselves, I'd invite people to look at this article critically, and pay careful attention to the weasel words. Specifically: - "Some astronomers argue…" - "NASA is investigating…" - "Many people have…" - "Many are keen…" I'm not familiar with the field of astronomy, but to me this article is just full of red flags that it's trying to make a big explosive story out of what amounts to a few people annoyed about Webb's past, four of which think he shouldn't have a telescope named after him and circulating a petition; and NASA doing its due-diligence and launching an investigation rather than ignoring the petition outright. Or, to put it another way, clickbait. A non-story until something concrete actually comes up. Something to keep people busy, and yelling out "just don't name anything after anyone because chances are they are not flawless".
- azinman2 5y agoIt claims 1250 signatures, which is more than “a few”.
- scrollaway 5y agoI'd wager it isn't. Depends a lot on who the names are (the article does claim there's some relevant ones in there). I'd probably sign such a petition if the evidence called for it. With an easy enough CTA, you could gather 1250 signatures just off that HN post alone. But 1250 signatures is very little. This one (https://www.change.org/p/eight-years-later-it-s-still-too-darn-hot-to-learn-in-denver-public-schools https://www.change.org/p/eight-years-later-it-s-still-too-da...) has 6500 signatures on change.org calling for some air conditioning in Denver public schools. The JWST is on a completely different scale than those schools.
- blululu 5y agoYet another delay to the deployment of this telescope. Hard for me to shake the cynical idea that this is just a smoke screen to mask the latest round of delays and overruns.[1] Or at least allow everyone involved to put a new less tainted project name on their resume. In my perception I associate ‘James Webb’ with colossal engineering mismanagement more than I do with a dead astronomer. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nasas-james-webb-space-telescope-is-delayed-again/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nasas-james-webb-...
- XorNot 5y agoEngineers tuning the most complicated spaceborne deployment system ever built are not being retasked to investigate a petition about the namesake of the vehicle.
- serverholic 5y agoI really hate this modern idea that we need to cancel every historical figure because they don't live up to our modern standards. When you cancel someone you basically are saying they're evil. Do we really want to treat the entirety of human history as evil? Because, spoiler alert every human in history has done something we consider wrong today.
- azinman2 5y agoBut playing devils advocate here, would you be ok with naming things after Stalin? Hitler? Ivan the terrible? Or keeping things named after them? I’m guessing there’s a spectrum here, so the question is where’s the line?
- chucksta 5y agoYes, we name things after Satan and Hell. So why not, doesn't mean it has to be a "good" thing
- teddyh 5y agoAs time passes, history becomes legend, legend becomes myth, and actual people turn into symbols of something else: http://freefall.purrsia.com/ff2000/fv01950.htm http://freefall.purrsia.com/ff2000/fv01950.htm
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoSeems like a big leap. I don't think anyone is saying James Webb was evil, but that maybe Nasa should be careful of honoring a man who didn't reflect their current values. That said I'm not sure it's worth it to change the name because very few people even know who James Webb was.
- serverholic 5y agoStrong actions call for strong words. Observing living people who are cancelled, it's like a scarlett letter. It's beyond getting a slap on the wrist. Getting cancelled is getting branded as a bad person.
- albertopv 5y ago"He that is without sin among you, let him cast the first stone."
- FredPret 5y agoAs an atheist I must say there are some useful lines in the Bible, like this one
- fallingknife 5y agoWe have managed to come to this point in our history with all of the various changes in values over time without renaming everything from the last generation. Until now. I come from Georgia, which is named for King George of England, our enemy in the Revolutionary war. And they didn't even rename that! I can't stand these new authoritarians.
- akomtu 5y agoNASA should start a committee to investigate Webb's past: set up the rules of the committee and start nominating members (at least 19) approved by a complicated 5 stage voting process by another committee. All in the name of objectivity. Drag it out for 10 years, have meetings from time to time, keep those activists busy, and let real astronomers do the real work.
- helios_invictus 5y agoThis is an interesting read. https://hmoluseyi.medium.com/was-nasas-historic-leader-james-webb-a-bigot-131c821d5f12 https://hmoluseyi.medium.com/was-nasas-historic-leader-james...
- belorn 5y agoLooking at what occurred during 1950 Truman's presidency, James webb as part of the state department was likely involved in many of the decisions around the Korean war. However the outrage is not over his war activity, but rather the Lavender and Red scare. How come? Is a war that killed millions of citizens much more morally acceptable than discrimination?
- sp332 5y agoCurrently, yes, because the war is over and international relations have changed since than. But LGBT+ people are still being discriminated against, so his actions there are more relevant to people now.
- jacknews 5y agoWhy is it named after a bureaucrat anyway? In fact, why do we name scientific and mathematical tools and discoveries after people at all? It adds a political dimension and an unnecessary layer of obscurity.
- JanSt 5y agoRelevant: https://mobile.twitter.com/SamHarrisOrg/status/848013785981796355/photo/1 https://mobile.twitter.com/SamHarrisOrg/status/8480137859817... What will be the reason hn_user cannot be the name of 2120s newest spaceship? Did they eat meat of real animals? Did they own more than they needed? Didn‘t they help others as much as they could?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]