3 ms·
Does anyone have experience using this to sync between a Windows PC and a Mac? I've tried using OneDrive and it's pretty bad. I basically keep it disabled unti
by karmakaze 5y ago
Does anyone have experience using this to sync between a Windows PC and a Mac?
I've tried using OneDrive and it's pretty bad. I basically keep it disabled until I remember, "hey I haven't synced in a while, turn it on until complete, then turn off again."
- yepthatsreality 5y agoNo but you may want to try rclone. Not exactly lightweight but it’s very easy to use and configure with a variety of storage services.
- karmakaze 5y agoThanks, this is the only answer that seems to understand what I want. Most of the other comments say sync != backup, but depending on your (or my) use case either could work just fine. rsync is good enough for me so rclone may be too. Hopefully I don't run into any OS/filesystem difference problems, e.g. case-insensitivity, special chars, or path lengths.
- yepthatsreality 5y agoFYI, rclone is built on top of rsync. So you’ll have a good understanding of how it works underneath. Think of it as rsync + remote storage and service mounting tool. The nicest part about rclone IMO, is the plethora of services it can mount, so if you have compatibility issues (which you shouldn’t) then you could choose another service.
- 1123581321 5y agoThis Backblaze product doesn’t sync between computers. Their B2 storage can, but you need a client for it that can automatically work with S3-compatible storage. I use Arq but free options exist.
- spoonjim 5y agoSync and backup are different things. Dropbox is the best at sync but would get very costly for large backups. Backblaze is the best for disaster recovery backup.
- crazygringo 5y agoIt's backup, not sync. Your basic consumer choices for cloud-based sync are OneDrive, Google Drive, or DropBox. I prefer Google Drive now that I can keep all my files in the cloud and download/cache on demand, rather than keep it synced -- this way I get a usable 2TB disk rather than being limited to my laptop's 256GB storage. Google announced a new unified app yesterday actually: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/07/new-google-drive-app-unifies-business-and-home-use-cases/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/07/new-google-drive-app...
- interestica 5y agoDoes HN have something against Mega? It seems like it would fall more in line. It even has a CLI.
- karmakaze 5y agoI don't actually need/want any sort of sync integration. I do however want a remote copy of only current local files, which is a kind of sync. Then be able to make a local copy of the current remote files in a device/directory of my choice. A command-line tool to start the sync operation is fine, especially if it can run incrementally/resume.
- crazygringo 5y agoI'm curious, can you clarify? What do you mean by "current" in "only current local files" and "current remote files"? What does it mean to want a remote copy of only current local files, as opposed to all local files?
- karmakaze 5y ago'current local files' are the files that are currently on the machine I'm using right now. 'current remote files' are the files that the cloud storage has from the last sync operation with any computer. When I perform a sync between a computer I'm on and cloud storage, any new remote files (since last sync on this computer) are copied down, any files deleted locally are deleted remotely, newer local files copied up. I think I can script this with rclone (if it's anything like rsync).
- Symbiote 5y agoI've used Syncthing to sync between Mac, Linux and Android. They have a Windows client. It's not the most intuitive software to set up, especially on mobile where there are confusing filesystem restrictions from the OS, but once set up seems to work nicely. I don't use the versioning / read-only features, so I don't know how well it performs for sort-of-backup purposes.
- stavros 5y agoSyncthing has worked for years for me without a single hitch.
- karmakaze 5y agoThis looks interesting, but I was interested in each computer doing a sync with cloud storage. I realize that's not well-defined, but even keeping the more recently updated version in any sync session is ok with me. The thing I wanted is that I only use one computer at a time and don't leave the others on so doing direct pc <-> mac sync is less convenient, compared to run a sync on whichever machine I'm using at the time. Should I just be getting some cloud VM that backs up its storage and use rsync/ssh?
- Symbiote 5y agoIf there's always at least one computer switched on (which be a rented VM, or even a phone if that's enough storage) then Syncthing could work. I haven't tried making many edits from different places with lots of time offline though — mostly, I use it to sync photos I take on my phone to my computers and vice-versa for DSLR pictures, and music etc from the computers to my phone. Files generally sync within a few seconds. rclone is the cloud equivalent of rsync, it syncs to S3, GCS etc. But you'd have to set up the "latest version" part yourself (--update?) and something to make the synchronization happen after changes (inotify on Linux?).
- Spooky23 5y agoOneDrive and Google Drive are similar and fail in similar ways, I think because they look at files and not blocks. A lot of the goofy OneDrive gotchas have been resolved, but I don’t trust it for backup. Dropbox is king of sync, especially if you are on the same LAN as it syncs locally. That said, Dropbox has a long-term strategy of alienating their customers through annoying upsell and doing weird stuff with clients. Personally, I went the old school route and setup a file server. I bought a surplus HP Thin Client on EBay and stuck a big SSD in it… it’s a silent, low power device that I can backup with standard Unix tools. I think the device was $50 and the drive $189 on Black Friday.
- karmakaze 5y agoWoah, it occurs to me that I've cloud-blinded myself. Do I really, really need offsite backup? If not having an always on third machine really does do the job, especially if I can get remote access set up for it. I kinda don't want to handle the physical media though. It works well short term, but for longer time frames I can't be trusted. I have misplaced/erased/reused/damaged so many devices. It's also a pain to keep up with the upgrading/updating of the various interfaces the devices use.
- Spooky23 5y agoYou don’t need to be dogmatic about it! You can have a little file server, and have it backup to something like backblaze, aws, rsync.net, and just focus on the backup aspect.
- vxNsr 5y agoif you want protection from a ransomware attack you absolutely want a cloud backup, or you need to setup a cloud-like backup solution, where the "local" server is somehow airgapped from your local network and uses a different set of credentials, and none of your local-net pc's have access to it, except to write new files.
- Isthatablackgsd 5y agoIf you using OneDrive as a backup, it is not designed for that. You need to use the service that are specialized for backups which BackBlaze is the right product for it. OneDrive is mainly a online storage/vault with syncing capabilities. If you have a thousands of file to backup to OneDrive, you will have a problem since OneDrive need to upload everything that you want to backup to. Imagine 500,000 files that OneDrive have to upload for the backup, that will take a while. Their upload speed is not that great which is why they are not designed for backup.
- karmakaze 5y agoMy specific case is keeping a cloud copy of my audio media, in the order of 30 to 80 GB and most files do not change with metadata in auxiliary files. I started the initial upload and went to bed--it may have taken a few hours. Either sync or backup would be fine as long as unchanged files are not transferred. Automatic or manually (or scheduled) tasks are fine too.