9 ms·
PG&E doesn’t really make that much money from serving those more rural communities and houses where those fires are likely to occur. They subsidize those higher
by seanmcdirmid 5y ago
PG&E doesn’t really make that much money from serving those more rural communities and houses where those fires are likely to occur. They subsidize those higher cost to serve areas with all the money they make in the big urban areas that aren’t at risk at all. Burying lines will just cause urban areas to subsidize urban areas even more, when there really should be some consequence for deciding to build your house in or abutting a dry forest with the need to have power brought in through that forest.
- floatingatoll 5y agoI absolutely agree that the incentives to build homes in/by forests need to be rethought, or at least handled better at the building code / enforcement level.
- mlyle 5y agoIn many cases these are transmission lines between urban areas that cross rural areas. Or in the case of the Camp Fire, we're talking about a transmission line constructed in the 1920's to carry hydroelectric power from the Sierra Nevada to other areas-- primarily Contra Costa County.
- hedora 5y agoIf that is true, then how do rural-only power companies outside of California provide much better service at much lower prices than PG&E? Also, running a mile of power line in a California city is orders of magnitude more expensive than running a mile of power line in rural areas outside of California. To the extent that PG&E follows the law (sometimes they just steal the money, and blow up towns years later when the system decays), I doubt they make much profit in the city. At any rate, PG&E prices are completely out of control in rural areas. All in, I paid ~$10K for a 5 foot run from an existing transformer. All they did was run three wires five feet, and re-energize their own transformer. It took them three years. In the meantime, we built a house with a gas generator and Lithium ion batteries. I’m not including that expense in the $10K, nor am I including delay of construction or wiring on our side of the PG&E box. I am including the second pole and power backing board they had us build because the first one (built to their specifications) was unacceptable. Edit: Also, they made us bury our lines, but refused to bury theirs in a reasonable timeframe. Hopefully we’ll get buried service lines out of this. Edit 2: I forgot. They refused to give us permission to move our box to eliminate their unburied lines. So, it wasn’t that we wanted them to pay to bury the lines. We wanted their engineers to sign off on moving a transformer, and then decommissioning their lines. Since then, they’ve had people on our property multiple times to deal with trees that interfere with the line they wouldn’t let us pay to eliminate.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoBurying in urban areas is expensive but you don’t have so much length to bury. The work is also amortized by high population density. They definitely make all their money in cities, most utilities do. The monopoly license to operate in a city makes servicing rural areas tolerable, but everyone would avoid servicing them at the same rates if they didn’t have to.