21 ms·
I see a lot of comments misinterpreting this. First, it's not about private files, it's about distributing content. Google isn't spying on your private files,
by crazygringo 5y ago
I see a lot of comments misinterpreting this.
First, it's not about private files, it's about distributing content.
Google isn't spying on your private files, but does scan them when you share them publicly. E.g. keep all the pirated movies you want on your Drive, and even give private access to friends, but the moment you make them publicly viewable Google scans them and limits access accordingly. So no, this isn't applying to your private diary or privately shared documents.
And second, to those who claim absolute free speech with no limits -- notice that the two main categories here are related to democracy and health. All our legal protections ultimately depend on a democratic foundation -- undo that with misinformation and you don't have anything anymore. Similarly, your rights don't matter much if you're dead. Companies aren't allowed to advertise rat poison as medicine and neither are you.
- hf98shf89sh 5y agoSo, last year when the Wuhan lab leak was a conspiracy theory, it would have been (and was) censored. But what happens when Google/their allies change their mind and determine that something is no longer a conspiracy theory?
- gjs278 5y agothe rest of us were fine before google did this drive ban. how about they just put a warning on it for morons like you and let the rest of us read it?
- rscoots 5y agoWho at Google do you trust to decide what information you and I are allowed to know? What is this person's qualifications? How can they be held to account when they inevitably get it wrong? Where will the highly-transparent write-ups detailing moderation decisions be published? Seems like if Google actually gave a damn about the morality of censorship as some sort of 'neccessary evil' you'd be able to answer these questions easily^. Until then, it's a non-starter in my book.
- systemvoltage 5y agoTo add: Who at Google listens to dissent!? No one is allowed to say anything - there is sort of a chilling effect internally at Google. It’s debateless policies that are spreading on the world stage. People need to rise up against a small group of individuals located in Menlo Park, CA who are demonstrably and utterly out of the touch with the rest of the world, but deciding how and what information flows. These people have no idea how agriculture works or how people live in Indonesia or what conflicts are going on in Namibia.
- revnode 5y agoThis is the key problem with all censorship, however well-intentioned. A person is needed to censor. People make mistakes. Sometimes by accident, sometimes on purpose. There is a strong dis-incentive to having any transparency or accountability. If there were, you might be held liable for your mistakes and nobody wants that.
- joe_the_user 5y agoI don't trust Google to fully filter information for it's credibility ... so I don't automatically trust things shared on Google drive. But I don't have to trust that Google won't suppress valid positions drive since there are many alternatives for sharing information beyond Google drive, which isn't meant to primarily host public content in any case.
- rscoots 5y ago>many alternatives for sharing information beyond Google drive You'll be disturbed to learn then that every major social network heavily censors information in an opaque manner. What about the elderly or others who might only know how to use Facebook or YouTube? Fuck em?
- joe_the_user 5y agoFirst, since you've been derailing thing from one question another, I have to mention that a thing shared publicly from a Google drive account is no more accessible than a thing shared from a website that a person sets themselves, so Google drive accessibly is not particular answer to social network news filtering. But on the topic of social network news filtering, anyone who uses a social network is implicitly consenting to that network's filtering of information. Once upon a time, most people got their news from a single newspaper - well informed people might read several papers as well as newsmagazines but even this implied a lot of filtering. Those newspapers filtered the news more heavily than any present network.
- gjs278 5y agoI only get two comments a day and im going to spend the next one on you as well. the rest of the world would be better off if you were dead because you are leading us down a path to actual hell. let people write whatever the fuck they want you fucking fascist prick. not everyone knows how to make a website and google drive might be how they communicate their information. it’s the equivalent to locking up a guy standing on venice beach with a megaphone because he sounds crazy, and he probably is, but he’s got the right to do it. google drive is a common carrier and as long as they’re not violating the laws of the country it’s being distributed in, they should fuck off and not worry about it.
- freedomben 5y agowhat about if you share a file with select people? Is that still "private" or does it become public the moment you give someone else access?
- contravariant 5y agoThere's something fundamentally flawed about the idea that censorship in the name of preventing misinformation is protecting the foundation of democracy. You cannot have true democracy if people cannot disagree with their governments, they must be able to disagree with any truth or opinion such a government might consider self-evident, just on the off chance they're right. I should at this point note that Google doesn't directly claim to go quite that far in preventing misinformation, they mostly claim to disallow things that could harm the democractic process (e.g. telling people to vote at the wrong place, their candidate has died, etc.). At least that kind of information is usually agreed upon (if not there are bigger problems than mere misinformation), though they seem to try to include claims of voter-fraud, which is a bit dangerous.
- hackererror404 5y agoImagine if Britain had this same technology when the USA was founded... It of course would have quickly cracked down on communications and it would have done so in the name of "peace" and "what's right"... This idea that thinking critically of a government and even believing that perhaps the government as it stands today is not the government "of and for the people" (sure could be interpreted as anti-democracy by that same corrupt government)... And maybe that's not correct, but who is the government to say that we can or cannot challenge them in public discourse as it is supposedly protected under the first amendment? This is indeed an insanely slippery slope and people willing to trade their freedoms because they think it's for the ultimate good, I think are really making a mistake... it's not difficult to understand that this is one of the first steps of an actual fundamentally corrupt government... This is easily open to abuse and vast interpretation.
- akira2501 5y ago> undo that with misinformation and you don't have anything anymore. That presumes that we have come from a period that was somehow free of misinformation. This is obviously false, and all we're doing is trading one corrupt system of control for another. Democracy also demands that the burden of proof is on the accuser, don't you feel this same standard should apply to those, who of their own volition, take on the task of fighting this "misinformation?" Shouldn't those deprived have recourse? > Companies aren't allowed to advertise rat poison as medicine and neither are you. Advertising is always a commercial activity. If I'm merely sharing my opinion that rat poison, in some dose, might possibly serve as a cure for some particular ailment, how am I advertising? Isn't there a responsibility of the other end user to not accept medical advice from anonymous information published from a free document sharing service? I'm not sure the trade offs you suggest are gaining us anything important.
- driverdan 5y ago> Google isn't spying on your private files This is false. All of the major services that host images scan them for child porn, regardless if they're private or shared. I don't know how they're going to apply these rules and, unless you work there and are involved in this, neither do you.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThis is a point most miss. I’m curious how they know if something is/isn’t CP. Anyone have any experience in this realm? Do they have to use CP to compare against? Wouldn’t that be illegal?
- paxys 5y agoLook up photodna. Basically they compare hashes of uploaded images to a database of known child porn.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway83058 5y agoI work at Google. I’m not involved with this change specifically, but suffice it to say there is far more advanced processing than simple hash checks for CSAM being run on every file uploaded to Drive. I would be surprised if all files weren’t subject to these checks, but whether or not Google will take action on them is another matter.
- Jyaif 5y agoI hope you are wrong as that would be economically and environmentally wasteful.
- wmil 5y agoA few years back people were getting messages from Google if their docs contained hate speech. Google's response was that it was a corporate feature that was accidentally turned on for all accounts. So they certainly have infrastructure to do deep content scans of all users docs. Realistically they probably do still scan all accounts for internal metrics, it's just notification that has been disabled.
- tyingq 5y ago>First, it's not about private files, it's about distributing content. Sort of. People use "anybody with the link can view" for lots of purposes that are far short of broad public publishing. I use it for sharing with single digit numbers of people I already know, or sometimes just for myself for things that don't need to be private.
- listmaking 5y agoActually, this is not even about distribution exactly, but about the "Report Abuse" button: what this page lists are categories of things that, if someone with access to the file clicks on "Report Abuse", whoever is acting on those flags may decide is a violation. Note that the page says: > After we are notified of a potential policy violation, we may review the content and take action… So (1) it's not about Google proactively scanning all your files (even public ones: though I guess with sufficiently public files, sooner or later someone will click on "Report Abuse", perhaps even by accident), and (2) I imagine it could happen with files you shared with just your friend, if your "friend" decides to "Report Abuse". (Disclaimer: I work at Google but not on Google Drive or anything related to these policies.)
- ping_pong 5y agoYou are assuming a professional is reading whatever the content is you are distributing and will make a rational, fair decision. No. It's going to be a minimum wage indentured Google servant that doesn't quite understand what they are reading but they have 17.5 seconds per case to make a decision. They will shoot first and ask questions later. What if the document is satire but they couldn't understand it? Oh well there goes one strike against your account, or maybe that's your third strike and now ALL your Google accounts are banned. We already know what the appeals process is like. Unless you get it publicized on Hacker News et al, you won't get any chance to appeal.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- prepend 5y agoI don’t want a cloud storage provider with only private storage. If I have a library of book files I want to share it with my spouse and if Google is trying to filter out misinform and not let me distribute it to my spouse, that’s bad. I think we’ll have augmented intelligence through computing soon and imagine how horrific it will be if Google says “you can think misinfo, we just won’t let you think it?” That’s bad. Storing, creating, and distributing don’t need limits like this. Asimov’s three laws were possible and they still had issues. Imagine having a law for robots that they couldn’t speak what Google thought is misinfo.
- wes-k 5y ago> Companies aren't allowed to advertise rat poison as medicine and neither are you. You may want a different example :). > Warfarin first came into large-scale commercial use in 1948 as a rat poison. Warfarin was formally approved for human use by the US FDA to treat blood clots in 1954. Source: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warfarin https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warfarin
- LMYahooTFY 5y ago>All our legal protections ultimately depend on a democratic foundation -- undo that with misinformation and you don't have anything anymore. No, they don't. They have never depended on an entity deciding what information should be disseminated and what information should not be. This move isn't any different than AT&T or the one guy with a Gutenberg Press in your region deciding what you can and cannot read. Our legal protections depend on the citizens and the government adhering to them.
- imwillofficial 5y ago> undo that with misinformation and you don't have anything anymore. And how is this defined? At one time everyone agreed the earth was flat.
- MichaelMoser123 5y agoMao in 1956: let a hundred flowers bloom ... Mao a year later: but watch out for the weeds. In those days the CPC apparently also has had a change in their 'terms and conditions'.
- mastazi 5y ago> when you share them publicly from the wording in the link[1], it seems even if you share the document with just one single person, and that person flags it, Google is then allowed to investigate. So, the pre-condition is not sharing publicly, just sharing. > So no, this isn't applying to your private diary or privately shared documents. Well this seems to be inaccurate based on the text cited below[1], do you have sources that back your claim? There is nothing saying that privately shared documents can't be reviewed. The only necessary condition seems to be just that someone flagged your content, which could be the one person you shared that content with. [1] "After we are notified of a potential policy violation, we may review the content and take action, including restricting access to the content, removing the content, and limiting or terminating a user’s access to Google products".
- zekrioca 5y agoIt is funny how people blindly trust Google on this..
- wutbrodo 5y ago> All our legal protections ultimately depend on a democratic foundation -- undo that with misinformation and you don't have anything anymore. Similarly, your rights don't matter much if you're dead. This is an insane conclusion to draw, because it blithely ignores that it positions Google as an oracle of what's threatening to democracy and what isn't. The examples in the current policy are fairly narrow, but this is a categorical line being crossed (for better or worse). Those who are concerned by the increasing encroachment of effective utilities on what can be communicated need to speak up when clear lines are crossed, because it's the only way to avoid frog-boiling.
- intended 5y agoThis positions google as an intermediary. Someone else has figured out what is misinformation and is telling google.
- wutbrodo 5y agoThe idea that _anyone_ can reliably enough decree what's misinformation is ludicrous. I acknowledge that there are vast masses of incredibly stupid people that need to pretend that Truth is handed down on clay tablets by God in order to function. We're much better off with the scientific establishment wearing this mantle than, say, religious institutions. And its pointless to try to convince these people that science is an iterative, incremental process that's based in skepticism, not certainty. But the minority of society that understands and participates in the process of truth-formation (including scientists!) produces a widely disproportionate amount of epistemic value, and society depends on this process for basic functioning. It's amazing to me that this isn't clear to everyone after the pandemic, of all things. The amount of claims that were banned from social media as "misinformation" that became expert consensus a couple of months later is mind-boggling. Following smart and quantitative people on Twitter was wayyyy more likely to provide you a healthy and safe pandemic experience than following the incoherent and self-contradictory public health recommendations (let alone policy). More important than this "direct-to-consumer" ability to discuss the pandemic is that experts themselves form their opinions through this type of discussion. The notion that there's a "someone else" who has reliably figured out which dissent is out of bounds is laughable. I'll note again that Google's current policy is limited to fairly simple things, but it's an important Schelling fence being torn down and worthy of commenting on (and pushing back against, if yiu believe the trend is harmful).
- zekrioca 5y agoWhy do they scan it when made public? Why does it have to be pro-active and not reactive?
- ogurechny 5y ago“Democracy” and “health” are high level man-made abstractions, so they can hardly be placed at the root of anything, that's not just because of “free speech”. See how you didn't even try to use, say, “personal rights” and “personal life”; the panegyric for those who “know what's better for you” needs vague impersonal “democracy” and “health”. Google has been doing anything it wants with people's data, news like these just mean they are lazily formalizing their power.
- make3 5y agoYour message implies that you trust that Google will use this message in a clean way. They won't; they have a history of using algorithms to detect TOS abuses in a very Gung-ho way without any sort of functional appeal process.
- sMarsIntruder 5y ago> Google isn't spying on your private files Yes, it is.
- bolangi 5y agoI don't even use google, except I have a youtube login, and many friends I correspond with use gmail. In the present surveillance regime we can experience, through the medium of digital communications, the myth of the Evil Eye and the fear of being watched with bad intention.
- CheezeIt 5y agoWhy are you acting like it stops here?
- FooHentai 5y ago>Google isn't spying on your private files, but does scan them when you share them publicly. What's more likely: A) That they make a single-pass scan over a file for various purposes B) They make multiple, separate scans over a file at different times depending on sharing status and other factors I'd contend that it's more likely to be A, and that it almost certainly happens as soon as the data becomes visible to Google. I'd be very surprised if they didn't scan immediately to de-dupe and detect illegal pornography, for example. Once that's a given, it doesn't make much sense to do a separate kind of scanning later based on a different set of criteria; You scan once and flag for the respective detections immediately.
- pfortuny 5y agoThis argument is exactly what the Inquisition argued. Now try to explain to me why the Inquisition is bad.
- hfkwnfb 5y agoI don't think there's much distinction between "you're not allowed an opinion" and "you're allowed an opinion as long as you don't tell anyone".
- swiley 5y agoPeople deciding what to share and who to vote for are equivalent. You effectively don't get one without the other.
- intricatedetail 5y agoCome on man, this is classic boiling frog.
- jejones3141 5y agoI take rat poison as medicine--warfarin, just in much smaller doses than the rats get. For that matter, the most toxic substance known to man, botulism toxin, is being promoted for various medical and cosmetic uses.
- dalbasal 5y ago>> it's not about private files, it's about distributing content The distinction between private files and distributed content is blurred-2-nonexistent, and Google Drive is not a neutral player in that process. The whole premise is that these are just sharing settings. The premise of this service is that controlling your own files is passe, because content distribution, creation, consumption and need to work seamlessly. Also, this isn't outside of the greater Alphabet complex. Even in social media, where they are a secondary player, they own Youtube... also premised on the sharing and distributing model.
- concordDance 5y ago> notice that the two main categories here are related to democracy and health Funny you should mention health... Imagine if Google banned speaking out against Cryonics or life extension technologies on this basis.
- TroisM 5y ago> Google isn't spying on your private files actually, it does... at least on the ones hosted by Google.
- brigandish 5y agoI agree with your first paragraph but this: > All our legal protections ultimately depend on a democratic foundation is the wrong way round. I suspect you're speaking from a US perspective. The US constitution limits the rights of goverment for the benefit of the people, it does not limit the rights of the people for the benefit of government.