7 ms·
Sometimes solecisms can reveal linguistic ingenuity
- euroclear 5y agohttps://outline.com/5qBRep https://outline.com/5qBRep
- morpheos137 5y agoMore often they reveal poor intellect or hyperactive autocomplete.
- nefitty 5y agoThere are different types of intelligence. I’m good at cooking but bad at math. Some people excel at physical endeavors but might have difficulties with language. “Poor intellect” means nothing at best. “Poor language skills” more effectively conveys what you seem to have intended to convey, although you did it without any source or backing argument.
- bitwize 5y agoYeah, statistics says no. Cognitive aptitude in one area correlates very strongly with aptitude in other areas, leading the people who measure this stuff to conclude that there is pretty much one factor for general intelligence. The rest is training. You're bad at math because you're ill-practiced at it and/or you never found a way to overcome your math anxiety.
- oh_sigh 5y agoWell what if a person has a high intellect but is ill-practiced in English?
- majormajor 5y agoLet's say that's correct - the person you're replying to is still more correct than the one they were replying to: a misused word could not distinguish poor intellect from unfamiliarity.
- necovek 5y agoI don't think there's an obligation in a comment to address the parent of a post you are responding to, let alone all the parents which we'd get if that obligation was there and transitive :) You can also address only a part of the comment, like I did here. For instance, I have not given an opinion on the latter part of your comment.
- bradknowles 5y agoThe Johnson O’Connor Research Foundation disagrees with you, and they’ve been studying aptitudes since 1922. See https://jocrf.org/aptitudes https://jocrf.org/aptitudes
- aynsof 5y agoAn 'eggcorn' that always makes my eye twitch is 'bunker down'. To hunker down is to take a squat or crouch down on your heels. If I recall correctly, it comes from a similar root as 'haunches'. 'Bunker down' makes sense as an eggcorn, but I find it much less romantic somehow.
- skmurphy 5y agoI learned it as "hone in" from hone meaning to sharpen or narrow (honing a blade). It seems to me that "home in" only makes sense if you are trying to return. If you seeking a new target hone in strikes me as more accurate. Apparently Webster disagrees.
- _0ffh 5y ago>"home in" only makes sense if you are trying to return Under that interpretation, homing missiles sound like a really bad idea.
- skmurphy 5y agoHoming torpedoes and homing missiles sound more like boomerangs to me. But while a boomerang returns if you miss your target, it does not explode.
- sebmellen 5y agoI don’t think I’ve heard a single person in my life say “home in on”, it’s always been “hone in on”.
- DaveExeter 5y agoI've never heard "hone in on"! If someone said it, I would assume they just mispronounced 'home'. "hone in on" makes no sense!
- sebmellen 5y agoHmmm, curious. I suppose I may have just been chronically misunderstanding everyone my whole life. What a revelation! To me, as suggested in the article, “honing” a sense or blade makes “hone in” seem more logical. But I’m sure my parents both used “hone in” — Merriam Webster has an interesting definition and considers both correct: https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/home-in-or-hone-in https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/home-in-or-hon....
- zimpenfish 5y agoConversely (UK English, many decades) I've never heard anyone says "hone in on" (entirely possible I've read it in prose and auto-translated it to "home in on" without noticing, mind.)
- nealabq 5y agoYears ago I read an article about Ray Kurzweil where the journalist referred to "a Ray processor". A mishearing of "Array processor" I suppose.
- yesenadam 5y agoOnes I've seen online recently: tenets referred to as tenants, Here here! instead of Hear, hear!, chock it up to instead of chalk it up to, chalk full instead of chock-full – this page explain it originally was choke-full, which makes more sense. https://eggcorns.lascribe.net/english/945/chalked/ https://eggcorns.lascribe.net/english/945/chalked/
- nescioquid 5y agoI recall a meeting in which someone used the expression "flush out" and was corrected by someone else with "flesh out", which prompted a third to posit that the correct expression was "fletch out", claiming the true origin of the expression was in arrow-making. Would have been better delivered while leaving the meeting, making for a "Parthian shot".
- dekhn 5y agoflush out is what you to birds in a bush, flesh out is what you do to the skeleton of an idea, and fletch out isn't a thing.