7 ms·
"Their system dynamics model published by the Club of Rome identified impending ‘limits to growth’ (LtG) that meant industrial civilization was on track to coll
by giantg2 5y ago
"Their system dynamics model published by the Club of Rome identified impending ‘limits to growth’ (LtG) that meant industrial civilization was on track to collapse sometime within the 21st century, due to overexploitation of planetary resources."
I'm sorry, but - No shit!
Of course there are growth and population limits, and we are close to them. Everyone talks about global warming, but few talk about population and consumption as the main driver for that. We like the narrative that we have the technology to face climate issues and future resource scarcity because it means we're not doomed.
We will either need unpalatable or forced lifestyle/societal changes or we will inevitably face these unwanted changes when consumption outpaces resources.
Oh and China is now suggesting 3 kids per couple will be to tolerated...
- ashtonkem 5y agoOver population is not an issue for two reasons. 1 - Birth rates are falling. We’re getting pretty damned close to the peak of human population. There are some very easy steps we can do to expedite this, such as helping reduce infant mortality rate among the global poor, a move that is known to reduce fertility rates too. 2 - Consumption is wildly uneven among the world’s population. Focusing on population implies that those areas with high fertility rates are the issue, when in fact the primary limiting factor is and will remain the high consumption rate of the world’s richest nations.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoPopulation momentum means population will peak at 11.2 billion people near the end of the century [1] before it declines. Total fertility rate drop isn't happening fast enough (need to get closer to 1 vs 2.1 replacement rate), and we've already locked in the expansion to 11.2 billion. 3 billion people can't afford to get enough nutrition [2]. That number will increase before it decreases. Consider we're already on the path to exceed our carbon budget [3], and billions of people are trying to climb out of poverty (which requires fossil fuels, resources, and food production, which we are already managing....poorly and unsustainably). Many countries still offer funds to people to have children and have pro-natalist policies (to goose economic policy and pay for elderly entitlements and stave off the economic contraction). We're not just headed off the cliff; we're pushing our foot on the gas. TLDR Those who consume the most will need to consume less, and even then there is likely not enough to go around for first world standards for all. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/future-population-growth https://ourworldindata.org/future-population-growth [2] https://ourworldindata.org/diet-affordability https://ourworldindata.org/diet-affordability [3] https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-how-much-carbon-budget-is-left-to-limit-global-warming-to-1-5c https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-how-much-carbon-budget-...
- ashtonkem 5y agoYes, there is work to be done. But I really really dislike the overpopulation and “tough decisions” narrative because: 1) It places the onus and blame on the people that are currently not the problem. 2) It implies that we must force people to have fewer kids, when evidence shows that women universally want to have fewer kids given the choice. We don’t need to coerce them, we need to help them.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoPhysical systems don't really care how distasteful ideas are. I don't mean to be rude, at all, but facts are life isn't fair. Climate systems don't sit around arguing over the equitability of development rights based on who emitted carbon when. Rich countries burned fossil fuels for 100+ years to develop. Does anyone think those countries are going to revert to much lower standards (somewhere between European and developing country standards) to give that same advantage to developing countries? Absolutely not. EDIT: I want to be very clear before my edit window expires; I do not believe anyone should be forced not to have kids (although I would be onboard paying folks who choose not to have kids a direct transfer payment, just as it's not taboo to pay people to have kids and many governments do it). But I also believe no one should have one or many kids if their socioeconomic circumstances don't allow for it. We should absolutely strive to empower and educate women, as you mention this causes a natural decline in fertility rates [1]. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#empowerment-of-women https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#empowerment-of-wom...
- fsloth 5y ago"But I also believe no one should have one or many kids if their economic circumstances don't allow for it." In EU area you can have as many children you like and the social safety nets will generally carry you trough caring for your child. I suggest you use some other means of argumentation than wealth of parents, as that is a non-issue here (mostly).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 5y agoYou assume that our current population is sustainable. Is it? We aren't living sustainable lives. Sure, this varies by country, but I believe this is globally true. We are expected to peak well beyond our current level. Estimates are about 10-11 billion - a 25%+ increase. A major problem with your infant mortality comment and consumption comment is that reducing infant mortality is also associated with modern lifestyles and an increase in consumption. Consumption patterns change as the mortality and fertility rates drop and economic opportunities increase. Our economies are built on consumerism and spending. We see this trend in developing nations today (you have to compare for various demographics, not just the country level).
- ashtonkem 5y agoIt’s not sustainable, and that has absolutely nothing to do with population count and everything to do with how we’ve structured our society. We could eliminate everyone but America and it still wouldn’t be sustainable, it would just take longer to tip over into disastrous global warming. It is literally impossible to make a society sustainable via birth rate alone, which is why I object to the argument vigorously. The only solution is to find a way to make our society and technology sustainable, rather than just hoping that birth control will fix it.
- giantg2 5y ago"It is literally impossible to make a society sustainable via birth rate alone, which is why I object to the argument vigorously." And who is making that argument? This isn't what I'm saying at all. "The only solution is to find a way to make our society and technology sustainable, rather than just hoping that birth control will fix it." I'm asking is our current global population level sustainable? It sounds like that's a no. There is at least point-in-time population limits to what our "sustainable" system can handle based on advances in technology and societal restrictions. I use quotes here because we do not have a sustainable system, and the number of people who can be sustainably supported is at least billions lower than we are at today given today's technology. It has to be a combinations of available sustainable tech/lifestyle and having a population that doesn't exceed the limits of sustainability.
- Aunche 5y agoI do agree with your overall point. That said, while an impoverished family with a dozen children isn't consuming much today, inevitably, they're going to consume a lot more as their nation gets wealthier, which is what's happening in Asia. As you alluded to, the solution is to develop these countries more quickly, so they'll no longer be incentives to have more children.
- giantg2 5y agoBut the birth rate isn't really the point. It's a proxy for consumption. As the nation gets wealthier, the per capita consumption goes up and generally creates a net increase in consumption.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThe point is that developing countries will increase their per capita consumption regardless. If birth rate decreases with level of consumption/gdp, you want to accelerate into it, thereby limiting the peak total consumption. For example, it would be better if Nigeria hit a European standard of living and stabilizes population sooner at say 400 million people. The alternative is they grow per capita consumption more slowly and hit an EU standard and stabilize later at 1 billion people.
- giantg2 5y ago"The point is that developing countries will increase their per capita consumption regardless. If birth rate decreases with level of consumption/gdp, you want to accelerate into it, thereby limiting the peak total consumption." Generally the accelerations coincide with one another. The only reason the population is increasing now is because some developments are being taken advantage of like food supply and medical care. It depends if sooner is better. Many times it's easier to implement new technologies from scratch rather than revamp old infrastructure. If we rush implementation, then it can just be a waste of resources (look at sewage treatment in many parts of Africa that modeled it after the US).
- themgt 5y agoThis only holds true if you are ok with areas with high birth rates and low consumption remaining poor and refusing to let them migrate to the rest of the world, which seems a hugely unlikely scenario in practice. It seems most likely that either these areas will develop economically and thus consumption will rise, or their skyrocketing populations and lack of development will cause rising internal tensions/crises and pressure to emigrate to the higher-consumption parts of the world. Most likely some of both. "Adding 2.5 billion poor people to the planet in 80 years won't be a problem because we'll ensure they stay impoverished and in their home countries" isn't really as palatable a solution to overpopulation as you make it sound.
- ashtonkem 5y agoYour point is true if and only if we cannot decouple standards of living and carbon emissions. Then again if that’s true then we are doomed; restricting the world’s poor from breeding or consuming would not be enough to save this planet, the global rich currently produces more than enough CO2 to damn us all. The only way to save our species is to find a way to decouple standards of living from carbon production. Anything else is insufficient and can only delay the inevitable at best.
- giantg2 5y ago"Your point is true if and only if we cannot decouple standards of living and carbon emissions." There are other concerns like food production, soil erosion, fish stocks, loss of biodiversity, etc. Its not just about CO2.
- goeiedaggoeie 5y agoI wonder once birthrates stabalise globally whether we will be back into a Malthusian economic cycle since we invest in sales and growth.
- Ygg2 5y ago> Oh and China is now suggesting 3 kids per couple will be to tolerated. To rephrase it a bit. China is now suggesting 27h for optimal Earth rotation. It's never going to happen. Their population is going downhill fast.
- viscanti 5y agoIt might not be feasible for China to get to 3 kids per couple, but it points out there's a natural tension between governments that want population growth for economic reasons and a need to reduce population growth (if there aren't major technological breakthroughs that reduce the pressure of overpopulations).
- ertian 5y agoYeah, largely as a result of their one-child policy, the cost of raising a child in China has gone through the roof. People poured everything into getting the very best for their child (and grandparents did the same). My definite impression is that most new couples in China are worrying about how they'll afford one child, not debating whether or not to have a third.
- giantg2 5y agoThis also seems to support the idea that as fertility tolerates drop, per capita resource consumption rises to meet a more modern lifestyle.
- glial 5y ago> few talk about population and consumption as the main driver for that. This seems like the elephant in the room to me. It's almost never discussed, at least in the US, but as you say, it's the driver for global warming, ecological devastation, and resource constraints of all kinds. Us humans love to talk about our ability to adapt to new environments, but our lack of willingness to plan long-term is highlighting that our adaptability is not universal. Edit: in before 'but what about the economic growth?': that's the point. Growth is not sustainable, at least when growth is related to resource utilization.
- inkblotuniverse 5y agoTechnological improvement is growth. That isn't intrinsically tied to increasing resource utilisation.
- aaron-santos 5y agoIt isn't entirely separate either. Often increases in efficiency direct increases in consumption. This observation was made by the English economist William Stanley Jevons and is known as Jevons paradox[1]. More recently, the economists Daniel Khazzoom, Leonard Brookes, and others have analyzed this relationship[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox [2] http://www.iaee.org/en/publications/ejarticle.aspx?id=1091 http://www.iaee.org/en/publications/ejarticle.aspx?id=1091
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt is a political non starter. US population growth is driven by immigration, not birth rates. Focusing on population reduction in other countries is politically toxic. It is too conceptually close to eugenics, genocide, and racial conflict. That said, the idea of reducing population growth still underpins efforts to improve the standard of living the third world, it just isn't branded as such.
- bmmayer1 5y agoI recommend reading about the Simon-Ehrlich wager of 1980[1] and also about Thomas Malthus[2]. Many very smart people have speculated many times in the past that major population-reduction strategies must be undertaken, and these doomsday predictions in terms of resource consumption have...almost always been wrong. In Paul Ehrlich's case, in 1968 he predicted that "millions of people will starve to death" in the 1970s due to population growth, and mass sterilization was needed to stop it. The reason why people keep outpacing our own resource constraints decade after decade is that humans, unlike bacteria or any other species you can model population growth after, can modify our own environment, along with the degree of our own resource usage. Which is all to say, that this statement has been proven demonstrably false more often in the past than it has been proven true: "We will either need unpalatable or forced lifestyle/societal changes or we will inevitably face these unwanted changes when consumption outpaces resources." [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon%E2%80%93Ehrlich_wager https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon%E2%80%93Ehrlich_wager [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Robert_Malthus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Robert_Malthus
- sjg007 5y agoGlobal warming and the heat domes killing crops will be a problem.
- convolvatron 5y agoMalthus wrote in 1798. maybe he was a little off. turn it around. there is a clearly a level of population and resource consumption where starvation sets in and consumption drops. you may personally believe that there is a lot of road left, but you seem to be asserting that it just never ends.
- cs702 5y agoYes, in essence all these dire forecasts are little more than fancy versions of Malthus's predictions, which assume that natural and other resources cannot be improved or increased as necessary by human ingenuity to support and promote societal well-being. Given how large the universe is, I'd bet there's a good chance that scientists, engineers, and enterprising people will find ways to make all these dire predictions wrong. Your comment should be at the top of the page, IMHO. (EDIT: I posted a comment referencing it; it's now at the top of the page.)
- seoaeu 5y ago> Of course there are growth and population limits, and we are close to them. This has been true for nearly all of human history. The thing about technology is that it changes what the limits are.
- Daishiman 5y agoAn exponential growth phenomenon is still limit by the basic laws of thermodynamics.
- giantg2 5y agoYes, and we don't know if the current population level is even sustainable. Just look at problems cause by our current technologies like fossil fuel based... everything (oil, gas, plastics, synthetic fertilizers, etc).
- blooalien 5y agoChanging limits does not eliminate them entirely, however. There are still limits, and those limits can still be exceeded.
- austincheney 5y ago> Of course there are growth and population limits, and we are close to them. No science agrees with this. All the models suggest there is a huge amount of land and resources available for a massive rise in population, but population models suggest humans will tap out at about 9 billion due to declining fertility just about everywhere except Nigeria. Because there is no alignment between resource production and population growth rates local effects continue to impose the greatest limitations just like with other animals. For example humans are really good at finding food. An efficient international network to distribute food further solves that problem, but if a population in a given locale exceeds the capacity of that local to distribute food people will starve despite food availability and human capabilities. If, as an economic aside, wolves hunt all the rabbits in a given location wolves will starve even if there are other food options and wolves can travel hundreds of miles. That is because a population density in a single location is invariably tied to the food capabilities of that location and changes take additional effort at expenses otherwise not necessary. When those wolves starve in the given locale that has no bearing on the world total wolf population, which is likely regular and stable. Humans have the same limitations due to population densities.
- giantg2 5y agoA lot higher than 9 billion https://www.un.org/en/global-issues/population https://www.un.org/en/global-issues/population "No science agrees with this" Sources? Using your wolves example, people can move to locations that are more developed and have the infrastructure for more food distribution. The main problem is that most people are so far removed from their food sources that they don't really think about whether there will be enough for their kids. You could have people starving to death, or something wolves dont have - global conflict.
- austincheney 5y agoAccording to your article 9 billion is still a safe estimate: The world population is projected to reach 8.5 billion in 2030, and to increase further to 9.7 billion in 2050 and 11.2 billion by 2100. As with any type of projection, there is a degree of uncertainty surrounding these latest population projections. These figures are based on the medium projection variant, which assumes a decline of fertility for countries where large families are still prevalent, as well as a slight increase of fertility in several countries with fewer than two children per woman on average. Survival prospects are also projected to improve in all countries.
- fsloth 5y ago"Oh and China is now suggesting 3 kids per couple will be to tolerated..." China came up with the same problem that all developed economies have come up against - low birthrate, and the all the economic baggage that comes with it. I find it unlikely the party could pump up birth rate just by dictate though.
- giantg2 5y agoThe problem is thinking of it as a problem. You can't have a sustainable system that requires birthrate (really a proxy for output and consumption) that increases infinitely.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt is absolutely a problem if population shrinks too fast. There is a threshold where the young literally can't feed care for the elderly.
- giantg2 5y agoAnd we are nowhere near shrinking too fast, especially since industrialization and automation provide the ability for a couple people to provide food/care for many.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoDepends on what you mean by we. This is a real concern in countries like Japan, China, and Korea. Less on the food side, and more on care and services side.
- mortenjorck 5y ago> Oh and China is now suggesting 3 kids per couple will be to tolerated... This phrasing, specifically "tolerated," implies a misunderstanding of the motivation behind the change in policy. The CCP is not "tolerating" up to three children per family; it is doing its usual ham-handed best to encourage it. China has blasted right through stage 3 (thanks to one-child) into stage 4 of the Demographic Transition Model, and is staring down the precipice of stage 5, where the likes of Japan already find themselves. If you're not familiar with the DTM: https://populationeducation.org/what-demographic-transition-model/ https://populationeducation.org/what-demographic-transition-...