8 ms·
There was a report by a psychologist who said Native American mascots have a negative effect on children of native Americans. This may or may not be the case o
by mc32 5y ago
There was a report by a psychologist who said Native American mascots have a negative effect on children of native Americans.
This may or may not be the case or may be true in some specific circumstances (Redskins, for example) but may not be true for all, however, many high schools are changing their team names based on this one study/conclusion which was funded by a tribe. Which is fine, but usually when there is a conflict of interest one wants to have additional independent studies that come to a similar conclusion.
- pryce 5y agoIf you're referring to Fryberg, Markus, Oyserman & Stone 2008, do you think that schools deciding to change their team names/mascots might have something to do with far larger and more broad cultural trends over the last couple of decades rather than these schools decisions resting primarily on the robustness and applicability (or otherwise) of this one paper?
- staticman2 5y agoIn your example there's no downside to changing the name, though. It's a low stakes decision. In the book "Trust- a Very Short Introduction" the author argues if the situation is "low stakes" you should need a lower level of evidence to trust someone than high stakes. While I think the author might discuss it only in the context of human interactions, I imagine you could apply the paradigm to this situation.
- zepto 5y ago> In your example there's no downside to changing the name, though. Changing a name in response to a conflicted and un-valid paper is a downside in itself.
- staticman2 5y agoIt didn't require a scientific paper to create the mascot but you seem to be arguing it requires a "good paper" that's been validated to rename it? You are demonstrating a status quo cognitive bias.
- mc32 5y agoSo if someone comes up with a paper that says the opposite (that using native American names) has a proven (by the a paid study) positive impact, since it's low stakes, we should go ahead and name teams after native American tribes?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- staticman2 5y agoI think we were talking about high school mascots not team names. Are those two scenarios equally low stakes? In one you change the high school mascot from a native american cartoon to an animal or something. I'm assuming native americans were not consulted with the creation of the mascot to begin with. In the other we change... what all the teams names? Is that a equivilent scenario? To be honest I'm finding it hard to relate to someone would care enough about a high school mascot to even need a study at all. Low stakes B.S. But that's me. Since this topic is probably of zero importance to anyone not native american who else is going to fund it, for that matter?
- zepto 5y ago> I'm assuming native americans were not consulted with the creation of the mascot to begin with. Seems like you are affirming the consequent and assuming it is harmful to native Americans. You are ignoring the issue of the paper. If the decision is based on a scientific paper, but the paper is conflicted or unvalidated, that is harmful because of the misuse of the scientific paper. If you want to change the mascot because of Native American’s preferences, that is a different matter.
- staticman2 5y agoHas anyone else studies this topic? If not it's kind of a catch 22 for the tribe, isn't it? Nobody wants to fund research on the topic, so when they fund research on it it's presumed invalid because of bias?
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> It's a low stakes decision At least not until the reactionary media's outrage machine decides to make it their current hill to die on... Also, this is America, where sports are taken far too seriously.
- jeromegv 5y agoSo native Americans tribes have for the majority almost been wiped out and eradicated due to something not very far from genocide (or at the minimum, a very targeted policy of extermination) And somehow you think that schools that have nothing to do with those people finally changing their very questionable names is due to a “conflict of interest of a psychologist”? Not because it was just racist?
- mc32 5y agoI don’t mind changing names if it’s based on evidence, not just because someone has some crusade. Should Aztecas Stadium change their name? What about the MN Vikings, NY Yankees, TX Cowboys? Kaiser Chiefs of ZA, Ebusa dwarfs of ZA?
- throwadogabone 5y agoIt could be argued that using that symbolism is more a form of respect than it is a form of racism. I don't think people who decided those names actively participated in the genocide, and objectively, they used those names and that symbolism as an ideal to look up to, they used it as a warrior symbol for their team. It could also be argued that it dilutes the image/culture/history and probably a bunch more things by wrapping it up in american plastic. I wouldn't argue with that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crooked-v 5y ago> It could be argued that using that symbolism is more a form of respect than it is a form of racism. Broadly speaking, the symbolism being used is usually either an obvious caricature of the real thing (see: the former Washington Redskins), or uses cultural and religious elements that are at best kind of offensive in the context of being used as a sportsball logo (see: most uses of peace pipe or war bonnet imagery). There are exceptions, but they're of the kind that generally come with either somebody actually doing the research or people of the given group actually participating locally.
- bigbillheck 5y ago> many high schools are changing their team names based on this one study/conclusion which was funded by a tribe. I've been following the efforts to have team names changed for quite some time and have never heard of this paper, but have heard of sustained lobbying over decades from a variety of native organizations.
- techrat 5y ago> many high schools are changing their team names based on this one study/conclusion which was funded by a tribe. Let's rephrase this. Many high schools are changing their team names because the study brought awareness to the generally ill-considered use of ethnic mascots. The study may have been a catalyst, but the appropriation and the insensitivity to it was always a problem.
- kortilla 5y ago> and the insensitivity to it was always a problem. For who? Moral outrage porn addicts?
- techrat 5y agoAlright. I'll bite. Why is it so important to you to continue to use caricature mascots that other people would find offensive over something benign like animals?
- andrepd 5y agoinb4 dang shows up telling you not to feed the troll :)
- kortilla 5y agoDon’t do that here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- kortilla 5y agoThat’s not the question at hand. I’m asking a specific question about who it’s been “problematic” for. > Why is it so important to you to continue to use caricature mascots I don’t give a shit about mascots at all. My complaint is specifically about people who concern troll on behalf of minorities that never asked for it (e.g. the Speedy Gonzales cancellation). Whenever someone tells you something is “problematic” without giving concrete reasoning, they are likely just looking to be outraged and spread righteous indignation.
- spoonjim 5y agoTeams didn't change their names because of that tribe-sponsored paper, they changed their names because white people wanted them to change. In 2016, when the main momentum of this started to come out, 9 in 10 Native Americans did not find it offensive [1]. But white people had already decided it was offensive, and white people have much more cultural influence than Native Americans, so in being perceived by white people as offensive it became offensive, to the point that just a few years later, a majority of Native Americans found it offensive [2]. But at all times through this, including today, a higher percentage of white people find the Redskins name offensive than of Native Americans. The Redskins changed their name because of pressure from white people, not because of pressure from Native Americans. More than a little ironic that even in this, Native Americans were barely listened to, while white people's feelings were considered very important. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/new-poll-finds-9-in-10-native-americans-arent-offended-by-redskins-name/2016/05/18/3ea11cfa-161a-11e6-924d-838753295f9a_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/new-poll-finds-9-in-10-... [2] https://news.berkeley.edu/2020/02/04/native-mascots-survey/ https://news.berkeley.edu/2020/02/04/native-mascots-survey/
- mc32 5y agoThis is even a worse reason to change names. Someone who has no stake in it at all then takes it open themselves to represent someone else as an aggrieved entity. And, to be clear, I'm okay with presenting evidence one way or another, but I object to willy-nilly claims and crusades.
- tester34 5y agoWow, just like with GitHub master branch stuff
- kbelder 5y agoAnd 'LatinX'