9 ms·
Those who know science are less likely to accept it if it’s controversial (2017)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- murgindrag 5y ago.... or the next best explanation: - If I know nothing, I'm likely to defer to authority - If I know a little, I know enough to at least distrust questionable authorities The declining trust makes sense, with the replication crisis, grandstanding, intentional p-hunting, and all the other stuff happening today. I've been affiliated with an elite school for most of my life -- more weakly in recent years, and it just feels sleazy at this point. These things have gone from accidentally wrong results to games to win academia points (high impact factor publications, etc.) and get jobs and prestige. The political split makes sense too. Trust in authority goes, in part, with representation. Conservatives are not welcome on elite university campuses. It's not just conservatives; other groups (like African Americans and some, although not many, immigrant groups) who have been excluded have historically had a hard time trusting those establishments. I'm from an ethnic group about a fifth of whom were killed based in part on eugenics research at Harvard. Thanks Harvard! That was in my parents' time, so the distrust from that has faded, but it at least give empathy for why skepticism is reasonable. I think one of the things I find painful in reading an article like this one is how self-centered it is. It comes off as "Why don't they trust us?" with two presumptions: - everything we believe is true - so there's something wrong with them and not with us If that were true, eugenics wouldn't have happened. The scientific establishment is just as susceptible to politics, biases, and everything else as any other establishment. I think it did pretty well around 1950-2000. Sometime in the nineties or early 00's, a gradual decline started, which is now a freefall. Distrust in things like climate change and vaccines are very dangerous consequences of that. However, it takes a very high level of scientific literacy to sort truth from fiction in a post-truth era. It's undermined by a history of very intentional dishonesty in both of those domains too. Throughout COVID19, the scientific establishment often exaggerated -- now obviously (see: masks) -- to bring about the behavior it wanted. Why would people believe them about vaccines? And climate change predictions had (knowingly) exaggerated timelines and impacts in the eighties and nineties, which are now being cited as reasons for distrust. It's the boy who cried wolf. Climate change is real, but if you have a history of lying about it, some people won't believe you. I don't see this changing without fundamentally realigning incentives in academia.
- speeder 5y agoTo add to that there is also outright commercial corruption too. For example a lot of governments made policy based on nutrition research on the US that later was found out to be fraudulent and corrupt, it caused a great damage to nutrition research, a lot of it is deeply distrusted now even when it is correct, and millions of people worldwide have bad diets based off this literally evil corrupt research that been destroying lives, sometimes literally killing people as they eat awful stuff thinking it is good for them. I was almost a victim of that too (when I was teenager, around 16, my Chrolesterol spiked to emergency levels, of the point people would want me to go into surgery to check if my heart was OK... medics and nutrition professionals only made it worse, giving me bogus advice, like giving me diets based on the "pyramid", I got better when I started to ignore them and do my own research). https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-point-blame-at-fat https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074...
- forcry 5y ago>I don't see this changing without fundamentally realigning incentives in academia. I think the corruption in science is a manifestation of Goodharts law. People started to believe everything with the science label blindly. Like if something that starts with "research has shown", then it must be true (now it is "overwhelming evidence"). And whenever that happens, what ever the label is, tends to get bought. (This is why we have toothpaste commercials with people in lab coats). So the long term solution is to actually decrease the trust of people in "science", the label. Then it will come to a point that just the label of science is not enough to sway the people. Then it has a chance to progress, un-disturbed by these corrupting forces. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- murgindrag 5y agoThat's part of the solution. Another part is to somehow change incentive and organizational structures. MIT, Harvard, Stanford, and similar schools made their reputations decades if not over a century ago, and the current people and structures aren't the same as the people who built those institutions. These are big institutions, with big money and big egos. The people at the top are politician types good at climbing corporate structures. It's hard to overstate the distorting impact billions of dollars and those levels of brand recognition have. It's also hard to overstate the degree to which Goodhart's Law is exaggerated when you have 1000:1 competition for faculty slots, among otherwise qualified applicants. It's Goodhart's law on steroids, turbo, and overdrive. You CANNOT get a faculty position at some labs without cheating, at least a little bit. I don't see this changing unless federal and philanthropic funds are radically redistributed.
- fourthark 5y agoWhat a dogmatic article. Science is a process, not a set of truths. It’s good that more educated people are more skeptical.
- vibrio 5y agoI totally agree that Science is a process and skepticism is essential, but is maintaining skepticism in the face of overwhelming evidence part of the scientific process or is it just being dogmatic/contrarian?
- BrianOnHN 5y agoIt's being naive and selfish. Whether it's the old guard failing to relinquish the amyloid hypothesis or some radical anti-vaxxer.
- garden_hermit 5y agoThere is sort of a 2-faced nature here. Scienitsts themselves should be maintaining intense skepticism over even the most fundamental beleifs of their field. Here is the "science as a process" that is constantly changing. However, science also plays a role in public life, where it might make a lot more sense to appeal to the authority and the track record of science. Here is the "science as a set of truths". Separating the two is difficult though. Some scientists will inevitably become dogmatic about theories in their own field, whereas some in the public will take advantage of internal scientific debates to cast doubt on the whole thing.
- vibrio 5y agoI agree. To restate or extend: Communication by Scientists in the popular media is challenging. For example, scientists always qualify conclusions, they are trained to avoid using "all", "always", "never", or using concepts like "theory" with mean different thing to scientists vs public--All of which is leveraged by those not in the art to imply "weak" or "uncertain" concepts or conclusions.
- nbbcfhbn 5y ago
- denton-scratch 5y agoThere seems to be an assumption in the article that skepticism about The Big Bang is as irrational as the belief that Bill Gates has contaminated vaccines with microchips; that humans didn't evolve; or that climate change is a hoax. I realise that there's a scientific consensus that The Big Bang occurred; but the fact is, the earliest evidence is the CMB ("evidence", as in "what is evident, observable"). That's 350,000 years after The Big Bang. Everything before that is informed speculation. There are plausible theories about what happened before then, that don't include Big Bangs. That is, a scientifically literate person without strong political or religious biases can still maintain a reasonable skepticism about The Big Bang.
- quietbritishjim 5y agoI suspect the big bang was meant as a code for believing the universe is more than several thousand years old. It's true that the scientifically minded participants could've interpreted it to mean something quite a lot more specific though.
- mfer 5y agoThe article makes a bunch of assumptions but it does point, indirectly, at an interesting element. Ideology. Empirical science via the scientific method is one thing. We can have a hypothesis, show through experimentation that the hypothesis is true or not in a repeatable manner, and come to understand what's going on. For things that happening in the past we cannot do that. We end up doing forensic science where we mix observation with assumptions born out of beliefs (ideology). Sometimes there is no observation but there is beliefs that a scientific idea is true. This second part is where we often end up with the divide. Yet, we don't talk enough about the assumptions and because they are often coupled to beliefs it's hard to let people with different beliefs run wild with their ideas. I wish there was more discussion on the assumptions.
- phkahler 5y agoExcept for physicists. They latch on to all sorts of crazy hypothesis to explain stuff they don't fully understand yet.
- chrischattin 5y agoPhysics isn’t immune to latching onto an idea dogmatically. From what I understand, string theory relies on elements which are impossible to verify experimentally.
- jjgreen 5y agoProbably more accurate to say that all of string theory is verifiable experimentally (or falsifiable) at energy levels which are 10s of orders of magnitude larger than we can now achieve. The end result is the same though.
- wombatmobile 5y ago> In terms of stem cell research, evolution, and the Big Bang, those with a stronger general education showed greater political polarization, with conservatives more likely to reject them. For those with a strong science education, those topics were also polarized, as was climate change. This indicates the polarisation is not a consequence of whether people understand and apply scientific methodology, but rather is a consequence of network effects. Even working scientists who practice scientific methods do not have first hand knowledge of much science. Time precludes them from working on anything other than their own respective special sub-disciplines. Rather, their knowledge comes from reading accounts by other scientists, or people they trust. What people are trusted by conservatives? People who may be very well versed in scientific and engineering methods, such as mining company executives, and investors in mining companies. It comes as no surprise that for economic reasons, such people downplay the importance of climate change research. As a consequence, people in their networks don't rate climate change as a threat. Likewise with the Big Bang vs Creationism. These are just proxies for social and political status that office bearers in churches, and anti-churches, enjoy, which gives them the power to communicate with and influence vast numbers of followers and acolytes. When you read about the numbers of people who believe the Big Bang vs those who believe in God, you aren't reading about a scientific evaluation. You are reading about political groupings in society amongst people who compete for power and resources.
- lambdaphagy 5y agoSome of the constructs in this paper are pretty tendentious, without much self-awareness about it. For example, one of the six measures they use for alignment with scientific consensus is: "should the government fund stem cell research?", which is a moral and political question rather than a scientific one. Two parties could agree on all of the positive facts about stem cell research while differing over whether the government ought to fund it.