6 ms·
Presuming we have 100% oil-powered car and jet transit vs 100% electric (assuming electric planes are developed), which one is worse for the environment? Oil or
by echelon 5y ago
Presuming we have 100% oil-powered car and jet transit vs 100% electric (assuming electric planes are developed), which one is worse for the environment? Oil or lithium?
Assume transportation levels remain constant or continue to grow.
What's the cost of the entire lifecycle? Mining/extraction, carbon emissions, recycling (or not), etc.
Honest question.
I'm coming from a disposition where it seems like lithium will be just as bad or worse from a mining and remediation perspective, worse from a recycling perspective, but better for carbon sequestration assuming we get power from solar, wind, nuclear, etc. and not coal. It seems like electric will also increase cardiovascular and pulmonary health since many studies link air quality to endothelial aging.
Overall, I'm curious if the trade-off are worth it.
I'm also interested in the geopolitical angle.
The US has energy on lock under the old regime, but energy alternatives seem as though they'll favor Europe and China (China especially for lithium), but not the oil powers. It also de-risks dependence on oil and coal for many countries that are net importers. Is this correct? How (or will?) a switch to electric transportation change the geopolitical world? Substantially?
Edit: downvoted for questions.
- lanstin 5y agoRight now carbon dioxide caused warming is more serious threat than a few more toxic metals. Sunlight is basically free money raining down all the time.
- lanstin 5y agoAlso, by definition silicon (panels) and lithium (batteries) are super common elements. Not going to be hard to find. Unlike oil, you can use the solar panels to fab more solar panels, because of the sun’s input. You can’t use coal to make more coal. The solar inputs are long since gone.
- k33n 5y agoSo you believe that carbon dioxide -- which will be used by plants to generate oxygen -- is a greater threat to the environment than toxic metals, which will take millions of years to dissipate? Something seems off...
- pfdietz 5y agoYes, CO2 is currently a much larger threat.
- k33n 5y agoNegative.
- pertymcpert 5y agoPlants don't absorb CO2 to get oxygen, they absorb it to get carbon. And what do you think happens to the plants afterwards? Do they store the carbon forever? What happens when they die?
- morpheos137 5y agoHe didn't say "get" oxygen. He said make oxygen. Yeah plants do ingest CO2 + H2O to make oxygen via photosynthesis. Oxygen is arguably a more toxic gas than CO2. It causes fires and oxidation. Dose make the poison. All aerobic metabolising organism exhale CO2. They have been for billions of years. The sky hasn't fallen. Some how I doubt it will from one species of animal burning fossils for a few tens of decades.
- pertymcpert 5y agoFirst of all, the purpose of photosynthesis is primarily for obtaining energy via carbon. Oxygen by itself is no use. Secondly, not all of the oxygen that a plant uses comes from photosynthesis. Some of it can be absorbed from water in the roots, and some is absorbed from the air itself between cells. The amount varies from species to species. More importantly, you've completely missed the bigger point. Carbon has been sequestered from the atmosphere over millions of years. Now we are releasing that carbon at a high rate over a few decades. The balance is being changed at an extremely fast rate, in a blink of a geological eye. So.... the OP originally tried to justify fossil fuels on the basis that plants will just absorb it. Can you answer my question to them? Where does that carbon go once a plant has absorbed it? Ok, so let me cut to the chase. Plants store the carbon. Plants eventually die. Carbon is mostly released back into the atmosphere either indirectly or directly. So increased plant sequestration is only a temporarily store, it can't help us fix the carbon issue permanently.
- aae42 5y agoProbably downvoted because there are a plethora of sources out there for you to easily do your own checking on. - https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/02/climate/electric-vehicles-environment.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/02/climate/electric-vehicles... - https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesellsmoor/2019/05/20/are-electric-vehicles-really-better-for-the-environment/?sh=549800da76d2 https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesellsmoor/2019/05/20/are-el... - https://www.wsj.com/graphics/are-electric-cars-really-better-for-the-environment/ https://www.wsj.com/graphics/are-electric-cars-really-better... There may be some articles from not as reputable sources that may find the answer to be a little more controversial... The TL;DR is generally: yes... electric is always greener, it's just a matter of how much. As they become more and more sustainably powered, the difference increases.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAlso, this line of “EVs are worse for the environment because of coal powered grids” is literally oil industry propaganda.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wwtrv 5y agoIt depends, if all of the energy you use to charge your car is produced in states like Wyoming or West Virginia (both of which export several times more electricity than they consume) driving a hybrid or any small/efficient IC car is definitely better. I think banning coal is something that we should definitely do before even considering banning IC cars…
- Tagbert 5y agoAccording the the study by the Union of Concerned Scientists, an EV powered by 100% coal produces about the same CO2 as a 50mpg ICE car. Very few grids are that dirty. Once you get out of those areas, the EV is much cleaner.
- peter303 5y agoBattery powered long distance flight is unlikely because gasoline/kerosene has 5 times the weight energy density of lithium ion. Short haul flights may be viable. Hydrogen fuel cell planes even better because hydrogen has 3 times the weight energy density of jet fuel and 15 times lithium batteries.
- selectodude 5y agoLong-haul flights work because burning the fuel means that it’s no longer weight being carried. In terms of energy to carried weight ratio, it’s basically infinite.
- Tagbert 5y agoWhat you may see are efforts to convert short-haul flights to electricity where the limited range is less of an issue.
- lazide 5y agoHydrogen is a non starter because of the need for heavy tanks no? Batteries are sealed contained
- JohnL4 5y agoRight. Liquid hydrogen is fluffy. Energy density by volume is 4 times lower than that of jet fuel. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20210401-the-worlds-first-commercial-hydrogen-plane https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20210401-the-worlds-first...
- nickik 5y agoThis is not true. It just requires rethinking the whole design of a plane. Density of energy is not everything. Batteries for example can be made structural, so they actually replace part of the weight of a plane, while kerosene has to be carried like cargo. ICE engines are far less efficient too. And the TWR of electric engines is better too. That again reduced the structural loads. Electric engines also don't need to oxygen and can potentially fly much higher, where there is less air resistance. Even if you can't get as far, the price to operate these planes will be so much lower, that for the waste majority of the market they will simply be cheaper. Maybe more trips with multiple stops. Maybe the very longest flights would still be out of reach with good lithium-sulfer batteries but I suspect at that point those flights will be economically not tenable anymore.
- ju-st 5y agoThere is only very little lithium in "lithium" batteries (1-10%). Batteries last a long time and even when they've lost a lot of capacity they are still usable in cheap used cars and can be repurposed as stationary energy storage.
- ashtonkem 5y agoYou have to be running 100% coal power plants before EVs are worse for the environment. For a pure oil fired power grid, which does not exist anywhere in America, EVs would win hands down. Once you get to a mix of natural gas, coal, and renewables, which is actually what the US grid looks like then EVs are massively better than gasoline cars.
- wwtrv 5y agoInternal combustion engines are actually very efficient. Burning gasoline in a power plant produces 2.13 pounds of CO2 per kWh, Model 3 LR consumes 16 kWh per 100km, so 34.08lb of CO2. A car consuming 7 liters of gas per 100km would emit 35lb of CO2. I assume energy loss from plant to battery is not insignificant so the IC should be better if the power grid is 100% petroleum (for coal it should be 2x worse). Sources: https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11 https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/info-tools/One%20table%20to%20rule%20them%20all%20v1.pdf https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/info-tools/One%20tab...
- gpm 5y agoWorth noting that your CO2 emission value for gasoline powered vehicles is tailpipe emissions, the total value (well to wheels) should be very roughly 25% higher. I don't know exactly what CO2 production your power plant number includes. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.6b02819#tbl1 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.6b02819#tbl1
- wwtrv 5y agoThanks just wanted to make a rough approximation since a purely coal/petrol network is not realistic anyway. https://www.eia.gov/tools/glossary/index.php?id=Net%20generation https://www.eia.gov/tools/glossary/index.php?id=Net%20genera... I believe it’s electricity generated at the plant, so we should add 5-15% for transmission losses and 8-20% depending on charger efficiency. Assuming 5% transmission and 10% charging loss using the well-to-wheel figures you posted charging in a 100% coal grid should be equivalent to and around 5.7l/100km / 41mpg IC car.
- bertil 5y agoIt’s roughly comparable for extraction cost for comparable weight: large variation depending on circumstances, etc. but you need 63 kg of Lithium for a Telsa that should drive a million miles. You’d need 50 thousand gallons of gas (200,000 L or 160 tons) to cover the same distance. So about three thousands times worst. The lifecycle balance isn’t something you can draw at scale on a high-definition screen and have the electric impact occupy more than a pixel or two. Same for Cobalt: it used to be used to make batteries, so there are worrisome stories but the metal is also something that refineries put in gas so… kinda the same: you are comparing a component with a consumable. Finally, you mention China, or you could have asked about Chile to, for Lithium. Neither are really the largest producers. They sure sound politically scary but it’s harder to paint Australia has a dangerous dictature. Scary countries aren’t the biggest marginal plan if prices go up: the reserves in Canada and USA are more promising. So yeah: shifting to those technologies will force a big geopolitical change and the executives at fossil fuel companies who boasted being accused of war crimes as a sign of commitment a sure way to advance their careers in front of large group including me (sic) might have a bit of a reckoning. I’ll let you guess which war zone, environmental disaster there were talking so causally about, because they are so many — hint: they were also accused of genocide there; except that’s not really a helpful hint, is it? The oil barons in the Gulf who routinely use slavery and prostitue girls as young as 7 or 8, both in broad daylight, might have to change their lifestyle too. Some people think that having a CEO posting weird meme on twitter, or advocating for long shift to end [see paragraph above] is unacceptable. Sure, it’s improvable as far as leadership goes, but… I like to ask: what’s the alternative? If we don’t have that, what do we have? In my case, it’s the eyes of a little girl, dragged through the hall of a luxurious hotel in Dubai. The documentarian who filmed and commented that scene had no doubt what was happening, or who paid for it: he did, every time he filled his tank.
- cinquemb 5y ago> So yeah: shifting to those technologies will force a big geopolitical change and the executives at fossil fuel companies who boasted being accused of war crimes as a sign of commitment a sure way to advance their careers in front of large group including me (sic) might have a bit of a reckoning. I’ll let you guess which war zone, environmental disaster there were talking so causally about, because they are so many — hint: they were also accused of genocide there; except that’s not really a helpful hint, is it? The oil barons in the Gulf who routinely use slavery and prostitue girls as young as 7 or 8, both in broad daylight, might have to change their lifestyle too. One also has to consider that existing structure of the global financial system, that finances a lot of these operations and has a lot of value locked up in them long term, has less incentive to pursue such initiatives to the degree that they can hedge the downside risks of the long term losses on those assets onto somebody else while building out new renewable infrastructure.
- onethought 5y agoIsn’t the answer in the fact that it’s recyclable. Not just the fact that you can recycle an old lithium battery into a new one. But that you can recharge it for 8+ years. You don’t even need to do the math: if you invented an oil car that you filled up with 800kg of oil once and it ran for 8 years. It’s clearly an improvement.
- nickik 5y ago> What's the cost of the entire lifecycle? Mining/extraction, carbon emissions, recycling (or not), etc. It is not very high. Specially now that there is series effort going into lithium production and the whole supply chain of batteries. Much more local production. In fact, in examples like this lithium production is not harmful at all. At worst its as bad as mining anything else. At best its a totally brine process where you are just extracting a little bit of salt from geological brine and pump it right back. > worse from a recycling perspective Worse then gasoline that gets burned up? How? The opposite is true, currently almost all lithium batteries are recycled or are simply going to secondary uses. Over the long term all major players have recycling efforts going on, because once you have series amounts of batteries reaching end of life, it simply makes sense to recycle as it will be cheaper then mining new. The air quality around some chemical plant is one thing, even under worse assumptions, its a million times better then driving gasoline cars threw cities where people actually live. > Is this correct? How (or will?) a switch to electric transportation change the geopolitical world? Substantially? All the materials needed for batteries exist in pretty much all continents. All the continents have the knowledge to produce all the required materials. Even if now it often happens in China. It will mean a major lost of importance for the big oil states. Other then that not much will change.