3 ms·
I don't know why it is always the same basic pattern. As soon as something becomes a "store of value" it ceases to be useful. It's a big problem with money and
by imtringued 5y ago
I don't know why it is always the same basic pattern. As soon as something becomes a "store of value" it ceases to be useful. It's a big problem with money and land. I put store of value in quotes because things like stocks and bonds are direct promises of value. Storing value has been delegated to the employees of the company or the borrower of the bond.
Meanwhile with Bitcoin, deflationary currency (think of the yen) and land where is that value coming from? Who are you delegating the process to? You are basically letting the rest of the world figure it out while doing nothing to help them figure it out. Clearly all the increases in value are coming out of the pocket of someone else.
Also, what is the point of an abstract "store of value"? At the end of the month you spent less than you earned. Meaning you didn't use up the labor of other people allotted to you this month. When you think about it, it basically means you worked and someone else didn't. Their time was wasted so to speak but you insist that the person that didn't work still owes you the labor you worked so hard for.
Even if you let the person work in that same month, that person would still have to know what you want to buy in the future and produce it ahead of time so that the product that you want to buy is sitting on a shelf waiting for you. But if that is the case, why not buy the product the month it was produced? Why delay the purchase?
It feels to me that our money system is flawed in exactly the opposite way that most people think. The average person wants their money to be flawed, I mean they want it to be sound money: Aesthetically pleasing to collect with as little utility as possible.
- simonh 5y agoThings like stocks and land are valuable because they do economic work. Land yields minerals, or hosts useful homes, shops, factories etc that provide services people need. Companies also provide needed goods and services. They are productive. They don’t just store value, they generate it. Their value is based on their ability to do economic work. This is why investment in companies is a good thing, it capitalises them so that they can expand, hire more workers, provide more and better products. Bitcoin is like gold. It does have a few economically useful functions, but it’s main actual use is purely as a store of value. It’s price is driven by speculation. That's a pure value store. Money in an economy is like oil in an engine, it reduces economic friction. It’s a substitute for barter. In principle it represents the value of economic work to produce goods or provide services. When I save money in a month I might spend it years later, but the thing I buy might have been manufactured before I was even born, or I might put a down payment on something yet to be made. It doesn’t matter, what matters is the value it has to me at that time. Being able to delay purchases until the time when you know what you need is an incredibly valuable benefit that eliminates huge amounts of waste.