4 ms·
>The argument for returning to the office has long been that chance encounters with colleagues inspire innovation and increase productivity. I think executives
by pydry 5y ago
>The argument for returning to the office has long been that chance encounters with colleagues inspire innovation and increase productivity.
I think executives are afraid to give the real reasons why they want everyone back in the office.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoWhat reasons do you think executives have to get everyone back?
- pydry 5y agoMainly a lack of trust in their workers, I think. It's not something that you can really say.
- McDyver 5y agoIf they lack trust in their workers, they can replace them, no? Especially if they don't force everyone to come to the office and hire remote workers. Win-win
- pydry 5y agoWhy would they trust the replacement workers any more?
- blamestross 5y agoIt seems like the real problem then would be that managers don't feel like they can evaluate trustworthiness without in-person interaction or a pantopticon.
- srswtf123 5y agoNo, the real problem is that for the most part, they can’t evaluate trustworthiness and use in-person interaction and a panopticon to cover up that fact.
- pydry 5y agoPretty much. During the pandemic one of the first things the company I worked for did was install extra invasive tracking on our laptops. The bullshit rationale, the fact it interfered with doing my actual job and the creepy vibes I got were one reason why I quit. Im almost certain theyll try to drag people back in.
- heavyset_go 5y agoThey think the panopticon is necessary, either for worker productivity, for their own job security, or out of outright disdain for their underlings. Many of them were also involved in signing multiyear leases and investing millions to billions of dollars in office real estate before the pandemic.
- hakfoo 5y agoProbably also helps management tier look busy. I can imagine if you have a scheduled video-chat with 15 minutes per employee, you can cover a 10-employee team in about 3 hours. If you have to hunt them across the company campus and find meeting rooms and times, it ballons to 8.
- MathYouF 5y agoThis is very true from what I've seen, but it doesn't mean managers who only do 3 hours of work aren't worth their daily wage. There are many programmers who only realistically do 3 hours of programming, but spend others thinking about the problem, researching, ect. Good managers in my experience have three important jobs: Scoping projects and getting the team together, motivating employees and handling their compant interfacing problems (talking to HR for them, managing account access issues, ect.), and most importantly talking with clients/stakeholders in a sympathetic ans professional way that many developers just won't do at the same quality. All of that might only take 3 hours of video calls per day, but for the good ones, it's a full day's work. For some, certain functions they're doing aren't needed, but most of the managers I've had have done valuable work that I wouldn't do as well and wouldn't want to have to do which would distract me from my work. Could professional football teams likely also have the players figure out training schedules, plane flights, diets, plays, recruiting? Probably, and some might be pretty good at it. So why don't they? Probably the reason those teams have coaches is the same as why managers in the tech space aren't all going to be proven useless working remotely, because they actually aren't.
- yunohn 5y ago> Scoping projects Maybe yours is a very different experience, but this hasn’t been mine both in engineering or sales teams. Quite often that’s a separate role, like project or engagement manager. And I’ve seen this in both large corps and mid-size startups.
- srswtf123 5y agoPersonally, I believe its to reclaim their former position in the social hierarchy. The pandemic revealed much of the management layer as useless. No one wants to cop to that, so now you see them twisting themselves in knots to justify the return. Frankly it'd be more respectable if it were honest. Sadly, honestly is not to be expected from American "Corporate Elites".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tluyben2 5y agoMany managers (executives included) need to see bums on seats and count hours in the office: they have very little to no other ways to measure worker productivity. As others say, it is trust but it is also a way of staying relevant for many bad managers. One of the big things coming from the pandemic was that wfh did not collapse entire companies but actually worked. A lot of management insisting people in the office 'was the only way' turned out to be more a problem with the quality of management than anything else.
- hudsonjr 5y agoI am wondering if this comes from "visual" mangers and execs. I used to have an exec that would try to drop big off the top of his head projects on me as he was walking by my cube. I'd usually say, "I'm right up against a deadline, but will look into it" and then go to my manager and say "wtf". I don't think we ever did anything with any of those spontaneous ideas. There were also managers from other departments that would not do anything over e-mail or chat. They'd traverse across campus to ask questions or "have a quick chat". It always annoyed me as it would be things I could find out, but couldn't really speak to off the top of my head. Things that would be perfect to handle over e-mail initially, and then talk in person if more context is needed. Sometimes I was not even the intended target of conversation, it's just whoever they were looking for was not at their desk.