5 ms·
Exercising free speech can have social consequences. You're free to advocate for the legalization of necrophilia; others are free to criticize you and disagree
by klyrs 5y ago
Exercising free speech can have social consequences. You're free to advocate for the legalization of necrophilia; others are free to criticize you and disagree with you (exercising their own free speech) or shun you (exercising their freedom of association).
Legal consequences imply non-free speech; employment consequences are more complicated.
edit: Responding to dead response; not gonna vouch for you again with that attitude...
Every freedom has consequences. You've got the right to bear arms, but you can shoot yourself in the foot. You've got the freedom to move about the country, but you can miss your sister's wedding if you're in another state. You've got the freedom to vote, but your elected politician won't always vote in the way you'd like. You've got the right to drink and smoke, but you might get cancer or other diseases. You've got the right to piss off your friends by spouting off hot takes, and you might lose those friends if they don't like what you have to say.
- alabamacadabra 5y agoIt’s simply not free speech then. Call it something else, you’re using incorrect terms. Edit because it seems the point is getting lost here: Let me rephrase this: freedom of speech seems to be such that one is not able to have legal action taken against them by the government for their speech. I am not debating that whatsoever. Within the context of the United States, “free” rights are used in the same sense of being granted “Liberty”. You are liberated from being unable to criticize the king, as it were. What are you specifically free from? You are free from the punishments that a king can inflict on you for having used your full speech capabilities. Now, here is where I believe we differ: to me, it’s merely an abstraction to have another entity restrict the speech. As in, sure, I’m not using money to purchase items with Bitcoin, I’m just exchanging money for something that can be exchanged for goods. In that same light it seems that you’re arguing “no one is restricting speech they’re just making it not possible for them to say those things and keep living” If that’s what it is, fine… let’s not call it “free speech”. I submit “free opportunities for punishment”.
- hogFeast 5y agoBut we aren't talking about necrophilia. It is about people who may work in an environment that is 95% Democrat being attacked as racists or whatever because they have a different political view. The issue isn't exactly about free speech but discrimination. And this happens in a million other ways too: being overweight, having a certain accent, being shorter than average. The fact that people have to resort to a "free speech" defence is indicative of the problem. And, of course, there will be "consequences"...no-one doubts that are consequences for not being like other people.
- minsc__and__boo 5y agoPolitical party is a personal choice and thus not a protected class. Freedom of association permits us to choose who we do and do not associate with based on that individual's own choices.
- gnicholas 5y agoIn many jurisdictions, political affiliation/activity is protected. [1] It looks like PA has had a couple cases on the matter, one offering protection and a more recent one limiting the first case to its facts (i.e., saying it is not precedential anymore). Details on page 319. 1: https://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/empspeech.pdf https://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/empspeech.pdf
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- minsc__and__boo 5y agoPA courts determined that the previous 1983 ruling (protecting political party from employer termination) is not good law, and will not use it as precedence again. There are laws in place to prevent employers from coercing employees into political action - i.e. you won't get your annual bonus unless you donate to this political candidate - but these are protections from extortion, and not exceptions to the general rule that political party is not a protected class.
- chris11 5y agoSomewhat ironically California considers political affiliations a protected class.
- minsc__and__boo 5y agoCalifornia protects employees from the threat of employers trying to force them into taking political action - i.e. you need to donate to a political candidate or attend a political event or be fired. It doesn't interfere with freedom of association for political actions taken by the employee independent of threat, such as being fired after making islamophobic comments.