18 ms·
Jeff Bezos’ Dystopian Legacy Goes Far Beyond Amazon
- nickff 5y agoThis seems to be an advertorial for a union; it is based on a report by UNI Global Union, and also authored by someone from there.
- arkitaip 5y agoYou know that decades of anti-union propaganda is still in effect when individuals are convinced that working together with other individuals and pooling their resources to improve their working conditions is a bad thing. Of course when companies do it - through trade associations or lobbying - it's seen as natural and necessary for their survival.
- krige 5y agoSpeaking from practice in a country where unions are a traditional thing, strong unions can and will screw over a workplace. It's usually about a show of power and abusing veto ability to stay in power until the place stagnates, loses competitive status and disintegrates.
- geewee 5y agoSpeaking from practice in a country where unions are also a traditional thing (Denmark), in fact so traditional our whole way of working and negotiating salary is based on it - I think strong unions are a wonderful thing that benefits the workers a lot.
- hjanssen 5y agoThere are several countries with strong unions and a tradition of unions taking part in company matters, a good example would be my place, Germany. I have never seen a union "screwing over" a company, but many times have I seen complains that the unions screwed the company over from people that directly or indirectly profit from weak or no unions.
- nickik 5y agoIts amazing how people endlessly talk about Germany but ignore all the other cases where Union are far less positive. How about we talk about how Venezuela Union bosses. How about the US car workers union being an endless pit of corruption. Switzerland is next to Germany, and has almost no union and there is not so much difference in overall standard of living and how workers are treated. The idea that Unions are this universal good and talking negative about them is simply being anti-worker pro-capitalist exploitation is a tiered talking point.
- dgb23 5y agoIn Switzerland many professions have a GAV (initiated by unions) with strong worker protection.
- jorvi 5y agoAFAIK, Denmark doesn't even have a minimum wage, it's just that pretty much every sector and niche of the economy has unions so it is de facto enforced via union <-> sector negotiations. Unions are great, and people who are against them fall in one of three categories: - business owner - absolute free market fetishists - one bad experience cherry pickers
- krige 5y agoMy current workplace is one such case of union killing a theoretically profitable company so I really am speaking from experience - the only reason the workplace still exists today is because after it went bankrupt it was bought out by an outsider who discarded the union part. Ironically it turned out to be for the best for both the company as a whole and the actual workers. Just because you don't hear of it - or don't want to hear of it - doesn't mean it doesn't happen.
- samsari 5y agoJust because you saw it is no reason to state that unions will become bad actors.
- nosianu 5y agoSpeaking from practice in a country where unions were strong for many decades, the German economy was doing pretty well all the time and if Germany loses out at some point it is hardly the union's fault (for example, the pressure to remain such a high net exporter seems hard to maintain forever). What kind of reasoning is it to look for one or a few examples of individuals screwing up and then claiming it as a property of the species? I think we found more than one criminal company or CEO, but you would not use that as an example for how useless or even bad companies and CEOs are. I would also have preferred that OP instead of pointing to the name of the source (and nothing else!) would at least have added something about the actual content of the linked article. It seems to me to be rarely justified to argue by just pointing at the source of the argument as if that is a counter argument to the actual argument that was made (which at that point remains unexplored and unknown, implying it's not even worth looking at it - but it was still worth formulating a comment?).
- dgb23 5y agoUnions have no general and inherent self-defense against corruption, so the larger, more powerful and more hierarchical they become, the more these kinds of problems can (and will) arise. Similar things can happen to worker coops, foundations and other organizations that emerge from the need of having a counterbalance to corrupted institutions and corporations. The only solution is to maintain and expand democratic decision making from within. An organization that claims to be about the people, its members, absolutely has to be run by those people directly.
- pydry 5y agoIt's interesting that when this topic rears its head a common attitude comes out (although is never outright stated): * Governments are frequently corrupt and when they are they should be reformed. * Businesses are frequently corrupt and when they are they should be reformed. * Unions are frequently corrupt. They should therefore not exist. Realistically corruption is a feature of all human institutions. Unions are special only insofar as they are institutions that threaten rather than defend the wealth of the American ruling classes.
- austhrow743 5y agoYou can't realistically abolish your government. Or at the least stop being governed by one. Other internal organisations will take its place or a foreign government will gobble you up. You can't realistically abolish businesses. An economy of just individual tradesmen all working independently cant come close to the efficiency gains a large business has and just straight up lack the capacity for large scale projects and R&D. It's going to lead to the same outcome as your government being abolished and then businesses being reinstated. Listed alongside the other two, the special thing about unions is they don't have this "you just straight up cant get rid of them and keep them gone" factor. So I think its completely reasonable for a person very concerned with corruption to take reform, reform, get rid of them stances respectively. Remove the institutions you can and fight corruption in the ones you cant.
- pydry 5y agoYou can abolish government. The results arent pleasant (see 90s mogadishu) but you can. This is the goal of so called "ancaps". It's great if you enjoy being a warlord. You can abolish businesses too. The 2nd largest economy from 1950-1970 did precisely that, TINA propaganda notwithstanding. Chinese SOEs also serve as a model for a business that isnt really a business. It's great if you're on the central committee. You can abolish unions as well. The results also arent exactly pleasant for the 90% of people who rely on selling their labor to survive. But it's fucking great for that top 10% if they dont exist.
- lapinot 5y agoBad unions are bad and the sky is blue. It should be pretty self-explanatory that nobody is gonna defend unions which "screw over the workplace", it's a straw-man. But some people still defend unions.. so, a more honest question would be: what do they think is a good union then? What should a union strive to do? What are the critics they agree with?
- jseban 5y agoThe people who are happy with the union will be people who are underperforming and/or belong to the mainstream majority of the people in the workplace. Just like always, the majority will benefit at the expense of the minority, so it will never be good for everyone, and push for conformity and restricting people's freedom, and in the end will probably be mostly arbitrary depending on what the majority in that workplace happens to be (mostly younger, singles, or older with kids etc). And even such general things such as negotiating pay will only be good for the lower performers, anyone who is a high performer will be better off negotiating their own salary.
- jseban 5y agoThis is exactly what happened in the recession in the 70s in Europe which caused a crisis in the industry in for example Sweden, and the reason why Thatcher had to push through the unpopular neoliberal reforms in the UK. Unions caused stagnation and the industry could not compete with the recovering global competition, from Japan etc.
- beigeoak 5y agoBut Amazon's motto is "Work hard. Have fun. Make history". Why are you against them having fun?
- sk4rekr0w 5y agoI find that most propaganda comes from unions as they increasingly seek a political relationship with workers rather than the economic relationship that workers want. On any union site - there are terms like "solidarity" with images of fists raised rather than actual data about improvement of wages or working conditions. This is why unions get trounced in votes by real workers, things like Prop 22 pass with easy margins, etc.
- skohan 5y ago> This is why unions get trounced in votes by real workers, things like Prop 22 pass with easy margins, etc. I think it also has to do with the massive discrepancy in resources pro and anti-union advocates are able to put towards those races. Uber and Lyft invested massively in defeating prop 22, even advertising in their app directly.
- sk4rekr0w 5y agoWhile I don't like the economic resource discrepancy in that case, there was mutually dirty fighting.. the ballot language on Prop 22 by the AG was what I would consider literal propaganda. What they lack in economic resources, they make up for in political power via bureaucratic control.
- skohan 5y agoI don't know how anyone could seriously hold the position that labor and corporate interests are on equal footing in any way. The history of the last 40 years in US labor relations has been a very consistent trend towards the consolidation of corporate power, alongside the erosion of labor's power.
- sk4rekr0w 5y agoSo 2 things: 1) I do not believe they are in equal footing generally and never stated that - I was pointing out the nuances with respect to Prop 22. Gig cos. didn't win just because they had more money - they won because AB5 is a despised policy. 2) Unions != Labor. Workers == Labor. This is the key point I'm trying to make.
- arcturus17 5y agoDecades of anti-union propaganda, sure, but also decades of self-serving, power-hungry, and occasionally outright corrupt organizations that do not serve the interests of workers. Workers are not dumb, do not lack agency nor are as influenceable by propaganda as one might think - this a myth perpetuated by the paternalistic left, which has actually served it terribly - and in many cases have freely chosen to ignore or root out these organizations.
- pydry 5y ago>nor are as influenceable by propaganda as one might think People don't notice the propaganda that works on them. Indeed, many go as far as to unknowingly make it part of their identity. People only notice the propaganda that doesn't work on them. >paternalistic left Realistically there is no organized left left - paternalistic or otherwise. There are two competing corporate factions, each as paternalistic as the other.
- Akronymus 5y ago>Decades of anti-union propaganda, sure, but also decades of self-serving, power-hungry, and occasionally outright corrupt organizations that do not serve the interests of workers. in the USA unions are pretty shit IMO. Over here in austria, they bargain for ALL workers in that field. And that bargaining sets a minimum per law, which means that no matter if you are union or not, you can still bargain yourself into a better deal.
- janpot 5y ago> decades of self-serving, power-hungry, and occasionally outright corrupt organizations that do not serve the interests of workers. Are you talking about unions, or companies?
- WalterBright 5y agoI'd agree with you if joining the union is voluntary. But it isn't. It's determined by a vote, which is not the same thing as individual choice. It's also not voluntary when there's a law that says one cannot work in a particular profession without joining the union.
- dgb23 5y agoThe overarching theme goes wider. For one it is about workers having some say in their lives outside of voting with their feet. Collective bargaining is one proven way to achieve that. The other is about the dehumanization of work environments with the help of "AI" AKA software. Similarly there are companies that force you to install spyware on your working device.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> force you to install spyware on your working device. If it’s their device, what’s wrong with that? Use your own device when you want privacy.
- dgb23 5y agoThere are many problems with that. For one there are security issues. There was an article just recently on HN that reported a large attack, exploiting the invasive nature of these tools. Secondly they are useless. Third, they are inhumane and show that there is a severe lack of human connection trust in these work environments. Also, it is not strictly "their" device in every case. There are firms that require freelancers/contractors to do the same on their device. This kind of behavior is a huge red flag, but too many juniors otherwise naive or desperate workers tolerate it.
- x4e 5y agoWhich network do you connect it to? Do you connect it to your home network which all your other devices are connected to and through which all your internet traffic is sent? Do you use it in your house? Does it then record everything it can see and hear within your house?
- deleted-account 5y agoFuck you scab
- Tistron 5y agoReading articles like this makes me appreciate living in the EU. It's not always great, but clearly it could be worse. Article 1 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights states "Human dignity is inviolable. It must be respected and protected." I feel like that would be broken were we to allow this behaviour towards workers.
- Hobli 5y agoThe EU like Bezos didnt care about it much while their empires expanded. The "enlightenment" happened only after their arms race to colonize the planet ended in world wars. Learning takes time. Emporer Bezos is thankfully a tad smarter than the Kings and Queens of the EU and his road to "enlightenment" will be much shorter with less devastation and trauma. I just hope, after they learn their lessons, the Amazon corporate robots will be less sanctimonious than present day Europeans.
- brainless 5y agoAs much as I agree with you, this should only give us more reasons to not let this happen. And more importantly people like Bezos should not be made idols. People should vocally complain what is wrong with this like many colonial nations complain (and I wholeheartedly support that). But I agree, learning takes time.
- ben_w 5y agoThe EU did not exist when the member states were expanding their empires. The UK joined the predecessor to the EU as a result of losing much of its empire. Indeed, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the European Convention of Human Rights both happened in the gap between WW2 and the Treaty of Rome. Though all this is a somewhat of an apples-to-vodka comparison, given the monarchs in Europe who are the same age as Bezos (e.g. Felipe VI) have a fairly different power dynamic than the founder, executive chairman, and 10% owner of a conglomerate valued at a trillion dollars even in those cases where they’re still getting their faces on all the money (Felipe doesn’t). This is all tangential to how well the article characterises the working environment at Amazon — Gell-Mann applies at the best of times, and Big Tech is big enough for capital-P-Politics to be important, but likewise none of that makes it wrong, and if it’s right, Amazon has no excuse for repeating well-trodden mistakes.
- aviraldg 5y agoLink should be updated to https://progressive.international/wire/2021-07-09-bezos-dystopian-legacy-goes-far-beyond-amazon/en https://progressive.international/wire/2021-07-09-bezos-dyst... (The current article mentions that is where it was originally published)
- MattGaiser 5y agoIsn't Amazon's fear of running out of people a sign of the market correcting this?
- shmageggy 5y agoThey're in no danger of running out of people to employ. Social safety nets are too weak and economic conditions for the poor are too precarious that there are plenty of people willing to endure abusive conditions for a paycheck. The high turnover rate only ensures that they end up employing the most desperate and vulnerable.
- tdsamardzhiev 5y agoNot if the alternative to working for Amazon is, well, death by starvation. People say communism falls apart once subjects stop having reasonably similar goals. Market economy is certainly more resistant to this, but is it infinitely more resistant? How far can we push inequality before that becomes an issue? Edit: That was meant as a response to the parent comment.
- RalfWausE 5y agoA radical thought: If i have the alternative to work for an dystopian megacorp or starve to death... why then not choose the third option: Go to jail while causing as much damage as possible? (Disclaimer: Only a philosophical thought)
- mbrodersen 5y agoBecause your actions will then give mega corps and the governments they control a reason to reduce your freedom even more.
- southerntofu 5y agoWell you don't need a Joker-style nihilistic attitude to cause as much damage as possible to everyone without distinction. This can also be achieved in a meaningful way following the workers tradition of sabotage and direct action. Hurt or destroy those people/structures making our lives hell. That makes sense. Just don't drag random people into it.
- antattack 5y agoDystopia is an imagined state, whereas Amazon's doing is quite real and tangible.
- peter_retief 5y ago"The billionaire who built a corporate empire on the backs of workers." Should read "The man who generated wealth and jobs".
- elevenoh 5y agoI think your should read is more accurate. I do wish it weren't within a more pure/honest & a less broken capitalism (i.e. insider-hegemony) model.
- peter_retief 5y agoSadly people have no idea just how bad things are without jobs and wealth. There is the possibility that spite and jealosy drive this criticism.
- galoisgirl 5y agoHe generated it all by himself without any involvement of the workers?
- qolop 5y agoYou can generate wealth AND have humane conditions for workers.
- fxtentacle 5y agoReading this, I'm so glad that in all of the EU it is illegal to fire someone purely based on a software decision. There's a minimum level of humanity that we should extend to everyone. Letting a known faulty AI decide if someone will have money for food tomorrow is way across the line. I'm not surprised that treating humans like cattle on their way to slaughter is hugely profitable. But I'm not sure we want to operate large companies like WW2 prisoner camps. Even if you truly don't care about the poor souls who have to work there, the people who turn insane from this treatment will still live in your country and maybe their kids will meet your kids in school and "educate" them on the cruelty of life. It's best not to push anyone down the mental abyss in the first place. And yet, here we (software developers) are, developing new monitoring and automation systems and deciding to delete someone's entire online life (Google account) without any oversight (AI) in the name of "efficiency" (higher profits for shareholders that we never met and never will).
- golergka 5y ago> Reading this, I'm so glad that in all of the EU it is illegal to fire someone purely based on a software decision. Why do people treat working for a company as something different from selling any other services or goods? If there was a law that limited your ability to cancel a gym membership or going to a different supermarket, you would rightfully object — it's not a government's business to get involved in your voluntary business transactions. Why treat a company that hires workers differently?
- kleiba 5y agoYour limited ability to cancel a gym membership is an important part of any gym's business model, at least where I live: it bets on people's impulse decision (say, at the beginning of a new year) to get in shape, a desire which often tapers off after a few weeks or months. But if your gym contract has a minimum duration of, say, two years, whether you go there or not, you pay.
- kleiba 5y agoThe way it is commonly seen is that workers deserve special protection through the law to make up for the inherent power imbalance between those who employ and those who are employed.
- nexus_dave 5y agoI never understood these communist type articles. If you don't like Amazon or what they are doing to their workers, don't shop on Amazon. If you think working for Amazon is bad, don't work for Amazon. If you want to live in a communist society, go and live in Venezuela or Cuba.
- southerntofu 5y ago"If you don't like what Hitler is doing, just ignore he's murdering millions of people". No thanks, i'd rather organize to have this guy killed to restore just a tiny little bit of justice on earth. You obviously have a very privileged position where you don't NEED TO work for Amazon. Lots of people are in a different position and i hope you appreciate that. Also, you obviously have no idea about the rich history of communism. Cuba and Venezuela can hardly be described as communist ; i'll refer to Emma Goldman on describing what is or isn't communism beyond the labels: https://infokiosques.net/IMG/pdf/there_is_no_communism_in_russia-pageparpage.pdf https://infokiosques.net/IMG/pdf/there_is_no_communism_in_ru...
- kortilla 5y agoNo true Scotsman
- southerntofu 5y agoIf you read the ideologies of those "communist" countries, they'll tell you communism is a stateless/classless society based on freedom as it was envisioned by Marx. I'm not using a personal definition to say they're not communist, i'm using their own. According to their vocabulary, such states are dictatorships of the proletariat, which is supposedly a step towards communism, but is NOT communism.
- jseban 5y agoSo how many large scale experiments with communism have we had during the last 100 years, and how many of them have ended in success? It's starting to get pretty ridiculous to argue against that kind of body of evidence. I have full respect for anyone trying to question and improve our society and economic system, but to just wind back the clock to 1968, pretend like nothing happened and start ranting about communism? Sorry, that's just a bit too much
- heurisko 5y agoI am a fan of Amazon's digital products and devices (the Kindle e-reader, Fire TV), but have noticed I buy fewer and fewer physical products from Amazon. This is in part, because of ideological reasons, but also because other online shops offer a better service than Amazon, and are also reasonably priced. In particular, I dislike that it seems to me more and more products are sold by third party sellers. I don't mind paying a bit extra from a retailer with a good reputation in my own country. I don't want to have to deal with a seller who is based in the other side of the world. Recently I made a large order of cycling gear from a specialist shop. I couldn't imagine buying it from Amazon, as I would be concerned some would be counterfeit, or only be available if it came from about 5 different sellers, all dispatching at different times.
- turbinerneiter 5y agoI think Stripe is disturbing Amazon. I used to order a lot of stuff from Amazon, because it was very convenient. Now it's a mess of 3rd party resellers, when I search an item I drown in indistinguishable copies of copies. In the other hand, there is small online shops or companies who have their own shops and sell directly. These sites just look better and you buy a specific brand or product. Stripe (and similar providers and other developments) made ordering from random Webshops as convenient to me than going to Amazon. It's like going to Apple, Bose, Levi's store instead of Walmart.
- o8r3oFTZPE 5y agoI remember reading stories in the late 90's/early 00's of workers in the Amazon warehouse becoming millionaires thanks to stock options and big jumps in the stock price. It sounds like that does not happen anymore except for employees in the offices. Perhaps employees in the offices know recognise that Amazon has overstepped its bounds but stick around waiting for vesting and/or (smaller) increases in stock price.
- menzoic 5y agoMassive success is rare and being there early is even more rare. It still happens. An artist who painted murals for Facebook's office got paid in shares that were worth $200M after IPO. Any current employees have no expectation in similar stock gains any time soon, that kind of explosive growth happens before IPO.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whitepaint 5y agoI've read similar articles so many times but they all lack one thing - solutions. Seriously, what should we do about it? Yeah, I agree that workers shouldn't be working so hard that they can't even go to the bathroom. Would we have a better world if Amazon didn't exist? I personally doubt it. So, it's not Amazon per se, it is the system, isn't? So, what are the solutions? How do we make it better? How do we minimize the suffering of these people? Or is it actually working pretty well and we should accept that some people will struggle badly no matter what the system is?
- lazyjones 5y ago> How do we make it better? You could, for example, offer these workers better jobs. Can you?
- whitepaint 5y agoWho should? And why should they (what incentives they'd have to do it)?
- ganzuul 5y ago> Seriously, what should we do about it? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worker_cooperative https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worker_cooperative Perhaps one can replace the legal contracts involved in this with algorithms to achieve the necessary scale.
- whitepaint 5y agoSo, make it a law that if you hire a person they'd have a stake in a company automatically? No one is stopping anyone to create worker cooperatives.
- solveit 5y agoIndeed. Worker cooperatives don't often take off because they're a bad idea. A company going under can be devastating for your career. If you have a significant stake in your company, you'll be broke as well as unemployed. People should diversify whenever they can and forcing people to hold a stake in their companies is a terrible idea.
- gouda-gouda 5y agoIf you consider America to be a corporatocracy, it’s hard not to consider it to be an authoritarian state at this point. The company I work at recently had everyone install some advanced monitoring software on every company’s laptop. Being fully remote, this effectively gives root access to someone in my home 8 hours a day. Sure, it’s a “company laptop” and all of that, but something feels extremely invasive about it and I don’t like it one bit.
- mbrodersen 5y agoI think there is a great business opportunity there: software that fool surveillance software.
- 55555 5y ago> Workers are voting with their feet. Turnover is high at both Teleperformance, the largest call centre employer (around 80% annually) and Amazon, 150%. This is... a mistake. What did they mean by this?
- hmhhcycbtsc557 5y agoI take it to mean that if you employ an average of 10 workers, each year 15 instances will have happened of a worker quitting and being replaced.
- saalweachter 5y agoOr phrased another way, employees stay for an average of 8 months at Amazon, 15 months at Teleperformance.
- eric4smith 5y agoWow… a guy that directly employed almost 2 million people and indirectly improved the lives of tens of millions of dependents in the Amazon ecosystem is a dystopian person. Bezos is far from perfect, but do we really think that that was his primary consideration of building and growing Amazon? Pretty much every organization that gets large enough tends to rot from the inside and get dystopian, despite the efforts of the founders. Anyone remember “don’t be evil”? Right. Maybe, just maybe, he resigned because he couldn’t deal with the dystopian aspects of how Amazon grew. My point is that it’s not a good idea to put the fact that a huge organization becomes “dystopian” at the feet of its founder.
- fukmbas 5y agoBezos is probably the worst billionaire ever
- epakai 5y agoBezos was well aware and a part of this growth. He was there personally when the company I worked for was acquired. He offered a silly anecdote about a breakfast octopus to the then CEO. In some ways the company has lived on past the CEOs desires to maintain it, but it's also not the same place. It's effectively turned into a way to push overstocked amazon wares. What was a big push to bring temporary employees on full-time 2 years prior has probably been disassembled for Amazon style hiring. After I left a enclosed cage and turnstile was added to the warehouse employee entrance (probably loss prevention, not totally unneeded, but who wants to feel like a prisoner at their job).
- contravariant 5y agoIs it really that unfair to blame the guy who profited most from it? If as you say increasing the size of an organization inevitably leads to a dystopian behemoth shouldn't we condemn people who do exactly that to grow their wealth?
- schwa_wedge 5y agoThese programs are weapons of literal war. They exist to deprive people of income while enriching people who don’t need the wealth and shouldn’t have it (because they turn it into power which they use for further ill). It’s amazing to me how many software engineers claim to be taking a moral stand by refusing to work for defense contractors, yet are willing to write these surveillance and “optimization” (worker squeezing) programs that give more power to employers… which is just as bad if not worse. The US government at least does a mix of good and evil things, whereas profit-motivated employers are clearly out for one side.
- hownottowrite 5y agoNobody in their right mind would want to employ humans in a megacorp machine like Amazon. The goal isn’t to mistreat humans or even to provide them with jobs. The goal is to gather data, build models, and replace the human components over time.