8 ms·
Trickle down doesn't work because it is motivated by the people who benefit from it rather than a macroeconomic need. If the labor market is a buyer market (em
by imtringued 5y ago
Trickle down doesn't work because it is motivated by the people who benefit from it rather than a macroeconomic need.
If the labor market is a buyer market (employers picking employees) then trickle down can't work by definition because the labor market is already stacked in favor of the employers. They already obtained all possible positive sum benefit from the strategy.
If the labor market is a sellers market then trickle down could work in theory but a sellers market means we are in an economic boom/expansion so people are happy and don't need further interventions beyond a raise in the interest rate.
>But in a network economy, the means of production have shifted. It’s 10X more fluid, can create wealth at a much higher rate, decrease costs at a much higher rate, and the network can raise all boats.
Okay now things are getting stupid. Economic saturation (aka overproduction) is sort of perverse. When companies boost production (creating wealth at a much higher rate), demand doesn't necesssarily catch up with increased production. [0] What happens is that the increase in productivity allows you to employ less people. That means less people can afford the overproduction because they are out of a job temporarily. Demand is going down in the short term. This means we are overproducing even more products relative to demand, resulting in even more layoffs. Lots of stuff and nobody there to buy it. Lack of demand then results in lack of investment. The economic growth and productivity growth are slowing down...
[0] It may sound shocking but billionaires wouldn't be billionaires if they didn't spend less than they earn. Creating more billionaires or giving them more money is an effective way of decreasing demand and thus the potential for your economy to grow.
- dfilppi 5y agoTrickle down doesn't "work", because "work" has been defined a certain way. Define "work" another way, and it does "work". It also presumes that the government somehow has first dibs on what people earn, which is absurd.
- ModernMech 5y agoAlso stated as "The purpose of the system is what it does". If the system as designed is concentrating wealth in the hands of a few individuals (who themselves helped set up the system), how can we say it's not working as intended? It seems to be working out very well for them.
- WalterBright 5y ago> concentrating wealth This implies that wealth is zero sum. It isn't. Creating wealth, which is what businesses do, is not "concentrating" it.
- triceratops 5y agoYou're talking past each other. If a business achieves a 10x leap in productivity and lowers prices for its customers, has it created wealth for others? Yes. If that business is owned by a single person, has that person's wealth relative to the rest of society increased? Also yes.
- WalterBright 5y agoI agree with your points. However, Creating wealth is not concentrating it.
- ModernMech 5y agoBusinesses create wealth, and then capture the vast majority of it in the process. Rising inequality should be proof enough for you that wealth concentration is happening.
- nickpp 5y agoNo, the greater society is actually enjoying the vast majority of value created by a business. You know, the people happily giving their money to the business in exchange for goods and services.
- ModernMech 5y agoWealth and value are different things. Value can be created without billionaires capturing most of the wealth.
- nickpp 5y ago
- goodpoint 5y agoNo, the whole promise of "trickle down" is that wealth is supposed to trickle down, as the name suggests. It does not work and increasing inequality is could be called "trickle up".
- ModernMech 5y agoThat's what you were told it's supposed to do. If it's not in fact doing that, then you have to ask yourself: who told you otherwise and why hasn't anyone fixed it? Also, who is incentivized not to fix it? You should be especially wary if the people who are incentivized not to fix it also have the power to fix it, and continually choose not to exercise it. Unfortunately in our system, the wealthiest people have the most power, and they are incentivized to maintain a system that makes them wealthier. The wealthier they get, the more power they have over the system. We only have to look back as far as the 2017 TCJA to see how this dynamic plays out in real time.
- jmcmichael 5y agoGovernment, at least in nation-states that are sovereign currency producers, does indeed have first dibs on what people earn. Income taxes are usually withdrawn from salaries before employees are paid, and in the case of independent contractors, business owners, and capital gains taxes, individuals are on the hook retroactively for taxes. The only perspective from which your statement makes sense is from the libertarian fantasy of government-as-parasite and individual-as-independent-producer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> [0] It may sound shocking but billionaires wouldn't be billionaires if they didn't spend less than they earn. Creating more billionaires or giving them more money is an effective way of decreasing demand and thus the potential for your economy to grow. You are saying that billionaires do more than consume; they save money. If we wish to be more specific, we could say that billionaires, by and large, invest money, billions of it, in enterprises which will make them more money. Economies don't grow from some abstract demand existing, they grow from production (of final goods and services). Investment in productive assets is the key to the economy's growth. Obviously some billionaires do more to be leeches than others, but that sort of enterprise seldom needs actual net investment. And obviously not all capital comes from billionaires, and not all billionaires deserve as much money as they have — but your premise here is quite backwards. A billionaire consuming all his wealth by building mansions, showy superyachts, private planes, and the like, is much worse for the economy than a typical billionaire investment, because the superyacht is not a productive asset, it is an extravagant waste.
- rezistik 5y agoEconomies grow because of growth of demand, not growth of production. Production grows in response to demand not the other way around.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoGross domestic product is a product, not a longing. You can demand all you like; if no one produces it, your economy does nothing. Production is driven by growth in demand because capitalists, realizing the demand exists, expand their production on the premise that they might earn more profit. In turn, capitalists also stop producing things that are not in demand, as this is unprofitable.
- majormajor 5y ago> Economies don't grow from some abstract demand existing, they grow from production (of final goods and services). Investment in productive assets is the key to the economy's growth. Production of something not in demand is a nonsensical way to try to grow an economy. Investment serves an economy by allowing production to happen to meet demand. It's not something we need to encourage particularly hard because it has a built-in profit motive. A billionaire spending all their money is an incentive for other people to invest in the production of those things being built, which is important because it creates income for the workers, which creates demand. Investing for the sake of investing in production otherwise is limited since if people aren't buying, less money is circulating, and less actual useful stuff (such as improvement in living standards) can happen as a result. But I suppose that pointless production (a lot of recent VC activity looks somewhat like this) is still better than a billionaire parking money in hedge funds or HFT shops that are just buying/selling stocks that represent past investment, instead of that money going to the productive enterprise itself.
- WalterBright 5y agoThis is another variation on the idea that the wealthy are hoarding cash. They aren't. All the cash is invested, one way or another. Even "cash" in a checking account isn't cash, the bank loans it out.
- Analemma_ 5y agoWhen people say “hoarding cash” we mean something a little more nuanced than literally stuffing it into a vault: just because the wealthy are investing, doesn’t mean it’s beneficial. The desperate search for any returns means tons of cash is getting plowed into things like real estate in expensive cities (which prices out more people) and startups like Wash.io that crash and burn because they have no market but in the process take down tons of small businesses with them which cannot bounce back because of the hysteresis involved. A lot of the “investing” done by the wealthy is at best useless if not actually a net negative to society, and a lot of that money would have more social benefit if it was middle- or working-class people spending on goods and services instead.
- WalterBright 5y ago> just because the wealthy are investing, doesn’t mean it’s beneficial. Investments flow to the most productive use of the money. Your hypothesis is that the most productive use is not the most beneficial. That's a pretty tough case to demonstrate. > is at best useless if not actually a net negative to society If people prefer to buy stuff from Amazon, how is that not of benefit to those people? As for real estate, there is only so much real estate in the cities. There is not enough for everyone. Who gets it? There has to be some distribution mechanism.
- triceratops 5y ago> Investments flow to the most productive use of the money. Investments flow to the highest-returning investment. Sometimes that's productive (new factories, infrastructure, research), but sometimes it's pure speculation (land, gold, crypto) or an active drain on health and productivity (patent trolls, telemarketing, tobacco).