4 ms·
I am bad with money. I’m also not abnormal. A 2017 survey by CareerBuilder found that 78 percent of Americans live paycheck to paycheck, while a 2019 survey by
by WarOnPrivacy 5y ago
I am bad with money. I’m also not abnormal. A 2017 survey by CareerBuilder found that 78 percent of Americans live paycheck to paycheck, while a 2019 survey by Bankrate found that 60 percent of us couldn’t cover a $1,000 emergency.
For most in this predicament, it has nothing to do with being bad with money. It has everything to do with their income being 80% of their essential bills.
- Swizec 5y ago> but I can tell you that there were $60 rounds of drinks purchased without a second thought and $25 cab rides to the bars. There were $1,500 ski-season cabin shares in Lake Tahoe and a $150-a-month membership at Equinox. There were multiple Starbucks lattes per day and $18 organic steak salads eaten at my desk. I don't think this is someone who can't cover essential bills with their salary. This is the trap kids fall into (my early 20's self included) when they first start making real money and it feels endless. It's not endless. It's very easy to fritter away.
- saurik 5y agoWarOnPrivacy wasn't saying that this person was someone who wasn't making much money; they were replying to the rational for this not being "abnormal": most people who live paycheck-to-paycheck--not this person, but most people--simply don't make much money... they aren't "bad with it".
- lhorie 5y agoIt's interesting hearing others' experiences on this. Among my circles, my friends would sometimes comment on how weird it was to come to terms with the fact they were no longer dirt poor college students and how now they had disposable income and how guilty they'd feel spending money due to the frugal student mentality. To this day, I still don't feel the urge to buy things on impulse, or because peers have them or do trendy things.
- Swizec 5y agoWhen it happened to me I went from a lifetime of being poor (not just college student poor, family poor before college even) to making 3x the national median salary in the span of 2 years. Yeah it was a little intoxicating and I def overdid it. No regrets tho. Moving to America (sfba) quickly fixed that. Now I’m back to being pretty frugal (but not too much) and investing in asset building. Turns out that’s more rewarding. But your early to mid 20’s are a great time to go a little crazy if you can. It will never again feel the same. You have little responsibility and lots of time to catch up later.
- laurent92 5y agoAs a reasonably frugal person, it is very annoying that outdoorsy people set the standard for spending, and they make me look stingy. I’m not stingy. I’m sane. They’re the ones going bankrupt ;) 20 years later: They’re married with kids and I’m single. Perhaps I really looked stingy ;) Moral of the story: People in average are de facto pushed to consume all their margin.
- koilke 5y agoI know the feeling. I often prefer not to eat anywhere the costs are more than $10 and usually go for places around $5. I wish to retire in a few years and they in a few decades.
- roland35 5y agoI feel like there are diminishing returns past $15 for a meal. I love pad Thai and normally that runs about $12 which I will gladly pay :)
- theartfuldodger 5y agoIt would be very difficult to get a lunch or dinner for $15 that was of any reasonable quality in my region. I do not live in an absurdly high COL area (CNY) What can you possibly be eating for $5 I think some people can treat eating as more utilitarian, while having a great meal or even a halfway decent meal is a true pleasure and an experience worth having as often as possible for myself. The small pleasure is what makes the grind feel worthwhile. I fully expect to walk out $25-$30 lighter after a basic entree/lunch, a drink and a tip, even if eating alone on a lunch break. A date with my wife ( on the low end) $70, bring out the whole family ($100) Do we have significantly different average prices. Maybe a pre-made gas station sandwich or single fast food sandwich could cost $5 A $5 meal sounds like a chore, an amazing roadside Shack find! or absolute trash ingredients not worth eating. How do you do it?
- ahartmetz 5y agoIt can hardly be true that 78% of Americans can only afford food, shelter, usually a car (any car!) and perhaps health insurance. A hint is that they live paycheck to paycheck, i.e. the spending just "happens" to match the earning. Don't get me wrong, of course there are genuinely poor people. But not far over half of the population.
- IkmoIkmo 5y agoI agree that that's a major point. Still, I'm consistently utterly surprised by friends/family/colleagues with similar income but a very different predicament. I was raised on welfare myself and started out my early twenties with minimum wage jobs including factory work. Yet I always had savings, the idea that I couldn't cover a $1000 emergency would be insane to me, especially structurally. Did that mean I had to live with my parents longer than I'd have liked to? Yes. I also didn't have a car and took the bus. I had a cheap Android phone. Wore secondhand clothes. I rarely ate out, and in my first 25 years of my life I never, ever, just went somewhere to get a coffee. But I did have a home, transport, clothes, a smartphone, food and coffee, and also savings. I don't want to victim-blame, there's certainly many who're trapped in a predicament. And it certainly helped being young, healthy, flexible, without kids, there's an immeasurable privilege to that situation versus the contrary (old, sick, with dependents). But I also saw plenty who weren't trapped and spent a ton on a way too expensive lease car they didn't need. Or who always had the latest iphone, and also had a minimum wage job. Or who rented a place downtown, instead of 20 minutes commute for a 30% discount. Those are lifestyle choices, which is completely fine to make, but not unconditionally. Once you have an emergency fund and you prioritize the short term over the long-term, it's simple a personal preference. But if you have no emergency fund, or if you have long-term goals you want to meet, you need to manage it. I have lots of friends who don't even spend the 1 hour a week to make and monitor a very basic budget for example. I mean let's be frank, median household income is $64k in the US. It's about the richest in the world, especially if you exclude the tiny rich states that have a few million people like Luxembourg there's nothing to really rival it. The idea that <1 week of median household income is an emergency for 4 out of 5 households is statistically not in line with 'for most it's just their predicament, not related to lifestyle or financial planning or management'.
- kenward 5y agoMy experience is pretty similar to yours but I think what you need to try to understand is that everyone has a different level of what is an acceptable "minimal" lifestyle. For a lot of people, these are habits/behaviors that they grew up with as well. It's complicated. Lack of financial literacy is another problem that, I think, exacerbates the above.
- AuthorizedCust 5y agoDo people who consider themselves “outdoorsy” tend to pursue employment opportunities that pay less than their potential earnings, had they pursued employment that maximized the value of their skills? It’s like a “pursue your passion” dilemma. If your passion is whitewater rafting, employment in that field will pay differently than, say, many kinds of employment facilitated by a computer science degree. Same dilemma goes for clergy, who often have marketable and lucrative skills they leave behind to pursue their calling.
- boring_twenties 5y agoAnecdotally, I'd say it's very common. In fact I often meet people who have abandoned previously lucrative careers to work for peanuts, in exchange for more skiing. A friend of mine used to be an investment banker; currently a server at a bar. I myself gave up software development and delivered pizza for a couple of years (though I later ended up with a decent compromise.)
- war1025 5y ago> It has everything to do with their income being 80% of their essential bills. There is some truth to that, but there is also a fair amount of truth to the fact that a lot of people list things as "essential" that really aren't. For many it's a trade off of being poor or looking poor, and they would much rather be poor than look poor. Money isn't that different than dieting. It's a pretty simple equation. Money in >= money out => Broke. Money in < money out => Not broke. With dieting, yes exercise more, but for the love of God, stop eating so damn much. With money, yes get a better paying job, but for the love of God stop buying so much stupid shit.
- strken 5y agoSimplifying dieting down to calories in calories out is one of my pet peeves, because it doesn't give you any information about how to achieve those goals. People don't automatically understand satiation, binge eating, macro and micronutrients, shopping, cooking, the caloric density of restaurant and takeaway food, BMR, the relatively tiny amount of calories burnt by exercise, or calorie tracking. These things aren't obvious and they're buried under a lot of misinformation. The same goes for budgeting. Saying "spend less and get a better paying job" doesn't really help compared to detailed instructions on how to open a savings account and automatically deposit 5% of your pay into it, reviewing your monthly expenditure, changing habits like ordering delivery food every weekend, long term investments like buying your own washing machine, or pursuing a qualification that will help you earn more.
- war1025 5y agoI agree with everything you said. I guess the point I was trying to make is more that doing these things is not impossible. It is just a matter of being properly informed (which is in itself a difficult task).
- wwweston 5y agoThis insight is hard to beat for explaining power. I've found it pretty easy to save money almost on accident with a six figure income, even without keeping too close an eye on expenditures. Helps if you skip buying the luxury auto, don't pick the most expensive living quarters you can, keep eating out under $10-15/day, and if you can be lucky+conscientious enough not to have catastrophic healthcare expenses, but you don't even have to do all of that and you can save 20% and pay your taxes. It's certainly possible closer to the median, but the belt has to be tighter. Bottom third? Pinching pennies. Pick marginal housing. $25/week groceries. Turn down social invitations when your gas/transport budget's up. And saving for that $1000 emergency will still be slow. There's something in a part of some people's psychology that wants to imagine that if you're just disciplined enough you can make it all happen no matter what the constraints are. Discipline can make a difference, but not the same scale of difference that greater resource inflows do.
- saalweachter 5y ago> And saving for that $1000 emergency will still be slow. And worse, when you inevitably need to tap it, it will be equally slow to refill.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago... and worse still, probably not enough.
- mancerayder 5y ago> I am bad with money. I’m also not abnormal. Reading stuff like this makes me feel old. The - new generation? - who seem to always publicly remind themselves that they're good enough after all and just like everyone else and normal and it's hard for us ... and now don't get me wrong: these things can be true. But I grew up not standing on a soapbox and exclaiming these things, and not thinking or writing in that way. It's kind of a race to the bottom if everything is treated like you're an object and not a subject, as in, blowing around in the wind by objective forces that are external. There really is a mix of external and subjective forces at play, but we're reminded of the external with this style. I would have said, "I fucked up. I used to be bad with money. Now I do this: __ __ __. "Bad with money" implies an immovable predicament and "I'm not alone" implies systemic forces at play. Again, the focus on the absolute and removal of the subject. Yes, I'm extrapolating quite a bit from so little, it's just that this style of writing seems ubiquitous now.
- caterama 5y agoEvoking the sense that there are systematic forces at play is intentional! Who cares if _you're_ bad with money? It could be an edge case that doesn't matter. But if it's normal to be bad with money (i.e. there are a lot of people who are bad with money), that's a little more interesting -- something to pay attention to. Also, as someone on the younger side, this mentality is comforting. It's the comfort of existing within a school of fish. Despite unpredictable currents that act on you like an object, it's comforting to know that there are many of you. A few individuals disappear here and there, but chances are the school will survive. You're normal, you belong, things are hard, but you'll probably be fine.
- knrz 5y agoAs someone also on the younger side, I want to echo what you've said: I've also felt feelings of not belonging, things are hard, but you'll probably be fine. More like the GP, however, I've gotten there not through identification with others but instead through the cultivation of a spiritual life philosophy. Like GP, I also grow tired of hearing these voices too often. I have a little sister, who is 13 now, and she feels submitted to her fate. More often than not she feels like a candle in the wind (queue Elton John) instead of a captain at the helm. But you're right, it is something to pay attention to. These little instances all add up to be statistically relevant and a source of knowledge for collective social truth-finding. One thing I must insist on, philosophically, however, is that we are not often served by identifying with sub-par things. Personal identification is very useful for aspiring and evolving, but personal identification with the present or the past can unnecessarily keep you anchored to bad habits.
- derefr 5y agoIt might, if you consider "choosing to live in a high-cost-of-living area when you could have access to jobs with similar pay in lower-cost-of-living areas" to be "being bad at money." (Or, to go even more hard-line, if you consider "choosing to not go into trades, medical specialties, or other high-career-wage-growth-per-input-hour-of-education career paths, when you have no reason to believe you're uniquely suited to/talented at the high-barrier-to-entry career path you've chosen instead, and thereby not especially likely to end up making money at it" to be "being bad at money.")
- skybrian 5y agoIt may be true, but I don't believe this sort of article is aimed at people who are already doing everything they can. It's aimed at people who aren't, like their formerly-irresponsible selves. Who knows, maybe publishing it in Outside will reach someone?
- deregulateMed 5y ago80% of their Essential bills leaves a lot to be invested or saved. I'd disagree, it's money management at that point. I'm more concerned about those who are unprofitable every paycheck and growing debt, no way to cut expenses further. Probably due to high COL and lack of education, but I can't blame someone for living where they have family .
- boring_twenties 5y agoI think you may have misread the comment you're responding to. They're saying income is 80% of expenses, not the other way around. In other words, expenses are 125% of income, leaving a negative number to be invested or saved.