4 ms·
And yet Apple is cooperating with authoritarian governments[1]. For example, in Myanmar[2]: > Most recently, there was a dispute with ProtonVPN (the company t
by heavyset_go 5y ago
And yet Apple is cooperating with authoritarian governments[1].
For example, in Myanmar[2]:
> Most recently, there was a dispute with ProtonVPN (the company that also makes ProtonMail) over an update for its app in the App Store. Proton Technologies claimed that Apple was intentionally blocking the update amid the ongoing crackdown in Myanmar.
And in China[2]:
> "China appears to have received help on Saturday from an unlikely source in its fight against tools that help users evade its Great Firewall of internet censorship: Apple."
> "The Republic of China flag emoji has disappeared from Apple iPhone’s keyboard for Hong Kong and Macau users. The change happened for users who updated their phones to the latest operating system."
> September 2019 — Apple adopts a “SIM canary”. If you insert a Chinese carrier SIM, apps like TikTok & Apple News no longer function.
> May 2021 — Censorship, Surveillance and Profits: A Hard Bargain for Apple in China
And in Russia[2]:
> October 2020 — Apple forced Telegram to close channels run by Belarus protestors
And in Pakistan[2]:
> February 2021 — Apple Removes Apps for Pakistani Government
There are about a dozen more examples than those in this article here[2]. Here's its conclusion:
> So what does any of this have to do with app developers? Why should we care? When it comes to the iOS App Store, Apple controls where we are allowed to distribute our apps. More importantly, Apple has the unilateral power remove our apps from any App Store region at any time to nurture its relationship with whatever unsavory government it is interested in pleasing in order to pursue its political motives or financial objectives.
> Apple’s centralized power over app distribution combined with its willingness to surrender to political pressures is incredibly concerning as ostensibly “democratic” governments across the globe (including the United Sates!) increasingly exhibit far-right, fascist behavior and implement fascist policies. What will happen when you need to build your own HKmap.live?
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26644216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26644216
[2] https://www.jessesquires.com/blog/2021/03/30/apple-cooperation-with-authoritarian-governments/ https://www.jessesquires.com/blog/2021/03/30/apple-cooperati...
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThis again. In authoritarian regimes, it’s either you comply or you are gone. The regime can cut every one of your phones off their networks in seconds. Noncompliance is not an option. It’s not like the US where you can fight with the FBI in court. The argument is whether you think their people should be able to use iPhones or not. If so, the rules are the rules. And the argument is that it would be better they had iPhones than domestic phones more likely to be compromised.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jolux 5y agoI mostly agree but I think it’s still a shame that American companies are forced to comply with draconian regulations like this. It’s probably more of a problem for diplomacy and state policy to solve than private actors though.
- heavyset_go 5y agoIt's interesting that you don't see the military junta that performed a coup[1] in Myanmar and contributed a genocide[2][3] as a rogue nation-state, but see cooperating with them as just the cost of doing business. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myanmar#2020_elections_and_2021_military_coup_d'%C3%A9tat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myanmar#2020_elections_and_202... [2] https://www.npr.org/2021/02/11/966923582/what-myanmars-coup-means-for-the-rohingya https://www.npr.org/2021/02/11/966923582/what-myanmars-coup-... [3] https://www.mei.edu/publications/myanmar-february-coup-and-rohingya-genocide https://www.mei.edu/publications/myanmar-february-coup-and-r...
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI’m not disputing what Myanmar did. I’m saying that let’s say Apple didn’t comply: 1. Within minutes, every iPhone is disabled from accessing the state owned cellular systems. 2. Any employees or executives in Myanmar risk arrest and, possibly, torture or death for allowing free speech and disobeying the government. 3. The average Myanmar citizen gets free speech for an hour or so, then gets informed they must buy a new phone, possibly made by a state owned enterprise, that is much more invasive to their privacy. So what, exactly, did making a stand accomplish? Absolutely nothing, and everyone is worse off.
- Miraste 5y agoThis is what would happen in China. Myanmar is not capable of it. > Within minutes, every iPhone is disabled from accessing the state owned cellular systems. Ludicrous. Myanmar has multiple private telcos. During the coup the military controlled internet access by the highly sophisticated means of cutting wires in data centers. It would take them days or weeks to individually block iPhones. > Any employees or executives in Myanmar risk arrest and, possibly, torture or death Some of those employees are US citizens. They all represent America's premier megacorporation. Killing them would not be a good move, especially as the US military finishes opening a spot on its "developing countries to demolish" list. > they must buy a new phone, possibly made by a state owned enterprise, that is much more invasive to their privacy. The junta can't make phones. Apple has no power in China but China and Myanmar are very, very different places. If they wanted to, they could exercise significant influence.
- simondotau 5y agoNearly everything you list involves Apple blocking features and material which individual Governments consider illegal or objectionable. Apple is merely complying with the laws of each country it trades within, just as you would expect Xiaomi to comply with US laws when they sell their electronics in America. If you don't like the laws of other countries, you should be angry with the Government which enacted them—not its citizens or corporate residents for complying with them.
- dustyharddrive 5y agoThe issue here is that Apple makes phones (the iOS App Store is the subject of much if these articles) where they are the gatekeepers to the only method of software installation, making this compliance more problematic.
- simondotau 5y agoI’d rather Apple be the ultimate technical gatekeeper than to have a device which, for all I know, comes pre-rooted by my dystopian government. Or where apps are distributed openly and are thus potentially loaded with spyware.