3 ms·
Gender is not a spectrum (2016)
- aaaronic 5y agoCouldn't get past "which for simplicity we can call the radical feminist view," in the third paragraph. Truly cringe-worthy to read in today's context (at least the cultural context I live in).
- raxxorrax 5y agoI don't think there were severe barriers to self expression 15 years ago and I think we now have them with some form of gender orthodoxy, although it is far more pronounced on the net than in reality. But the contrast is pretty large. Don't know what should be considered "cringe".
- speeder 5y agoThe author is feminist herself, and seemly her views match with that. The raeson she used "radical feminist view" seemly is to separate it from current "mainstream feminism". Then she goes on and on explaining the logical errors of the current view, and reach the conclusion that the "radical" view is actually correct. I don't agree with her on that (I think she found the logical errors, and wrote a good article, but I disagree with her conclusion), but that is what she meant anyway. Also her target readers are feminist themselves, there is no need to anything there be cringeworthy, it is a feminist telling other feminists why one of their beliefs might be wrong.
- dvfjsdhgfv 5y ago> I would be happy with this implication, because despite possessing female biology and calling myself a woman, I do not consider myself a two-dimensional gender stereotype. I am not an ideal manifestation of the essence of womanhood, and so I am non-binary. Just like everybody else. However, those who describe themselves as non-binary are unlikely to be satisfied with this conclusion, as their identity as ‘non-binary person’ depends upon the existence of a much larger group of so-called binary ‘cisgender’ people, people who are incapable of being outside the arbitrary masculine/feminine genders dictated by society. I believe this is a generational phenomenon. Each generation of social activists needs to fight for something new, otherwise they wouldn't be progressive. Logically, the author is right: we're all non-binary, so the self-identification as non binary seems to make no sense. However, emotionally it is valid: it is the very recognition that one has various characteristics ascribed to both genders that makes one feel as non-binary. It's quite different from ordinary "cis" people who are non-binary without realizing that. I believe the older generation of feminists understands that, but is not willing to emotionally accept it as valid.