4 ms·
But the custodians have to choose just one chain because they only have enough assets to back one copy. They don't want a situation where there's, say, 50B USDC
by wmf 5y ago
But the custodians have to choose just one chain because they only have enough assets to back one copy. They don't want a situation where there's, say, 50B USDCA and 50B USDCB backed by only $50B in assets. So if there's a fork, a custodian will decide that the USDC on one chain is redeemable and the USDC on all other chains is not redeemable (i.e. worth zero), then other DeFi assets on the losing chain will go to zero as well, and it snowballs.
- koolba 5y agoWhat if they choose two different chains?
- wmf 5y agoThat would explicitly break the one promise they made, which is that their coins are backed 1:1.
- koolba 5y agoI meant what if USDC and USDT pick two different chains to bless as their “official” chain? Is that not possible? EDIT: I just realized the last letter in your examples are “A” and “B” to signify two versions of the same thing. My eyes aren’t what they used to be!
- cinquemb 5y agoIt is possible.
- user-the-name 5y agoUSDT is already running on multiple chains. That is trivially possible. The question is what happens if one of those chains were to split.
- imtringued 5y agoBecause anyone can create a fork of a chain the forks have to be authorized. The easiest way to authorize a chain would be to let the custodian (is that the right word?) of USDT decide which chains are authorized for USDT. If the custodian authorizes overlapping USDT then it is equivalent to creating an empty chain and creating USDT out of nothing to fill the newly created chain. In other words it would dilute the value of USDT. This is an interesting problem because it shows a fundamental flaw in blockchains. They only have authority over themselves. No wonder cryptocurrencies and their advocates are so self centered. Because nothing that exists outside their chain (even other cryptocurrencies) is graspable! It's not trustless because the trust (in the algorithm) is still there, the difference is that they minimized the need for trust to the absolute minimum. It's no longer about how much you trust but about what you trust.
- cinquemb 5y agoFrax, USDT, and TrueUSD allow people to deposit into bank accounts and mint on eth mainnet or avalanche c-chain now (note: not mint on both places at the same time), neither make the claim that they are 1:1 backed (except for TrueUSD), but they make the claim that if you wanted to at any time (if you meet the criteria) you can withdraw from eth mainnet or avalanche c-chain to your bank account.
- lupire 5y agoWhen did Tether USDT stop (fraudulently) claiming to have backing assets?
- cinquemb 5y agoNone of this is related to the minting/burning across multiple chains or their cross chain redeemability (or lack thereof) but here are their respective claims: USDT claim (“Every Tether token is always 100% backed by our reserves, which include traditional currency and cash equivalents and, from time to time, may include other assets and receivables from loans made by Tether to third parties, which may include affiliated entities (collectively, “reserves”).”) [1] TrueUSD claim ("We work with independent third-party financial institutions to provide cash management for the underlying reserves backing TUSD tokens so that each TUSD token is backed by an equivalent amount of dollar deposits, cash equivalents, short-term government treasuries, or liquid investments. To achieve this, a portion of the dollar deposits backing TUSD are held in one or more depository accounts at our Banking Partners whose deposits may not be insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (“FDIC”). [2] Frax claim ("FRAX stablecoins can be minted by placing the appropriate amount of its constituent parts into the system. At genesis, FRAX is 100% collateralized, meaning that minting FRAX only requires placing collateral into the minting contract. During the fractional phase, minting FRAX requires placing the appropriate ratio of collateral and burning the ratio of Frax Shares (FXS). While the protocol is designed to accept any type of cryptocurrency as collateral, this implementation of the Frax Protocol will mainly accept on-chain stablecoins as collateral to smoothen out volatility in the collateral so that FRAX can transition to more algorithmic ratios smoothly. As the velocity of the system increases, it becomes easier and safer to include volatile cryptocurrency such as ETH and wrapped BTC into future pools with governance. ")[3] [1] https://tether.to https://tether.to [2] https://trueusd.com/terms-of-service/ https://trueusd.com/terms-of-service/ [3] https://docs.frax.finance/overview https://docs.frax.finance/overview
- dsr_ 5y agoThat implies that USDCblah is actually backed by traceable assets, 1:1. Have any of the so-called stable coins actually passed a complete third-party asset?
- dsr_ 5y agos/asse/audi/
- dcolkitt 5y agoThat's largely an orthogonal point. You may be suspicious of USDT or USDC's claim. But the point is that at least some fraction of the market is not, which is why USDT trades at $1.00. Now that may turn out in the future to be revealed to be a sham, and the market will lose faith. But right now USDT only has market value because some segment of people believe in the promises made by the Tether Corporation. If I fork the chain, and I'm running a clone of USDT, and the Tether Corp says "there are no promises behind that token", then very clearly forked-USDT will be worth zero.
- lupire 5y agonot quite. stablecoins do not get stability from belief in the backing assets. they get stability merely from a shared agreement to pretend the coin is stable, so as not to lose whatever stake they have put in.
- user-the-name 5y agoBut that shared agreement still does not transfer to the forked blockchain.
- nly 5y agoI don't think "pretend" is enough. I've certainly used USDT as a medium of exchange for a few minutes because it has a stable exchange rate, but I wouldn't hold it for an extended period.
- stepanhruda 5y agoShared agreement is not quite enough, that’s why algorithmic stablecoins fail. You can say that’s due to lack of agreement but it all comes down to incentives. The only reason stablecoins work is because they have a mechanism where you can quickly 1. mint a new coin and sell it for slightly more than $1 for it 2. buy a coin for less than $1 and redeem it for $1 in value
- cinquemb 5y agoYeah, I think in the case where one tries to fork the chain state and expects the assets on the new chain automatically be redeemable for something doesn't really work out. Though this may happen in reality because of bridges (centralized/decentralized + permission/less): one asset is locked in a smart contract (or many smart contracts) on one chain, then minted in equivalent amounts on another, people will trade as if holds the equivalent value modulo liquidity for the bridged asset (as long as the locking/minting assumptions with the bridges hold true).
- dane-pgp 5y agoWouldn't a custodian have a potential conflict of interest here, picking a chain whose rules, say, give the custodian a recurring "management fee" to support their important role?