7 ms·
Billionaires-in-space critics are 'largely right', Bezos concedes
- ethbr0 5y agoWay to sensationalize a quote into a headline, CNN. Relevant portion from the article (which itself isn't much more than PR reprint and fluff): Earlier in the day, during an interview that aired on "New Day," Crane asked Bezos, "There have been a chorus of critics saying that these flights to space are, you know, just joyrides for the wealthy, and that you should be spending your time and your money and energy trying to solve problems here on Earth. So what do you say to those critics?" Bezos didn't tap dance around the question: He said, "Well, I say they're largely right. We have to do both. You know, we have lots of problems here and now on Earth and we need to work on those, and we always need to look to the future. We've always done that as a species, as a civilization. We have to do both." He said this mission is about "building a road to space for the next generations to do amazing things there, and those amazing things will solve problems here on Earth."
- KozmoNau7 5y agoHe's really trying hard to cast billionaire space hops as something with the same scientific and societal impact as the space race. But what he and Branson are doing has none of that R&D that defined the space age, where innovations in materials and technology found real-world applications and became everyday objects for common people. All they're doing is spending millions of dollars doing something that has already been perfectly possible for over 70 years. There's no innovation or societal benefit to their private joyrides.
- harry8 5y agoHow much UK tax dollars did Branson end up securing from his tax haven to keep virgin afloat? Anyone know? I'd assume it was zero it was such an hideous thing to try on - your tax should save my wealth while I don't pay it. But we seem to have lost sense about these things at times.
- sideshowb 5y agoIt's worth noting that Elon, for all his faults, does seem to be leading innovation. But I agree with you about Branson and Bezos.
- danielsamuels 5y agoI think it's a shame that people have bundled Elon into the Bezos / Branson battle. What Musk is doing is far more useful (and has been for a while now) than the measuring contest that's happening between the other two.
- squarefoot 5y agoDon't forget about competition. It's a good thing that Musk has both Bezos and Branson biting his ass from their own rockets, if not only for PR.
- beloch 5y agoTwo questions regarding Musk that people should ask more often: 1. If the public money being thrown at SpaceX were redirected, what could NASA (or other private companies) do with it? 2. If the administrators of NASA collected $80B (combined) in salary and bonuses last year, largely from public coffers, would that be considered reasonable?
- ethbr0 5y agoIsn't the public money being thrown at SpaceX through NASA? NASA knows exactly what they're buying. They've just become such a bureaucratic, top-heavy, risk-adverse organization (by Congressional design) that it's a better deal to outsource pieces to SpaceX.
- mavhc 5y agoThey've always outsourced most of their stuff, to Boeing et al. Now they have a company to outsource stuff to that is 10x more efficient and will actually invent new systems.
- least 5y agoWe haven't even entered the real "Space Age." Commoditization of space flight is an important step. Call it whatever you want, it might be frivolous for Bezos and Branson to be the ones going into space, but who cares? It's such a small aspect of what's going on behind the scenes, where we have several private companies pouring billions into research of space flight. > But what he and Branson are doing has none of that R&D that defined the space age, where innovations in materials and technology found real-world applications and became everyday objects for common people. Except that these companies absolutely are doing R&D. We don't know what sort of "real world applications" might come from it in the future. We do know that right now, it's extremely expensive and difficult to go into space for anyone. Hopefully in the future going into space will become more than an expensive hobby for billionaires, but you can't get there without investment into space exploration. > All they're doing is spending millions of dollars doing something that has already been perfectly possible for over 70 years. Yet we still haven't returned to the moon and haven't gone to Mars, or to an asteroid, or to really anything else in that time. Being able to do it and it become a thing that we do are two different things entirely. We can't rely solely on NASA for innovations in space flight, especially when its funding can be stripped and killed off on the whim of a President, like Obama's disastrously bad space policy did during his presidency.
- mavhc 5y agoAll smartphone companies did was the same thing anyone could do in 1970 with a truck sized computer and radio tower. Doing the same thing but 10x cheaper is progress, also makes the thing that's 10x too expensive that's never been done before possible. Virgin Galactic and Virgin Orbit are making air launches easy, but they're not the first. Pegasus first flew in 1990, released at 12km, can launch 443 kg into orbit for $56 million. Virgin's LauncherOne, releases at 10.7km, can carry 500kg into orbit for $12 million
- KozmoNau7 5y agoThe entire reason NASA was down-prioritized and had finding stripped is because of wealthy private interests, who wanted that pie to go to them for profit, rather than to a public agency. And because the US only cares to do anything if there's a competition involved, the fall of the Soviet Union meant that politicians didn't really care anymore, they got lazy and lost their ambitions. Now China (and India) and speeding up and leaving the US in the dust. The money spent on private space exploration could be spent much better on public research and space exploration, with international space agencies working together, instead of funding billionaire joyrides and further lining their pockets with money they can barely figure out how to spend.
- HPsquared 5y ago"possible" has a financial component. They're making a lot of things possible by reducing costs. Several of the major technological innovations in history are a case of doing something "already possible" at a reduced cost: electric light, printing press, refrigerator...
- cassianoleal 5y ago> you should be spending your time and your money and energy trying to solve problems here on Earth. I think that largely misses the point, either on purpose or out of sheer ignorance. So far the main contention is that they should never have been allowed to amass such insane amount of money that they can have this dystopic billionaire space race. Had they paid better salaries to their employees, kept working conditions sane, had lower working hours, etc etc etc. they might have solved (or at least not created / helped with) many of said problems in the first place. Edit: typo
- nojito 5y agoI find this logic quite interesting. Amazon is often the best employer many individuals have ever had in their areas.
- cassianoleal 5y ago> many individuals What's the proportion of those to the total number of individuals employed, directly or indirectly by them?
- WJW 5y agoYes, most of the world being so shitty that even Amazon is one of the better employers is one of the problems back on earth that needs to be fixed. It's always a little sad to see some researcher work out a ballpark estimate for (say) giving every child on earth proper healthcare and even the pessimistic estimates are no more than 10% of what the western world spends on cosmetics alone. That said, I don't begrudge Bezos&Branson their space race hobby. Certainly better than the "who has the biggest yacht" type of shenanigans most rich people get up to.
- turbinerneiter 5y agoApperantly Jeff Bezos has a yacht that is so big that it comes with a smaller support yacht. The small one has a helipad.
- codyswann 5y agoJournalists today are such hacks. The whole "So and so is saying.... How would you like to respond?" Is so weak. As a journalist, do your research. If you have a question, ask YOUR question.
- soco 5y agoWhen you're a billionaire you need something to show off - because diamond dust desserts or shooting elephants are for simple millionaires. Thus, this space tourism and all the brouhaha about it is filling an important gap. Important for them, that is.
- bko 5y agoQ: There have been a chorus of critics saying that these flights to space are, you know, just joyrides for the wealthy, and that you should be spending your time and your money and energy trying to solve problems here on Earth. So what do you say to those critics? A: Well, I say they're largely right. We have to do both. You know, we have lots of problems here and now on Earth and we need to work on those, and we always need to look to the future. We've always done that as a species, as a civilization. We have to do both When did people begin to look to billionaires to solve problems on earth? I think a big problem is too much involvement in politics and policy by the wealthy.
- harry8 5y agoWhey they claimed their "benevolence" as a justification for paying less tax than a cashier is when people pointed out the overwhelming hypocrisy. I'm with you. We ditch their political influence entirely and tax them proportionately the same as everyone is supposed to be. Maybe ratchet up the rate some once you're beyond money that you can ever spend because you'll do something grossly moronic, rubbing everyone's faces in it like taking joy flights to space. Billionaires are a large-ish part of problems here on earth. Change my mind.
- simonh 5y agoA majority of billionairs globally are self made, having grown their wealth themselves. This mainly means building and growing companies that provide valuable goods and services, and employ lots of people doing productive work. Their wealth isn't in piles of cash, it's in their ownership and control of the enterprises they built. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/09/26/majority-of-the-worlds-richest-people-are-self-made-says-new-report.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/09/26/majority-of-the-worlds-riche... I'll ask you a question. Who else do you think should own and control those enterprises, and how should the control and ownership be taken away from the current owners? Is doing so really in the public interest? The exceptions I think we can agree are parasitic behaviours. Inherited wealth, rent seeking, corruption, however these are a minority of billionaires, and looking at the developed world a small minority.
- space_man 5y agoSome people piss in bottles so that other people can see the stars. Seems about right. It will trickle down eventually.
- Arnt 5y agoTrickle-down economics are a sham, that's been clear for a long time. But so is this idea that people like Bezos have any duty that we one-percenters on HN don't also have. "Trickle-down" means FROM people like us. We're the privileged 1%. (If you think you're not among the one richest per cent: There are about eight billion people on earth, so 1% is eighty million people. Do you really think there are eighty-one million people who earn/own more than you personally do?)
- space_man 5y agoI don't know about you, but I don't make my money by forcing people to piss in bottles.
- darkerside 5y agoIt's not unlikely someone in a sweatshop somewhere pissed in a bottle to make the shirt you're wearing right now 3% more quickly
- ben_w 5y agoNot directly, but I wouldn’t be surprised if the layers of indirection between your (or my) economic actions and literal slave labourers (as in some prisoners in the USA or China, not merely downtrodden working class masses who deserve better) is at most one higher than the level of indirection between Bezos and that. How many layers of hierarchy does Amazon have? 12? And what is made by inmates working for UNICOR or the Texas Department of Criminal Justice? I’m neither resident of nor a citizen of the USA, but I expect no more than 13 steps from my economic actions to the inmates.
- space_man 5y ago
- tonyvince7 5y ago"The universe is probably littered with the one-planet graves of cultures which made the sensible economic decision that there's no good reason to go into space--each discovered, studied, and remembered by the ones who made the irrational decision." - Randal Monroe of xkcd
- ethbr0 5y agoIt's a great quip. Single planetary culture is a local optima. Even mild resource extraction from space or a second planet massively boosts a civilization's resource base. Not sure why Bezos and Branson are getting flack, when people just as rich as them are spending it in worse ways. And, if it comes down to it, I'd rather see the super wealthy spend their money on technological advancement, than be another drop in the bucket on things government should be doing (social support, healthcare, etc).
- WJW 5y ago> Not sure why Bezos and Branson are getting flack, when people just as rich as them are spending it in worse ways. Most rich people don't get (or seek) quite as much media attention as these two.
- ethbr0 5y agoHow is that impacting the world negatively?
- mempko 5y agoBut you do realize, most technological advancement is done by the government right? Government investment in tech surpasses VC funding by a lot.
- HPsquared 5y agoEarly adopters pay more and support product development, which eventually trickles down. News at 11.
- rektide 5y agoRegardless of the very real conversation/questions of individuals who have amassed such titanic wealth, to me the question of these "joyrides for the wealthy" is that they are fantastically unbelievably ridiculously colossally polluting. I can think of no obvious parallel ways to have as outsized a negative impact on Spaceship Earth as this. Especially in such a short window of time.