3 ms·
I really dislike the term "individual contributor". I know it's an industry standard term for anyone who doesn't have direct reports, but it feels very inaccur
by simonw 5y ago
I really dislike the term "individual contributor".
I know it's an industry standard term for anyone who doesn't have direct reports, but it feels very inaccurate to me.
Just because an engineer doesn't have direct reports doesn't mean they aren't exhibiting all kinds of leadership behavior that elevates their contributions above the level of "individual" - teaching, mentoring, strategy work, leading projects.
I don't have a good suggestion for an alternative term though.
- 1123581321 5y agoThink of “contributor” as the key word in the term. It covers all that leadership. Then note “contributor”’s absence from “manager.” :)
- orangepenguin 5y agoMaybe technical contributors? You're right. In the most efficient organizations, leadership lets the technical decisions bubble up from the experts, rather than dictating them from the top.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Just because an engineer doesn't have direct reports doesn't mean they aren't exhibiting all kinds of leadership behavior that elevates their contributions above the level of "individual" - teaching, mentoring, strategy work, leading projects. That's a good point, but in my experience "individual contributor" is just a code phrase for "not managing direct reports". Being an IC doesn't mean you're not contributing leadership or strategy, it just means that you're not doing hiring/firing or performance reviews of direct reports.
- simonw 5y agoYeah that's how I understand the term too. So it's an effective piece of language, I just dislike it!
- Rapzid 5y agoYes, but at a lot of larger companies and perhaps the vast majority IC is code for "them". "Us" is management BTW.
- uberdru 5y agoIt's the tortured logic of late capitalism. People who actually 'contribute' somehow retain a semblance of individuality.
- mikepurvis 5y agoAs someone who has also been on the journey from early employee into project and team leadership, a formal management role, and then back to individual contributorship, I kind of agree, though at the same time I also don't really care about the title, and I know that being a "senior" or "staff" level individual contributor clearly implies a bunch of those other pieces, including things like soft leadership, independence to pursue strategic initiatives, etc.
- orangepenguin 5y agoYeah, titles like "staff engineer", "principal engineer", etc. are good because they imply expertise rather than responsibility for direct reports.
- blacktriangle 5y agoEh, it's kinda like the term "stakeholder." It just reeks of bureaucratic bullshit, but otoh it's a very real important concept that we just don't have another good word for, so we stick with it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jaaron 5y agoI agree about the IC terminology. The best I've seen so far is "maker" vs "manager"
- orangepenguin 5y agoOoh, I think "maker" would be a good word for it, though it's pretty inextricably tied to hobbyists.
- dnautics 5y agoI've definitely been in a company where they referred to me pointedly as an IC, as a way to signal they were not interested in me taking on tech leadership roles. I got the fuck out.