4 ms·
> Following Microsoft’s original disclosure in early March 2021, the United States Government also identified other vulnerabilities in the Exchange Server softw
by dmix 5y ago
> Following Microsoft’s original disclosure in early March 2021, the United States Government also identified other vulnerabilities in the Exchange Server software.
> Rather than withholding them, the United States Government recognized that these vulnerabilities could pose systemic risk and the National Security Agency notified Microsoft to ensure patches were developed and released to the private sector.
Finally they seem to be starting to take the defence of citizens and private industry seriously - in a far more public forum. Instead of just hearing the odd story of this happening through back channels.
From the linked press release:
https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/07/19/the-united-states-joined-by-allies-and-partners-attributes-malicious-cyber-activity-and-irresponsible-state-behavior-to-the-peoples-republic-of-china/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases...
- deepstack 5y ago>> Rather than withholding them, the United States Government recognized that these vulnerabilities could pose systemic risk and the National Security Agency notified Microsoft to ensure patches were developed and released to the private sector. It is amazing that NSA had to notify Microsoft. You would thing a company with that much money like MS, they would have drop several millions on a few pen test, and independent security audit companies. Digital security will never be trust unless these things are addressed in an open transparent way.
- pletsch 5y ago> You would thing a company with that much money like MS, they would have drop several millions on a few pen test, and independent security audit companies. Are you under the impression that MS doesn't spend millions on security? They're currently spending roughly $1b/year. This isn't going to be fixed by "a few pen test"
- sandworm101 5y agoIf they are spending a billion, these flaws show that obviously isn't enough.
- marcellus23 5y agoHow do you know they're not doing exactly that? For every 1 vulnerability that gets disclosed, we have no clue how many potential vulnerabilities were caught by security testing or practices. The entire nature of security is that it's impossible to have literally 0 vulnerabilities.
- _wldu 5y agoIt's not possible to find all the bugs and they only get noticed when they fail to find one. No one recognizes all the bugs that they continually find and fix.
- dahfizz 5y agoI don't understand why HN has such a flippant attitude towards cybersecurity. You would think a forum full of developers would understand the complexity of software. But the "just hire a pentester and you'll never have any bugs" and "just follow some (ill-defined) 'best practices' and you'll never be hacked" attitudes are so prevalent.
- runawaybottle 5y agoIf you are not outsourcing security, then you are not taking it seriously. It is the one thing where you need to give the job to the best person. But, we’re more likely to outsource the one thing you don’t need to outsource, like app developers.
- tablespoon 5y ago> I don't understand why HN has such a flippant attitude towards cybersecurity. You would think a forum full of developers would understand the complexity of software. HN is also full of contrarians and people who like to feel superior than everyone else (and often express that through flippant dismissals).
- fulafel 5y agoYou are hugely overestimating the level of security of software like this. There's a constant stream of vulnerability discoveries, disclosures and fixes. Those vulnerabilities don't pop into existence the week someone publicly discloses them and informs the vendor, they've been waiting there for anyone to find them for years. If MS wanted to replace a product like this with one that has a low probability of containing any remotely exploitable vulnerabilities, they'd have to go back to the drawing board, do a full rewrite witha completely different sw development process, take a lot of time or make some major functionality compromises (or probably both).
- billyhoffman 5y agoThe challenge the NSA has is it possesses 2 separate missions that are often in direct conflict: secure the communications of the United States, and to collect, eavesdrop, and compromise the communications of other countries. The United States Atomic Energy Commission of the 1950s and 60s had the same problem. Their mission was to both regulate nuclear power as well as research and promote the widespread adoption of nuclear power. Making things safe and keeping them safe while also making things easy and cheap are often in conflict. Ultimately it was split into two different agencies: One tasked with regulation and one Tasked with research and promotion. I believe both missions of the NSA are important. However I believe it should be split into two agencies each Enthusiastically pursuing a single mission to the best of their abilities. Imagine a cyber defense agency that does nothing but find and fix holes in computing infrastructure and major software projects. It pays for exploits and then works to patch them, promotes bug bounties, develops secure coding standards, audits open source projects, etc. Imagine something like The National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) that instead funds critical pieces of software like openSSL, etc. Is that necessarily the best form? Probably not but it’s way better than what we have now: every time the NSA suggests changes to “make something more secure “ there is a looming specter that they are lying and are actually trying to compromise things.
- pjmorris 5y ago> Imagine a cyber defense agency that does nothing but find and fix holes in computing infrastructure and major software projects. It pays for exploits and then works to patch them, promotes bug bounties, develops secure coding standards, audits open source projects, etc. Imagine something like The National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) that instead funds critical pieces of software like openSSL, etc. I like this idea. At the same time, I think the agency - or organization, if you prefer - should look something like the National Transportation Safety Board, where incidents are investigated, reported on, and recommendations are made in a way that improves user safety. Maybe the 'National Digital Safety Board'?
- hirako2000 5y agoOr they should stop stealing tax payers money and dissolve these agencies. The one thing they are good at is digging deeper and deeper the debt account, for virtually no benefit, and surely nuisance and worries.